The purpose of this double-blind, longitudinal clinical study was to assess the efficacy of a dentifrice containing 3.3% soluble pyrophosphate in inhibiting calculus formation and its effect upon the oral soft tissues. A total of 265 adult volunteers was given a dental prophylaxis. Each was examined for dental calculus and oral soft tissue pathology. The volunteers were then randomly assigned to use either a dentifrice containing soluble pyrophosphate and sodium fluoride or a placebo sodium fluoride formulation for ad libitum home usage. At the two-month completion of the study, 217 subjects were available for examination. The results showed that the group using the dentifrice containing soluble pyrophosphate experienced a significant 26% decrease in calculus formation as compared with the placebo group, with both dentifrices being equally well-tolerated by the oral soft tissues.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Axelsson, P. and Lindhe, J. (1978): Effect of Controlled Oral Hygiene Procedures on Caries and Periodontal Disease in Adults, J Clin Periodont5:133-151.
2.
Bercy, P. and Vreven, J. (1979): Correlation Between Calculus Index and Acid and Alkaline Pyrophosphatase Activities of Dental Plaque and Saliva, J Biol Buccale7:31-36.
3.
Briner, W.W. and Francis, M.D. (1973): In vitro and in vivo Evaluation of Anti-Calculus Agents, Calcif Tissue Res11:10-22. Draus, F.J.; Tarbet, W.J. ; and Miklos, F.L. (1968): Salivary Enzymes and Calculus Formation, J Periodont Res3:232-235. Draus, F.J.; Lesniewski, M.; and Miklos, F.L. (1970): Pyrophosphate and Hexametaphosphate Effects in in vitro Calculus Formation , Arch Oral Biol15:893-896.
4.
Edgar, W.M. and Jenkins, G.N. (1972): Inorganic Pyrophosphate in Human Parotid Saliva and Dental Plaque, Arch Oral Biol17:219-223.
5.
Everett, F.G.; Tuchler, H.; and Lu, K.H. (1963): Occurrence of Calculus in Grade School Children in Portland, Oregon, J Periodont34:54-59.
6.
Fauchard, P. (1946): The Surgeon Dentist. Translated by Lillian Lindsay from the 1746 Edition. London: Butterworth & Co.Fleisch , H. and Bisaz, S. (1962): Isolation from Urine of Pyrophosphate, A Calcification Inhibitor, Am J Physiol203:671-675. Fleisch, H.; Russell, G.G.; Bisaz, S.; Termine, J.D.; and Posner, A.S. (1968): Influence of Pyrophosphate on the Trans
7.
formation of Amorphous to Crystalline Calcium Phosphate, Calcif Tissue Res2:49-59.
8.
Francis, M.D.; Slough, C.L.; Briner, W.W.; and Oertel, R.P. (1977): An in vitro and in vivo Investigation of Mellitate and Ethane-1-Hydroxy-1,1-Diphosphonate in Calcium Phosphate Systems, Calcif Tissue Res23:53-60.
9.
Gaffar, A.; Niles, H.P.; and Davis, C.B. (1981): Evaluation of an Oligomer or an Oligomer Plus Cetyl Pyridinium Chloride Against Plaque, Stain, Calculus and Gingivitis, J Dent Res60 :1432-1439.
10.
Gaffar, A.; Moreno, E.C.; Mühlemann, H.R.; and Niles, H.P. (1983): Effects of EDITEMPA on Dental Calculus and Caries Formation in vivo, Calcif Tissue Int35:362-365.
11.
Glavind, L.; Zeuner, E.; and Attstrom, R. (1983): Evaluation of Various Feedback Mechanisms in Relation to Compliance by Adult Patients with Oral Home Care Instructions, J Clin Periodont10:57-68.
12.
Kakehashi, S. and Parakkal, P.F. (1982): Proceedings from the State of the Art Workshop on Surgical Therapy for Periodontitis, J Periodontol53:475-501.
13.
Kinoshita, S. and Muhlemann, H.R. (1966): Effect of Sodium Ortho- and Pyrophosphate on Supragingival Calculus, Helv Odont Acta10:46-48.
14.
Kupczak, L.J.; Volpe, A.R.; and King, W.J. (1969): Dental Plaque: Relationship Between Accumulation Patterns in Human Adult Dentition and Clinical Investigations, IADR Progr & Abstr48:No. 642.
15.
Lang, N.P.; Hotz, P.; Graf, H.; Gerring, A.M.; Saxer, V.P.; Sturzenberger, O.P.; and Meckel, A.H. (1982): Effects of Supervised Chlorhexidine Mouthrinses in Children, J Periodont Res17:101-111.
16.
Lehnhoff, R.W. and Grainger, R.M. (1974): Analysis of Co-variance, J Periodont Res9:7-30.
17.
Leung, S.W. (1956): Role of Calculus Deposition in Periodontal Disease . In: A Symposium on Preventive Dentistry, J.C. Muhler and M.K. Hine, Eds., St. Louis: The C.V. Mosby Company, pp. 206-216.
18.
Leung, S.W. (1960): Calculus, Its Formation and Possible Prevention , Penn Dent J27:3-9.
19.
Littleton, N.W. (1963): Dental Caries and Periodontal Disease Among Ethiopian Civilians, Pub Health Rep78:631.
20.
Lobene, R.R.; Brion, M.; and Socransky, S.S. (1969): Effect of Erythromycin on Dental Plaque and Plaque Forming Microorganisms of Man, J Periodont40:287-291.
21.
Loë, H. (1983): Principles of Aetiology and Pathogenesis Governing the Treatment of Periodontal Disease, Int Dent J33:119-126. Loë, H. and Schiott, C.R. (1970): The Effect of Mouthrinses and Topical Application of Chlorhexidine on the Development of Dental Plaque and Gingivitis in Man, J Periodont Res5:79-83. Mandel, I.D. (1967): Plaque and Calculus Measurements - Rate of Formation and Pathologic Potential , J Periodont38:721-732. Mühlemann, H.R.; Bowles, D.; Schait, A.; and Berni-Moulin, J.P. (1970 ): Effect of Diphosphonate on Human Supragingival Calculus , Helv Odont Acta14:31-33. Mukherjee, S. (1968): Formation and Prevention of Supra-Gingival Calculus, J Periodont Res3 (Supp #2):13-35.
22.
Picozzi, A.; Fischman, S.L.; Pader, M.; and Cancro, L.P. (1972): Calculus Inhibition in Humans, J Periodontol43:692-695. Rizzo, A.A.; Martin, G.R.; Scott, D.B.; and Mergen-Hagen, S.E. (1962): Mineralization of Bacteria, Science135 :439-444.
23.
Sand, H.F. (1949): The Carbonic Acid Content of Saliva and its Role in the Formation of Dental Calculus. Thesis. Oslo: Thronsen & Co.
24.
Sturzenberger, O.P. and Leonard, G.J. (1969): The Effect of a Mouthwash as Adjunct in Tooth Cleaning, J Periodont40 :299-301.
25.
Sturzenberger, O.P.; Swancar, J.R.; and Reiter, G. (1971): Reduction of Dental Calculus in Humans Through the Use of a Dentifrice Containing a Crystal-growth Inhibitor, J Periodont42:416-419.
26.
Suomi, J.D.; Greene, J.C.; Vermillion, J.R.; Doyle, J.; Chang, J.J.; and Leatherwood, E.C. (1971): The Effect of Controlled Oral Hygiene Procedures on the Progression of Peri
27.
odontal Disease in Adults: Results After Third and Final Year, J Periodontol42:152-160.
28.
Turesky, S.; Gilmore, N.D.; and Glickman, 1. ( 1967): Calculus Inhibition by Topical Application of the Chlormethyl Analogue of Vitamin C, J Periodont38:142-147.
29.
Villa, P. (1968): Degree of Calculus Inhibition by Habitual Tooth-brushing , Helv Odont Acta12:31-32.
30.
Vogel, J.J. and Amdur, B.H. (1967): Inorganic Pyrophosphate in Parotid Saliva and Its Relation to Calculus Formation, Arch Oral Biol12:159-163.
31.
Volpe, A.R.; Manhold, H.H.; and Hazen, S.P. (1965): In vivo Calculus Assessment: Part I. A Method and Its Examiner Reproducibility, J Perio36:292-298.
32.
Weinberger, B.W. (1948): An Introduction to the History of Dentistry. St. Louis: C.V. Mosby Company, p. 203.
