Creep-fatigue as a Possible Cause of Dental Amalgam Margin Failure

Abstract

Fracture of the margins is the most common cause of failure of dental amalgam restorations. Both corrosion and creep have been identified as possible contributors to this type of failure. The stresses that induce creep may arise from the continued setting expansion of the amalgam, the formation of corrosion products, mastication, or from the thermal expansion of the amalgam during ingestion of hot foods. The latter two are low-frequency cyclic stresses. The amalgams used in dentistry have fusion temperatures only about 40°C above mouth temperature, and they experience grain boundary sliding during creep deformation. Since grain boundary sliding, low-frequency cyclic stresses, and a temperature near the fusion temperature of the alloy are prerequisites for so-called "creep-fatigue fracture", this type of fracture may contribute to amalgam margin failure. Amalgam made from seven different alloys was condensed into stainless steel dies. After being allowed to set for seven days, the specimens were thermally cycled between 4°C and 50°C for 500 and 1000 cycles. Amalgam margin integrity was evaluated by scanning electron microscopy both before and after each cycling period. The amount of margin fracture was calculated after 1000 cycles. Thermal cycling of amalgam restorations placed in stainless steel dies resulted in predominantly intergranular fracturing of the amalgam margins, indicating that creep-fatigue failure may be a significant contributor to in vivo margin fracturing.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Argon, A.S. (1982): Mechanisms and Mechanics of Fracture in Creeping Alloys, Recent Advances in Creep and Fracture of Engineering Materials and Structures, Swansea, U.K.: Pineridge Press, pp. 1-52.

Asgar, K. and Sutfin, L. , (1965): Brittle Fracture of Dental Amalgam, J Dent Res 44: 977-988.

Bosivell, P.G. (1979): Transmission Electron Metallography of Non-Gamma-Two Silver Dental Amalgams, Scripta Met 13: 383-388.

Bryant, R.W. (1981): Marginal Fracture of Amalgam Restorations - A Review, Part 1, Aust Dent J 26:162-166; Part II, Aust Dent J 26:222-224.

Coffin, L.F., Jr. (1973): Fatigue at High Temperature; Fatigue at Elevated Temperature, ASTM STP520, Philadelphia, PA: Amer Soc for Testing and Materials, pp. 5-34.

Coffin, L.F. (1979): Damage Processes in Time-Dependent Fatigue - A Review. Creep-Fatigue Environment Interactions. Milwaukee : Proceedings of a Symposium of TSM-AIME, pp. 1-23.

Coffin, L.F. (1983): Overview of Temperature and Environmental Effects on Fatigue of Structural Metals; Fatigue, Environment and Temperature Effects , Proceedings of the 27 Sagamore Army Materials Research Conference, July, 1980. New Yolk : Plenum Press, pp. 1-40.

Craig, R.G. (1980): Restorative Dental Materials, 6th ed. St. Louis, MO: C.V. Mosby Co., p. 54.

Cruicksiianks-Boyd, D.W. (1983): Physical Metallurgy of Dental Amalgams: (3) Transverse Strength and Fracture Behaviour during Setting, J Dent 11:214-223.

10.

Derand, T. (1976): Creep in Amalgam Class V Restorations, Odont Revy 27:181-186.

11.

Derand, T. (1977): Marginal Failure of Amalgam Class II Restorations , J Dent Res 56:481-485.

12.

Duke, E.S. ; Cochran, M.A. ; Moore, B.K. ; and Clark, H.E. (1982): Laboratory Profiles of 30 High Copper Alloys, JADA 105: 636-640.

13.

Duperon, D.F. ; Nevile, M.D. ; and Kasloff, Z. (1971): Clinical Evaluation of Corrosion Resistance of Conventional Alloy, Spherical-Particle Alloy, and Dispersion-Phase Alloy, J Prosthet Dent 25 :650-656.

14.

Eames, W.B. and MacNamara, J.F. (1976): Eight High Copper Amalgam Alloys and Six Conventional Alloys Compared, J Oper Dent 1:98-107.

15.

Gell, M. and Leverant, G.R. (1973): Mechanisms of High Temperature Fatigue: Fatigue at Elevated Temperatures, ASTM STP520, Philadelphia, PA : Amer Soc for Testing and Materials, pp. 37-67.

16.

Grant, N.J. and Chaudhuri, A.R. (1965): Creep and Fracture: Deformation and Fracture at Elevated Temperatures. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, pp. 105-164.

17.

Hamilton, J.C. ; Moffa, J.P. ; Ellison, J.A. ; and Jenkins, W.A. (1983): Marginal Fracture not a Predictor of Longevity: A Ten Year Study, J Prosthet Dent 50:200-202.

18.

Harper, R.H. ; Schnell, R.J. ; Swartz, M.L. ; and Phillips, R.W. (1980): In vivo Measurements of Thermal Diffusion through Restorations of Various Materials, J Prosthet Dent 43: 180-185.

19.

Her, H. (1983): On Creep Mechanisms in Amalgams, J Dent Res 62:44-50.

20.

Her, H. ; Brune, D. ; Jorgenson, R.B. ; and Evje, D.M. (1983): Surface Degradation of Amalgams in vitro during Static and Cyclic Loading, Scand J Dent Res 91:488-495.

21.

Innes, D.B.K. and Youdelis, W.V. (1963): Dispersion Strengthened Amalgams, Can Dent Assoc J 29 :587-593.

22.

Jorgensen, K.D. (1965): The Mechanism of Marginal Fracture of Amalgam Fillings, Acta Odontol Scand 23:347-389.

23.

Malhotra, M.L. and Asgar, K. (1978): Physical Properties of Dental Silver-Tin Amalgams with High and Low Copper Contents, JADA 96:444-450.

24.

McTique, D. ; Prince, C. ; Nanda, C.R. ; and Sarkar, N. (1984): The in-vivo Corrosion of Dispersalloy, J Oral Rehabil 11:351-359.

25.

Metals Handbook (1980), Vol. 3, 9th ed. Metals Park, OH: American Society for Metals, pp. 34-35.

26.

Okabe, T. ; Butts, M.B. ; Mitchell, R.J. ; and Fairhurst, C.W. (1980): Grain Boundary Sliding and Creep in Dental Amalgams , IADR Progr & Abst 59: No. 100.

27.

Okabe, T. ; Butts, M.B. ; and Mitchell, R.J. (1983): Changes in the Microstructures of Silver-Tin and Admixed High Copper Amalgams during Creep, J Dent Res 62:37-43.

28.

Osborne, J.W. and Gale, E.N. (1980): Clinical Performance of Certain Commercial High-Copper-Content Amalgams, JADA 100:867-869.

29.

Osborne, J.W. ; Gale, E.N. ; Chew, C.L. ; Rhodes, B.F. ; and Phillips, R.W. (1978): Clinical Performance and Physical Properties of Twelve Amalgam Alloys, JDent Res 57 :983-988.

30.

Osborne, J.W. ; Winchell, P.G. ; and Phillips, R.W. (1978): A Hypothetical Mechanism by which Creep Causes Marginal Failure of Amalgam Restorations, J Ind Dent Assoc 57:16-17.

31.

Paffenbarger, G.C. ; Rupp, N.W. ; and Patel, P.R. (1979): Linear Dimensional Change of Copper-Rich Dental Amalgam, JADA 99:468-471.

32.

Paffenbarger, G.C. and Rupp, N.W. (1983): Relation between Clinical Behaviour and Expansion of Three Amalgams, AADR Abst 62:No. 21.

33.

Phillips, R.W. (1982): Science of Dental Materials, 8th ed. Toronto: W.B. Saunders Co. , pp. 54, 313, and 315.

34.

Plant, C.G. ; Jones, D.W. ; and Darvell, B.W. (1974): The Heat Evolved and Temperatures Attained during Setting of Restorative Materials, Br Dent J 137:233-238.

35.

Sarkar, N.K. (1978): Creep, Corrosion and Marginal Fracture of Dental Amalgams, J Oral Rehabil 5:413-423.

36.

Sarkar, N.K. ; Osborne, J.W. ; and Leinfelder, K.F. (1982): In vitro Corrosion and in vivo Marginal Fracture of Dental Amalgam. JDent Res 61 :1262-1268.

37.

Simmons, E.W. ; Barghi, N. ; and Muscott, J.R. (1976): Thermocycling of Pit and Fissure Sealants, J Dent Res 55:606-610.

38.

Sutow, E.J. ; Jones, D.W. ; Owen, C.G. ; Hall, G.C. ; and Milne, E.L. (1984): Fatigue Fracture of Dental Amalgams, IADR Abst 63:No. 66.

39.

Sutow, E.J. ; Jones, D.W. ; Hall, G.C. ; and Milne, E.L. (1985): The Response of Dental Amalgam to Dynamic Loading , J Dent Res 64:62-66.

40.

Williams, H.D. and Corti, C.W. (1968): Grain Boundary Migration and Cavitation during Fatigue, J Metal Science 2:28-31.

41.

Zardiackas, L.D. ; Bayne, S.C. ; and Carlson, M.D. (1982): Fatigue Fracture Analysis of Amalgam by SEM-EDAX , IADR Prog and Abstr 61 :No. 6 29.