Nerve Regeneration Through Collagen Tubes

Abstract

Severe nerve injuries may require microsurgical grafting to span a defect. Introduction of graft material into a highly vascular recipient bed is documented to aid in early regeneration of neuronal blood supply.

A silicone rod (SR)-induced fibrovascular sheath was employed to evaluate the regeneration of rat tibial nerve through 2-mmdiameter collagen tubes (CT) or contralateral nerve autografts (AUTO). At first operation, 5 mm of right tibial nerve was resected from 30 retired male breeder Sprague-Dawley rats. Resected nerve was replaced with either a 5 x 2 mm SR or the nerve ends were sutured to the intermuscular fascia.

Four weeks later, animals were repaired by replacing the SR with either a CT or a contralateral AUTO from the left tibial nerve. Three months later, EMG testing was performed, and histologic sections were prepared.

The EMG latency and the size of the compound action potential for sheathed or non-sheathed CT or AUTO were statistically superior to controls at the 95% confidence level. All other intergroup comparisons of latency and action potential size were statistically insignificant. The proportion of nerve fibers traversing the surgical sites was not influenced by the method of repair or by the presence or absence of sheathing. Tubulized repairs most closely resembled unoperated nerves, and autografted repairs had a large diameter, but much fibrosis, whereas controls displayed immaturity and disorganization.

Our observations suggest that there was no difference between repairs performed with or without a vascular pseudosheath. However, CT supported regeneration better than did AUTO repair.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berry, R.B. ; Ewart, W.R. ; Reeve, D.R.E. ; and Sommerlad, B.C. : Experimental Observations on the Behavior of Nerve Grafts in Sheaths Formed Around Silicone Rods, Br J Plast Surg 33:324, 1980.

Bora, F.W. : Peripheral Nerve Repair in Cats: The Fascicular Stitch, J Bone Joint Surg 49(A):659, 1967.

Bora, F.W. ; Pleasure, D.E. ; and Didizian, N.A. : A Study of Nerve Regeneration and Neuroma Formation After Nerve Suture by Various Techniques, J Hand Surg 1:138, 1976.

Braun, R.M. : Experimental Peripheral Nerve Repair Tubulation, Surg Forum 15:452, 1964.

Braun, R.M. : Comparative Studies of Neurorrhaphy and Sutureless Nerve Repair, Surg Gyn Abst 122:15, 1966.

Cabaud, H.E. ; Rodkey, W.G. ; McCarroll, H.R. ; Mutz, S.B. ; and Niebaur, JJ : Epineurial and Perineurial Nerve Repairs : A Critical Comparison, J Hand Surg 1 :131, 1976.

Colten, T. : Statistics in Medicine. Little, Brown & Co. , 1974.

Grabb, W.C. ; Bement, S.L. ; Koepke, G.H. ; and Green, R.A. : Comparison of Methods of Peripheral Nerve Suturing in Monkeys, Plast Reconstr Surg 46:3, 1980.

Gutmann, E. and Sanders, F.K. : Recovery of Fiber Numbers and Diameters in the Regeneration of Peripheral Nerves, J Physiol 101:489, 1947.

10.

Howard, F.M. : Electromyography and Conduction Studies in Peripheral Nerve Injuries , Surg Clin N A 52: 1343, 1972. Jacobson , S. and Guth, L. : An Electrophysiological Study of the Early Stages of Peripheral Nerve Regeneration, J Exp Neurol 11:48, 1965.

11.

Kline, D.G. and Hayes, G.J. : The Use of a Resorbable Wrapper for Peripheral Nerve Repair, J Neurosurg 21:737, 1964.

12.

Kline, D.G. ; Hayes, G.J. ; and Morse, A.S. : A Comparative Study of Responses of Species to Peripheral Nerve Injury . 2. Crush and Severance with Primary Suture, J Neurosurg 21:980, 1964.

13.

Lehman, R.A.N. and Hayes, G.T. : Degeneration and Regeneration in Peripheral Nerve, Brain 90:285, 1967.

14.

Lundborg, G. and Hansson, H. : Regeneration of Peripheral Nerve Through a Pre-formed Tissue Space , Brain Res 178:573, 1977.

15.

Lundborg, G. and Hansson, H. : Nerve Regeneration Through Preformed Pseudosynovial Tubes, J Hand Surg 5:35, 1980.

16.

Lundborg, G. ; Dahlin, L.B. ; Danielson, N.P. ; Hansson, H. ; and Larsson, K. : Reorganization and Orientation of Regenerating Nerve Fibers, Perineurium and Epineurium in Preformed Mesothelial Tubes - An Experimental Study on the Sciatic Nerve of Rats, J Neuroscience 6:265, 1981.

17.

Magladery, J.W. and McDougall, D.B. : Electrophysiologic Studies in Nerve Reflex Activity in Normal IAN , Bull Johns Hopkins Hosp 86:265, 1950.

18.

Metz, R. and Seeger, W. : Collagen Wrapping of Nerve Homo-transplants in Dogs. A Preliminary Report , Eur Surg Res 1:157, 1969.

19.

Miyamoto, Y. : Experimental Studies on Repair for Peripheral Nerves: Effects of Tension at Suture Site on Intraneural Circulation, Hiroshima J Med Sci 28:13, 1979.

20.

Miyamoto, Y. : Experimental Studies on Repair for Peripheral Nerves: Relationship Between Circulatory Disturbance at Nerve Stumps Caused by Tension at Suture Line and Axon Regeneration, Hiroshima J Med Sci 28:87, 1979.

21.

Miyamoto, Y. : End to End Coaptation Under Tension on Repair of Peripheral Nerves . In: Posttraumatic Peripheral Nerve Regeneration, Gorio, Millesi , and Mingrino , Eds., Raven Press, 1981.

22.

Nomuar, S. : Nerve Transplantation and Regeneration and Recovery of Function. In: Nerve Degeneration and Regeneration: Fundamentals and Applications , Kasuma and Nakamura , Eds. Tokyo: Igatushoin , 1975.

23.

Orgel, M.G. and Terzis, J.K. : Coordination of Axon Neurophysiology and Axon Counting Techniques in Nerve Regeneration. In: Management of Peripheral Nerve Problems, Omer and Spinner, Eds. W.B. Saunders , 1980.

24.

ROSEN, J.M. and JEWETT, D.L.: In: Nerve Repair and Regenera

25.

tion, Jewett, D.L. and McCarroll , Eds. C.V. Mosby, 1980, Chapter 15.

26.

Rosen, J.M. ; Jewett, D.L. ; and Kaplan, E.N. : Regeneration Following Nerve Repair, Abst Soc Neurosci 3 :390, 1977.

27.

Rosen, J.M. et al. : Fascicular Sutureless and Suture Repair of Peripheral Nerves: A Comparison Study in Laboratory Animals, Orthop Res 8:85, 1979.

28.

Sunderland, S. : Nerves and Nerve Injuries. Churchill Living-stone , 1978.

29.

Sunderland, S. : The Pros and Cons of Funicular Nerve Repair. J Hand Surg 4:201, 1979.

30.

Terzis, J. ; Faibisoff, B. ; and Williams, H.B. : The Nerve Gap: Suture Under Tension Versus Graft, Plast Reconstr Surg 56:166,1975.

31.

Thulin, C.A. : Electrophysiologic Studies of Peripheral Nerve Regeneration with Special Reference to the Small Diameter (Gamma) Fibers, Exp Neurol 2:598, 1960.

32.

Wall, P.E. ; Scadding, J.W. ; and Tomkiewicz, M.A. : The Protection and Prevention of Experimental Anaesthesia Dolorosa, Pain 6:175, 1979.

33.

Weiss, P.A. and Taylor, A.C. : Guides for Nerve Regeneration Across Gaps, J Neurosurg 3:400, 1946.

34.

Wise, A.J. ; Cemalettin, T. ; Davis, P. ; and Kaye, I.S. : A Comparative Analysis of Macro- and Microsurgical Neuropathy Techniques , Amer J Surg 117:666, 1969.

35.

Yamazaki, Y. and Noma, H. : Effect of the Perineurial Vascular Net on Experimental Grafting of the Inferior Alveolar Nerve, J Oral Maxillofac Surg 41:219, 1983.