Increasing numbers of clinical trials have demonstrated the benefits of incomplete caries removal, in particular in the treatment of deep caries. This study systematically reviewed randomized controlled trials investigating one- or two-step incomplete compared with complete caries removal. Studies treating primary and permanent teeth with primary caries lesions requiring a restoration were analyzed. The following primary and secondary outcomes were investigated: risk of pulpal exposure, post-operative pulpal symptoms, overall failure, and caries progression. Electronic databases were screened for studies from 1967 to 2012. Cross-referencing was used to identify further articles. Odds ratios (OR) as effect estimates were calculated in a random-effects model. From 364 screened articles, 10 studies representing 1,257 patients were included. Meta-analysis showed risk reduction for both pulpal exposure (OR [95% CI] 0.31 [0.19-0.49]) and pulpal symptoms (OR 0.58 [0.31-1.10]) for teeth treated with one- or two-step incomplete excavation. Risk of failure seemed to be similar for both complete and incomplete excavation, but data for this outcome were of limited quality and inconclusive (OR 0.97 [0.64-1.46]). Based on reviewed studies, incomplete caries removal seems advantageous compared with complete excavation, especially in proximity to the pulp. However, evidence levels are currently insufficient for definitive conclusions because of high risk of bias within studies.
Al-ZayerMAStraffonLHFeigalRJWelchKB (2003). Indirect pulp treatment of primary posterior teeth: a retrospective study. Pediatr Dent25:29-36.
2.
BanerjeeAWatsonTFKiddEA (2001). Dentine caries: take it or leave it?S Afr Dent J56:189-192.
3.
BarthelCRRosenkranzBLeuenbergARouletJF (2000). Pulp capping of carious exposures: treatment outcome after 5 and 10 years: a retrospective study. J Endod26:525-528.
4.
BjørndalLKiddE (2005). The treatment of deep dentine caries lesions. Dent Update32:402-404, 407-410, 413.
5.
BjørndalLLarsenT (2000). Changes in the cultivable flora in deep carious lesions following a stepwise excavation procedure. Caries Res34:502-508.
6.
BjørndalLLarsenTThylstrupA (1997). A clinical and microbiological study of deep carious lesions during stepwise excavation using long treatment intervals. Caries Res31:411-417.
7.
BjørndalLReitCBruunGMarkvartMKjældgaardMNäsmanP. (2010). Treatment of deep caries lesions in adults: randomized clinical trials comparing stepwise vs. direct complete excavation, and direct pulp capping vs. partial pulpotomy. Eur J Oral Sci118:290-297.
8.
BowenJLMathu-MujuKRNashDAChanceKBBushHMLiHF (2012). Pediatric and general dentists’ attitudes toward pulp therapy for primary teeth. Pediatr Dent34:210-215.
9.
BrunthalerAKönigFLucasTSperrWSchedleA (2003). Longevity of direct resin composite restorations in posterior teeth: a review. Clin Oral Investig7:63-70.
10.
CasagrandeLBentoLWDalpianDMGarcía-GodoyFde AraujoFB (2010). Indirect pulp treatment in primary teeth: 4-year results. Am J Dent21:34-38.
11.
DoiJItotaTToriiYNakaboSYoshiyamaM (2004). Micro-tensile bond strength of self-etching primer adhesive systems to human coronal carious dentin. J Oral Rehabil31:1023-1028.
12.
FitzgeraldMHeysRJ (1991). A clinical and histological evaluation of conservative pulpal therapy in human teeth. Oper Dent16:101-112.
13.
FoleyJEvansDBlackwellA (2004). Partial caries removal and cariostatic materials in carious primary molar teeth: a randomised controlled clinical trial. Br Dent J197:697-701.
14.
FusayamaTOkuseKHosodaH (1966). Relationship between hardness, discoloration, and microbial invasion in carious dentin. J Dent Res45:1033-1046.
15.
GriffinSOOongEKohnWVidakovicBGoochBFBaderJ. (2008). The effectiveness of sealants in managing caries lesions. J Dent Res87:169-174.
16.
HandelmanSLWashburnFWoppererP (1976). Two-year report of sealant effect on bacteria in dental caries. J Am Dent Assoc93:967-970.
17.
HandelmanSLLeverettDHIkerHP (1985). Longitudinal radiographic evaluation of the progress of caries under sealants. J Pedod9:119-126.
18.
HayashiMFujitaniMYamakiCMomoiY (2011). Ways of enhancing pulp preservation by stepwise excavation—a systematic review. J Dent39:95-107.
19.
HeinrichRKneistSKünzelW (1991). Klinisch kontrollierte Untersuchung zur Caries-profunda-Therapie am Milchmolaren. Dtsch Zahnärztl Z46:581-584.
20.
HevingaMAOpdamNJFrenckenJETruinGJHuysmansMC (2010). Does incomplete caries removal reduce strength of restored teeth?J Dent Res89:1270-1275.
21.
HigginsJPGreenS (2009). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
22.
HigginsJPThompsonSG (2002). Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med21:1539-1558.
23.
HuangXLiLHuangCDuX (2011). Effect of ethanol-wet bonding with hydrophobic adhesive on caries-affected dentine. Eur J Oral Sci119:310-315.
24.
InnesNPEvansDJStirrupsDR (2011). Sealing caries in primary molars: randomized control trial, 5-year results. J Dent Res90:1405-1410.
25.
JordanRESuzukiMSkinnerDH (1978). Indirect pulp-capping of carious teeth with periapical lesions. J Am Dent Assoc97:37-43.
26.
KiddEA (2004). How ‘clean’ must a cavity be before restoration?Caries Res38:305-313.
27.
KiddEAFejerskovO (2004). What constitutes dental caries? Histopathology of carious enamel and dentin related to the action of cariogenic biofilms. J Dent Res83(Spec No.C):C35-C38.
28.
KingJBCrawfordJJLindahlRL (1965). Indirect pulp capping: a bacteriologic study of deep carious dentine in human teeth. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol20:663-669.
29.
LangelandKLangelandLK (1968). Indirect capping and the treatment of deep carious lesions. Int Dent J18:362-380.
30.
LeksellERidellKCvekMMejàreI (1996). Pulp exposure after stepwise versus direct complete excavation of deep carious lesions in young posterior permanent teeth. Endod Dent Traumatol12:192-196.
31.
LulaECMonteiro-NetoVAlvesCMRibeiroCC (2009). Microbiological analysis after complete or partial removal of carious dentin in primary teeth: a randomized clinical trial. Caries Res43:354-358.
32.
MagnussonBOSundellSO (1977). Stepwise excavation of deep carious lesions in primary molars. J Int Assoc Dent Child8:36-40.
33.
MaltzMGarciaRJardimJJde PaulaLMYamagutiPMMouraMS. (2012). Randomized trial of partial vs. stepwise caries removal. J Dent Res91:1026-1031.
34.
MaltzMJardimJJMestrinhoHDYamagutiPMPodestáKMouraMS. (2013). Partial removal of carious dentine: a multicenter randomized controlled trial and 18-month follow-up results. Caries Res47:103-109.
35.
MarshPD (2006). Dental plaque as a biofilm and a microbial community — implications for health and disease. BMC Oral Health6(Suppl 1):14.
36.
Mertz-FairhurstEJCurtisJWErgleJWRueggebergFAAdairSM (1998). Ultraconservative and cariostatic sealed restorations: results at year 10. J Am Dent Assoc129:55-66.
37.
MickenautschSYengopalVBanerjeeA (2010). Pulp response to resin-modified glass ionomer and calcium hydroxide cements in deep cavities: a quantitative systematic review. Dent Mater26:761-770.
38.
MiyashitaHWorthingtonHQualtroughAPlasschaertA (2007). Pulp management for caries in adults: maintaining pulp vitality. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2:CD004484.
39.
OenKTThompsonVPVenaDCaufieldPWCurroFDasanayakeA. (2007). Attitudes and expectations of treating deep caries: a PEARL Network survey. Gen Dent55:197-203.
40.
OongEMGriffinSOKohnWGGoochBFCaufieldPW (2008). The effect of dental sealants on bacteria levels in caries lesions. J Am Dent Assoc139:271-278.
41.
OrhanAIOzFTOrhanK (2010). Pulp exposure occurrence and outcomes after 1- or 2-visit indirect pulp therapy vs complete caries removal in primary and permanent molars. Pediatr Dent32:347-355.
42.
ParisSHopfenmullerWMeyer-LueckelH (2010). Resin infiltration of caries lesions. J Dent Res89:823-826.
43.
PhonghanyudhAPhantumvanitPSongpaisanYPetersenPE (2012). Clinical evaluation of three caries removal approaches in primary teeth: a randomised controlled trial. Community Dent Health29:173-178.
44.
QudeimatMAAl-SaieghFAAl-OmariQOmarR (2007). Restorative treatment decisions for deep proximal carious lesions in primary molars. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent8:37-42.
45.
RibeiroCCBaratieriLNPerdigãoJBaratieriNMRitterAV (1999). A clinical, radiographic, and scanning electron microscopic evaluation of adhesive restorations on carious dentin in primary teeth. Quintessence Int30:591-599.
46.
RickettsD (2001). Restorative dentistry: management of the deep carious lesion and the vital pulp dentine complex. Br Dent J191:606-610.
47.
RickettsDKiddEInnesNClarksonJE (2006). Complete or ultraconservative removal of decayed tissue in unfilled teeth. Cochrane Database Syst Rev3:CD003808.
48.
SawuschRH (1982). Direct and indirect pulp capping with two new products. J Am Dent Assoc104:459-462.
49.
SundbergHMejàreIEspelidITveitAB (2000). Swedish dentists’ decisions on preparation techniques and restorative materials. Acta Odontol Scand58:135-141.
50.
ThompsonVCraigRGCurroFAGreenWSShipJA (2008). Treatment of deep carious lesions by complete excavation or partial removal. J Am Dent Assoc139:705-712.
51.
WambierDSdos SantosFAGuedes-PintoACJaegerRGSimionatoMR (2007). Ultrastructural and microbiological analysis of the dentin layers affected by caries lesions in primary molars treated by minimal intervention. Pediatr Dent29:228-234.
52.
WeberCMAlvesLSMaltzM (2011). Treatment decisions for deep carious lesions in the Public Health Service in Southern Brazil. J Public Health Dent71:265-270.
53.
WeerheijmKLde SoetJJvan AmerongenWEde GraaffJ (1992). Sealing of occlusal hidden caries lesions: an alternative for curative treatment?ASDC J Dent Child59:263-268.
54.
WeiSSadrAShimadaYTagamiJ (2008). Effect of caries-affected dentin hardness on the shear bond strength of current adhesives. J Adhes Dent10:431-440.
55.
YengopalVHarnekerSYPatelNSiegfriedN (2009). Dental fillings for the treatment of caries in the primary dentition. Cochrane Database Syst Rev12:CD004483.
56.
YoshiyamaMDoiJNishitaniYItotaTTayFRCarvalhoRM. (2004). Bonding ability of adhesive resins to caries-affected and caries-infected dentin. J Appl Oral Sci12:171-176.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
