Developmental Influences on Geometric Illusion Susceptibility among Hong Kong Chinese Children

Abstract

Hong Kong Chinese developmental results are presented to test cross-cultural developmental theories relating to changes in illusion susceptibility with age. The Muller-Lyer (M-L) and Sander-Parallelogram (S-P) illusion data confirm the expected decrease with age from 3-12 (Walter, 1942), and the later increase to age 21 due to exposure to a more sophisticated environment (Wapner and Werner, 1957). The data also supported Piaget and Morf's (1956) developmental hypotheses regarding contiguous and noncontiguous versions of the Horizontal-Vertical (H-V) illustions. The United States, Hong Kong, and Arunta cross-cultural comparisons also support the "carpentered world hypothesis," while H-V illusion susceptibility was also related to ecologically valid desert/urban differences in habits of perceptual inference. However, intersample differences in retinal pigmentation and the cross-sectional nature of the study may have influenced the results.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ARMSTRONG, R. E. , E. V. RUBIN , M. STEWART , and L. KUNTURE (1970) "Susceptibility to the Milller-Lyer, Sander Parallelogram and the Distorted Room illusions, as a function of age, sex and retinal pigmentation among Midwestern children." Northwestern University Department of Psychology Research Report. (mimeo)

BERRY, J. W. (1972) "Miiller-Lyer susceptibility: culture ecology or race." International J. of Psychology 6: 193-197.

BERRY, J. W. (1968) "Ecology, perceptual development and the Muller-Lyer illusion." British J. of Psychology 29: 205-210.

BERRY, J. W. (1966) "Temne and Eskimo perceptual skills." International J. of Psychology 1: 207-229.

BINET. A. (1895) "La mesure des illusions visuelles chez les enfants." Revue Philosophique de France et de l'Etranger 40: 11-25.

BONTE, M. L. (1962) "The reaction of two African societies to the Muller-Lyer illusion." (unpublished)

BROVERMAN, D. N. , F. E. CLARKSON , E. L. KLAIBER , and V. VOGEL (1972) "The ability to automatize: a function basic to learning and performance," in C. Chris (ed.) Multidisciplinary Approaches to Identification, Diagnosis, and Remedial Education. New York: Macmillan.

BRUNSWIK, E. (1956) Perception and the Representative Design of Psychological Experiments. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.

DAWSON, J.L.M. (1972) "The effects of sex hormones on cognitive style in rats and men." J. of Behaviour Genetics 2: 21-42.

10.

DAWSON, J.L.M. (1967a) "Traditional versus Western attitudes in Western Africa: the construction, validation and application of a measuring device." British J. of Social and Clinical Psychology 6: 81-96.

11.

DAWSON, J.L.M. (1967b) "Cultural and physiological influences on spatial-perceptual processes in West Africa, Parts I and II." International J. of Psychology 2: 115-128; 171-185.

12.

DAWSON, J.L.M. (1963) "Psychological effects of social change in West Africa." Ph.D. thesis. University of Oxford.

13.

DAWSON, J.L.M. B. M. YOUNG , and P. C. CHOI (forthcoming) "Developmental influences in pictorial depth perception." J. of Cross-Cultural Psychology.

14.

DAWSON, J.L.M. , H. LAW , A. LEUNG , and R. A. WHITNEY (1971) "Scaling Chinese traditional-modern attitudes and the GSR measurement of important versus unimportant Chinese concepts." J. of Cross-Cultural Psychology 2: 1-27.

15.

FISHFR, G. H. (1968) "An experimental comparison of rectilinear and curvilinear illusions." British J. of Psychology 59: 23-28.

16.

FRAISSF, P. and P. VAUTRFY (1956) "The influence of age, sex, and specialized training on the vertical-horizontal illusion." Q. J. of experimental Psychology 8: 114-114.

17.

GARDNER, R. W. (1961) "Cognitive controls of attention deployment as determinants of visual illusions." J. of Abnormal Social Psychology 62: 120-120.

18.

GARDNER, R. W. (1957) "Field-dependence as a determinant of susceptibility to certain illusions." Amer. Psychologist 12: 397-397.

19.

GOUGH, H. G. and R. M. OLTON (1972) "Field dependence as related to non-verbal measures of perceptual performance and cognitive ability." J. of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 38: 338-342.

20.

GREGOR, A. J. and D. A. MacPHERSON (1965) "A study of susceptibility to geometric illusion among cultural subgroups of Australian Aborigines." Psychologia Africana 11: 1-13.

21.

HEISS, A. (1 930) "Zum problem der isolierenden abstraktion." Neue Psychologie Studie 4: 285-318.

22.

HERSKOVITS, M. J. , D. T. CAMPBELL , and M. H. SEGALL (1956) A Cross-Cultural Study of Perception Evanston, Ill.: Northwestern Univ. Press.

23.

HLUSE, G. A. (1957) "Etudes psychologiques sur les noirs Sudannais et Guineens." Revue de Psychologie des Peuples 12: 35-68.

24.

JAHODA, G. (1971) "Retinal pigmentation, illusion susceptibility and space perception." International J. of Psychology 6: 199-208.

25.

JAHODA, G. (1966) "Geometric illusion and environment: a study in Ghana." British J. of Psychology 57: 193-199.

26.

JAHODA, G. and B. STACEY (1970) "Susceptibility to geometric illusions according to culture and professional training." Perception and Psychophysics 7: 179-184.

27.

MacCOBY, E. E. (1967) The Development of Sex Differences. London: Tavistock.

28.

McGURK, E. (1965) "Susceptibility to visual illusions." J. of Psychology 61: 127-143.

29.

MORGAN, P. (1959) "A study in perceptual differences among cultural groups in Southern Africa, using tests of geometric illusion." J. of National Institute for Personnel Research 8: 39-43.

30.

NASH, J. (1970) Developmental Psychology: A Psychobiological Approach. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.

31.

NG, H.-Y. (1969) "The Miller-Lyer illusion." B.A. honors thesis. University of Hong Kong.

32.

OMBREDANE, A. (1954) L'exploration de la mentalites des noir Congolais au moyen d'une epreuve projective de Congo T.A.T. Bruxelles. Belgium: L'Institut Royale Coloniale.

33.

PIAGIT, J. (1969) The Mechanisms of Perception. New York: Basic Books.

34.

PIAGIT, J. (1961) Les mecanismes perceptifs. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.

35.

PIAGIT, J. and B. ALBI`RTINl (1954) "Recherches sur le development des perceptions, XIX. Observations sur la perception des bonnes formes dans l'enfant par actualisation des lignes virtuelles." Archives Psychology (Geneve) 34: 203-243.

36.

PIAGIT, J. (1950) "Recherches sur Ie development des perceptions, XXI. L'illusion de MUller-Lyer." Archives Psychology (Geneve) 34: 155-202.

37.

PlAGFT, J. and A. MORI (1956) "Recherches sur le development des perceptions, XXX. Les comparaisons verticales a faible intervalle." Archives Psychology (Geneve) 35: 289-319.

38.

PIAGIl'T, J. , F. MAIRE , and F. PRIVAT (1954) "Recherches sur le development des perceptions, XVIII. La resistance des bonnes formes a L'illusion de Miiller-Lyer." Archives Psychology (Geneve) 34: 155-202.

39.

POLLACK, R. H. (1970) "Miller-Lyer illusion: effect of age, lightness contrast and hue." Science 170: 93-95.

40.

POLLACK, R. H. (1966) "Temporal range of apparent movement as a function of age and intelligence." Psychonomic Sci. 5: 243-244.

41.

POLLACK, R. H. (1963) "Contour detectability threshold as a function of chronological age." Perceptual and Motor Skills 17: 411-417.

42.

POLLACK, R. H. and S. D. SILVER (1967) "Magnitude of the Miiller-Lyer illusion in children as a function of the pigmentation of the fundus oculi." Psychonomic Sci 8: 83-84.

43.

RIVERS, W.H.R. (1905) "Observations on the senses of the Todas." British J. of Psychology 1: 321-396.

44.

RIVERS, W.H.R. (1901a) "Introduction and vision," in A. C. Haddon (ed.) Reports of the Cambridge Anthropological Expedition to the Torres Straits. Cambridge. Eng.: Cambridge Univ. Press.

45.

RIVERS, W.H.R. (1901b) "Primitive color vision." Popular Sci. Monthly 59: 44-58.

46.

SEGALL, M. H. , D. T. CAMPBELL , and M. J. HERSKOVITS (1966) The Influence of Culture on Visual Perception. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.

47.

RIVERS, W.H.R. (1963) "Cultural differences in the perception of geometric illusions." Science 139: 769-771.

48.

SPITZ, H. H. (1963) "Cross-cultural differences." Science 422-422.

49.

WALTER, A. (1942) "A genetic study of geometrical-optical illusions." Genetic Psych. Monographs 25: 101-155.

50.

WAPNER, S. and H. WERNER (1957) Perceptual Development: An Investigation Within the Framework of Sensory-Tonic Field Theory. Worcester, Mass.: Clark Univ. Press.

51.

WITKIN, H. A. , D. R. GOODENOUGH , and S. A. KARP (1967) "Stability of cognitive style from childhood to young adulthood." J. of Personality and Social Psychology 7: 291-300.

52.

WITKIN, H. A. , R. B. DYK , H. E. PATERSON , D. R. GOODENOUGH , and S. A. KARP (1962) Psychological Ditferentiation. New York: John Wiley.

53.

WITKIN, H. A. , H. B. LEWIS , M. HERTZMAN , R. MACHOVER , P. MLISSNFR , and S. WAPNER (1954) Personality Through Perception. New York: Harper.

54.

WOHLWILL, J. F. (1960) "Developmental studies of perception." Psych. Bull. 57: 249-288.

55.

WURSTEN, H. (1947) "Recherches sur le development des perceptions, IX. L'evolution des comparaisons de longueurs de l'entant a I'adulte avec variation d'angle entre la verticle et l'horizontale." Archives Psychology (Geneve) 32: 1-144.