Following Orders or Following the Oath? Assessing Democratic Norm Endorsement Among Service Academy Cadets

Abstract

How strongly embraced within the officer corps is the commitment to supporting and defending the Constitution and to the ethic of nonpartisanship? This article answers that question through a 2019/2020 survey of 1,470 service academy students, including with a list experiment. The results show that cadets engage in what we term “selective endorsement” of norms, whereby they endorse norms as long as they are not in tension with their partisan identities. In particular, the list experiment reveals that when provided an opportunity to obscure their preferences, many cadets supported following civilian orders, even those at odds with democratic traditions—and that partisan dynamics may play a role in determining how they respond. The article has important implications for scholarly research on norm robustness and socialization, as well as practical consequences for civil-military relations in light of ongoing challenges to democracy in the United States today.

Keywords

democratic institutions armed forces civil-military relations norms domestic politics national security

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bartels

Larry.

2022. “Beyond the Running Tally: Partisan Bias in Political Perceptions,” Political Behavior 24 (2): 133.

Blair

Graeme

Imai

Kosuke

. 2012. “Statistical Analysis of List Experiments.” Political Analysis 20: 47-77.

Brooks

Risa A.

2020. “Paradoxes of Professionalism: Rethinking U.S. Civil-Military Relations.” International Security 44 (4): 7-44.

Brooks

Risa A.

Robinson

Michael A.

Urben

Heidi A.

. 2021. “What Makes a Military Professional? Evaluating Norm Socialization in West Point Cadets.” Armed Forces & Society 48: 803-827.

Brooks

Risa A.

Votel

Joseph L.

. 2020. “11-Rethinking the Norms and Practices of U.S. Civil-Military Relations. [podcast].” International Security: Off the Page.

Brotz

Howard

Wilson

Everett

. 1946. “Characteristics of Military Service.” American Journal of Sociology 51 (5): 371-375.

Burbach

David T.

2018. “Partisan Dimensions of Confidence in the U.S. Military, 1973–2016,” Armed Forces & Society 45 (2): 211-233.

Campbell

Angus

Converse

Philip E.

Miller

Warren E.

Stokes

Donald E.

1960. The American Voter. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Canter

Sam

. 2020. “Generals Are People Too: And Their Involvement in Politics is Part of the American Tradition.” Real Clear Defense. July 1.

10.

Carforio

Giuseppe

. 2018. “Military Officer Education.” Handbook of the Sociology of the Military, 2nd ed., edited by Carforio

Giuseppe

Nuciari

Marina

. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.

11.

Checkel

Jeffrey T.

2017. “Socialization and Violence.” Journal of Peace Research 54 (5): 592-605.

12.

Cillizza

Chris

Williams

Brenna

. 2019. “15 Times Donald Trump Praised Authoritarian Leaders.” CNN, July 2.

13.

Corstange

Daniel

. 2009. “Sensitive Questions, Truthful Answers? Modeling the List Experiment with LISTIT.” Political Analysis 17, no. 1 (Winter): 45-63.

14.

Dalton

Chris

. 2021. “Why the Military Should Educate its Members About the Constitution.” Military Times, February 10.

15.

Dempsey

Jason

. 2010. Our Army: Soldiers, Politics, and American Civil-Military Relations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

16.

Dempsey

Martin E.

2012. “From the Chairman: Putting Our Nation First.” Joint Force Quarterly 65 (April 2012): 4-5.

17.

Deitelhoff

Nicole

Zimmermann

Lisbeth

. 2019. “Norms Under Challenge: Unpacking the Dynamics of Norm Robustness.” Journal of Global Security Studies, 4, no. 1 (January): 2-17.

18.

Dornbusch

Sanford M.

1955. “The Military Academy as an Assimilating Institution.” Social Forces 33 (4): 316-321.

19.

Droitcour

Caspar

R. A.

Hubbard

M. L.

Parsley

T. L.

Visscher

Ezzati

T. M.

. 1991. The item count technique as a method of indirect questioning: a review of its development and a case study application. In Measurement Errors in Surveys, edited by Biemer

P. P.

Groves

R. M.

Lyberg

L. E.

Mathiowetz

N. A.

Sudman

, 185-210. New York: Wiley.

20.

Drutman

Lee

Goldman

Joe

Diamond

Larry

. 2020. “Democracy Maybe: Attitudes on Authoritarianism in America.” Democracy Fund Voter Study Group.

21.

Dunford

Joseph F.

Jr.

2016. “Upholding Our Oath.” Joint Force Quarterly 82 (July 2016): 2-3.

22.

Farrell

Theo

. 2005. “World Culture and Military Power,” Security Studies 14 (3): 448-488.

23.

Feaver

Peter D.

Kohn

Richard H.

. 2001. Soldiers and Civilians: The Civil-Military Gap and American National Security. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

24.

Feaver

Peter

. 2023. Thanks for Your Service. Oxford University Press (forthcoming).

25.

Finney

Nathan K.

Mayfield

Tyrell O.

. 2018. Redefining the Modern Military: The Intersection of Profession and Ethics. Annapolis: Naval Institute Press.

26.

Gallup , 2022. “Healthcare System,” accessed July 27, 2022.https://news.gallup.com/poll/4708/healthcare-system.aspx

27.

Gilens

Martin

Sniderman

Paul M.

Kuklinski

James H.

. 1998. “Affirmative Action and the Politics of Realignment.” British Journal of Political Science 28, no. 1 (January): 159-183.

28.

Glynn

Adam N.

2013. “What Can We Learn with Statistical Truth Serum? Design and Anlysis of the List Experiment.” Public Opinion Quarterly 77: 159-72.

29.

Graham

Matthew H.

Svolik

Milan W.

. 2020. “Democracy in America? Partisanship, Polarization, and the Robustness of Support for Democracy in the United States.” American Journal of Political Science 114 (2): 392-402.

30.

Hammill

John P.

Segal

David R.

Segal

Mady Wechsler

. 1995. “Self-Selection and Parental Socioeconomic Status as Determinants of the Values of West Point Cadets.” Armed Forces & Society 22, no. 1 (Fall): 113.

31.

Hoover Green

Amelia

. 2016. “The Commander’s Dilemma: Creating and Controlling Armed Group Violence.” Journal of Peace Research 53 (5): 621.

32.

Imai

Kosuke

. 2011. “Multivariate Regression Analysis for the Item Count Technique.” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 106: 407-416.

33.

Jones

Dustin

. 2021. “Joint Chiefs Remind U.S. Forces That They Defend the Constitution.” NPR, January 12, 2021.

34.

Kelty

Ryan

Kleykamp

Meredith

Segal

David R.

. 2010. “The Military and the Transition to Adulthood.” The Future of Children 20 (1): 181-207.

35.

Kleykamp

Meredith

Hipes

Crosby

MacLean

Alair

. 2018. “Who Supports U.S. Veterans and Who Exaggerates Their Support?” Armed Forces & Society 44, no. 1 (Fall): 92-115.

36.

Kramon

Eric

Weghorst

Keith

. 2019. “(Mis)Measuring Sensitive Attitudes with the List Experiment”, Public Opinion Quarterly 83: 236-263.

37.

Krebs

Ronald R.

Ralston

Robert

Rapport

Aaron

. 2021. “No Right to Be Wrong: What Americans Think About Civil-Military Relations.” Perspectives on Politics, 11 March.

38.

Kuklinski

J. H.

Cobb

M. D.

Gilens

. 1997. “Racial Attitudes And the “New South”. Journal of Politics 59 (2): 323-349.

39.

Legros

Sophie

Cislaghi

Beniamino

. 2020. “Mapping the Social-Norms Literature: An Overview of Reviews.” Perspectives on Psychological Science 15 (1): 62-80.

40.

Marshall

Samuel L. A.

2000. Men against Fire: The Problem of Battle Command. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press.

41.

Miles Joyce

Renanah

. 2022. “Soldiers’ Dilemma: Foreign Military Training and Liberal Norm Conflict,” International Security 46 (4): 48-90.

42.

Milley

Mark

. 2020. National Defense University Commencement Address. Washington, D.C.: Speech, National Defense University, June 11, 2020.

43.

Moskos

Charles. C.

1975. “The American Combat Soldier in Vietnam.” Journal of Social Issues 31, no. 4 (Fall): 25-37.

44.

Mullen

Michael G.

2008. “From the Chairman: Military Must Stay Apolitical.” Joint Force Quarterly 50 (July 2008): 2-3.

45.

Robinson

Michael A.

Cohn

Lindsay P.

Margulies

Max Z.

. 2020. “Dissents and Sensibility: Conflicting Loyalties, Democracy, and Civil-Military Relations.” In Reconsidering American Civil-Military Relations, edited by Beehner

Lionel

Brooks

Risa

Mauer

Dan

, 63-84.

46.

Rosenfleld

Bryn

Imai

Kosuke

Shapiro

Jacob N.

, 2016. “An Empirical Validation Study of Popular Survey Methodologies for Sensitive Questions”, American Journal of Political Science 60: 783-802.

47.

Sanchez Cuenca

Ignacio

, 2017. “From a Deficit of Democracy to a Technocratic Order,” Annual Review of Political Science 20: 351-369.

48.

Snider

Don M.

2002. “The U.S. Army as Profession.” In The Future of the Army Profession, edited by Snider

Don M.

Matthews

Lloyd J.

, 14. Boston: McGraw-Hill.

49.

Snider

Don M.

Priest

Robert F.

Lewis

Felisa

. 2001. “The Civilian-Military Gap and Professional Military Education at the Precommissioning Level.” Armed Forces & Society 27, no. 2 (Winter): 249-272.

50.

Sniderman

Paul M.

Carmines

Edward G.

. 1997. “Reaching Beyond Race.” PS: Political Science & Politics 30 (3): 466-471.

51.

Solender

Andrew

. 2020. “Trump Says He Will ‘Negotiate’ Third Term Because He’s ‘Entitled’ to It.” Forbes. September 13. https://www.forbes.com/sites/andrewsolender/2020/09/13/trump-says-he-will-negotiate-third-term-because-hes-entitled-to-it/?sh=97077e0287cb

52.

Svolik

Milan W.

2020. “When Polarization Trumps Civic Virtue: Partisan Conflict and the Subversion of Democracy by Incumbents,” Quarterly Journal of Political Science 15: 3-31.

53.

Tankel

Stephen

. 2020. “Trump’s Moves Are Right Out of the Authoritarian Playbook.” Just Security, June 3.

54.

Thornhill

Paula

. 2021. “How to Teach Troops About the Constitution.” Defense One, February 18, 2021.

55.

Tsuchiya

Hirai

Ono

. 2007. “A Study of the Properties of the Item Count Technique.” Public Opinion Quarterly 71 (2): 253-272.

56.

Ulrich

Marybeth P.

2020. “Civil-Military Relations Norms and Democracy: What Every Citizen Should Know.” In Reconsidering American Civil-Military Relations, edited by Beehner

Brooks

, and Maurer , 41-62.

57.

Urben

Heidi A.

2021. Party, Politics, and the Post-9/11 Army. Amherst, NY: Cambria Press.

58.

Villatoro

Daniel

Andrighetto

Guila

Conte

Rosaria

Sabater-Mir

Jordi

. 2015. “Self-Policing Through Norm Internalization,” Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation 18 (2): 1-16.

59.

Weber

Christopher

Federico

Christopher

Feldman

Stanley

. 2017. How Authoritarianism Is Shaping American Politics (And It’s Not Just about Trump. Washington Post: Monkey Cage, May 10.

60.

Wolter

Felix

Laier

Bastian

. 2014. “The Effectiveness of the Item Count Technique in Eliciting Valid Answers to Sensitive Questions. An Evaluation in the Context of Self-Reported Delinquency.” Survey Research Methods 8 (3): 153-168.

61.

Zaller

John

. 1992. The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.14 MB

0.00 MB

1.46 MB