In intractable conflicts, what factors lead populations to accept negotiated outcomes? To examine these issues, we conduct a survey experiment on a representative sample of the Jewish Israeli population and a companion experiment on a representative sample of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza. We find that holding the negotiated settlement outcome constant, approval of the settlement is strongly influenced by whether it is framed as a negotiating defeat for one side—if and only if respondents are primed to be indignant—and that these effects are strongly mediated by perceptions of the fairness of the settlement outcome. Moral indignation produces a desire for concessions for concession’s sake. Such conflicts over political framing violate assumptions of the rationalist literature on conflict processes and suggest important new directions for conflict theorizing.
AlbinCecilia. 2001. Justice and Fairness in International Negotiation. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
2.
AlbinCeciliaDruckmanDaniel. 2012. “Equality matters: Negotiating an end to civil wars.” Journal of Conflict Resolution56:155–73.
3.
AndrighettoG.CastelfranchiC.MayorE.McBreenJ.Lopez-SanchezM.ParsonsS.2013. “(Social) Norm Dynamics.” In Dagstuhl Follow-Ups (Vol. 4). Schloss Dagstuhl-Leibniz-Zentrum fuer Informatik.
4.
AngieAmanda D.ConnellyShaneWaplesEthan P.KligyteVykinta. 2011. “The Influence of Discrete Emotions on Judgement and Decision-making: A Meta-analytic Review.” Cognition & Emotion25 (8): 1393–422.
5.
Bar-TalDaniel. 2013. Intractable Conflicts: Socio-psychological Foundations and Dynamics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
6.
BarnhartJoslyn N.2016. “Status Competition and Territorial Aggression: Evidence from the Scramble for Africa.” Security Studies25 (3): 385–419.
7.
BarrettLisa Feldman. 2006. “Solving the Emotion Paradox: Categorization and the Experience of Emotion.” Personality and Social Psychology Review10 (1): 20–46.
8.
BerinskyAdam J.2009. In Time of War: Understanding American Public Opinion from World War II to Iraq. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
9.
BerkowitzLeonard. 2010. “Appraisals and Anger: How Complete are the Usual Appraisal Accounts of Anger?.” In International Handbook of Anger, 267–286. New York, NY: Springer.
10.
BlountSally. 1995. “When Social Outcomes aren't Fair: The Effect of Causal Attributions on Preferences.“ Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes63 (2): 131–44.
11.
BraderTed. 2006. Campaigning for Hearts and Minds: How Emotional Appeals in Political Ads Work. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
12.
BraderTedMarcusGeorge E.. 2013. “Emotion and Political Psychology.” The Oxford Handbook of Political Psychology2:165–204.
13.
BraderTedValentinoNicholas A.. 2007. “Identities, Interests, and Emotions: Symbolic versus Material Wellsprings of Fear, Anger, and Enthusiasm.” In The Affect Effect: Dynamics of Emotion in Political Thinking and Behavior, edited by Russell NeumanW.MarcusGeorge E.CriglerAnn N.MackuenMichael, 180–201. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
CasperJonathan D.TylerTomFisherBonnie. 1988. “Procedural Justice in Felony Cases.” Law and Society Review22:483–507.
16.
Cheung-BlundenVioletBlundenBill. 2008. “The Emotional Construal of War: Anger, Fear, and Other Negative Emotions.” Peace and Conflict14 (2): 123–50.
17.
Cohen-ChenSmadarHalperinEranCrispRichard J.GrossJames J.. 2014. “Hope in the Middle East Malleability Beliefs, Hope, and the Willingness to Compromise for Peace.” Social Psychological and Personality Science5 (1):67–75.
18.
CollS.2009. “The Back Channel: India and Pakistan’s Secret Kashmir Talks.” The New Yorker, March 2.
CrawfordNeta C.2000. “The Passion of World Politics: Propositions on Emotion and Emotional Relationships.” International Security24 (4): 116–56.
21.
DecetyJeanYoderKeith J.. 2017. “The Emerging Social Neuroscience of Justice Motivation.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences21 (1): 6–14.
22.
DawesRobyn M.ThalerRichard H.. 1988. “Anomalies: Cooperation.” The Journal of Economic Perspectives2:187–97.
23.
DeStenoDavidPettyRichard E.RuckerDerek D.WegenerDuane T.BravermanJulia. 2004. “Discrete Emotions and Persuasion: The Role of Emotion-induced Expectancies.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology86 (1): 43.
24.
DeStenoDavidPettyRichard E.WegenerDuane T.RuckerDerek D.. 2000. “Beyond Valence in the Perception of Likelihood: The Role of Emotion Specificity.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology78 (3): 397.
25.
DruckmanDanielAlbinCecilia. 2011. “Distributive Justice and the Durability of Negotiated Agreements.” Review of International Studies37 (3): 1137–68.
26.
DruckmanJames N.McDermottRose. 2008. “Emotion and the Framing of Risky Choice.” Political Behavior30 (3): 297–321.
27.
DufwenbergM.KirchsteigerG.. 1999. A Theory of Sequential Reciprocity (discussion paper). CentER, Tilburg University.
28.
EskineKendall J.KacinikNatalie A.PrinzJesse J.. 2011. “A Bad Taste in the Mouth Gustatory Disgust Influences Moral Judgment.” Psychological Science22 (3): 295–99.
29.
FearonJames D.1994. “Domestic Political Audiences and the Escalation of International Disputes.” American Political Science Review88 (3): 577–92.
30.
FearonJames D.1995. “Rationalist Explanations for War.” International Organization49:379.
31.
FiskeAlan PageRaiTage Shakti. 2014. Virtuous Violence: Hurting and Killing to Create, Sustain, End, and Honor Social Relationships. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
32.
ForgasJoseph P.TanHui Bing. 2013. “Mood Effects on Selfishness versus Fairness: Affective Influences on Social Decisions in the Ultimatum Game.” Social Cognition31 (4): 504–17.
33.
FoyleDouglas C.1999. Counting the Public In: Presidents, Public Opinion, and Foreign Policy. New York: Columbia University Press.
34.
FranckThomas M.1995. Fairness in International Law and Institutions. New York: Oxford University Press.
35.
GayerCorinna CarmenLandmanShiriHalperinEranBar-TalDaniel. 2009. “Overcoming Psychological Barriers to Peaceful Conflict Resolution: The Role of Arguments about Losses.” Journal of Conflict Resolution53 (6): 951–75.
36.
GiacaloneRobert A.GreenbergJerald, eds. 1997. Antisocial Behavior in Organizations. Sage.
37.
GingesJeremyAtranScott. 2009. “What Motivates Participation in Violent Political Action.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences1167 (1): 115–23.
38.
GingesJeremyAtranScottMedinDouglasShikakiKhalil. 2007. “Sacred Bounds on Rational Resolution of Violent Political Conflict.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences104 (18): 7357–60.
39.
GingesJeremyAtranScottSachdevaSonyaMedinDouglas. 2011. “Psychology out of the Laboratory: The Challenge of Violent Extremism.” American Psychologist66 (6): 507.
40.
GoddardStacie E.2009. “When Right Makes Might: How Prussia Overturned the European Balance of Power.” International Security33 (3): 110–42.
41.
GottfriedMatthew S.TragerRobert F.. 2016. “A Preference for War: How Fairness and Rhetoric Influence Leadership Incentives in Crises.” International Studies Quarterly60:243–57.
42.
GriskeviciusVladasShiotaMichelle N.NeufeldSamantha L.. 2010. “Influence of Different Positive Emotions on Persuasion Processing: A Functional Evolutionary Approach.” Emotion10 (2): 190.
43.
GrobeDeanaDouthittRobinZepedaLydia. 1999. “A Model of Consumers’ Risk Perceptions toward Recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone (rbGH): The Impact of Risk Characteristics.” Risk Analysis19 (4): 661–73.
44.
HaidtJonathan. 2001. “The Emotional Dog and Its Rational Tail: A Social Intuitionist Approach to Moral Judgment.” Psychological Review108 (4): 814.
HallTodd H.2011. “We Will Not Swallow This Bitter Fruit: Theorizing a Diplomacy of Anger.” Security Studies20 (4): 521–55.
47.
HallTodd H.2015. Emotional Diplomacy: Official Emotion on the International Stage. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
48.
HallTodd H.RossAndrew A. G.. 2015. “Affective Politics after 9/11.” International Organization69 (04): 847–79.
49.
HalperinEran. 2011. “Emotional Barriers to Peace: Emotions and Public Opinion of Jewish Israelis about the Peace Process in the Middle East.” Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology17 (1): 22.
50.
HalperinEranGrossJames J.. 2011. “Intergroup Anger in Intractable Conflict: Long-Term Sentiments Predict Anger Responses During the Gaza War.” Group Processes & Intergroup Relations14 (4): 477–88.
51.
HalperinEranCohen-ChenSmadarGoldenbergAmit. 2014. “Indirect Emotion Regulation in Intractable Conflicts: A New Approach to Conflict Resolution.” European Review of Social Psychology25 (1): 1–31.
52.
HassnerRon. 2009. War on Sacred Grounds. New York: Cornell University Press.
53.
HeusslerTobiasHuberFrankMeyerFrederikVollhardtKaiAhlertDieter. 2009. “Moderating Effects of Emotion on the Perceived Fairness of Price Increases.” Advances in Consumer Research36:332–38.
54.
HodsonGordonCostelloKimberly. 2007. “Interpersonal Disgust, Ideological Orientations, and Dehumanization as Predictors of Intergroup Attitudes.” Psychological Science18 (8): 691–98.
55.
HorbergE. J.OveisChristopherKeltnerDacherCohenAdam B.. 2009. “Disgust and the Moralization of Purity.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology97 (6): 963.
56.
ImaiKosukeKeeleLukeTingleyDustin. 2010. “A General Approach to Causal Mediation Analysis.” Psychological Methods15 (4): 309.
57.
IvanCristina-Elena. 2015. “On Disgust and Moral Judgments: A Review.” Journal of European Psychology Students6 (1): 25–36.
58.
JohnsonEric J.TverskyAmos. 1983. “Affect, Generalization, and the Perception of Risk.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology45 (1): 20.
KapsteinEthan B.2006. Economic Justice in an Unfair World: Toward a Level Playing Field. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
61.
KapsteinEthan B.2008. “Fairness Considerations: Lessons from International Trade Negotiations.” Political Science Quarterly123 (2): 229–45.
62.
KaufmanStuart J.2001. Modern Hatreds: The Symbolic Politics of Ethnic War. Cornell University Press.
63.
KaufmanStuart J.2006. “Escaping the Symbolic Politics Trap: Reconciliation Initiatives and Conflict Resolution in Ethnic Wars.” Journal of Peace Research43 (2): 201–18.
64.
KaufmanStuart J.2009. “Narratives and Symbols in Violent Mobilization: The Palestinian-Israeli Case.” Security Studies18 (3): 400–34.
65.
KertzerJoshua D.BrutgerRyan. 2015. “Decomposing Audience Costs: Bringing the Audience Back into Audience Cost Theory.” American Journal of Political Science60:234–49.
66.
KertzerJoshua D.PowersKathleen E.RathbunBrian C.IyerRavi. 2014. “Moral Support: How Moral Values Shape Foreign Policy Attitudes.” The Journal of Politics76 (03): 825–40.
67.
KertzerJoshua D.RathbunBrian C.. 2015. “Fair Is Fair: Social Preferences and Reciprocity in International Politics.” World Politics67 (4): 613–55.
68.
KeynesJohn Maynard. 2013. The Economic Consequences of the Peace. London, UK: Courier Corporation.
69.
KyddAndrew. 2005. Trust and Mistrust in International Relations. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
70.
KyddAndrewWalterBarbara F.. 2002. “Sabotaging the Peace: The Politics of Extremist Violence.” International Organization56 (02): 263–96.
71.
LandlsJean M.GoodsteinLynne. 1986. “When Is Justice Fair? An Integrated Approach to the Outcome versus Procedure Debate.” Law & Social Inquiry11 (4): 675–704.
72.
LechelerSophieSchuckAndreas R. T.VreeseClaes H. de. 2013. “Dealing with Feelings: Positive and Negative Discrete Emotions as Mediators of News Framing Effects.” Communications38 (2): 189–209.
73.
LevineDavid K.1998. “Modeling Altruism and Spitefulness in Experiments.” Review of Economic Dynamics1 (3): 593–622.
74.
LevyJack S.1992. “Prospect Theory and International Relations: Theoretical Applications and Analytical Problems.” Political Psychology13:283–310.
75.
LindJennifer. 2011. “2. An Unhappy Phase in a Certain Period.” In Sorry States, 26–100. Cornell University Press.
76.
ManekinDevorahGrossmanGuyMittsTamar. 2019. “Contested Ground: Disentangling Material and Symbolic Attachment to Disputed Territory.” Political Science Research and Methods7:679–97.
77.
MaozIfatMcCauleyClark. 2009. “Threat Perceptions and Feelings as Predictors of Jewish-Israeli Support for Compromise with Palestinians.” Journal of Peace Research46 (4): 525–39.
78.
MaozIfatWardAndrewKatzMichaelRossLee. 2002. “Reactive Devaluation of an ‘Israeli’ vs. ‘Palestinian’ Peace Proposal.” Journal of Conflict Resolution46 (4): 515–46.
79.
MarcusGeorge E.2000. “Emotions in Politics.” Annual Review of Political Science3 (1): 221–50.
80.
MatanockAila M.Garbiras-DazNatalia. 2018. “Considering Concessions: A Survey Experiment on the Colombian Peace Process.” Conflict Management and Peace Science35 (6): 637–55.
81.
MatsumotoDavidFrankMark G.HwangHyisung C.. 2015. “The Role of Intergroup Emotions in Political Violence.” Current Directions in Psychological Science24 (5): 369–73.
82.
MercerJonathan. 2010. “Emotional Beliefs.” International Organization64 (01): 1–31.
83.
MollJorgede Oliveira-SouzaRicardoMollFernanda TovarIgnácioFátima AzevedoBramatiIvanei E.Caparelli-DáquerEgas M.EslingerPaul J.. 2005. “The Moral Affiliations of Disgust: A Functional MRI Study.” Cognitive and Behavioral Neurology18 (1): 68–78.
84.
MessickDavid M.SentisKeith P.. 1979. “Fairness and Preference.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology15 (4): 418–34.
85.
MiceliMariaCastelfranchiCristiano. 2019. “Anger and its Cousins.” Emotion Review11 (1): 13–26.
86.
MollJorgede Oliveira-SouzaRicardo. 2007. “Moral Judgments, Emotions and the Utilitarian Brain.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences11 (8): 319–21.
87.
NabiRobin L.2010. “The Case for Emphasizing Discrete Emotions in Communication Research.” Communication Monographs77 (2): 153–59.
88.
NabiRobin L.DillardJames P.PfauM.. 2002. “Discrete Emotions and Persuasion.” In The Persuasion Handbook: Developments in Theory and Practice, edited by DillardJames PricePfauMichael, 289–308. Thousands Oaks, CA: Sage.
89.
O’Neill, Barry. 2001. “Risk Aversion in International Relations Theory.” International Studies Quarterly45 (4): 617–40.
90.
PetersenRoger D.2011. Western Intervention in the Balkans: the Strategic use of Emotion in Conflict. Cambridge University Press.
91.
PetersenRogerZukermanSarah. 2010. “Anger, Violence, and Political Science.” In International Handbook of Anger, 561–81. New York, NY: Springer.
92.
PettyRichard E.DeStenoDavidRuckerDerek D.. 2001. “The Role of Affect in Attitude Change.” In Handbook of Affect and Social Cognition, edited by ForgasJoseph P., 212–33. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
93.
PickettJustin T.BakerThomasMetcalfeChristiGertzMarcBellandiRose. 2014. “Contact and Compromise Explaining Support for Conciliatory Measures in the Context of Violent Intergroup Conflict.” Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency50: 272–99.
94.
RabinMatthew. 1998. “Psychology and Economics.” Journal of Economic Literature36 (1): 11–46.
95.
RenshonJonathanLernerJennifer. 2012. “The Role of Emotions in Foreign Policy Decision Making.” In Encyclopedia of Peace Psychology, edited by ChristieDaniel J.MontielCristina, 313–17. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell Press.
96.
RossAndrew A. G.2013. Mixed Emotions: Beyond Fear and Hatred in International Conflict. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
97.
RossLeeWardAndrew. 1995. “Psychological Barriers to Dispute Resolution.” In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 27, 255–304. Academic Press.
98.
RozinP.LoweryL.ImadaS.HaidtJ.. 1999. “The CAD Triad Hypothesis: A Mapping between Three Moral Emotions (Contempt, Anger, Disgust) and Three Moral Codes (Community, Autonomy, Divinity).” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology76 (4): 574.
99.
SabucedoJosé-ManuelDuránMónica Alzate MarRodríguezMaría-Soledad. 2011. “Emotional Responses and Attitudes to the Peace Talks with ETA.” Revista Latinoamericana de Psicología43 (2): 289–96.
100.
SandmanPeter M.MillerPaul M.JohnsonBranden B.WeinsteinNeil D.. 1993. “Agency Communication, Community Outrage, and Perception of Risk: Three Simulation Experiments.” Risk Analysis13 (6): 585–98.
101.
SchnallSimoneHaidtJonathanCloreGerald L.JordanAlexander H.. 2008. “Disgust as Embodied Moral Judgment.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin34: 1096–109.
102.
SchultzKenneth. 2001. Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
103.
ShapiroRobert Y.2011. “Public Opinion and American Democracy.” Public Opinion Quarterly75 (5): 982–1017.
104.
SheaferTamirDvir-GvirsmanShira. 2010. “The Spoiler Effect: Framing Attitudes and Expectations toward Peace.” Journal of Peace Research47 (2): 205–15.
105.
SpezioMichael L.AdolphsRalph. 2007. “Emotional Processing and Political Judgment: Toward Integrating Political Psychology and Decision Neuroscience.” In The Affect Effect: Dynamics of Emotion in Political Thinking and Behavior, edited by NeumannW. R.MarcusG. E.CriglerA. N.MacKuenM., 71–95. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
106.
SpielbergerCharles D.ReheiserEric C.. 2010. “The Nature and Measurement of Anger.” In International Handbook of Anger, 403–412. New York, NY: Springer.
107.
SteinJanice Gross. 2008. “Foreign Policy Decision Making: Rational, Psychological, and Neurological Models.” In Foreign Policy: Theories, Actors, Cases, edited by SmithSteveHadfieldAmeliaDunneTimothy, 101–16. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
108.
SteinRachel. 2015. “War and Revenge: Explaining Conflict Initiation by Democracies.” American Political Science Review109 (3): 556–73.
109.
SunsteinCass R.2008. “Some Effects of Moral Indignation on Law.” Vt. L. Rev. 33: 405.
110.
SvenssonIsak. 2007. “Fighting with Faith Religion and Conflict Resolution in Civil Wars.” Journal of Conflict Resolution51 (6): 930–49.
111.
TomzMichael. 2007. “Domestic Audience Costs in International Relations: An Experimental Approach.” International Organization61 (4): 821–40.
TragerRobert F.2015. “Diplomatic Signaling among Multiple States.” The Journal of Politics77 (3): 635–47.
114.
TragerRobert F.VavreckLynn. 2011. “The Political Costs of Crisis Bargaining: Presidential Rhetoric and the Role of Party.” American Journal Political Science55 (3): 526–45.
115.
TylerTom R.1988. “What Is Procedural Justice-criteria Used by Citizens to Assess the Fairness of Legal Procedures.” Law & Society Review22:103.
116.
UgazioGiuseppeLammClausSingerTania. 2012. “The Role of Emotions for Moral Judgments Depends on the Type of Emotion and Moral Scenario.” Emotion12 (3): 579.
117.
WegenerDuane T.PettyRichard E.. 1994. “Mood Management across Affective States: The Hedonic Contingency Hypothesis.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology66 (6): 1034.
118.
WiedemannPeter M.ClaubergMartinSchiitzHolger. 2003. “Understanding Amplification of Complex Risk Issues: The Risk Story Model Applied to the EMF Case.” In The Social Amplification of Risk, edited by PidgeonNickKaspersonRoger E.SlovicPaul, 286–304. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
119.
WongSeanon S.2015. “Emotions and the Communication of Intentions in Face-to-face Diplomacy.” European Journal of International Relations22:144–67.
120.
ZartmanWilliamFaureGuy. 2005. Escalation and Negotiation in International Conflicts. New York: Cambridge University Press.
121.
ZellmanAriel. 2015. “Framing Consensus: Evaluating the Narrative Specificity of Territorial Indivisibility.” Journal of Peace Research52 (4): 492–507.
122.
ZellmanAriel. 2019. “‘Hawking’ Territorial Conflict: Ethnopopulism and Nationalist Framing Strategies.” East European Politics35 (4): 474–95.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
