Scholars think that friendly nations adopt secrecy to avoid domestic costs and facilitate cooperation. But this article uncovers a historical puzzle. Between 1870 and 1916, over 80 percent of alliance ties were partially or completely covert. Otherwise, hidden pacts are rare. Why was secrecy prevalent in this particular period and not others? This article presents a theory of “portfolio consistency.” Public agreements undermine the rank of hidden alliances. A partner willing to openly commit to another country but not to you signals the increased importance of this other relationship. States pressure their covert partners to avoid subsequent public pacts. This creates a network effect: the more secret partners a state has, the greater the incentives to maintain secrecy in later military agreements. Covert alliances have a cumulative effect. In seeking the flexibility of hidden partnerships, states can lock themselves into a rigid adherence to secrecy.
AltonjiJosephElderToddTaberChristopher. 2005. “Selection on Observed and Unobserved Variables: Assessing the Effectiveness of Catholic Schools.” Journal of Political Economy113 (1): 151–84.
2.
AndrassyJulius. 1927. Bismarck, Andrassy, and Their Successors. London, UK: T. Fisher Unwin.
3.
BarnesJ. A.1994. A Pack of Lies: Towards a Sociology of Lying. New York: Cambridge University Press.
4.
BasMuhammetSchubRobert. 2016. “Mutual Optimism as a Cause of Conflict: Secret Alliances and Conflict Onset.” International Studies Quarterly60 (3): 552–64.
5.
BaumMatthew A. 2004. “Going Private.” Journal of Conflict Resolution48 (5): 603–31. doi:10.1177/0022002704267764.
6.
BrownMarvin. 1973. Heinrich von Haymerle. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.
7.
BurrW.KimballJ.. 2003. “Nixon’s Secret Nuclear Alert: Vietnam War Diplomacy and the Joint Chiefs of Staff Readiness Test, October 1969.” Cold War History3 (2): 113–56.
8.
CarsonAustin. 2016. “Facing Off and Saving Face: Covert Intervention and Escalation Management in the Korean War.” International Organization70:103–31.
9.
CarsonAustinYarhi-MiloK.. 2017. “Covert Communication: The Intelligibility and Credibility of Signaling in Secret.” Security Studies26 (1): 124–56.
10.
CasoL.GnisciA.VrijA.MannS.. 2005. “Processes Underlying Deception: An Empirical Analysis of Truths and Lies When Manipulating the Stakes.” Journal of Interviewing and Offender Profiling2:195–202.
11.
CrawfordVincent. 2003. “Lying for Strategic Advantage.” The American Economic Review93 (1): 133–49.
12.
CrescenziMark J. C.KathmanJacobKleinbergKatjaWoodReed. 2009. “Reliability, Reputation, and Alliance Formation.” Prepared for the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, Toronto, CA.
13.
DeeksAshley. 2017. “A (Qualified) Defense of Secret Agreements.” Arizona State Law Journal49:713–94.
14.
DePauloB. M.LindsayJ. L.MaloneB. E.MuhlenbruckL.CharltonK.CooperH.. 2003. “Cues to Deception.” Psychological Bulletin129:74–118.
15.
DingmanRoger. 1988. “Atomic Diplomacy during the Korean War.” International Security13 (3): 50–91.
DonnoDaniela. 2010. “Who Is Punished? Regional Intergovernmental Organizations and the Enforcement of Democratic Norms.” International Organization64 (4): 593–625.
18.
DownsGeorge W.RockeDavid M.. 1987. “Tacit Bargaining and Arms Control.” World Politics39:297–325.
19.
DugdaleE. T. S., ed. 1928. German Diplomatic Documents, 1871–1914, vol. 1. London, UK: Methuen.
FearonJames. 1994. “Domestic Political Audiences and the Escalation of International Disputes.” American Political Science Review88 (3): 577–92.
22.
FearonJames D.1995. “Rationalist Explanations for War.” International Organization45 (3): 379–414.
23.
FordhamBenjaminPoastPaul. 2014. “All Alliances Are Multilateral: Rethinking Alliance Formation in an International System.” Journal of Conflict Resolution58 (2): 307–35.
24.
FRUS. 1957. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1955-1957. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Accessed June 13, 2017. http://digital.library.wisc.edu/1711.dl/FRUS.
25.
GibbsDavid. 1995. “Secrecy and International Relations.” Journal of Peace Research32 (2): 213–28.
26.
GiblerD.2008. International Military Alliances, 1648-2008. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
27.
GilbertD. T.1991. “How Mental Systems Believe.” American Psychologist46:107–19.
28.
GilpinRobert. 1981. War and Change in International Politics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
GranhagP. A.StrmwallL. A.. 2002. “Repeated Interrogations: Verbal and Nonverbal Cues to Deception.” Applied Cognitive Psychology16:243–57.
31.
GreenhillBrian. 2010. “The Company You Keep: International Socialization and the Diffusion of Human Rights Norms.” International Studies Quarterly54 (1): 127–45.
32.
HallToddYarhi-MiloK.. 2012. “The Personal Touch: Leaders? Impressions, Costly Signaling, and Assessments of Sincerity in International Affairs.” International Studies Quarterly56 (3): 560–73.
33.
HandelMichael. 1990. Weak States in the International System. London, UK: Frank Cass.
34.
HartwigM.GranhagP. A.StrmwallL.KronkvistO.. 2006. “Strategic Use of Evidence during Police Interrogations: When Training to Detect Deception Works.” Law and Human Behavior30:603–19.
35.
HeckmanJames. 1979. “Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error.” Econometrica47 (1): 153–61.
36.
HolmesMarcus. 2013. “The Force of Face-to-face Diplomacy: Mirror Neurons and the Problem of Intentions.” International Organization67 (4): 829–61.
37.
IkenberryG. John. 2001. After Victory: Institutions, Strategic Restraint, and the Rebuilding of Order after Major Wars. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
38.
JaggersK.MarshallM.. 2007. “Polity IV Project: Political Regime Characteristics and Transitions, 1800-2006.” Vienna, VA: Center for Systemic Peace Data Manual.
39.
JobBrian. 1992. “The Insecurity Dilemma: National, Regime, and State Securities in the Third World.” In The Insecurity Dilemma, edited by JobBrian, 81–93. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
40.
KingGaryZengLangche. 2001. “Explaining Rare Events in International Relations.” International Organization55 (3): 693–715.
41.
KleinJamesGoertzGaryDiehlPaul F.. 2006. “The New Rivalry Dataset: Procedures and Patterns.” Journal of Peace Research43 (3): 331–48.
42.
KlierThomas H.McMillenDan. 2005. “Clustering of Auto Supplier Plants in the U.S.: GMM Spatial Logit for Large Samples.” Working Paper Series WP-05-18, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. Accessed August 20, 2014. http://ideas.repec.org/p/fip/fedhwp/wp-05-18.html.
43.
KomerRobert. 1986. “Problems of Over-extension: Reconciling NATO Defence and Out-of-area Contingencies.” The Adelphi Papers26 (207): 60–67.
44.
KurizakiShuhei. 2007. “Efficient Secrecy: Public versus Private Threats in Crisis Diplomacy.” American Political Science Review101 (3): 543–58.
45.
LakeDavid A.2009. Hierarchy in International Relations. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
46.
LangerWilliam. 1931. European Alliances and Alignments, 1871-1890. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
47.
LeedsBrett Ashley. 2003. “Do Alliances Deter Aggression? The Influence of Military Alliances on the Initiation of Militarized Interstate Disputes.” American Journal of Political Science47 (3): 427–39.
48.
LeedsB. A.MattesM.. 2015. “Change in Source of Leader Support (CHISOLS) Dataset.” Accessed May 15, 2017. http://www.chisols.org/.
49.
LeedsBrett AshleyRitterJeffreyMitchellSara McLaughlinLongAndrew. 2002. “Alliance Treaty Obligations and Provisions, 1815-1944.” International Interactions28:237–60.
50.
LevenduskyMatthewHorowitzMichael. 2012. “When Backing Down Is the Right Decision: Partisanship, New Information, and Audience Costs.” Journal of Politics74 (2): 323–38.
51.
LipsonCharles. 1991. “Why Are Some International Agreements Informal?” International Organization45:495–538.
52.
MattesMichaela. 2012. “Reputation, Symmetry, and Alliance Design.” International Organization66 (4): 679–707.
53.
McManusRoseanneYarhi-MiloK.. 2017. “The Logic of ‘Offstage’ Signaling: Domestic Politics, Regime Type, and Major Power-Protégé Relations.” International Organization71 (4): 701–33.
54.
MearsheimerJohn J.1994. “The False Promise of International Institutions.” International Security19 (3): 5–49.
55.
MedlicottW. N.1956. Bismarck, Gladstone, and the Concert of Europe. London, UK: Athlone Press.
56.
MercerJonathan. 1996. Reputation and International Politics. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
57.
MillerGregory D.2003. “Hypotheses on Reputation.” Security Studies12 (3): 40–78.
58.
MillerJenniferCramerJacobVolgyThomas J.BezerraPaulHauserMeganSciabarraChristina. 2015. “Norms, Behavioral Compliance, and Status Attribution in International Politics.” International Interactions41 (5): 779–804.
59.
PalmerGlennD’OrazioVitoKenwickMichaelLaneMatthew. 2015. “The MID4 Data Set: Procedures, Coding Rules, and Description.” Conflict Management and Peace Science32:222–42.
60.
PoastPaul. 2010. “(Mis)Using Dyadic Data to Analyze Multilateral Events.” Political Analysis18 (4): 403–25.
61.
Polakow-SuranskySasha. 2011. The Unspoken Alliance: Israel’s Secret Relationship with Apartheid South Africa. London, UK: Vintage.
62.
PribramAlfred. 1920. The Secret Treaties of Austria-Hungary, 1879-1914. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
63.
RamsayKristopher W.2011. “Cheap Talk Diplomacy, Voluntary Negotiations, and Variable Bargaining Power.” International Studies Quarterly55 (4): 1003–23.
64.
RitterJeffrey Munro. 2004. “‘Silent Partners’ and Other Essays on Alliance Politics.” PhD thesis, Harvard University.
65.
RogersEverett. 2003. Diffusion of Innovations, 5th ed. New York: Free Press.
66.
SaburovPeter Alexandrovitch. 1929. The Saburov Memoirs. London, UK: Cambridge University Press.
67.
SchuesslerJohn. 2010. “The Deception Dividend: FDR’s Undeclared War.” International Security34 (4): 133–65.
SiversonRandolph M.KingJoel. 1980. “Attributes of National Alliance Membership and War Participation, 1815-1965.” American Journal of Political Science24:1–15.
70.
SmallMelvin. 1995. Democracy and Diplomacy: The Impact of Domestic Politics in U.S. Foreign Policy, 1789-1994. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
71.
SnyderJackBorghardErica. 2011. “The Cost of Empty Threats: A Penny, Not a Pound.” American Political Science Review105 (3): 437–56.
72.
SpenceS. A.HunterM. D.FarrowT. F. D.GreenR. D.LeungD. H.HughesC. J.GanesanV.. 2004. “A Cognitive Neurobiological Account of Deception: Evidence from Functional Neuroimaging.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London359:1755–62.
73.
SpenceS. A.FarrowT. F. D.HerfordA. E.WilkinsonI. D.ZhengY.WoodruffP. W. R.. 2001. “Behavioural and Functional Anatomical Correlates of Deception in Humans.” Neuroreport: For Rapid Communication of Neuroscience Research12:2849–53.
74.
StrmwallL. A.HartwigM.GranhagP. A.. 2006. “To Act Truthfully: Nonverbal Behaviour and Strategies during a Police Interrogation.” Psychology, Crime, & Law12:207–19.
SylvanDavidMajeskiStephen. 2009. U.S. Foreign Policy in Perspective: Clients, Enemies and Empire(Routledge Advances in International Relations and Global Politics). New York: Routledge.
77.
TragerRobert. 2010. “Diplomatic Calculus in Anarchy: How Communication Matters.” American Political Science Review104 (2): 347–68.
78.
VitalDavid. 1982. The Survival of Small States. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
79.
VrijA.MannS.. 2001. “Telling and Detecting Lies in a High-stake Situation: The Case of a Convicted Murderer.” Applied Cognitive Psychology15:187–203.
80.
VrijAldertMannSamantha A.FisherRonald P.LealSharonMilneRebeccaBullRay. 2008. “Increasing Cognitive Load to Facilitate Lie Detection: The Benefit of Recalling an Event in Reverse Order.” Law and Human Behavior32 (3): 253–65.
81.
WallerBruce. 1974. Bismarck at the Crossroads. London, UK: Athlone Press.
82.
WaltzKenneth N.1979. Theory of International Politics. New York: McGraw-Hill.
83.
WassermanStanleyFaustKatherine. 1994. Social Network Analysis: Methods and Applications. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
84.
WeitsmanPatricia. 2004. Dangerous Alliances: Proponents of Peace, Weapons of War. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
85.
WhiteC. H.BurgoonJ. K.. 2001. “Adaptation and Communicative Design: Patterns of Interaction in Truthful and Deceptive Conversations.” Human Communication Research27:9–37.
86.
WinrowGareth. 1994. “NATO and Out-of-area: A Post-cold War Challenge.” European Security3 (4): 617–38.
87.
Yarhi-MiloK.2013. “Tying Hands behind Closed Doors: The Logic and Practice of Secret Reassurance.” Security Studies22 (3): 403–35.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
