Previous studies adopting the collective vulnerability approach have shown that condemnation of war atrocities is grounded in communal experiences of victimization and is strongest in locations where victimization was spread across ethnic boundaries. Based on a representative survey conducted in 2006 (N = 2,012) across the former Yugoslavia, we find a similar pattern for acceptance of collective guilt. While personal victimization does not have a significant impact, the acceptance of guilt is strongest in more war-affected regions. Moreover, the results show the importance of the type of communal-level victimization: acceptance of guilt is lowest in regions marked by asymmetric violence and highest in regions marked by symmetric violence. Our findings suggest that collective victimization should not be treated as a uniform phenomenon and challenge the assumption that rejection of in-group guilt is an inevitable outcome of collective victimization.
AjdukovicDeanBiruskiDinka Corkalo. 2008. “Caught between the Ethnic Sides: Children Growing up in a Divided Post-war Community.” International Journal of Behavioral Development32 (4): 337–47.
3.
AndrighettoLucaMariSilviaVolpatoChiaraBehluliBurim. 2012. “Reducing Competitive Victimhood in Kosovo: The Role of Extended Contact and Common Ingroup Identity.” Political Psychology33 (4): 513–29.
4.
BakkeKristin M.O’LoughlinJohnWardMichael D.. 2009. “Reconciliation in Conflict-affected Societies: Multilevel Modeling of Individual and Contextual Factors in the North Caucasus of Russia.” Annals of the Association of American Geographers99 (5): 1012–21.
5.
BalcellsLaiaJustinoPatricia. 2014. “Bridging Micro and Macro Approaches on Civil Wars and Political Violence Issues, Challenges, and the Way Forward.” Journal of Conflict Resolution58 (8): 1343–59.
6.
Bar-TalDanielChernyak-HaiLilySchoriNoaGundarAyelet. 2009. “A Sense of Self-perceived Collective Victimhood in Intractable Conflicts.” International Review of the Red Cross91 (874): 229–58.
7.
Bar-TalDanielOrenNetaNets-ZehngutRafi. 2014. “Sociopsychological Analysis of Conflict-supporting Narratives: A General Framework.” Journal of Peace Research51 (5): 662–75.
8.
BatesDouglasMaechlerMartinBolkerBen. 2012. “lme4: Linear Mixed-effects Models Using S4 Classes.” R package version 0.999999-0.
9.
BilaliRezarta. 2013. “National Narrative and Social Psychological Influences in Turks’ Denial of the Mass Killings of Armenians as Genocide.” Journal of Social Issues69 (1): 16–33.
10.
BilaliRezartaRossMichael A.. 2012. “Remembering Intergroup Conflict.” The Oxford Handbook of Intergroup Conflict, 123–35.
11.
BiroMiklosAjdukovicDeanCorkaloDinkaDjipaDinoMilinPetarWeinsteinHarvey M.. 2004. “Attitudes toward Justice and Social Reconstruction in Bosnia and Herzegovina and Croatia.” In My Neighbor, My Enemy: Justice and Community in the Aftermath of Mass Atrocity, edited by StoverE.WeinsteinH. M., 183–205. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
12.
BranscombeNyla R.SlugoskiBenKappenDiane M.. 2004. “The Measurement of Collective Guilt: What It Is and What It Is Not.” In Collective Guilt: International Perspectives, edited by BranscombeN. R.DoosjeB., 16–34. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
13.
BrownRupertCehajicSabina. 2008. “Dealing with the Past and Facing the Future: Mediators of the Effects of Collective Guilt and Shame in Bosnia and Herzegovina.” European Journal of Social Psychology38 (4): 669.
14.
BrozSvetlana. 2005. Good People in an Evil Time: Portraits of Complicity and Resistance in the Bosnian War. New York, NY: Other Press.
15.
Canetti-NisimDaphnaHalperinEranSharvitKerenHobfollStevan E.. 2009. “A New Stress-based Model of Political Extremism Personal Exposure to Terrorism, Psychological Distress, and Exclusionist Political Attitudes.” Journal of Conflict Resolution53 (3): 363–89.
16.
ČehajićSabinaBrownRupert. 2010. “Silencing the Past Effects of Intergroup Contact on Acknowledgment of In-group Responsibility.” Social Psychological and Personality Science1 (2): 190–96.
17.
DoosjeBertjanEllemersNaomiSpearsRussell. 1995. “Perceived Intragroup Variability as a Function of Group Status and Identification.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology31 (5): 410–36.
18.
EckKristine. 2012. “In Data We Trust? A Comparison of UCDP GED and ACLED Conflict Events Datasets.” Cooperation and Conflict47 (1): 124–41.
19.
ElcherothGuy. 2006. “Individual-level and Community-level Effects of War Trauma on Social Representations Related to Humanitarian Law.” European Journal of Social Psychology36 (6): 907–30.
20.
ElcherothGuyPenicSandraFaselRachelGiudiciFrancescoGlaeserStephanieJoyeDominiqueGoffJean-Marie LeMorselliDavideSpiniDario. 2013. “Spatially Weighted Context Data and Their Application to Collective War Experiences.” Sociological Methodology43 (1): 364–411.
21.
ElcherothGuySpiniDario. 2009. “Public Support for the Prosecution of Human Rights Violations in the Former Yugoslavia.” Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology15 (2): 189–214.
22.
ElcherothGuySpiniDario. 2014. “Beyond Collective Denial: Public Reactions to Human Rights Violations and the Struggle over the Moral Continuity of Communities.” In War, Community, and Social Change: Collective Experiences in the Former Yugoslavia, edited by SpiniD.ElcherothG.Corkalo BiruskiD., 205–26. Berlin, Germany and New York, NY: Springer.
23.
FaselRachelSpiniDario. 2010. “Effects of Victimization on the Belief in a Just World in Four Ex-Yugoslavian Countries.” Social Justice Research23 (1): 17–36.
24.
HapperCatherinePhiloGreg. 2013. “The Role of the Media in the Construction of Public Belief and Social Change.” Journal of Social and Political Psychology1 (1): 321–36.
25.
HewstoneMilesCairnsEdVociAlbertoHambergerJuergenNiensUlrike. 2006. “Intergroup Contact, Forgiveness, and Experience of ‘The Troubles’ in Northern Ireland.” Journal of Social Issues62 (1): 99–120.
26.
HewstoneMilesCairnsE.VociA.McLernonF.NiensU.NoorM.. 2004. “Intergroup Forgiveness and Guilt in Northern Ireland: Social Psychological Dimensions of “The Troubles.”” In Collective Guilt: International Perspectives, edited by BranscombeN. R.DoosjeB., 193–215. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
27.
ImhoffRolandBilewiczMichalErbHans-Peter. 2012. “Collective Regret versus Collective Guilt: Different Emotional Reactions to Historical Atrocities.” European Journal of Social Psychology42 (6): 729–42.
28.
JelicMargaretaBiruskiDinka CorkaloAjdukovicDean. 2013. “Predictors of Collective Guilt after the Violent Conflict.” Collegium Antropologicum37 (1): 1–10.
29.
JungeTillPenicSandraCossutaMathieuElcherothGuy. 2013. “Spacom: Spatially Weighted Context Data for Multilevel Modelling.” R package version 1.0-0.
30.
KurspahićKemal. 2003. Prime Time Crime: Balkan Media in War and Peace. Washington, DC: US Institute of Peace Press.
31.
LeachColin WayneZeineddineFouad BouČehajić-ClancySabina. 2013. “Moral Immemorial: The Rarity of Self-criticism for Previous Generations’ Genocide or Mass Violence.” Journal of Social Issues69 (1): 34–53.
32.
LewisJustin. 2004. “Television, Public Opinion and the War in Iraq: The Case of Britain.” International Journal of Public Opinion Research16 (3): 295–310.
33.
MačekIvana. 2009. Sarajevo under Siege: Anthropology in Wartime. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
34.
MazziottaAgostinoFeuchteFriederikeGauselNicolayNadlerArie. 2014. “Does Remembering Past Ingroup Harmdoing Promote Postwar Cross-group Contact? Insights from a Field-experiment in Liberia.” European Journal of Social Psychology44 (1): 43–52.
35.
MutzDiana C.1998. Impersonal Influence: How Perceptions of Mass Collectives Affect Political Attitudes. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
36.
MyersElissaHewstoneMilesCairnsEd. 2009. “Impact of Conflict on Mental Health in Northern Ireland: The Mediating Role of Intergroup Forgiveness and Collective Guilt.” Political Psychology30 (2): 269–90.
37.
NoorMasiBrownRupert JamesPrenticeGarry. 2008. “Precursors and Mediators of Intergroup Reconciliation in Northern Ireland: A New Model.” British Journal of Social Psychology47 (3): 481–95.
38.
NoorMasiShnabelNuritHalabiSamerNadlerArie. 2012. “When Suffering Begets Suffering the Psychology of Competitive Victimhood between Adversarial Groups in Violent Conflicts.” Personality and Social Psychology Review16 (4): 351–74.
39.
PaluckElizabeth Levy. 2009. “Reducing Intergroup Prejudice and Conflict Using the Media: A Field Experiment in Rwanda.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology96 (3): 574.
40.
PenicSandraBiruskiDinka CorkaloElcherothGuy. 2014. “Threatened Powers. When Blaming ‘The Others’ Grows Out of Internal Instability and Protest.” In War, Community, and Social Change: Collective Experiences in the Former Yugoslavia, edited by SpiniD.ElcherothG.Corkalo BiruskiD., 163–82. Berlin, Germany: Springer.
41.
RaleighClionadhLinkeAndrewHegreHavardKarlsenJoakim. 2010. “Introducing ACLED: An Armed Conflict Location and Event Dataset Special Data Feature.” Journal of Peace Research47 (5): 651–60.
42.
RoccasSoniaKlarYechielLiviatanIdo. 2006. “The Paradox of Group-based Guilt: Modes of National Identification, Conflict Vehemence, and Reactions to the in-group’s Moral Violations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology91 (4): 698.
43.
SchneiderGeraldBussmannMargitRuheConstantin. 2012. “The Dynamics of Mass Killings: Testing Time-series Models of One-sided Violence in the Bosnian Civil War.” International Interactions38 (4): 443–61.
44.
Schori-EyalNoaHalperinEranBar-TalDaniel. 2014. “Three Layers of Collective Victimhood: Effects of Multileveled Victimhood on Intergroup Conflicts in the Israeli–Arab Context.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology44 (12): 778–94.
45.
SekulićDuškoMasseyGarthHodsonRandy. 2006. “Ethnic Intolerance and Ethnic Conflict in the Dissolution of Yugoslavia.” Ethnic and Racial Studies29 (5): 797–827.
46.
ShnabelNuritHalabiSamerNoorMasi. 2013. “Overcoming Competitive Victimhood and Facilitating Forgiveness through Re-categorization into a Common Victim or Perpetrator Identity.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology49 (5): 867–77.
47.
SimkusAlbertRingdalKristen. 2013. The Aftermath of War: Experiences and Social Attitudes in the Western Balkans. Farnham, UK: Ashgate.
48.
SpiniDarioElcherothGuyFaselRachel. 2008. “The Impact of Group Norms and Generalization of Risks across Groups on Judgments of War Behavior.” Political Psychology29 (6): 919–41.
49.
SpiniDarioElcherothGuyFaselRachel. 2011. “TRACES: Methodological and Technical Report.” LIVES Working Papers, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, 4.
50.
SpiniDarioElcherothGuyFaselRachel. 2014. “Towards a Community Approach of the Aftermath of War in the Former Yugoslavia: Collective Experiences, Social Practices, and Representations.” In War, Community, and Social Change: Collective Experiences in the Former Yugoslavia, edited by SpiniD.ElcherothG.Corkalo BiruskiD., 3–24. Berlin, Germany: Springer.
51.
StoverEricWeinsteinHarvey M.. 2004. My Neighbor, My Enemy: Justice and Community in the Aftermath of Mass Atrocity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
52.
StrausScott. 2013. The Order of Genocide: Race, Power, and War in Rwanda. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
53.
ThompsonMark. 1999. Forging War: The Media in Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Hercegovina. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
54.
VollhardtJohanna Ray. 2012. “Collective Victimization.” In Oxford Handbook of Intergroup Conflict, edited by TroppL., 136–57. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
55.
VollhardtJohanna RayBilaliRezarta. 2015. “The Role of Inclusive and Exclusive Victim Consciousness in Predicting Intergroup Attitudes: Findings from Rwanda, Burundi, and DRC.” Political Psychology36 (5): 489–506.
56.
VollhardtJohanna RayBilewiczMichal. 2013. “After the Genocide: Psychological Perspectives on Victim, Bystander, and Perpetrator Groups.” Journal of Social Issues69 (1): 1–15.
57.
WeidmannNils B.2009. “Violence and the Changing Ethnic Map: The Endogeneity of Territory and Conflict in Bosnia.” Households in Conflict Network. Accessed April 6, 2016. http://ideas.repec.org/p/hic/wpaper/64.html.
58.
WohlMichael J. A.BranscombeNyla R.. 2008. “Remembering Historical Victimization: Collective Guilt for Current Ingroup Transgressions.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology94 (6): 988.
59.
WohlMichael J. A.BranscombeNyla R.KlarYechiel. 2006. “Collective Guilt: Emotional Reactions When One’s Group Has Done Wrong or Been Wronged.” European Review of Social Psychology17 (1): 1–37.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
