Truth telling has come to play a pivotal role in postconflict reconciliation processes around the world. A common claim is that truth telling is healing and will lead to reconciliation. The present study applies recent psychological research to this issue by examining whether witnessing in the gacaca, the Rwandan village tribunals for truth and reconciliation after the 1994 genocide, was beneficial for psychological health. The results from the multistage, stratified cluster random survey of 1,200 Rwandans demonstrate that gacaca witnesses suffer from higher levels of depression and PTSD than do nonwitnesses, also when controlling for important predictors of psychological ill health. Furthermore, longer exposure to truth telling has not lowered the levels of psychological ill health, nor has the prevalence of depression and PTSD decreased over time. This study strongly challenges the claim that truth telling is healing and presents a novel understanding of the complexity of truth-telling processes in postconflict peace building.
American Psychiatric Association.1994. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 4th ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association.
2.
Asmal, K., L. Asmal, and R.S. Roberts.1994. Reconciliation through truth: A reckoning of apartheid’s criminal governance. Cape Town, South Africa: David Philip.
3.
Backer, David.2007. Victims’ responses to truth commissions: Evidence from South Africa. In Security, reconstruction, and reconciliation: When the wars end, ed. M. Ndulo, 165-96. London : University College London.
4.
Basoglu, Metin, Maria Livanou, Cvetana Crnobaric, Tanja Franciskovic, Enra Suljic, Dijana Duric, and Melin Vranesic.2005. Psychiatric and cognitive effects of war in former Yugoslavia: Association of lack of redress for trauma and posttraumatic stress reactions. Journal of the American Medical Association294:580-90.
5.
Biggar, Nigel.2001. Burying the past: Making peace and doing justice after civil conflict. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
6.
Biro, Miklos, Dean Adjukovic, Dinka Corkalo, Dino Djipa, Petar Milin, and Harvey M. Weinstein .2004. Attitudes toward justice and social reconstruction in Bosnia and Herzegovina and Croatia. In My neighbor, my enemy: Justice and community in the aftermath of mass atrocity , ed. E. Stover and H. M. Weinstein, 183-205. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
7.
Blanchard, Edward B., Jacqueline Jones-Alexander, Todd C. Buckley, and Catherine A. Forneris .1996. Psychometric properties of the PTSD Checklist (PCL). Behavior Research and Therapy34 (8): 669-73.
8.
Bolton, Paul, and Lincoln Ndogoni .2000. Cross-cultural assessment of trauma-related mental illness: CERTI crisis and transition tool kit. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University, World Vision International .
9.
Borer, Tristan Anne.2006. Truth telling as a peace-building activity: A theoretical overview. In Telling the truths: Truth telling and peace building in post-conflict societies, ed. T. A. Borer, 1-57. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
10.
Brahm, Eric.2005. Patterns of truth: Examining truth commission impact in cross-national context. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, Honolulu, HI.
11.
Brahm, Eric.2007. Uncovering the truth: Examining truth commission success and impact. International Studies Perspectives8:16-35.
12.
Breslau, N., R.C. Kessler, H.D. Chilcoat, L.R. Schultz, G.C. Davis, and P. Andreski.1998. Trauma and posttraumatic stress disorder in the community: The 1996 Detroit area survey of trauma. Archives of General Psychiatry55 (7): 626-32.
13.
Brewin, Chris R.2001. A cognitive neuroscience account of posttraumatic stress disorder and its treatment. Behavior Research and Therapy39 (4): 373-93.
14.
Brewin, Chris R., Bernice Andrews, and John D. Valentine .2000. Meta-analysis of risk factors for posttraumatic stress disorder in trauma-exposed adults. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology68 (5): 748-66.
15.
Brounéus, Karen.2008. Truth telling as talking cure? Insecurity and retraumatization in the Rwandan gacaca courts. Security Dialogue39 (1): 55-76.
16.
Byrne, Catherine C.2004. Benefit or burden: Victims’ reflections on TRC participation . Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology10 (3): 237-56.
17.
Collier, Paul, V.L. Elliot, Håvard Hegre, Anke Hoeffler, Marta Reynal-Querol, and Nicholas Sambanis .2003. Breaking the conflict trap: Civil war and development policy. Washington, DC: World Bank.
18.
Corkalo, Dinka, Dean Adjukovic, Harvey M. Weinstein, Eric Stover, Dino Djipa, and Miklos Biro.2004. Neighbors again? Intercommunity relations after ethnic cleansing. In My neighbor, my enemy: Justice and community in the aftermath of mass atrocity, ed. E. Stover and H. M. Weinstein, 143-61. Cambridge , UK: Cambridge University Press.
19.
de Jong, J.T., I.H. Komproe, M. Van Ommeren, Mustafa El Masri, Mesfin Araya, Noureddine Khaled, Willem van de Put, and Daya Somasundaram .2001. Lifetime events and posttraumatic stress disorder in 4 postconflict settings. Journal of the American Medical Association286:555-62.
20.
de Ridder, Trudy.1997. The trauma of testifying: Deponents’ difficult healing process. Track Two6 (3-4): 30-34.
21.
DeLaet, Debra L.2006. Gender justice: A gendered assessment of truth-telling mechanisms. In Telling the truths: Truth telling and peace building in post conflict societies, ed. T. A. Borer, 151-79. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
22.
Dimitrijevic, Nenad.2006. Justice beyond blame: Moral justification of (the idea of) a truth commission. Journal of Conflict Resolution50:368-82.
23.
Fletcher, Laurel E., Harvey A. Weinstein, and Jamie Rowen.2009. Context, timing and the dynamics of transitional justice: A historical perspective. Human Rights Quarterly31:163-220.
24.
Forbes, David, Mark Creamer, and Dirk Biddle.2001. The validity of the PTSD checklist as a measure of symptomatic change in combat-related PTSD. Behavior Research and Therapy39:977-86.
25.
Ford, Nathan, Edward J. Mills, Rony Zachariah, and Ross Upshur.2009. Ethics of conducting research in conflict settings. Conflict and Health3 (7).
26.
Frans, Ö., P.-A. Rimmö, L. Åberg, and M. Fredrikson.2005. Trauma exposure and post-traumatic stress disorder in the general population. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica111:291-99.
27.
Gibson, James L.2004. Does truth lead to reconciliation? Testing the causal assumptions of the South African truth and reconciliation process. American Journal of Political Science48 (2): 201-17.
28.
Gibson, James L.2006. The contributions of truth to reconciliation: Lessons from South Africa. Journal of Conflict Resolution50:409-32.
29.
Gilboa-Schechtman, Eva, and Edna B. Foa.2001. Patterns of recovery from trauma: The use of intraindividual analysis. Journal of Abnormal Psychology110 (3): 392-400.
30.
Green, Bonnie L., Lisa A. Goodman, Janice L. Krupnick, Carole B. Corcoran, Rachel M. Petty, Patricia Stockton, and Nicole M. Stern .2000. Outcomes of single versus multiple trauma exposure in a screening sample. Journal of Traumatic Stress13 (2): 271-86.
31.
Hamber, Brandon.2001. Does the truth heal? A psychological perspective on political strategies for dealing with the legacy of political violence . In Burying the past. Making peace and doing justice after civil conflict, ed. N. Biggar, 131-48. Washington, DC : Georgetown University Press.
32.
Herman, Judith Lewis.2003. The mental health of crime victims: Impact of legal intervention . Journal of Traumatic Stress16 (2): 159-66.
33.
Ingelaere, Bert.2008. The gacaca courts in Rwanda. In Traditional justice and reconciliation after violent conflict: Learning from African experiences , ed. L. Huyse and M. Salter, 25-60. Stockholm: International IDEA.
34.
Kaminer, Debra, Dan J. Stein, Irene Mbanga, and Nompumelelo Zungu-Dirwayi .2001. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa: Relation to psychiatric status and forgiveness among survivors of human rights abuses. British Journal of Psychiatry178:373-77.
35.
Kaminski, Marek M., and Monika Nalepa.2006. Judging transitional justice: A new criterion for evaluating truth revelation procedures. Journal of Conflict Resolution50:383-408.
36.
Kessler, Ronald C., Amanda Sonnega, Evelyn Bromet, Michael Hughes, and Christopher Nelson .1995. Posttraumatic stress disorder in the national comorbidity survey. Archives of General Psychiatry52 (12): 1048-60.
37.
Kostic, Roland.2007. Ambivalent peace: External peacebuilding, threatened identity and reconciliation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Uppsala, Sweden: Uppsala University, Department of Peace and Conflict Research .
38.
Lederach, John Paul.1999. The journey toward reconciliation. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press.
39.
Lie, Tove Grete, Helga Malmin Binningsbo, and Scott Gates.2007. Post-conflict justice and sustainable peace. Post-Conflict Transitions Working Paper 5, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 4191, World Bank.
40.
McNally, Richard J., Richard A. Bryant, and Anke Ehlers.2003. Does early psychological intervention promote recovery from posttraumatic stress?Psychological Science in the Public Interest4 (2): 45-79.
41.
Meernik, James.2005. Justice and peace? How the international criminal tribunal affects societal peace in Bosnia. Journal of Peace Research42 (3): 271-89.
42.
Mendeloff, David.2004. Truth-seeking, truth-telling, and postconflict peacebuilding: Curb the enthusiasm?International Studies Review6 (3): 355-80.
43.
Mendeloff, David.2009. Trauma and vengeance: Assessing the psychological and emotional effects of post-conflict justice. Human Rights Quarterly31:592-623.
44.
Michael, Tanja, Sarah L. Halligan, David M. Clark, and Anke Ehlers.2007. Rumination in posttraumatic stress disorder . Depression and Anxiety24:307-17.
45.
Modvig, J., J. Pagaduan-Lopez, J. Rodenburg, C.M.D. Salud, R.V. Cabigon, and C.I.A. Panelo.2000. Torture and trauma in post-conflict East Timor. The Lancet356:1763.
46.
Mollica, R.F., K. Donelan, S. Tor, J. Lavelle, C. Elias, M. Frankel, and R.J. Blendon.1993. The effect of trauma and confinement on functional health and mental health status of Cambodians living in Thailand-Cambodia border camps. Journal of the American Medical Association270:581-86.
47.
Mollica, Richard F., Keith McInnes, Charles Poole, and Svang Tor.1998. Dose-effect relationships of trauma to symptoms of depression and posttraumatic stress disorder among Cambodian survivors of mass violence. British Journal of Psychiatry173:482-88.
48.
National Service of Gacaca Courts in Rwanda.2006. Gacaca process: A justice leading to unity and reconciliation in Rwanda. Kigali: National Service of Gacaca Courts in Rwanda.
49.
O’Connell, Jamie.2005. Gambling with the psyche: Does prosecuting human rights violators console their victims?Harvard International Law Journal46 (2): 295-345.
50.
Pagnier, Jet.2004. Gacaca tribunals: Justice and reconciliation in Rwanda? Master’s thesis, University of Amsterdam .
51.
Paluck, Elizabeth Levy.2009. Reducing intergroup prejudice and conflict using the media A field experiment in Rwanda. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology96 (3): 574-87.
52.
Paunovic, Nenad, and Lars-Göran Öst .2001. Cognitive-behavior therapy vs exposure therapy in the treatment of PTSD in refugees. Behaviour Research and Therapy39:1183-97.
53.
Pham, Phuong N., Harvey M. Weinstein, and Timothy Longman .2004. Trauma and PTSD symptoms in Rwanda: Implications for attitudes toward justice and reconciliation. Journal of the American Medical Association292:602-12.
54.
Rose, Suzanna, Jonathan Bisson, Rachel Churchill, and Simon Wessely.2002. Psychological debriefing for preventing post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews2.
55.
Rose, Suzanna, Jonathan Bisson, and Simon Wessely.2003. Psychological debriefing for preventing posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Cochrane Library1.
56.
Snyder, Jack, and Leslie Vinjamuri .2004. Trials and errors: Principle and pragmatism in strategies of international justice. International Security28 (3): 5-44.
57.
Staub, Ervin, and Laurie Anne Pearlman .2001. Healing, reconciliation, and forgiving after genocide and other collective violence. In Forgiveness and reconciliation: Religion, public policy & conflict transformation , ed. R. G. Helmick and R. L. Petersen.Philadelphia: Templeton Foundation Press.
58.
Staub, Ervin, Laurie Anne Pearlman, Alexandra Gubin, and Athanase Hagengimana .2005. Healing, reconciliation, forgiving and the prevention of violence after genocide or mass killing: An intervention and its experimental evaluation in Rwanda. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology24 (3): 297-334.
59.
Stein, Murray B., John R. Walker, and David R. Forde .2000. Gender differences in susceptibility to posttraumatic stress disorder. Behavior Research and Therapy38 (6): 619-28.
60.
Stover, Eric.2004. Witnesses and the promise of justice in the Hague . In My neighbor, my enemy: Justice and community in the aftermath of mass atrocity, ed. E. Stover and H. A. Weinstein, 104-20. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
61.
Thoms, Oskar N. T., James Ron, and Roland Paris.2008. The effects of transitional justice mechanisms: A summary of empirical research findings and implications for analysts and practitioners. Ottawa, Canada: University of Ottawa, Centre for International Policy Studies .
62.
Truth and Reconciliation Commission.1998. Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa report. Cape Town: South African Government.
63.
Uvin, Peter.2003. The gacaca tribunals in Rwanda. In Reconciliation after violent conflict: A handbook, ed. D. Bloomfield, T. Barnes, and L. Huyse, 116-21. Stockholm: International IDEA.
64.
van Emmerik, Arnold A. P., Jan H. Kamphuis, Alexander M. Hulsbosch, and Paul M. G. Emmelkamp.2002. Single session debriefing after psychological trauma: A meta-analysis. The Lancet360:766-71.
65.
Veijola, Juha, Jari Jokelainen, Kristian Läksy, Liisa Kantojärvi, Pirkko Kokkonen, Marjo-Riitta Järvelin, and Matti Joukamaa.2003. The Hopkins Symptom Checklist-25 in screening DSM-III-R Axis-I disorders. Nordic Journal of Psychiatry57:119-23.
66.
Villa-Vicencio, Charles.2007. Where the old and new meet: Transitional justice and traditional reconciliation practices in Africa. Paper presented at the Claude Ake memorial lecture 2007, Uppsala University , Uppsala, Sweden.
67.
Weathers, Frank W., Brett T. Litz, Herman Debra S. , Jennifer A. Huska, and Terence M. Keane.1993. The PTSD checklist (PCL): Reliability, validity, and diagnostic utility. Paper presented at the annual meeting of International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies, San Antonio, TX.
68.
Weissman, M.M., R.C. Bland, G.J. Canino, C. Faravelli, S. Greenwald, H.G. Hwu, P.R. Joyce, E.G. Karam, C.K. Lee, J. Lelloch, J.P. Lepine, S.C. Newman, M. Rubio-Stipec, J.E. Wells, P.J. Wickramaratne, H. Wittchen, and E.K. Yeh.1996. Cross-national epidemiology of major depression and bipolar disorder. Journal of the American Medical Association276:293-99.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
