To investigate the implications of source selection, three different sources regarding Guatemalan state terror are compared: newspapers, human rights documents, and interviews with eyewitnesses. Results show that each source pays attention to diverse types and aspects of repression in line with the objectives of the observer, the characteristics of the repressive events, and the overall political context within which events take place. Who is consulted influences what is observed/recorded. Suggestions are presented for understanding sociopolitical behavior through diverse data sources, especially behavior related to contentious activity and/or occurring within contexts that are not easily penetrable.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aldrich, John , and Forrest Nelson. 1984. Linear probability, logit, and probit models. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
2.
Azar, Edward, S.Cohen, T. Jukam , and John McCormick. 1972. The problem of source coverage in the use of international events data. International Studies Quarterly16:373-388.
3.
Ball, Patrick. 1998. Liberal hypocrisy and totalitarian sincerity: The social and ideological origins of the national non-government human rights movements in El Salvador, Pakistan, and Ethiopia. Ph.D. diss., University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
4.
Ball, Patrick , Paul Kobrak, and Herbert Spirer. 1999. State violence in Guatemala, 1960-1996: A quantitative reflection. Washington, DC: American Association for the Advancement of Science.
5.
Beissinger, Mark . 1998. Event analysis in transitional societies: Protest mobilization in the former Soviet Union. In Acts of dissent: New developments in the study of protest, edited by Dieter Rucht, Ruud Koopmans, and Friedhelm Neidhardt. Berlin: Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin fur Sozialforschung (WZB).
6.
Blaser, Art . 1981. Assessing human rights: The NGO contribution. In Global human rights: Public policies, comparative measures and NGO strategies, edited by Ved P. Nanda, James R. Scarritt, and George W. Shepherd Jr.Boulder, CO: Westview.
7.
Bond, Doug, J.Craig Jenkins , Charles L. Taylor, and Kurt Shock. 1997. Mapping mass political conflict and civil society. Journal of Conflict Resolution41:553-579.
8.
Brockett, Charles D.1992. Measuring political violence and land inequality in Central America. American Political Science Review86:169-176.
9.
Burrowes, Robert . 1974. Mirror, mirror on the wall...: A comparison of event data sources. In Comparing foreign policies: Theories, findings, and methods, edited by James N. Rosenau. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage; New York: Halsted Press.
10.
Churchill, Ward , and Jim Vander Wall. 1990. Agents of repression: The FBI's secret wars against the Black Panther party and the American Indian movement. Boston: South End Press.
11.
Corradi, Juan , Patricia Weiss Fagen, and Manuel Antonio Garreton, eds. 1992. Fear at the edge: State terror and resistance in Latin America. Berkeley: University of California Press.
12.
Danzger, Herbert . 1975. Validating conflict data. American Sociological Review40:570-584.
13.
Davenport, Christian . 1995. Multi-dimensional threat perception and state repression: An inquiry into why states apply negative sanctions. American Journal of Political Science39:683-713.
14.
Davenport, Christian . 1999. Human rights and the democratic proposition. Journal of Conflict Resolution43:92-116.
15.
Davenport, Christian, and Marika Litras. 2001. Rashomon and repression: An empirical inquiry into alternative history. Manuscript.
16.
Francisco, Ron . 1996. Coercion and protest: An empirical test in two democratic states. American Journal of Political Science40:1179-1204.
17.
Francisco, Ron . 2000. European protest and coercion data (Code book). Available from the University of Kansas Web site: http://lark.cc.ukans.edu/~ronfran/data/index.html
18.
Franzosi, Roberto . 1987. The press as a source of socio-historical data. Historical Methods20:5-16.
19.
Franzosi, Roberto . 1990. Strategies for the prevention, detection and correction of measurement error in data collected from textual sources. Sociological Methods and Research18:442-472.
20.
Franzosi, Roberto . 2001. From words to numbers. New York: Cambridge University Press.
21.
Gans, Herbert . 1980. Deciding what's news: A study of CBS Evening News, NBC Nightly News, Newsweek, and Time. New York: Vintage Books.
22.
Gibney, Mark , and Stephen M. Caliendo. 1997. “All the news that's fit to print?” New York Times coverage of human rights violations. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, September, New York.
23.
Goodman, James . 1994. Stories of Scottsboro. New York: Pantheon.
24.
Grele, Ronald . 1998. Movement without aim: Methodological and theoretical problems in oral history. In The oral history reader, edited by Robert Perks and Alistair Thomson. New York: Routledge.
25.
Hibbs, Douglas , 1973. Mass political violence. New York: John Wiley.
26.
Hirsch, Herbert . 1995. Genocide and the politics of memory: Studying death to preserve life. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
27.
Hocke, Peter . 1998. Determining the selection bias in local and national newspaper reports on protest events. In Acts of dissent: New developments in the study of protest, edited by Dieter Rucht, Ruud Koopmans, and Friedhelm Neidhardt. Berlin: WZB.
28.
Jackman, Robert W. , and William A. Boyd. 1979. Multiple sources in the collection of data on political conflict. American Journal of Political Science23:434-445.
29.
Jaggers, Keith , and Ted Gurr. 1995. Transitions to democracy: Tracking the third wave with Polity III indicators of democracy and autocracy. Journal of Peace Research32 (4): 469-482.
30.
Judge, George , W. E. Griffiths, R. Hill, Helmut Lutkepohl, and Tsoung-Chao Lee. 1985. The theory and practice of econometrics. New York: John Wiley.
31.
Keck, Margaret , and Kathryn Sikkink. 1998. Activists without borders: Transnational issue networks in international politics. Working paper no. 8 of the Advanced Study Center, International Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
32.
Krain, Mathew . 1997. State-sponsored mass murder: A study of the onset and severity of genocides and politicides. Journal of Conflict Resolution41:331-360.
33.
Kundera, Milan . 1995. Testaments betrayed: An essay in nine parts. New York: Harper Perennial.
34.
Lasswell, Harold , and Dorothy Blumenstock. 1939. World revolutionary propaganda: A Chicago study. New York: Knopf.
35.
Lawyers Committee for Human Rights . 1991. Critique, review of the U.S. Department of State's country reports on human rights practices for 1991. Washington, DC: Lawyers Committee for Human Rights.
36.
Lustick, Ian S.1996. History, historiography, and political science: Multiple historical records and the problem of selection bias. American Political Science Review90:605-618.
37.
McAdam, Douglas . 1982. Political process and the development of the black insurgency, 1930-1970. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
38.
McCarthy, John , Clark McPhail, and Jackie Smith. 1996. Images of protest: Dimensions of selection bias in media coverage of Washington demonstrations, 1982, 1991. American Sociological Review61:468-499.
39.
McCarthy, John, Larissa Titarenko, Clark McPhail, and Boguslaw Augustyn. 2000. Stability in the structure of selection bias in newspaper coverage of protest events: A comparison of four daily newspapers through stages of transition from communism in Minsk, Belarus. Manuscript.
40.
McClelland, Charles . 1972. Theoretical problems. In The analysis of international politics, edited by James Rosenau, V. Davis, and M. East. New York: Free Press.
41.
McCormick, James M. , and Neil J. Mitchell. 1997. Human rights violations, umbrella concepts, and empirical analysis. World Politics49:510-525.
42.
McPhail, Clark , and Ronald Wohlstein. 1983. Individual and collective behaviors within gatherings, demonstrations, and riots. American Review of Sociology9:579-600.
43.
Moeller, Susan . 1999. Compassion fatigue: How the media sell disease, famine, war and death. New York: Routledge.
44.
Moore, Will . 1998. Repression and dissent: Substitution, context and timing. American Journal of Political Science42:851-873.
45.
Mueller, Carol . 1997. International press coverage of East German protest events, 1989. American Sociological Review69:820-832.
46.
Oliver, Pam , and Daniel Myers. 1999. How events enter the public sphere: Conflict, location, and sponsorship in local newspaper coverage of public events. American Journal of Sociology105 (1): 38-87.
47.
Olzak, Susan . 1992. The dynamics of ethnic competition and conflict. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
48.
Poe, Steven , and Neal Tate. 1994. Repression of human rights to personal integrity in the 1980s: A global analysis. American Political Science Review88:853-872.
49.
Rucht, Dieter , and Friedhelm Neidhardt. 1998. Methodological issues in collecting protest event data: Units of analysis, sources and sampling, coding problems. In Acts of dissent: New development in the study of protest, edited by Dieter Rucht, Ruud Koopmans, and Friedhelm Neidhardt. Berlin: WZB.
50.
Rude, G . 1964. The crowd in history: A study of popular disturbances in France and England, 1730-1848. New York: John Wiley.
51.
Rummel, Rudolph . 1966. Dimensions of conflict behavior within nations, 1946-1959. Journal of Conflict Resolution10:65-73.
52.
Samuelson, Douglas A. , and Herbert Spirer. 1992. Use of incomplete and distorted data in inference about human rights violations. In Human rights and statistics: Getting the record straight, edited by Thomas B. Jabine and Richard Claude. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
53.
Schudson, Michael . 1987. Deadlines, datelines and history. In Reading the news: A Pantheon guide to popular culture, edited by Robert Karl Manoff and Michael Schudson. New York: Pantheon.
54.
Sigal, Leon . 1987. Sources make the news. In Reading the news: A Pantheon guide to popular culture, edited by Robert Karl Manoff and Michael Schudson. New York: Pantheon.
55.
Snyder, David . 1976. Theoretical and methodological problems in the analysis of governmental coercion and collective violence. Journal of Political and Military Sociology4:277-293.
56.
Snyder, David , and William R. Kelly. 1977. Conflict intensity, media sensitivity and the validity of newspaper data. American Sociological Review42:1105-1117.
57.
Sommer, Henrik , and James Scarritt. 1999. The utility of Reuters for events analysis in area studies: The case of Zambia-Zimbabwe interactions, 1982-1993. International Interactions25:29-59.
58.
Sorokin, Pitirim . 1937. A social and cultural dynamics. Vol. 3, Fluctuation of social relationships, war, and revolution. New York: American Book Company.
59.
Spilerman, Seymour . 1970. The causes of racial discrimination: A comparison of alternative explanations. American Sociological Review35:627-649.
60.
Stohl, Michael , David Carleton, George Lopez, and Stephen Samuels. 1986. State violation of human rights: Issues and problems of measurement. Human Rights Quarterly8:592-606.
61.
Tarrow, Sidney . 1989. Democracy and disorder: Protest and politics in Italy, 1965-1975. New York: Clarendon.
62.
Taylor, Charles L. , and David A. Jodice. 1983. World handbook of political and social indicators. Vol. III. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
63.
Tilly, Charles , Louise Tilly, and R. Tilly. 1975. The rebellious century. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
64.
Tuchman, Gaye . 1978. Making news: A study in the construction of reality. New York: Free Press.
65.
Waltz, Susan . 1995. Human rights and reform: Changing the face of North African politics. Berkeley: University of California Press.
66.
Wooley, John . 2000. Using media-based data in studies of politics. American Journal of Political Science44:156-173.
67.
Ziegenhagen, Eduard . 1986. The regulation of political conflict. New York: Praeger.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
