Finite Element Analysis of the Arcan Specimen for Fiber Reinforced Composites under Pure Shear and Biaxial Loading

Abstract

Linearly elastic finite element analyses were used to examine the effects of fiber orientation, notch angle and notch root radius on the stress distribution in Arcan specimens in order to optimize the specimen geometry for the unidirectional, fiber reinforced composite AS4/PEEK under shear and biaxial loadings. Two fiber orientations, three notch angles and five notch root radii were examined. A comparison between butterfly-shaped and circular S-shaped specimens was also made. For specimens with fibers running across the specimen from grip to grip (1-2 orientation), a 1340 notch angle was found to be the best choice due to superior stress uniformity along the gage section and minimum transverse normal stress along the notch flank. However, specimens with fibers running from notch to notch (2-1 orientation), required a 900 notch angle for optimum stress uniformity along the gage section and minimum transverse normal stress along the specimen notch. It was also found that, along the gage section, the largest shear stress concentration occurred near the notch roots of the 1-2 specimen, yet it was not seen in the 2-1 specimen. This made the 2-1 specimen a better candidate for determining the shear properties of fiber reinforced composites. It was also found that the butterfly-shaped specimen bonded to steel grips provided much more uniform normal stresses than the original circular S-shaped specimen did. As a result, a butterfly-shaped Arcan specimen with a 2-1 fiber orientation, a 900 notch angle, a 2.38 mm root radius and bonded to steel grips was found to be very suitable for examining the longitudinal deformation behavior of this particular fiber reinforced composite under both shear and biaxial loading. Strain distributions from the finite element analyses were also compared to those obtained from moire measurements. At low load levels, there was excellent agreement between the two. Nonlinear effects mitigated stress concentrations at higher load levels.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. N. Iosipescu , "New Accurate Procedure for Single Shear Testing of Metals," J. Materials, 2, 1967, 537-566.

2. J. M. Slepetz , T. F. Zagaeski and R. F. Novello , "In-plane Shear Test for Composite Materials," Rep. No. AMMRC TR 78-30, Army Material & Mechanics Research Center, Watertown, MA, 1978.

3. C. T. Herakovich and H. W. Bergner, Jr. , "Finite Element Stress Analysis of a Notched Coupon Specimen for In-Plane Shear Behavior of Composites," Composites, 11, 1980, 149-154.

4. C. T. Herakovich , H. W. Bergner, Jr. and D. E. Bowles , "A Comparative Study of Composite Shear Specimens Using the Finite Element Method," in Test Methods and Design Allowables for Fibrous Composites, C. C. Chamis , Ed., ASTM STP 734, 1981, 129-151.

5. D. E. Walrath and D. F. Adams . "The Iosipescu Shear Test as Applied to Composite Materials," Experimental Mechanics, 23, 1983, 105-110.

6. S. S. Wang and A. Dasgupta , "Development of Iosipescu-Type Test for Determining Shear Properties of Fiber Composite Materials: Critical Anisotropic Elasticity Analysis and Experiment," Mechanical Eng. Dept., Univ. of Houston, 1986.

7. M. Kumosa and D. Hull , "Mixed-Mode Fracture of Composites Using Iosipescu Shear Test," Int. J. Fracture, 35, 1987, 83-102.

8. D. F. Adams and D. E. Walrath , "Further Development of the Iosipescu Shear Test Method," Experimental Mechanics, 27, 1987, 113-119.

9. J. Morton , H. Ho , M. Y. Tsai and G. L. Farley , "An Evaluation of the Iosipescu Specimen for Composite Materials Shear Property Measurement," J. Composite Materials, 26,1992, 708-750.

10.

10. J. A. Barnes , M. Kumosa and D. Hull , "Theoretical and Experimental Evaluation of the Iosipescu Shear Test," Comp. Sc. and Tech. 28, 1987, 251-268.

11.

11. M.-J. Pindera , G. Choksi , J. S. Hiddle and C. T. Herakovich , "A Methodology for Accurate Shear Characterization of Unidirectional Composites," J. Composite Materials, 21, 1987, 1164-1184.

12.

12. D. F. Adams and D. E. Walrath , "Current Status of the Iosipescu Shear Test Method," J. Composite Materials, 21, 1987, 494-507.

13.

13. M.-J. Pindera , "Shear Testing of Fiber Reinforced Metal Matrix Composites," in Metal Matrix Composites: Testing, Analysis and Failure Modes, W. S. Johnson , Ed., ASTM STP 1032, 1989, 19-42.

14.

14. B. S. Spigel , R. Prabhakaran and J. W. Sawyer , "An Investigation of the Iosipescu and Asymmetrical Four-Point Bend Tests," Experimental Mechanics, 27, 1987, 57-63.

15.

15. M. G. Abdallah and H. E. Gascoigne , "The Influence of Test Fixture Design on the Iosipescu Shear Test for Fiber Composite Materials," in Test Methods and Design Allowables for Fibrous Composites, C. C. Chamis , Ed., ASTM STP 1003, 1989, 231-260.

16.

16. M.-J. Pindera , P. Ifju and D. Post , "Iosipescu Shear Characterization of Polymeric and Metal Matrix Composites," Experimental Mechanics, 30, 1990, 101-108.

17.

17. W. R. Broughton , M. Kumosa and D. Hull , "Analysis of the losipescu Shear Test as Applied to Unidirectional Carbon-Fiber Reinforced Composites," Comp. Sci. and Tech. 38, 1990,299-325.

18.

18. H. Ho , M. Y. Tsai , J. Morton and G. L. Farley , "An Experimental Investigation of Iosipescu Specimen for Composite Materials," Experimental Mechanics, 31, 1991, 328-336.

19.

19. H. Ho , M. Y. Tsai , J. Morton and G. L. Farley , "Numerical Analysis of the Iosipescu Specimen for Composite Materials," Comp. Sci. and Tech. 46, 1993, 115-128.

20.

20. H. Ho , H. T. Budiman , M.-Y. Tsai , J. Morton and G. L. Farley , "Composite Material Shear Property Measurement Using the Iosipescu Specimen," in Composite Materials: Testing and Design, E. T. Camponeschi, Jr. , Ed., ASTM STP 1206, 1993, 70-89.

21.

21. H. Ho , J. Morton and G. L. Farley , "Non-Linear Numerical Analysis of the Iosipescu Specimen for Composite Materials," Comp. Sci. and Tech. 50, 1994, 355-365.

22.

22. N. Goldenberg , M. Arcan and E. Nicolau , "On the Most Suitable Specimen Shape for Testing Shear Strength of Plastics," ASTM STP 247, 1958, 115-121.

23.

23. M. Arcan , Z. Hashin and A. Voloshin , "A Method to Produce Uniform Plane-Stress States with Applications to Fiber-Reinforced Materials," Experimental Mechanics, 18, 1978, 141-146.

24.

24. A. Voloshin and M. Arcan , "Failure of Unidirectional Fiber-Reinforced Materials-New Methodology and Results," Experimental Mechanics, 20, 1980, 280-284.

25.

25. M. Arcan , "Discussion of the Iosipescu Shear Test as Applied to Composite Materials," Experimental Mechanics, 24, 1984, 66-67.

26.

26. S.-C. Hung and K. M. Liechti , "A Reevaluation of the Arcan Specimen for Determining the Shear Moduli of Fiber Reinforced Composites," Experimental Mechanics, 37, 1997, 460-468.

27.

27. R. H. Marloff and S. E. Gabrielse , "Further Evaluation of Proposed Biaxial Stress Test Specimen for Composite Materials," in Advances in Composite Materials Vol. 1, A. R. Bunsell et al. , Eds., Pergamon Press, Elmsfold, N.Y., 1980, 885-899.

28.

28. R. H. Marloff , "Finite Element Analysis of Biaxial Stress Test Specimen for Graphite/Epoxy and Glass Fabric/Epoxy Composites," ASTM STP 787, Daniel, I. M. , Ed., 1982, 34-49.

29.

29. S.-C. Hung and K. M. Liechti , "A Reevaluation of the Arcan Specimen for Determining the Shear Moduli of Fiber Reinforced Composites," EMRL Report No. 96/7, The University of Texas at Austin.

30.

30. S. Kyriakides , R. Arseculeratne , E. J. Perry and K. M. Liechti , "On the Compressive Failure of Fiber Reinforced Composites," Int. J. Solids Structures, 32, 1995, 689-738.

31.

31. H. Ho , M. Y. Tsai , J. Morton and G. L. Farley , "In-Plane Shear Testing of Graphite-Woven Fabric Composites," Experimental Mechanics, 34, 1994, 45-52.

32.

32. P. Ifju , "The Shear Gage: For Reliable Shear Modulus Measurements of Composite Materials," Experimental Mechanics, 34, 1994, 369-378.

33.

33. F. Pierron and A. Vautrin , "Accurate Comparative Determination of the In-Plane Shear Modulus of T300/914 by the Iosipescu and 450 Off-Axis Tests," Comp. Sci. and Tech. 52, 1994, 61-72.

34.

34. F. Pierron , A. Vautrin and B. Harris , "The Iosipescu In-Plane Shear Test: Validation on an Isotropic Material," Experimental Mechanics, 35, 1995, 130-136.

35.

35. N. Sukumar and M. Kumosa , "Application of the Finite Element Iterative Method to Cracks and Sharp Notches in Isotropic and Orthotropic Media," International Journal of Fracture, 58, 1992, 177-192.