Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2026
Experimental research and model characterization on Mode I,Mode II and mixed-mode I/II delamination growth behavior of CFRP composites under quasi-static and fatigue loading
This paper seeks to comprehensively investigate the interlaminar delamination growth behavior of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) composites under quasi-static and fatigue loading by experimental research and model characterization. Mode I, Mode II and Mixed-mode I/II quasi-static and fatigue delamination growth tests were systematically conducted on double cantilever beam (DCB), end-notched flexure (ENF) and mixed-mode bending (MMB) specimens, respectively. The results show that the fatigue delamination growth (FDG) rate decreases with the increase of stress ratio under the same mode mixture and with the increase of mode mixture under the same stress ratio. Meanwhile, the delamination damage of CFRP composites is much more sensitive to fatigue loading in Mixed-mode I/II compared to pure Mode I and Mode II. A new FDG model considering both stress ratio and mode mixture effects is developed to characterize the FDG behavior of CFRP composites, showing good correlation with the experimental data. In addition, it can be found from fractographic analysis that mode mixture, loading condition and stress ratio significantly affect the microscale damage mechanisms during delamination growth process. The comprehensive experimental findings of the FDG behavior of CFRP composites and the new FDG model considering both stress ratio and mode mixture effects can provide effective theoretical and data references for engineering practice.
GranadosJJMartinezXBarbuLG, et al.Fatigue prediction of composite materials based on serial/parallel mixing theory. Compos Struct2022; 291: 115516.
2.
ZabalaHAretxabaletaLCastilloG, et al.Dynamic 4 ENF test for a strain rate dependent mode II interlaminar fracture toughness characterization of unidirectional carbon fibre epoxy composites. Polym Test2016; 55: 212–218.
3.
GongYTianDLCaoTC, et al.An R-curve effect-included delamination growth criterion for mixed-mode I/II delamination predictions of composite laminates. Compos Struct2022; 295: 115846.
4.
ASTM Standard D5528. Standard test method for Mode I interlaminar fracture toughness of unidirectional fiber-reinforced polymer matrix composites. American Society for Testing and Materials, 2021.
5.
ASTM Standard D7905. Standard test method for determination of the Mode II interlaminar fracture toughness of unidirectional fiber-reinforced polymer matrix composites. American Society for Testing and Materials, 2019.
6.
ASTM Standard D6671. Standard test method for mixed Mode I-Mode II interlaminar fracture toughness of unidirectional fiber reinforced polymer matrix composites. American Society for Testing and Materials, 2022.
HojoMTanakaKGustafsonCG. et al.Effect of stress ratio on near-threshold propagation of delamination fatigue cracks in unidirectional CFRP. Compos Sci Technol1987; 29: 273–292.
9.
YaoLJSunYGuoLC, et al.Mode I fatigue delamination growth with fibre bridging in multidirectional composite laminates. Eng Fract Mech2018; 189: 221–231.
10.
HojoMNakashimaKKusakaT, et al.Mode I fatigue delamination of Zanchor-reinforced CF/epoxy laminates. Int J Fatig2010; 32(1): 37–45.
11.
ShahverdiMVassilopoulosAPKellerT. Experimental investigation of R-ratio effects on fatigue crack growth of adhesively-bonded pultruded GFRP DCB joints under CA loading. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2012; 43(10): 1689–1697.
12.
SchonJ. A model of fatigue delamination in composites. Compos Sci Technol2000; 60(4): 553–558.
13.
RansCAlderliestenRBenedictusR. Misinterpreting the results: how similitude can improve our understanding of fatigue delamination growth. Compos Sci Technol2011; 71: 230–238.
14.
YaoLJSunYGuoLC, et al.Fibre bridging effect on the Paris relation of Mode I fatigue delamination in composite laminates with different thicknesses. Int J Fatig2017; 103: 196–206.
15.
TeimouriFHeidari-RaraniMAboutalebiFH. Finite element modeling of Mode I fatigue delamination growth in composites under large-scale fiber bridging. Compos Struct2021; 263: 113716.
16.
GroganDMLeenSBBradaighCMO. An XFEM-based methodology for fatigue delamination and permeability of composites. Compos Struct2014; 107: 205–218.
17.
MartulliLMBernasconiA. An efficient and versatile use of the VCCT for composites delamination growth under fatigue loadings in 3D numerical analysis: the Sequential Static Fatigue algorithm. Int J Fatig2023; 170: 107493.
18.
TeimouriFHeidari-RaraniMAboutalebiFH. An XFEM-VCCT coupled approach for modeling Mode I fatigue delamination in composite laminates under high cycle loading. Eng Fract Mech2021; 249: 107760.
19.
HongRCHiguchiRLuX, et al.Numerical analysis of fatigue evolution of laminated composites using cohesive zone model and extended finite element method. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2025; 190: 108653.
20.
YaoLJAlderliestenRCBenedictusR. Interpreting the stress ratio effect on delamination growth in composite laminates using the concept of fatigue fracture toughness. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2015; 78: 135–142.
21.
LiuCQGongYGongYK, et al.Mode II fatigue delamination behaviour of composite multidirectional laminates and the stress ratio effect. Eng Fract Mech2022; 264: 108321.
22.
KhanRAlderliestenRBadshahS, et al.Effect of stress ratio or mean stress on fatigue delamination growth in composites: critical review. Compos Struct2015; 124: 214–227.
23.
KhanRAlderliestenRYaoLJ, et al.Crack closure and fibre bridging during delamination growth in carbon fibre/epoxy laminates under Mode I fatigue loading. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2014; 67: 201–211.
24.
JiaJDavalosJF. Study of load ratio for mode-I fatigue fracture of wood-FRP-bonded interfaces. J Compos Mater2004; 38(14): 1211–1230.
25.
YaoLJCuiHGuoLC, et al.A novel total fatigue life model for delamination growth in composite laminates under generic loading. Compos Struct2021; 258: 113402.
26.
KhanRAlderliestenRBenedictusR. Two-parameter model for delamination growth under Mode I fatigue loading (part A: experimental study). Compos Appl Sci Manuf2014; 65: 192–200.
27.
AlderliestenRCKhanRBenedictusR. Two-parameter model for delamination growth under Mode I fatigue loading (part B: model development). Compos Appl Sci Manuf2014; 65: 201–210.
28.
AllegriG. Modelling fatigue delamination growth in fibre-reinforced composites: power-law equations or artificial neural networks?Materials & Desig2018; 155: 59–70.
29.
WangJXYaoLJHeZX, et al.Physics-informed machine learning model for Mode I fatigue delamination growth in composite laminates under different load ratios. Compos B Eng2026; 309: 113074.
30.
YaoLJAlderliestenRCZhaoMY, et al.Bridging effect on Mode I fatigue delamination behavior in composite laminates. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2014; 63: 103–109.
31.
TeimouriFHeidari-RaraniMAboutalebiFH, et al.Experimental characterization and cyclic cohesive zone modeling of Mode I delamination growth in glass/epoxy composite laminates under high cycle fatigue. Eng Fract Mech2024; 296: 109853.
32.
GongYZhaoLBZhangJY, et al.Crack closure in the fatigue delamination of composite multidirectional DCB laminates with large-scale fiber bridging. Compos Struct2020; 244: 112220.
33.
DonoughMJGunnionAJOrificiAC, et al.Scaling parameter for fatigue delamination growth in composites under varying load ratios. Compos Sci Technol2015; 120: 39–48.
34.
Farmand-AshtianiECugnoniJBotsisJ. Effects of large scale bridging in load controlled fatigue delamination of unidirectional carbon-epoxy specimens. Compos Sci Technol2016; 137(12): 52–59.
35.
YaoLAlderliestenRCZhaoM, et al.Discussion on the use of the strain energy release rate for fatigue delamination characterization. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2014; 66: 65–72.
36.
AllegriGJonesMIWisnomMR, et al.A new semi-empirical model for stress ratio effect on Mode II fatigue delamination growth. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2011; 42 (7): 733–740.
37.
ShivakumarKChenHAbaliF, et al.A total fatigue life model for Mode I delaminated composite laminates. Int J Fatig2005; 28(1): 33–42.
38.
ChenHShivakumarKAbaliF. A comparison of total fatigue life models for composite laminates. Fatig Fract Eng Mater Struct2006; 29 (1): 31–39.
39.
PengLZhangJYZhaoLB, et al.Mode I delamination growth of multidirectional composite laminates under fatigue loading. J Compos Mater2011; 45(10): 1077–1090.
40.
ZhaoLBGongYZhangJY, et al.A novel interpretation of fatigue delamination growth behavior in CFRP multidirectional laminates. Compos Sci Technol2016; 133: 79–88.
41.
GongYLiWCLiuH, et al.A novel understanding of the normalized fatigue delamination model for composite multidirectional laminates. Compos Struct2019; 229: 111395.
42.
JiangLFZhangYXGongY, et al.A new model characterizing the fatigue delamination growth in DCB laminates with combined effects of fiber bridging and stress ratio. Compos Struct2021; 268: 113943.
43.
PengLXuJFZhangJY, et al.Mixed mode delamination growth of multidirectional composite laminates under fatigue loading. Eng Fract Mech2012; 96: 676–686.
44.
ZhangJYPengLZhaoLB, et al.Fatigue delamination growth rates and thresholds of composite laminates under mixed mode loading. Int J Fatig2012; 40: 7–15.
45.
BlancoNGamstedtEKAspLE, et al.Mixed-mode delamination growth in carbon–fibre composite laminates under cyclic loading. Int J Solid Struct2004; 41(15): 4219–4235.
46.
RamkumarRLWhitcombJD. Characterization of Mode I and mixed-mode delamination growth in T300/5208 graphite/epoxy. In: Delamination and Debonding of Materials ASTM STP, 1985, vol 876, pp. 315–335.
47.
AllegriGWisnomMRHallettSR. A new semi-empirical law for variable stress-ratio and mixed-mode fatigue delamination growth. Compos Appl Sci Manuf2013; 48: 192–200.
48.
QuanDMurphyNIvankoviA, et al.Fatigue delamination behaviour of carbon fibre/epoxy composites interleaved with thermoplastic veils. Compos Struct2022; 281: 114903.
49.
JohriNKandpalBCKumarN, et al.Effect of ply thickness and orientation on fatigue delamination of laminated composites using cohesive zone model. Mater Today Proc2021; 46: 11040–11045.
50.
SumanMLJMurigendrappaSMKattimaniS. Characterisation of fatigue delamination growth in plain woven hybrid laminated composites subjected to Mode-I loading. Theor Appl Fract Mech2024; 129: 104236.
51.
YaoLJChuaiMYLiHY, et al.Temperature effects on fatigue delamination behavior in thermoset composite laminates. Eng Fract Mech2024; 295: 109799.
52.
YaoLJHeZXHeYL, et al.Hygrothermal ageing effects on Mode I fatigue delamination in multidirectional composite laminates.Int J Fatig2024; 188: 108520.
53.
PengADengJCaiDA, et al.On damage behavior and stability of composite T-shaped stiffened panels under compression after impact considering impact locations. Thin-Walled Struct2023; 182: 110295.
54.
MailletIMichelLSouricF, et al.Mode II fatigue delamination growth characterization of a carbon/epoxy laminate at high frequency under vibration loading. Eng Fract Mech2015; 149: 298–312.
55.
HahnHTTurkgencO. The effect of loading parameters on fatigue of composite laminates: part IV information systems. Technical report2000, DOT/FAA/AR-00/48.
56.
JIS K 7086. Testing methods for interlaminar fracture toughness of carbon fiber reinforced plastics. Japanese Industrial Standards Committee, 2013.
57.
Banks-SillsLShorOSimonI, et al.Quasi-static modes I, II and mixed modes I/II fracture toughness of two laminate composites: part I—testing. Eng Fract Mech2023; 277: 108934.
58.
SchreerLGStamopoulosAGStablaP, et al.Hygrothermal degradation of modes I and II fracture toughness in flat carbon/epoxy composites: experimental and numerical insights. Eng Fract Mech2025; 326: 111393.
59.
HojoMTanakaKGustafsonCG, et al.Effect of stress ratio on nearthreshold propagation of delamination fatigue cracks in unidirectional CFRP. Compos Sci Technol1987; 29(4): 273–292.
60.
PascoeJAAlderliestenRCBenedictusR. Methods for the prediction of fatigue delamination growth in composites and adhesive bonds–a critical review. Eng Fract Mech2013; 112: 72–96.
61.
PereiraABDe MoraisAB. Mode I interlaminar fracture of carbon/epoxy multidirectional laminates. Compos Sci Technol2004; 64(13): 2261–2270.
62.
TanakaKTanakaH. Stress-ratio effect on Mode II propagation of interlaminar fatigue cracks in graphite/epoxy composites. ASTM special technical publication1997; 1285: 126–142.
63.
TanakaHTanakaKKatohH, et al.Stress-ratio effect on propagation of delamination fatigue cracks in unidirectional graphite/epoxy laminates under mixed mode (I+ II) loading. Zairyo1999; 48(12): 1408–1415.
64.
TanakaHTanakaKTsujiT, et al.Mixed-mode (I+ II) propagation of delamination fatigue cracks in unidirectional graphite/epoxy laminates. Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, Series A1999; 65(636): 1676–1683.
