The Response of Composite Joints with Bolt-Clamping Loads,Part II: Model Verification

Abstract

Extensive experiments were performed to characterize the material response due to bearing failure in composite bolted joints with and without lateral clamp-up supports. Composite plates made of T800H/3900-2graphite/epoxy were selected in the tests, and various washer sizes and clamping forces were used in the study. The clamping force in the bolt was found to vary with the applied load, and may increase significantly due to a sudden through-the-thickness expansion of the laminate under the washers where bearing failure occurred. Experiments showed that the joint strength and response can be significantly affected by the bolt clamp-up, and the bolt bearing failure is a 3-D phenomenon. The results of the tests were utilized to verify the model predictions proposed in Part I of the study. The model predicts both the failure load and response of bolted composite joints very well for various clamping forces and washer sizes. The predicted bolt clamp-up load as a function of the applied load agreed also well with the data, which validates that the proposed incompressibility assumption in the model for bearing-damaged material. Based on the model, a parametric study was performed to evaluate the sensitivities of bearing load to bolt stiffness, clamping force, washer size, joint geometry such as width, edge distance and bolt sizes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

1. Sun, H.-T. , Chang, F.-K. and Qing, X. The response of composite joints with bolt-clamping Loads, Part I: Model development. Journal of Composite Materials, 36(1): 47–67.

2. Stockdale, J.H. and Matthews, F.L. (1971). The effect of clamping pressure of bolt bearing loads in glass fiber-reinforced plastics. Composites, 7: 34–38.

3. Crews, J.H. (1981). Bolt-bearing fatigue of graphite/epoxy laminates. In: Kedward, K.T. (ed.), ASTM STP 749. Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials. pp. 131–144.

4. Matthews, F.L. , Roshan, A.A. and Philips, L.N. (1982). The bolt bearing strength of glass/carbon hybrid composites. Composites, 13: 225–227.

5. Collings, T.A. (1982). On the bearing strength of CFRP laminates. Composites, 13: 241–252.

6. Collings, T.A. and Beauchamp, M.J. (1984). Bearing deflection behavior of a loaded hole in CFRP. Composites, 15(1): 33–38.

7. Cooper, C. and Turvey, G.J. (1995). Effects of joint geometry and bolt torque on the structure performance of single bolt tension joints in pultruded GRP steel material. Composite Structure, 32: 217–226.

8. Graham, U. , Winsom, M.R. and Webber, P.H. (1994). A novel finite element investigation of the effect of washer friction in composite plates with bolt–filled holes. Composite Structure, 29: 329–339.

9. Balie, J.A. , Duggan, M.F. and Bradshaw, N.C. (1981). Design data for graphite cloth epoxy bolted joints at temperatures up to 450 K. In: Kedward, K.T. (ed.), ASTM STP 749. Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials. pp. 165–180.

10.

10. Herrington, P.D. and Sabbaghian, M. (1993). Fatigue failure of composite bolted joints. Journal of Composite Materials, 27(5): 491–512.

11.

11. Akay, M. (March, 1989). Bearing strength of As-cured and hydrothermally conditioned carbon fiber/epoxy composites under static and dynamic loading. Composites, 23(2): 101–108.

12.

12. Hung, C.-L. and Chang, F.-K. (1996). Bearing failure of bolted composite joints. Part II: Model and verification. Journal of Composite Materials, 30(12): 1359–1400.

13.

13. Wang, H.-S. , Hung C.-L. and Chang, F.-K. (1996). Bearing failure of bolted composite joints. Part I: Experimental characterization. Journal of Composite Materials, 30(12): 1248–1313.

14.

14. Chang, F.-K. , Qing, X. , Sun, H.-T. and Yan, Y. (1999). Damage tolerance-based design of bolted composite joints. Final Report to the Boeing Commercial Airplane Groups and the Federal Aviation Administration, Aeronautics and Astronautics Department, Stanford University.

15.

15. Morgan, M.E. and Beckwith, S.W. (March 19–21, 1985). Bolt torque loading and radial gap effects on thick-wall composite joint strength. In: Proceedings of the 30th National SAMPE Symposium. pp. 1321–1334.

16.

16. Horn, W.J. and Schmitt, R.R. (1993). Influence of clam-up force on the strength of bolted composite joints. AIAA Journal, 32(3): 665–667.

17.

17. Smith, P.A. , Ashby, M.F. and Pascoe, K.J. (1987). Modeling clamp-up effects in composite bolted joints. Journal of Composite Materials, 21(12): 878–897.