Paul Butler argues that due to disparate impact on African Americans in the criminal justice system, African American jurors ought to exercise their right of nullification when there are African American defendants of nonviolent crimes. That is, they should refuse to convict these defendants in part to redress the racism and discrimination experienced by Blacks, and in part because Butler argues that these defendants should be addressed in the African American community instead. In this article I summarize Butler's call to nullify and critically review Leipold's and Marder's critiques of Butler's proposal. I argue that Butler's call is a principled tool to use while also working to change disparate treatment and impact due to discrimination in the criminal justice system, while also exploring the problematic issue of returning offenders to the community.
Alexander, R., Jr., & Gyamerah, J. (1997). Differential punishing of African Americans and Whites who possess drugs: A just policy or a continuation of the past? Journal of Black Studies, 28(1), 97-111.
2.
Barnes, C.W., & Kingsnorth, R. (1996). Race, drug, and criminal sentencing: Hidden effects of the criminal law. Journal of Criminal Justice, 24(1), 39-55.
3.
Berger, V. (1998, November 2). Might affirmative action balance U.S. Justice?The National Law Journal, p. A21.
4.
Biederman, J., Wilens, T., Mick, E., Milberger, S., Spencer, T.J., & Faraone, S.V. (1995). Psychoactive substance use disorders in adults with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): Effects of ADHD and psychiatric comorbidity. American Journal of Psychiatry, 152(11), 1652-1658.
5.
Butler, P. (1995). Racially based jury nullification: Black power in the criminal justice system. Yale Law Journal, 105(3), 677-725.
6.
Butler, P. (1997a). Affirmative action and the criminal law. University of Colorado Law Review, 68, 841-889.
7.
Butler, P. (1997b). Brotherman: Reflections of a reformed prosecutor . In E. Cose (Ed.), The Darden dilemma: 12 Black writers on justice, race, and conflicting loyalties (pp. 1-19). New York: HarperCollins.
8.
Butler, P. (1997c). Symposium: The role of race-based jury nullification in American criminal justice. John Marshall Law Review, 30, 911-922. Retrieved March 6, 2002, from Lexis-Nexis Academic Universe database.
9.
Colb, S.F. (2002, January 20). The Crown Heights verdicts and race-conscious jury selection. Retrieved June 23, 2006, from http://archives.cnn.com/2002/LAW/01/columns/fl.colb.jury.race.01.20/
10.
Eckholm, E. (2006, March 20). Plight deepens for Black men, studies warn. The New York Times, pp. A1, A18.
11.
Farnham, D. (1997). Jury nullification: History proves it's not a new idea. Criminal Justice, 11, 5-14.
12.
Flynn, K. (1999, December 1). State cites racial inequality in New York police searches. The New York Times, p. A22.
13.
Fritsch, J. (2000, February 26). Four officers in Diallo shooting are acquitted of all charges. The New York Times, pp. A1, A13.
14.
Goldberg, J. (1999, June 20). The color of suspicion. The New York Times Magazine, pp. 50-57, 64, 85, 87.
15.
Harker, V. (2000, January 5). Phoenix police sued over beating: Black resident says racial profiling at fault. The Arizona Republic , pp. A1, B7.
16.
Harrison, P.M., & Beck, A.J. (2006). Prison and jail inmates at midyear 2005. Retrieved June 30, 2006, from http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/pjim05.pdf
17.
Herbert, B. (1999, November 4). Breathing while Black. The New York Times, p. A27.
18.
Hockstader, L. (2003, June 16). 13 imprisoned in Tulia drug sweep to be freed today; racial divide still deep in Texas town. The Washington Post, p. A03. Retrieved August 2, 2004, from HighBeam Research database.
19.
Johnson, R. (2000). American prisons and the African-American experience: A history of social control and racial oppression. Corrections Compendium, 25(9), 6, 8, 10, 28-30.
20.
King, M.L. (1963). Letter from Birmingham Jail. Retrieved June 23, 2006, from http://www.stanford.edu/group/King/frequentdocs/birmingham.pdf
21.
Kocieniewski, D. (1999, December 23). U.S. will monitor New Jersey police on race profiling. The New York Times, pp. A1, A26.
22.
Leipold, A.D. (1996). The dangers of race-based jury nullification: A response to Professor Butler. UCLA Law Review, 44(1), 109-141.
23.
Marbley, A.F., & Ferguson, R. (2004). Putting back together our communities of color: A systemic model for rehabilitation. Journal of African American Studies, 7(4), 75-85.
24.
Marbley, A.F., & Ferguson, R. (2005). Responding to prisoner reentry, recidivism, and incarceration of inmates of color: A call to the communities. Journal of Black Studies, 35(5), 633-649.
25.
Marder, N.S. (1999b). The myth of the nullifying jury. Northwestern University Law Review, 93(3), 877-959.
26.
Marder, N.S. (2002a). Juries, drug laws, and sentencing. Journal of Gender, Race & Justice, 6, 337-380.
27.
Marder, N.S. (2002b). Juries, justice & multiculturalism. Southern California Law Review, 75, 659-726.
28.
Miller, J. (1996). Search and destroy: African American males in the criminal justice system. New York: Cambridge University Press.
29.
Palmer, L.D. (1999, March 21). More Blacks serving time in U.S. prisons . The Arizona Republic, p. A19.
30.
The price of prisons. (2004, June 26). The New York Times, p. A26.
31.
Rashbaum, W.K. (2000, March 17). Unarmed man is shot to death in scuffle with three undercover detectives. The New York Times, p. A19.
32.
Roy, Y. (2000, February 26). Racial profiling is center of debate . The Arizona Republic, p. A25.
33.
United Press International. (2003, June 2). Tulia defendants freed by Texas law. Comtex [online news network]. Retrieved August 2, 2004, from HighBeam Research database.
34.
U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2003). Prison statistics. Retrieved July 31, 2004, from http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/prisons.htm
35.
U.S. goes to war on racial profiling. (1999, December 23). The Arizona Republic, p. A3.
36.
Wellman, D.T. (1993). Portraits of White racism (2nd ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.
