Abstract
Emerging economies of India and South Africa, among other member countries, endorsed the Data for Development agenda in the New Delhi leaders’ declaration during the G20 Summit in September 2023. With a focus on Sustainable Development Goal 16.9 of compulsory legal identity for all, this effort seeks to use data as a vital resource for sustainable development. The purpose of this study is to research how privacy in general and data privacy in particular have become crucial concerns for netizens, companies, and governments in the new digital public sphere. This article examines the significance of citizens’ digital identity and its implications for personal data privacy. Methodologically, this research uses a comparative analysis of digital identity projects undertaken in India and South Africa, namely the Aadhaar card and the Smart ID, respectively. The finding reveals the complexities of laws and challenges faced by both nations in providing their citizens with the Right to Privacy and the Right to Identity. This paper studies how India and South Africa perceive an individual’s Right to Privacy and the legal safeguards established in their respective legal systems, with a particular focus on the Protection of Personal Information Act 2013, the Home Affairs National Identification System, India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023, and the Aadhaar Act. This research aims to gain insights into how both nations strike a balance between providing legal digital identity to all their citizens without compromising their privacy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.Aadhaar Ecosystem (2023 ) UIDAI Ecosystem - Unique Identification Authority of India | Government of India . Unique Identification Authority of India | Government of India . Available at: https://uidai.gov.in/en/ecosystem/uidai-ecosystem.html (accessed 18 June 2025 )
2.Accessnow (2019 ) National digital identity programmes . Available at: https://www.accessnow.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/Digital-Identity-Paper-Nov-2019.pdf (accessed 18 June 2025 )
3.
Ananthakrishnan
G
(2017 ) M P Sharma and Kharak Singh: The cases in which SC ruled on privacy . The Indian Express , 18 July . Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/m-p-sharma-and-kharak-singh-the-cases-in-which-sc-ruled-on-privacy-4756964/
4.
Anas
S
Choudhary
B
(2023 ) We should and can improve Aadhaar . The Times of India . Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/toi-editorials/we-should-and-can-improve-aadhaar/
5.
Bentham
J
(2024 ) The Panopticon Writings by Jeremy Bentham: 9781844676668 | PenguinRandomHouse.com: Books . PenguinRandomhouse.com . Available at: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/233378/the-panopticon-writings-by-jeremy-bentham/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
6.
Bowen
N
(2020 ) After 7-year wait, South Africa’s Data Protection Act enters into force . IAPP , 1 July . Available at: https://iapp.org/news/a/after-a-7-year-wait-south-africas-data-protection-act-enters-into-force/
7.
Breckenridge
K
(2014 ) Biometric State: The Global Politics of Identification and Surveillance in South Africa, 1850 to the Present . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
8.
Chabane
M
(2021 ) Automated Biometric Identification System (ABIS) progress and plans to resolve downtimes at DHA offices; with Deputy Minister | PMG . Pmg.org.za; Home Affairs , 30 November . Available at: https://pmg.org.za/committee-meeting/33954/
9.
Chakraborty
A
Obhan
A
Sundram
AK
(2019 ) Data Protection Laws Demystified . 1st ed . Gurgaon, India : OakBridge .
10.Constitutional Court of South Africa (2021 ) Amabhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism NPC and Another Versus Minister of Justice and Correctional Services and Others, CCT278/19 & CCT279/19 www.concourt.org.za § Constitutional Law. Available at: https://www.concourt.org.za/index.php/judgement/383-amabhungane-centre-for-investigative-journalism-npc-and-another-v-minister-of-justice-and-correctional-services-and-others-minister-of-police-v-amabhungane-centre-for-investigative-journalism-npc-and-others-cct278-19-cct279-19 (accessed 18 June 2025 )
11.DPDPA (2023 ) Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023 | Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India . Available at: https://www.meity.gov.in/content/digital-personal-data-protection-act-2023 (accessed 18 June 2025 )
12.Dvara Research and
Narayan
A
(2022 ) Payment failures in direct benefit transfers . Dvara Research . Available at: https://dvararesearch.com/payment-failures-in-direct-benefit-transfers/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
13.Express Web Desk (2017 ) Right to privacy judgment: a timeline of the case . The Indian Express , 24 August . Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/india/right-to-privacy-judgment-a-timeline-of-the-case-4811110/
14.
Foucault
M
(1978 ) The Birth of Biopolitics Michel Foucault Edited by Michel Senellart . Available at: https://ctheory.sitehost.iu.edu/resources/fall2020/Foucault_Michel_The_Birth_of_Biopolitics.pdf
15.
16.Global Freedom of Expression (2021 ) AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism v. Minister of Justice and Minister of Police v. AmaBhungane Centre for Investigative Journalism . New York : Columbia University . Available at: https://globalfreedomofexpression.columbia.edu/cases/amabhungane-centre-for-investigative-journalism-v-minister-of-justice-and-minister-of-police-v-amabhungane-centre-for-investigative-journalism/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
17.Government of India (2023 ) Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology . Government of India | Home Page , 11 August . Available at: https://www.meity.gov.in/writereaddata/files/Digital%20Personal%20Data%20Protection%20Act%202023.pdf
18.
Gupta
A
(2023 ) Decoding Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 - KPMG India . KPMG , 29 September . Available at: https://kpmg.com/in/en/home/insights/2023/08/decoding-digital-personal-data-protection-act-2023.html
19.HANIS (2024 ) Department of Home Affairs - Smart ID Card . Available at: https://www.dha.gov.za/index.php/id-smart-card (accessed 18 June 2025 )
20.ID4Africa (2014 ) About – ID4Africa . ID4Africa . Available at: https://id4africa.com/about (accessed 19 June 2025 )
21.ID4D (2017 ) Home | Identification for Development . Available at: https://id4d.worldbank.org/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
22.India Post (n.d.) The Indian Post Office Act, 1898 CONTENTS . Available at: https://www.indiapost.gov.in/VAS/DOP_RTI/TheIndianPostOfficeAct1898.pdf (accessed 8 December 2024 ).
23.Indian Express (2018 ) Supreme Court rules Aadhaar not mandatory for bank accounts, mobile numbers, school admissions . The Indian Express , 26 September . Available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/india/aadhaar-verdict-supreme-court-judgment-uidai-5374829/
24.IndiaStack (2016 ) IndiaStack – Technology for 1.2 Billion Indians . Indiastack . Available at: https://indiastack.org/
25.International Telecommunication Union (2023 ) Facts and Figures 2023 - Internet Use . Available at: https://www.itu.int/itu-d/reports/statistics/2023/10/10/ff23-internet-use/ (accessed 19 June 2025 )
26.
Jain
M
(2019 ) The Aadhaar Card: Cybersecurity Issues with India’s Biometric Experiment . The Henry M. Jackson School of International Studies , May 9 . Available at: https://jsis.washington.edu/news/the-aadhaar-card-cybersecurity-issues-with-indias-biometric-experiment/
27.
Kelion
L
(2013 ) Dexter payment card malware strikes South Africa . BBC News , 16 October . Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-24550505
28.
Lele
S
(2023 ) AYUSH Jharkhand allegedly hacked, records of 320,000 patients leaked . @Bsindia; Business Standard , 4 September . Available at: https://www.business-standard.com/india-news/health-data-of-320k-people-allegedly-leaked-from-ayush-jharkhand-s-website-123090401010_1.html
29.
Lyon
D
(1994 ) The Electronic Eye: The Rise of Surveillance Society (NED-New edition) . Minneapolis, MI : University of Minnesota Press . Available at: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.ctttsqw8%7D
30.
Macdonald
A
(2024 ) Issuance of 2.5M smart IDs part of South Africa’s 2025 budget plan . Biometric Update | Biometrics News, Companies and Explainers , 18 July . Available at: https://www.biometricupdate.com/202407/issuance-of-2-5m-smart-ids-part-of-south-africas-2025-budget-plan
31.MeitY (2014 ) UID | Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India . Available at: https://www.meity.gov.in/content/uid (accessed 19 June 2025 )
32.
Mithun
MK
(2019 ) Aadhaar data stolen by I-T Grids proves UIDAI’s main database can be breached: Experts . The News Minute , 17 April . Available at: https://www.thenewsminute.com/andhra-pradesh/aadhaar-data-stolen-i-t-grids-proves-uidais-main-database-can-be-breached-experts-100215
33.National Health Act 2003 (2004 ) Government Gazette REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA . Available at: https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/a61-03.pdf (accessed 19 June 2025 )
34.OpenRightsGroup (2014 ) Independent Report on E-voting in Estonia | A Security Analysis of Estonia’s Internet Voting System by International E-voting Experts . Ann Arbor, MI : University of Michigan .
35.
Patel
F
(2024 ) Data breaches cost SA organisations over R360m in 3 years . The Citizen , 22 November . Available at: https://www.citizen.co.za/lifestyle/technology/data-breaches-sa-organisations-millions/
36.
Patil
S
Desai
V
(2014 ) Unique identification disaster? SC holds UID not mandatory, no biometric data to be shared without consent - privacy - India . Mondaq , April . Available at: https://www.mondaq.com/india/privacy-protection/306796/unique-identification-disaster-sc-holds-uid-not-mandatory-no-biometric-data-to-be-shared-without-consent
37.PIB (2023 ) The Post Office Act 2023 comes into effect from today . Available at: https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=2026249 (accessed 19 June 2025 )
38.POPIA (2021 ) Protection of Personal Information Act (POPI Act) . Available at: https://popia.co.za/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
39.Privacy International (2021 a) Q&A South African Constitutional Court amaBhungane case . London : Privacy International . Available at: https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/4417/qa-south-african-constitutional-court-amabhungane-case
40.Privacy International (2021 b) South Africa . London : Privacy International . Available at: https://privacyinternational.org/location/south-africa
41.Republic of South Africa (1996 ) The constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 . Available at: https://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/SAConstitution-web-eng.pdf
42.RICA (2003 ) Regulation of Interception of Communications and Provision of Communication-related Information Act 70 of 2002 | South African Government . Available at: https://www.gov.za/documents/regulation-interception-communications-and-provision-communication-related-information–13 (accessed 18 June 2025 )
43.RICO (2002 ) Regulation of Interception of Communications and Provision of Communication-Related Information Act 70 of 2002 [Assented to 30 December 2002] [Date of Commencement: 30 September 2005] (Unless otherwise indicated) . Available at: https://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/acts/2002-070.pdf
44.RSA (2024 ) Smart Identity Document (ID) card roll-out | South African Government . Available at: https://www.gov.za/af/about-government/smart-identity-document-id-card-roll-out
45.
Saal
P
(2018 ) Latest traffic fine leak leaves a million South Africans exposed . TimesLIVE , 25 May . Available at: https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2018-05-25-latest-traffic-fine-leak-leaves-a-million-south-africans-exposed/
46.
47.SAnews (2019 ) Home Affairs issues 13m smart ID cards . SAnews; South African Government News Agency , 10 July . Available at: https://www.sanews.gov.za/south-africa/home-affairs-issues-13m-smart-id-cards
48.
Sangwan
S
(2023 ) Top 10 operational impacts of India’s DPDPA – Scope, key definitions and lawful data processing . IAPP . Available at: https://iapp.org/resources/article/operational-impacts-of-indias-dpdpa-part1/
49.
Sen
S
(2019 ) A Decade of Aadhaar: Lessons in Implementing a Foundational ID System SRIJONI . SEN . Available at: https://www.orfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/ORF_Issue_Brief_292_Aadhaar.pdf
50.SFLC (2021 ) S. 69 of the Information Technology Act and the Decryption Rules: Absence of adequate procedural safeguards . India : Software Freedom Law Center, India • Defender of Your Digital Freedom . Available at: https://sflc.in/s-69-information-technology-act-and-decryption-rules-absence-adequate-procedural-safeguards/
51.
Singh
P
(2019 ) Aadhaar and data privacy: biometric Identification and anxieties of recognition in India . Information, Communication & Society 24 (7 ): 1 –16 .
52.SCO (2013 ) Fundamental Right to Privacy. Supreme Court Observer . Available at: https://www.scobserver.in/cases/puttaswamy-v-union-of-india-fundamental-right-to-privacy-case-background/ (accessed 19 June 2025 )
53.South African Government (2013 ) Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 | South African Government . Available at: https://www.gov.za/documents/protection-personal-information-act (accessed 19 June 2025 )
54.
Staff
N
(2019 ) Aadhaar data leak: Details of 7.82 cr Indians from AP and Telangana found on IT Grids’ database . Firstpost , 15 April . Available at: https://www.firstpost.com/india/aadhaar-data-leak-details-of-7-82-cr-indians-from-ap-and-telangana-found-on-it-grids-database-6448961.html
55.State of California Department of Justice (2019 ) California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) . Los Angeles, CA : State of California - Department of Justice - Office of the Attorney General . Available at: https://www.oag.ca.gov/privacy/ccpa
56.Supreme Court of India (2024 ) Justice B.N. Srikrishna | Supreme Court of India | India . Sci.gov.in. Available at: https://www.sci.gov.in/judge/justice-b-n-srikrishna/ (accessed 18 June 2025 )
57.Thales (2024 a) South African ID card: identity and citizenship . Thales Group . Available at: https://www.thalesgroup.com/en/markets/digital-identity-and-security/government/customer-cases/south-africa
58.Thales (2024 b) Thales Identity Management System: an end-to-end offer to address universal ID programs challenges . Thales Group . Available at: https://www.thalesgroup.com/en/markets/digital-identity-and-security/government/identity/id-management-system
59.The World Bank (2025 ) Principles on identification for sustainable development : Toward the digital age . World Bank. Available at: https://documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/213581486378184357/principles-on-identification-for-sustainable-development-toward-the-digital-age
60.UIDAI . (n.d.). Usage of Aadhaar. Unique Identification Authority of India | Government of India . Retrieved June 19, 2025, from https://uidai.gov.in/en/my-aadhaar/about-your-aadhaar/usage-of-aadhaar.html
61.UIDAI (2024 a) Unique Identification Authority of India . Government of India . Available at: https://uidai.gov.in/en/about-uidai/unique-identification-authority-of-india.html
62.UIDAI (2024 b) Usage of Aadhaar . Unique Identification Authority of India | Government of India . Available at: https://uidai.gov.in/en/my-aadhaar/about-your-aadhaar/usage-of-aadhaar.html
63.UNECA (2023 ) Africa digital identity landscape: key findings . Available at: https://www.uneca.org/sites/default/files/TCND/Africa_Report_on_Digital_ID.pdf
64.United Nations (1966 ) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights . OHCHR; United Nations , 16 December . Available at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenant-civil-and-political-rights
65.United Nations (2015 ) The 17 Sustainable Development Goals . United Nations . Available at: https://sdgs.un.org/goals
66.USAID (2020 ) Digital Identity | Digital Development | U.S . Agency for International Development . Available at: https://www.usaid.gov/digital-development/digital-id
67.
Zuboff
S
(2019 ) Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power . New York : Public Affairs .