Abstract
Despite some controversy regarding its usefulness, strategic culture has become a widely accepted phrase in the sense of a ‘shaping framework’ for strategic behaviour. Due to its relevance in attaining a goal, the strategic has become a multidisciplinary term that can be construed in a variety of ways. In the case of India, strategic culture explains why the country has taken a very different approach to national security and foreign policy than other countries in similar situations. Postcolonial India, unlike China or Pakistan, did not seek alliances with strong countries to strengthen its national security, staying ‘nonaligned’ even after major wars in 1962 and 1965. After the rise of the BJP in the Indian government since 2014, although realpolitik and Hindu nationalism provide alternatives to the Nehruvian legacy that has dominated Indian strategic culture, Nehruvianism continues to dominate the country’s strategic thought. Thus, this article aims to access India’s defence cooperation with the United States and Russia, through the lens of strategic culture.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alam
MB
(2019 ) Contextualising India–Russia relations . World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues 23 (1 ): 48 –59 .
2.
Bakshi
J
(1999 ) Russia and India: From Ideology to Geopolitics . Delhi : Dev Publication .
3.
Bharti
MS
(2022 ) Indo-French defence cooperation in the light of regional security balance in South Asia . Polish Political Science Yearbook 51 (2 ): 7 –18 .
4.
Carmack
D
Mathur
A
Pant
HV
, et al (2022 ) India-US relations: priorities in the next decade . The Heritage Foundation , 30 June . Available at: https://www.heritage.org/asia/commentary/india-us-relations-priorities-the-next-decade
5.
Castren
ML
(2020 ) Shrikant Paranjpe, India’s strategic culture: the making of national security policy . International Studies 57 (4 ): 412 –414 .
6.
Choudhury
SL
(2021 ) India and Russia broaden defense ties despite potential risk of U.S. sanctions . CNBC , 7 December . Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/12/07/india-russia-broaden-ties-and-military-cooperation.html
7.CSIS (2022 ) U.S.-India security and defense cooperation . Centre for Strategic & International Studies , 12 July . Available at: https://www.csis.org/programs/wadhwani-chair-us-india-policy-studies/past-india-chair-projects/us-india-security-and
8.Embassy of India in Moscow (2022 ) Bilateral relations: India-Russia defence cooperation . Embassy of India, Moscow, Russia , 19 June . Available at: https://indianembassy-moscow.gov.in/india-russia-defence-cooperation.php#:~:text=India%20and%20Russia%20have%20an,the%20apex%20of%20this%20structure
9.ET Energyworld (2021 ) Revitalising India-Russia ties – putting the Modi-Putin meeting in perspective . The Economic Times , 5 December . Available at: https://energy.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/oil-and-gas/opinion-revitalising-india-russia-ties-putting-the-modi-putin-meeting-in-perspective/88105855?redirect=1
10.
Fani
MI
(2009 ) The indo-US strategic partnership in post 9/11: implication for Pakistan . Journal of Pakistan Vision 10 (2 ): 131 –159 .
11.
Garamone
J
(2022 ) U.S., India take steps to increase cooperation, ties between 2 largest democracies . U.S. Department of Defense News , 11 April . Available at: https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/2996395/us-india-take-steps-to-increase-cooperation-ties-between-2-largest-democracies/
12.
Glenn
J
(2009 ) Realism versus strategic culture: competition and collaboration? International Studies Review 11 (3 ): 523 –551 .
13.
Gray
CS
(1981 ) National style in strategy: the American example . International Security 6 (2 ): 21 –47 .
14.
Haiqi
Z
Chia
C
(2021 ) India and Russia: contemporising historical ties and broadening cooperation. ISAS Insight No . 702, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University of Singapore . Available at: https://www.isas.nus.edu.sg/papers/india-and-russia-contemporising-historical-ties-and-broadening-cooperation/
15.
Hudaya
M
Putri
DA
(2019 ) Strategic culture: the answer of international relations study to overcome challenges in the globalized world . Tersedia Dalam . Available at: https://pssat.ugm.ac.id/wp-content/uploads/sites/513/2019/03/Paper-1.Pdf
16.
Jain
BM
(2003 ) India and Russia: reassessing the time-tested ties . Pacific Affairs 76 (3 ): 375 –397 .
17.
Johnston
AI
(1995 ) Thinking about strategic culture . International Security 19 (4 ): 32 –64 .
18.
Jones
RW
(2006 ) India’s Strategic Culture . Virginia: Defence Threat Reduction Agency.
19.
Joshi
M
(2018 ) Modi-Putin meet: as global ties are being disrupted, a vital moment to shore up an old relationship . ORF Commentaries , 24 May . Available at: https://www.orfonline.org/research/modi-putin-meet-as-global-ties-are-being-disrupted-a-vital-moment-to-shore-up-an-old-relationship/
20.
Kapoor
N
(2019 ) India-Russia ties in a changing world order: in pursuit of a special strategic partnership . ORF Occasional Paper, 218 . Available at: https://www.orfonline.org/research/india-russia-ties-in-a-changing-world-order-in-pursuit-of-a-special-strategic-partnership-56877/#_edn8
21.
Katju
V
(2021 ) 50 years of Indo-Soviet treaty . The Tribune , 9 August . Available at: https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/comment/50-years-of-indo-soviet-treaty-294975
22.
Klein
BS
(1988 ) Hegemony and strategic culture: American power projection and alliance defence politics . Review of International Studies 14 (2 ): 133 –148 .
23.
Koithara
V
(2005 ) India-US defense cooperation: expectations and prospects . Economic and Political Weekly 40 (32 ): 3585 –3589 .
24.KPMG India (2021 ) Indo-US defence partnership: the road ahead . KPMG Report . Available at: https://home.kpmg/in/en/home/insights/2021/09/indo-us-defence-partnership-road-ahead.html
25.
Kundu
ND
(2008 ) India’s strategic cooperation with Russia and its ‘near abroad’states . India Quarterly 64 (4 ): 73 –101 .
26.
Laskar
RH
(2021 ) Putin calls India ‘great power’, Modi says friendship with Russia is a ‘constant’ despite challenges . Hindustan Times , 6 December . Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/putin-calls-india-great-power-modi-says-friendship-with-russia-is-a-constant-despite-challenges-101638804228207.html
27.
Mastny
V
(2010 ) The soviet union’s partnership with India . Journal of Cold War Studies 12 (3 ): 50 –90 .
28.MEA (2010 ) Joint statement: celebrating a decade of the India- Russian federation strategic partnership and looking ahead . Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India , 21 December . Available at: https://mea.gov.in/bilateral-documents.htm?dtl/5118/Joint+Statement+Celebrating+a+Decade+of+the+India+Russian+Federation+Strategic+Partnership+and+Looking+Ahead
29.MEA (2017 ) Brief on India-U.S. Relations . Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India . Available at: https://www.mea.gov.in/Portal/ForeignRelation/India_US_brief.pdf
30.MEA (2021 ) India- Russia joint statement following the visit of the President of the Russian Federation . Media Center: Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India , 6 December . Available at: https://mea.gov.in/bilateral-documents.htm
31.MEA (2022 ) Declaration on strategic partnership between the Republic of India and the Russian Federation . Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India . Available at: https://mea.gov.in/Images/pdf/DeclerationStrategicPartnership.pdf
32.
Mishra
V
(2018 ) India–US defence cooperation: assessing strategic imperatives . Strategic Analysis 42 (1 ): 1 –14 .
33.
Mohanty
A
(2010 ) Indo-Russian strategic partnership in the twenty-first century . Indian Foreign Affairs Journal 5 (1 ): 69 –84 .
34.
Mohanty
A
(2011 ) Toasting legacy of 1971 indo-soviet friendship treaty. Russia Beyond , 9 August . Available at: https://www.rbth.com/articles/2011/08/09/toasting_legacy_of_1971_indo-soviet_friendship_treaty_12842
35.
Paranjpe
S
(2020 ) India’s Strategic Culture: The Making of National Security Policy . New Delhi: Taylor & Francis.
36.
Ranhotra
SS
(2022 ) What makes PM Modi and President Putin’s friendship so special . TFI Post , 7 March . Available at: https://tfipost.com/2022/03/what-makes-pm-modi-and-president-putins-friendship-so-special/
37.
Sachdeva
G
(2011 ) India’s relations with Russia . In:
Scott
D
(ed.) Handbook of India’s International Relations . London: Routledge, pp. 213 –222 .
38.
Shah
B
(2021 ) Resetting the time-tested friendship Modi-Putin summit . The Times of India , 19 December . Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/bipin-shah/resetting-the-time-tested-friendship-modi-putin-summit/
39.
Shah
SAA
(2001 ) Russo-India military-technical cooperation . Strategic Studies 21 (4 ): 46 –86 .
40.
Snyder
JL
(1977 ) The Soviet Strategic Culture. Implications for Limited Nuclear Operations . California: Rand Corp Santa Monica Calif.
41.
Stobdan
P
(ed.) (2010 ) India-Russia Strategic Partnership: Common Perspectives . New Delhi : Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses .
42.The Hindu (2021 ) A robust friendship: on Modi-Putin summit meeting . The Hindu , 8 December . Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/editorial/a-robust-friendship-on-modi-putin-summit-meeting/article37889404.ece
43.
Unjhawala
Y
(2022 ) India and the US: defense collaboration is key . The Diplomat , 19 April . Available at: https://thediplomat.com/2022/04/india-and-the-us-defense-collaboration-is-key/
44.U.S. Department of State (2021 ) U.S. Security Cooperation with India. U.S . Security Cooperation with India, Fact Sheet on January 20 . Available at: https://www.state.gov/u-s-security-cooperation-with-india/
45.
Wezeman
PD
(2019 ) Trends in International Arms Transfers, 2018 . Stockholm: SIPRI Fact Sheet .
46.
Zaman
R
(2009 ) Strategic culture: a ‘cultural’ understanding of war . Comparative Strategy 28 (1 ): 68 –88 .