Though the “local turn” in peacebuilding increased interest in traditional methods of conflict resolution, a comparative assessment of the effectiveness of these methods vis-à-vis hybrid and modern approaches is only just emerging. This paper adds to this nascent body of research by analyzing the trends in the applications and effectiveness of different communal conflict resolution approaches to end localized conflict in Africa. The paper found out that in communal conflicts with an annual conflict-death of 25 or more, the type of conflict resolution method used and the intensity of the conflict influence the effectiveness of a communal peace agreement. This result is in line with the hypothesis that traditional mechanisms are comparatively more effective than hybrid and modern methods. In communal conflicts with less than 25 annual deaths, hybrid approaches appear to be as effective as traditional methods, though our confidence in this result is tempered by the limited size of our sample and the lack of control over ‘conflict intensity’ as a relevant variable.
AminKAE (2010) Darfur, grand conflict: inter-communal rift and grass-root initiatives for reconciliation. African Peace and Conflict Journal2(3): 90–105.
2.
BellCBadanjakS (2019) Introducing PA-X: a new peace agreement database and dataset. Journal of Peace Research56(3): 452–466.
3.
BeynaLSLundMStaoks StacyS, et al (2001) The effectiveness of civil society initiatives in controlling violent conflicts and building peace: a study of three approaches in the greater Horn of Africa, synthesis report on key findings and lessons for improving practices. Management System International. Available at: http://www.usaid.gov/regions/afr/conflictweb/pbp_report.pdf
BoegeV (2021) Hybrid Political Orders and Customary Peace. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6.
BradburyM (2008) The Search for Peace: Synthesis Report of Peace Mapping Study, Somali Programme. Oxford: James Curry.
7.
BriggM (2010) Culture: challenges and possibilities. In: RichmondO (ed.) Palgrave Advances in Peacebuilding: Critical Developments and Approaches. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 329–346.
8.
BroscheJElfverssonE (2012) Communal conflict, civil war, and the state: complexities, connections, and the case of Sudan. African Journal on Conflict Resolution12(1): 33–60.
9.
BrownMABoegeVClementsKP, et al (2010) Challenging statebuilding as peacebuilding—working with hybrid political orders to build peace. In: RichmondO (ed.) Palgrave Advances in Peacebuilding: Critical Developments and Approaches (ProQuest Ebook Central). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.99–115.
DatzbergerS (2015) Peace building and the depoliticisation of civil society: Sierra Leone 2002–13. Third World Quarterly36(8): 1592–1609.
12.
DaviesSPetterssonTÖbergM (2023) Organized violence 1989–2022, and the return of conflict between states. Journal of Peace Research60(4): 691–708.
13.
DöringSMustasiltaK (2023) Spatial patterns of communal violence in Sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Peace Research. Epub ahead of print 7 July. DOI: 10.1177/00223433231168187.
14.
DuursmaA (2022) State weakness, a fragmented patronage-based system, and protracted local conflict in the Central African Republic. African Affairs121(483): 251–274.
15.
DuursmaAGamezSM (2023) Introducing the African Peace Processes (APP) dataset: negotiations and mediation in interstate, intrastate and non-state conflicts in Africa. Journal of Peace Research60(6): 1010–1020.
16.
EckK (2014) The law of the land: communal conflict and legal authority. Journal of Peace Research51(4): 441–454.
17.
EhrhardtDAlaoDOUmarMS (ed.) (2024) Traditional Authtorities and Security in Contemporary Nigeria.London: Taylor & Francis.
18.
EhrhardtDAlaoDOUmarMS (2024a) Conclusion: Creative genius in postcolonial Nigeria: Reimagining traditional rulership at a safe distance from politics. In: EhrhardtAlaoD.O.UmarM.S. (eds.) Traditional Authtorities and Security in Contemporary Nigeria. London: Taylor & Francis, pp.273–290.
19.
EhrhardtDAlaoDOUmarMS (2024b) Introduction: Traditional Authority, security governance, and Nigerian agency. In: EhrhardtAlaoD.O.UmarM.S. (eds.) Traditional Authtorities and Security in Contemporary Nigeria. London: Taylor & Francis, pp 1–23.
20.
ElfverssonE (2015) Providing security or protecting interests? Government interventions in violent communal conflicts in Africa. Journal of Peace Research52(6): 791–805.
21.
ElfverssonENilssonD (2022) The pursuit of inclusion: conditions for civil society inclusion in peace processes in communal conflicts in Kenya. Cooperation and Conflict57(2): 171–190.
22.
EzeaniEAkovETOkoyeKE (2024) Unethical practices and the role of traditional ruler-ship institutions in modern conflict resolution in Tivland, Nigeria. African Security Review33(1): 33–48.
23.
FataiAGOlufemiLMOlubunmiL-BF, et al (2024) Government institutions and persistent communal conflicts in Nigeria. Conflict Resolution Quarterly41(3): 281–297.
24.
GintyRM (2008) Indigenous peace-making versus the liberal peace. Cooperation and Conflict43(2): 139–163.
25.
GintyRM (2014) Everyday peace: bottom-up and local agency in conflict-affected societies. Security Dialogue45(6): 548–564.
GurrTR (2008) Minorities, nationalists, and Islamists: managing communal conflict in the twenty-first century. In: CrockerCAHampsonFOAallPR (eds) Leashing the Dogs of War: Conflict Management in a Divided World. Washington, DC: United States Institute for Peace, pp.131–160.
28.
HolzingerKKernFGKromreyD (2016) The dualism of contemporary traditional governance and the state: institutional setups and political consequences. Political Research Quarterly69(3): 469–481.
29.
IssifuAKBukariKN (2022) (Re)thinking homegrown peace mechanisms for the resolution of conflicts in Northern Ghana. Conflict, Security & Development22(2): 221–242.
KifleAA (2015) State-building and non-state conflicts in Africa. Strategic Review for Southern Africa = Strategiese oorsig vir suider-africa37(1): 212.
KwesiS-GFantayeD (2012) Traditional authority and modern hegemony: peacemaking in the Afar region of Ethiopia. In: MutisiM (ed.) Integrating Traditional and Modern Conflict Resolution: Experiences from Selected Cases in Eastern and the Horn of Africa (African Dialogue Monograph Series no. 2). Durban, South Africa: ACCORD, pp.75–98.
34.
LoganC (2013) The roots of resilience: exploring popular support for African traditional authorities. African Affairs112(448): 353–376.
35.
Mac GintyRRichmondOP (2013) The local turn in peace building: a critical agenda for peace. Third World Quarterly34(5): 763–783.
36.
MamdaniM (1996) Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the Legacy of Late Colonialism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
37.
MarkBJohnRMichaelM, et al (2006) Local Peace Processes in Sudan, Baseline Study. Nairobi, Kenya: Rift Valley Institute.
38.
MenkhausK (2008) The rise of a mediated state in northern Kenya: the Wajir story and its implications for state-building. Afrika Focus21(2): 23–38.
39.
MurithiT (2008) African indigenous and endogenous approaches to peace and conflict resolution. In: DavidF (ed.) Peace and Conflict in Africa. London: Zed Books, pp.16–30.
40.
MustasiltaK (2019) Including chiefs, maintaining peace? Examining the effects of state–traditional governance interaction on civil peace in sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Peace Research56(2): 203–219.
41.
MutisiMBartoliASentongoA, et al (eds) (2012) Integrating Traditional and Modern Conflict Resolution: Experiences From Selected Cases in Eastern and the Horn of Africa (Africa Dialogue). Durban, South Africa: ACCORD.
OsaghaeEE (2000) Applying traditional methods to modern conflict: possibilities and limits. In: ZartmanIW (ed.) Traditional Cures for Modern Conflicts: African Conflict Medicine. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, pp.201–217.
PaffenholzT (2011) Civil society beyond the liberal peace and its critique. In: CampbellSChandlerDSabaratnamM (eds) A Liberal Peace? The Problems and Practices of Peacebuilding. London: Zed Books, pp.138–155.
46.
PospisilJ (2022) Dissolving conflict. Local peace agreements and armed conflict transitions. Peacebuilding10(2): 122–137.
47.
RandazzoE (2021) The local, the “indigenous” and the limits of rethinking peacebuilding. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding15(2): 141–160.
48.
SalomeB (2012) Customary mediation in resource scarcities and conflict in Sudan: making a case for the Judiyya. In: MutisiM (ed.) Integrating Traditional and Modern Conflict Resolutions: Experiences from Selected Eastern and Horn of Africa Countries. Durban, South Africa: ACCORD, pp.121–146.
SundbergREckKKreutzJ (2012) Introducing the UCDP non-state conflict dataset. Journal of Peace Research49(2): 351–362.
52.
SzumilasM (2010) Explaining odds ratios. Journal of the Canadian Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry19(3): 227–229.
53.
TobiasH (2007) Bringing the Sultan back in: elders as peacemakers in Ethiopia’s Somali region. In: BuurLKyedHM (eds) State Recognition and Democratization in Africa: A New Down for Traditional Authorities?New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp.31–51.
UnruhJD (2005) Changing conflict resolution institutions in the Ethiopian pastoral commons: the role of armed confrontation in rule-making. GeoJournal64(3): 225–237.
58.
WatsonDC (2023) Rethinking inter-communal violence in Africa. Civil Wars: 1–30. Epub ahead of print 6 March 2023. DOI: 10.1080/13698249.2023.2180924.
59.
WigTKromreyD (2018) Which groups fight? Customary institutions and communal conflicts in Africa. Journal of Peace Research4(55): 415–429.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
