Since its liberation from colonial rule, India, a largely populated country, has always banked on mega projects to accelerate its economic development. However, such mega-development projects are found to generate very limited socioeconomic benefits for the very people for whom they were initially designed and planned. On the other hand, many such projects are benefiting the rich ‘omnivores’ and adversely affecting the livelihood of the land-dependent ‘ecosystem people’. This article deals with just such a story of ephemeral development, that of Independent India’s first mega project, the Hirakud Dam on the Mahanadi River. By making its main focus the issues of irrigation-water management and the plight of the tail-end farmers in recent years, this article highlights how the key objectives of India’s multipurpose river dam project, Hirakud, have failed during the last 50 years of its operation in terms of flood control, irrigation coverage and electricity generation.
Baboo B. ( 1992) Technology and Social Transformation: The Case of the Hirakud Multipurpose Dam Project in Orissa. New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company.
2.
Blaser M, Feit HA and McRae G (eds) (2004) In the Way of Development: Indigenous Peoples, Life Projects and Globalization . London and New York: Zed Books.
3.
Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) ( 1985) The State of India’s Environment 1984-85: The Second Citizens’ Report. New Delhi: Centre for Science and Environment.
4.
Cernea MM ( 1996) Eight Main Risks: Impoverishments and Social Justice in Resettlement. Washington, DC: Environment Department, World Bank.
5.
Doraiswamy R. and Mollinga P. ( 2003) Tail-enders and other deprived in canal irrigation system: Issues in Karnataka. Unpublished research report presented at the National Workshop on Tail-Enders and Other Deprived in Canal Irrigation System, Development Support Centre, Ahmedabad (28-29 November).
6.
D’Souza R. ( 2006) Drowned and Dammed: Colonial Capitalism and Flood Control in Eastern India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
7.
Fernandes W. ( 1994) Development-Induced Displacement in the Tribal Areas of India. New Delhi: Indian Social Institute.
8.
Gadgil M. and Guha R. ( 1995) Ecology and Equity: The Use and Abuse of Nature in Contemporary India. London and New Delhi: Routlege and Penguin Books India.
Gouda AK, Pati BK and Biswal MK ( 2007) 50 Barshara Hirakud: ‘Khadiku Sina Pediku Nahin’ . Jala Jeevan Samvad18: 4-13 (Oriya).
11.
Government of India (2008) Economic Survey 2007-08. New Delhi: Ministry of Finance, Economic Division & Oxford University Press.
12.
Government of Orissa (2006) Vulnerability reduction for sustainable development: In the context of natural disasters. In: Government of Orissa Orissa Human Development Report 2004. Bhubaneswar: Planning and Coordination Department, 161-189.
13.
Independent Commission on Population and Quality of Life (ICPQL) (1996) Caring for the Future: Report of the Independent Commission on Population Quality and Life. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
Joy KJ and Paranjpe S. ( 2003) Tail-enders and other deprived in canal irrigation system: Issues in Maharashtra. Unpublished research report presented at the National Workshop on Tail-Enders and Other Deprived in Canal Irrigation System, Development Support Centre, Ahmedabad (28-29 November).
15.
Mahapatra LK ( 1999) Resettlement, Impoverishment and Reconstruction in India . New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House .
16.
Mathur HM and Marsden D (eds) (1998) Development Projects and Impoverishment Risks: Resettling Project Affected People in India. Delhi : Oxford University Press.
17.
Meadows DH, Meadows DL, Randers J. and Behrens WW III ( 1972) The Limits to Growth. New York: Universe Books.
18.
Meher R. ( 2004) Stealing the Environment: Social and Ecological Effects of Industrialization in Rourkela. New Delhi: Manohar.
19.
Meher R. ( 2010) How Mineral-based Industrial Development Marginalizes and Displaces People in India: Three Case Studies. Lewiston, New York: Edwin Mellen Press.
20.
Oommen TK ( 2006) Coping with development pathologies: Resistance to displacement . Sociological Bulletin55(2): 267-280.
21.
Panda RK ( 2007) Industry vs agriculture: The battle over water in Hirakud . Infochange News & Features January.
22.
Pattanaik SK, Das B. and Mishra A. (nd) Hirakud Dam Project: Expectations and realities. In: Pria (ed.) People and Dams. New Delhi : Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA).
23.
Rajagopal A. ( 2003) Tail-enders and other deprived in canal irrigation system: Issues in Tamil Nadu. Unpublished research report presented at the National Workshop on Tail-Enders and Other Deprived in Canal Irrigation System, Development Support Centre, Ahmedabad (28-29 November).
24.
Shah AC ( 2003) Tail-enders and other deprived in canal irrigation system: Issues in Gujarat. Unpublished research report presented at the National Workshop on Tail-Enders and Other Deprived in Canal Irrigation System, Development Support Centre, Ahmedabad (28-29 November).
25.
Supkar K. ( 2010) Hirakud Jala Parichalanare Sarkar Vastavabadi Huantu. In Dash G (ed.) Vikalpa Vikas . Bhubaneswar: Gabeshana Chakra (Oriya), 34-35.
26.
Taylor BR (ed.) (1995) Ecological Resistance Movements: The Global Emergence of Radical and Popular Environmentalism . Albany, NY: State University of New York.
27.
Vashishtha PS ( 2003) Tail-enders and other deprived in canal irrigation system: Issues in Haryana. Unpublished research report presented at the National Workshop on Tail-Enders and Other Deprived in Canal Irrigation System, Development Support Centre, Ahmedabad (28-29 November).
28.
Viegas P. ( 1992) The Hirakud Dam oustees: Thirty years after. In: Ganguly Thukral E (ed.) Big Dams, Displaced People: Rivers of Sorrow Rivers of Change. New Delhi: Sage Publications, 29-53.
29.
World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) ( 1987) Our Common Future. New York and New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
