Contrasting Employee Assistance,Health Promotion,and Quality of Work Life Programs and Their Effects on Alcohol Abuse and Dependence *

Abstract

Numerous programs addressing employee alcohol abuse and dependence have appeared in organizations in the U.S. since the 1940s. Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) have effectively used a dual strategy of constructive confrontation and counseling for dealing with problem drinkers at the work site. In many organizations, however, practitioners have begun to treat problem drinkers by altering this strategy and/or relying on health promotion programs (HPPs) and quality of work life (QWL) efforts. This article compares EAPs, HPPs, and QWL, discussing their theoretical underpinnings, methods, and demonstrated effectiveness in treating alcohol abuse and dependence. The author encourages cooperation among EAP, HPP, and QWL practitioners in addressing work place factors related to drinking problems, and makes several recommendations for future research.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akabas

S. H.

Kurzman

P. A.

(1982). Work, workers, and work organizations: A view from social work. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Alderfer

C. P.

(1977). Organization development. Annual Review of Psychology, 28, 197–223.

Asma

Eggert

Hilker

(1971). Long-term experience with rehabilitation of alcoholic employees. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 13, 581–585.

Becker

M. H.

(1986). The tyranny of health promotion. Public Health Review, 14, 15–25.

Belasco

J. A.

Trice

H. M.

(1969). The assessment of change in training and therapy. New York: McGraw-Hill.

Bellack

A. S.

Hersen

(1980). Introduction to clinical psychology. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bellingham

Johnson

McCauley

(1985). The AT&T Communications total life concept. Corporate Commentary, 5(4), 1–13.

Beyer

J. M.

Trice

H. M.

(1984). A field study of the use and perceived effects of discipline in controlling work performance. Academy of Management Journal, 27(4), 743–764.

Burke

W. W.

(1980). Organization development and bureaucracy in the 1980s. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 16(3), 423–437.

10.

Carter

(1977, winter). Social work in industry: A history and a viewpoint. Social Thought, 3, 7–31.

11.

Chopra

K. S.

Preston

D. A.

Gerson

L. W.

(1979). The effects of constructive coercion on the rehabilitative process. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 21, 749–752.

12.

Clement

Gibbs

D. A.

(1983). Employee consideration of health promotion programs: Financial variables. Journal of Public Health Policy, 4, 45–55.

13.

Conrad

(1987a). Wellness in the work place: Potentials and pitfalls of worksite health promotion. The Milbank Quarterly, 65(2), 255–275.

14.

Conrad

(1987b). Who comes to work-site wellness programs? A preliminary review. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 29(4), 317–320.

15.

Conrad

(1988). Health and fitness and work: A participant's perspective. Social Science and Medicine, 26(5), 545–550.

16.

Conrad

. Moving worksite health promotion further upstream. Fitness in Business..

17.

Cosper

(1979). Drinking as conformity: A critique of sociological literature and occupational differences in drinking. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 40, 18–82.

18.

Cummings

T. G.

Molloy

E. S.

(1977). Productivity and the quality of work life. New York: Praeger.

19.

Davis

M. K.

Rosenberg

Iverson

D. C.

Vernon

T. M.

Bauer

(1984). Worksite health promotion in Colorado. Public Health Reports, 99, 538–543.

20.

Denenberg

T. S.

Denenberg

R. V.

(1983). Alcohol and drugs: Issues in the workplace. Washington, DC: Bureau of National Affairs.

21.

Deutscher

(1966). Words and deeds: Social science and social policy. Social Problems, 13(3), 233–254.

22.

Dickson

W. J.

Roethlisberger

F. J.

(1966). Counseling in an organization: A sequel to the Hawthorne researches. Boston: Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University.

23.

Dupont

R. L.

Basen

M. M.

(1982). Control of alcohol and drug abuse in industry: A literature review. In Parkinson

R. S.

Associates , (Eds.), Managing health promotion in the workplace. Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield.

24.

Edwards

D. W.

(1975). The evaluation of troubled-employee and occupational programs. In Williams

Moffat

, (Eds.), Occupational Alcoholism Programs. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas.

25.

Elkouri

E. A.

(1985). How arbitration works (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Bureau of National Affairs.

26.

Everly

G. S.

Feldman

R. H. L.

(1985). Occupational health promotion. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

27.

Faucheux

Amado

Laurent

(1982). Organizational development and change. Annual Review of Psychology, 33, 343–270.

28.

Feinstein

B. B.

Brown

E. G.

(1982). The new partnership. Cambridge, MA: Schenkman.

29.

Ferguson

C. A.

Fersing

J. E.

(1965). The legacy of neglect: An appraisal of the implications of emotional disturbances in the business environment. Dallas: Industrial Mental Health Associates.

30.

Fielding

J. E.

(1984a). Corporate health management. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

31.

Fielding

J. E.

(1984b). Health promotion and disease prevention at the worksite. Annual Review of Public Health, 5, 237–265.

32.

Franco

S. C.

(1960). A company program for problem drinkers: Ten years follow-up. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 2, 157–162.

33.

Frank

(1979). The present status of outcome studies. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 47, 310–316.

34.

Frank

L. L.

Hackman

J. R.

(1975). A failure of job enrichment: The case of the change that wasn't. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 11, 413–426.

35.

Friedlander

Brown

L. D.

(1974). Organization development. Annual Review of Psychology, 25, 313–341.

36.

Garfield

S. L.

(1983). Clinical psychology: The study of personality and behavior (2nd ed.). New York: Aldine.

37.

Giberson

L. G.

(1936). Psychiatry in industry. Personnel Journal, 15, 91–95.

38.

Glaser

Strauss

(1968). Discovery of grounded theory. Chicago: Aldine.

39.

Goldenberg

(1983). Contemporary clinical psychology (2nd ed.). Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.

40.

Gross

Etzioni

(1985). Organizations in society. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

41.

Habbe

(1969). Company controls for drinking problems: Studies in personnel policy (no. 218). New York: National Industrial Conference Board.

42.

Henderson

Bacon

(1953). Problem drinking: The Yale Plan for business and industry. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 14, 247–262.

43.

Herzlinger

R. E.

Calkins

(1986). How companies tackle health costs (Part 3). Harvard Business Review, 63(6), 70–80.

44.

Heyman

(1978). Alcoholism programs in industry. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers Center for Alcohol Studies.

45.

Hollis

J. F.

(1987). The effectiveness of worksite health promotion efforts. Portland, OR: Greater Portland Business Group on Health.

46.

Hornstein

H. A.

Bunker

B. B.

Burke

W. W.

Gindes

Lewicki

R. J.

, (Eds.) (1971). Social intervention: A behavioral science approach. New York: Free Press.

47.

Kahn

R. L.

(1974). Organization development: Some problems and proposals. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 10, 485–502.

48.

Katz

H. C.

Kochan

T. A.

Weber

M. R.

(1985). Assessing the effects of industrial relations systems and efforts to improve the quality of working life on organizational effectiveness. Academy of Management Journal, 28(3), 509–526.

49.

Kurtz

Googins

Howard

(1984). Measuring the success of alcoholism programs. Journal of Alcohol Studies, 45(1), 33–45.

50.

Landman

J. T.

Dawes

R. M.

(1982). Psychotherapy outcome: Smith and Glass' conclusions stand up under scrutiny. American Psychologist, 37, 504–516.

51.

Lawler

E. E.

(1986). High-involvement management. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

52.

Lott

G. N.

(1946). Emotional first-aid stations in industry. Industrial Medicine, 15, 419–422.

53.

MacLeod

A. G. S.

(1985). EAPs and blue collar stress. In Cooper

C. L.

Smith

M. J.

, (Eds.), Job stress and blue collar work. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

54.

McGill

A. M.

(1979). Proceedings of the National Conference on Health Promotion Programs in Occupational Settings. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.

55.

McLean

A. A.

(1973). Occupational mental health: Review of an emerging art. In Noland

R. L.

(ed.), Industrial mental health and employee counseling (pp. 107–137). New York: Behavioral Publications.

56.

Manello

T. A.

Seaman

F. J.

(1979). Prevalence, costs and handling of drinking problems on seven railroads (final report). Washington, DC: University Research.

57.

Margolis

B. L.

Kroes

W. H.

Quinn

R. P.

(1974). Job stress: An unlisted occupational hazard. Journal of Occupational Medicine, 16(10), 659–661.

58.

Miller

R. E.

Shain

Golaszewski

T. J.

(1985). The synergism of health promotion and restoration in the prevention of substance abuse in the workplace. Health Values, 9(5), 50–58.

59.

Mills

(1975, March/April). Human resources—Why the new concern? Harvard Business Review, pp. 120–134.

60.

Moberg

(1974). Follow-up study of persons referred for inpatient treatment from an industrial alcoholism program. Unpublished paper prepared for the occupational program section of the annual meeting of the Alcohol and Drug Problems Association, San Francisco.

61.

Myers

J. K.

Weissman

M. M.

Tischler

G. L.

Holzer

C. E.

Leaf

P. J.

Orvashel

Anthony

J. C.

Boyd

J. H.

Burke

J. D.

Kramer

Stoltzman

(1984). Six month prevalence of psychiatric disorders in three communities. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry, 41, 959–978.

62.

O'Donnell

M. P.

Ainsworth

T. H.

(1984). Health promotion in the workplace. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

63.

O'Toole

(1973). Work in America. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare.

64.

Ozley

L. M.

Ball

J. S.

(1982, May). Quality of worklife: Initiating successful efforts in labor-management organizations. Personnel Administrator, 27, 27–33.

65.

Parker

(1985). Inside the circle: A union guide to QWL. Boston: South End Press.

66.

Parkinson

R. S.

Associates (1982). Managing health promotion in the workplace. Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield.

67.

Pasmore

W. A.

Sherwood

J. J.

, (Eds.) (1978). Socio-technical systems: A source book. La Jolla, CA: University Associates.

68.

Phillips

Older

(1977). A model for counseling troubled supervisors. Alcohol, Health, and Research World, 2, 24–30.

69.

Phillips

D. A.

Purvis

A. J.

Older

H. L.

(1980). Turning supervisors on. Center City, MN: Hazelden.

70.

Porras

J. I.

Berg

P. O.

(1978). The impact of organization development. Academy of Management Review, 3, 249–266.

71.

Presnall

L. F.

(1956). People, production and personnel counseling. Paper presented at the New Mexico Mining Association Convention, Carlsbad, NM.

72.

Presnall

L. F.

(1966). Alcoholism and employees. Paper presented at the University of Utah School of Alcoholism Studies.

73.

Pugh

D. S.

Hickson

Hinnings

C. R.

(1985). Writers on organization (3rd ed.). Beverly Hills: Sage.

74.

Rachman

S. J.

Wilson

G. T.

(1980). The effects of psychological therapy (2nd ed.). New York: Pergamon Press.

75.

Reynolds

B. C.

(1975). Social work and social living. Washington, DC: National Association of Social Work Classics.

76.

Robins

L. N.

Helzer

J. E.

Weissman

M. M.

Orvashel

Gruenberg

Burke

J. D.

Regier

D. A.

(1984). Lifetime prevalence of specific psychiatric disorders in three sites. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry, 41, 949–958.

77.

Roethlisberger

Dickinson

W. J.

(1939). Management and the worker. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

78.

Roman

P. M.

(1981). From employee alcoholism to employee assistance: Deemphasis on prevention and alcohol programs in work-based programs. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 42, 244–272.

79.

Roman

(1988). Growth and transformation in workplace alcoholism programming. In Galenter

(ed.), Recent developments in alcoholism (vol. 6) (pp. 131–158). New York: Plenum Press.

80.

Roman

P. M.

Blum

T. C.

(1985). The core technology of employee assistance programs. ALMACAN, 15, 8–12.

81.

Roman

P. M.

Blum

T. C.

(1987). Ethics in worksite health programming: Who is served. Health Education Quarterly, 14(1), 57–70.

82.

Roman

P. M.

Blum

T. C.

(1988). Formal intervention in employee health. Social Science and Medicine, 26(5), 503–514.

83.

Runcie

J. F.

(1980, May/June). By day I make the cars. Harvard Business Review, 58, 106–115.

84.

Salancik

G. R.

Pfeffer

(1978). A social information processing approach to job attitudes and task design. Administrative Science Quarterly, 23, 224–253.

85.

Sandler

Sobelman

S. A.

(1985). Employee assistance programs—Alcohol abuse and related concerns. In Everly

G. S.

Jr. Feldman

R. H. L.

, (Eds.), Occupational health promotion. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

86.

Schoenbach

V. J.

Wagner

E. H.

Karon

J. M.

(1983). The use of epidemiologic data for personal risk assessment in health hazard/health risk appraisal programs. Journal of Chronic Diseases, 36, 625–638.

87.

Shain

Groeneveld

(1980). Employee assistance programs. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath.

88.

Shain

Suurvali

Boutilier

(1986). Healthier workers: Health promotion and employee assistance programs. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.

89.

Shapiro

D. A.

Shapiro

(1982). Meta-analysis of comparative therapy outcome studies: A replication and refinement. Psychological Bulletin, 92, 581–604.

90.

Sloan

R. P.

Gruman

J. C.

Allegrante

J. P.

(1987). Investing in employee health. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

91.

Smart

(1974). Employee alcoholics treated voluntarily and under constructive coercion. Quarterly Journal of Studies of Alcoholism, 35, 196–209.

92.

Smith

M. L.

Glass

G. V.

(1977). Meta-analysis of psythotherapy outcome studies. American Psychologist, 32, 752–760.

93.

Smith

M. L.

Glass

G. V.

Miller

T. I.

(1980). The benefits of psychotherapy. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

94.

Social Science and Medicine (1988). Worksite health promotion. 26(5).

95.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

(1982). Understanding EAP self-referral: Toward a social network approach. Contemporary Drug Problems, 11, 269–293.

96.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

(1986). Inside an emotional health program: A field study of workplace assistance for troubled employees. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.

97.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

Staudenmeier

W. J.

Jr. Trice

H. M.

(1988). Ideology and referral categories in EAP research. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 24(4), xxx–xxx.

98.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

Trice

H. M.

(1986). Strategies for Employee Assistance Programs: The Crucial Balance (Key Issues Series No. 30). Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.

99.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

Trice

H. M.

(1987). Social construction of alcohol problems in a union's peer counseling program. Journal of Drug Issues, 17(3), 223–254.

100.

Staudenmeier

W. J.

Jr. (1985). Alcohol and the workplace: A study of social policy in a changing America. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Washington University, St. Louis.

101.

Staudenmeier

W. J.

Jr. (1987). Context and variation in employer policies on alcohol. Journal of Drug Issues, 17(3), 255–271.

102.

Steele

P. D.

(1988). Employee assistance programs in context: A case of constructive brokering. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 24(4), xxx–xxx.

103.

Stein

B. A.

(1983). Quality of work life in action: Managing for effectiveness. New York: American Management Association.

104.

Trice

H. M.

(1962a). Alcoholism in industry: Modern procedures. New York: Christopher D. Smithers Foundation.

105.

Trice

H. M.

(1962b). The job behaviors of problem drinkers. In Pittman

D. J.

Snyder

C. R.

, (Eds.), Society, culture and drinking patterns. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

106.

Trice

H. M.

(1964). New light on identifying the alcoholic employee. Personnel, 41(5), 18–25.

107.

Trice

H. M.

Belasco

J. A.

(1966). Emotional health and employee responsibility (Bulletin No. 57), Ithaca, NY: New York State School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Cornell University.

108.

Trice

H. M.

Belasco

J. A.

(1968). Supervisory training about alcoholics and other problem employees. Quarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 29, 282–298.

109.

Trice

Beyer

(1981). A data-based examination of selection-bias in an evaluation of a job-based alcoholism program. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research, 5(4), 489–496.

110.

Trice

Beyer

(1984a). Employee assistance programs: Blending performance-oriented and humanitarian ideologies to assist emotionally disturbed employees. In Greenley

J. R.

(ed.), Research in community and mental health (vol. 4) (pp. 245–297). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.

111.

Trice

Beyer

(1984b). Work related outcomes of constructive confrontation strategies in a job-based alcoholism program. Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 45, 393–404.

112.

Trice

Beyer

J. M.

Coppess

(1981). Sowing seeds of change: How work organizations respond to occupational program consultants. Journal of Drug Issues, 11, 311–336.

113.

Trice

H. M.

Roman

P. M.

(1978). Spirits and demons at work: Alcohol and other drugs on the job (2nd ed.). Ithaca, NY: New York State School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Cornell University.

114.

Trice

H. M.

Schonbrunn

(1981). A history of job based alcohol programs, 1900–1955. Journal of Drug Issues, 19, 636–648.

115.

Trice

H. M.

Sonnenstuhl

W. J.

(1988). Work place risk factors and drinking behavior: Implications for research and prevention. Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 24(4), xxx–xxx.

116.

Von Wiegand

(1971, March). The problem of alcoholism. Environmental Control and Safety Management, pp. 21–28.

117.

Walton

R. E.

(1977). The diffusion of new work structures: Explaining why success didn't take. In Mirvis

P. H.

Berg

D. N.

, (Eds.), Failures in organization development and change. New York: Wiley Interscience.

118.

Zald

M. N.

McCarthy

J. D.

(1980). Social movement industries: Competition and cooperation among movement organizations. Research in Social Movements, Conflicts, and Change, 3, 1–20.