Currently, there exist several academic and legal questions on which common perception is not established among states. One of them concerns the interpretation of ‘general principles of law’ mentioned in Article 38(1)(c) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice. Variance in the interpretation of ‘general principles of law’ manifests itself mainly in controversies over whether they are principles of domestic law or international law and over the implication of ‘civilized nations’ that qualifies ‘general principles of law’. The article aims at analysing such divergent views surrounding ‘general principles of law’ and voicing the authors’ view on the matter. By examining the principles in comparison with international conventions and custom, and in terms of wordings employed in the relevant provisions, the article attempts to demonstrate that they must be viewed as principles shared by national law systems of certain states. It also argues that in view of the essential characteristics of international law, and in terms of the meaning of the term ‘civilized nations’, ‘general principles of law’ cannot be deemed a universal source of international law, and in particular, that since the phrase ‘civilized nations’ was not intended to include all states in the world, it is necessary to amend the relevant wording.
AnghieA. (1999). Finding the peripheries: Sovereignty and colonialism in nineteenth-century international law. Harvard International Law Journal, 40, 1–80.
2.
AppleJ. G. (Ed.). (2007, Jul/Aug). What are general principles of international law. 2. US.
3.
Arakas (The Georgios) Case (Greco-Bulgarian Mix. Arb. Trib. 1927).
4.
BrownlieI. (1998). Principles of public international law. Oxford.
5.
CasseseA. (2005). International law(2nd ed.). Oxford University Press.
6.
ChengB. (1953). General principles of law as applied by international courts and tribunals. Cambridge University Press.
7.
ChengB. (2012). General principles of law as applied by international courts and tribunals. Law Press.
8.
ChimniB. S. (2018). Customary international law: A third world perspective. The American Journal of International Law.
9.
CrawfordJ. (2012). Brownlie's principles of public international law(8th ed.). Oxford University Press.
10.
DeganV.-D. (1997). Sources of international law. Martinus Nijhoff.
11.
EllisJ. (2011). General principles and comparative law. European Journal of International Law, 22, 949–971.
12.
GajaG. (2016). General principles of law. In R. Wolfrum (Ed.), Max Plank encyclopedia of international law(para. 16). Oxford University Press.
13.
GardinerR. (2012). Treaty interpretation. In D. Hollis (Ed.), Oxford guide to treaties. Oxford University Press.
14.
GarnerB. A. (Ed.). (2009). Black's law dictionary(9th ed.). Thomson Reuters.
15.
GeT. (2017). Study on the implication of general principles of law. Fujian Law Science, 132(4), 41–43.
16.
HauserR. (2002). China and developments in international law: Wang Tieya as a contemporary. Journal of the History of International Law, 4, 142–158.
17.
HegelG. W. (1979). Philosophy of right. Oxford.
18.
HoffmannT. (2016). The concept of the standard of civilization in international law. http://jog.tk.mta.hu/mtalwp
19.
ILC. (2006). Fragmentation of international law: Difficulties arising from the diversification and expansion of international law. Rep. of the Study Group of the International Law Commission, 58th Session. United Nations.
20.
ICJ. (1949). Corfu Channel Case (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland v. Albania), ICJ Rep 4.
21.
ICJ. (1951). Reservations to the convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide, Advisory Opinion, ICJ Rep 15, para 23.
22.
ICJ. (1969). North Sea Continental Shelf (Germany v. Denmark; Germany v. Netherlands) ICJ Rep 3, para 74.
23.
ICJ. (1997). Case concerning Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary v. Slovakia) ICJ Rep 7.
24.
ILR. (1992). Amco Asian Corporation and Other v. Republic of Indonesia, ICSID ARB/81/1, Award of November 20, 1984, 89 ILR, 405, p. 504.
25.
JiangS. B. (2010). Study on general principles of law under international law. Beijing Unversity Review of International and Comparative Law.
26.
KelsenH. (1952). Principles of International Law. Rinehart.
27.
KoskenniemiM. (2004). The gentle civilizer of nations: The rise and fall of international law 1870–1960. Cambridge University Press.
28.
League of Nations. (1920). Records of the First Assembly, Meetings of the Committee. Geneva.
29.
LepardB. D. (2010). The relationship between customary international law and general principles of law. In B. D. Lepard (Ed.), Customary international law: A new theory with practical applications. Cambridge University Press.
30.
LiH. P. (1982). Jus Cogens and international law. Chinese Yearbook of International Law.
31.
Lord LloydJ. (2018, February16). General principles of law in international law and common law. http://www.supremecourt.uk/docs/speech-180216.pdf
32.
MendelsonM.. (2016). The use of domestic law principles in the development of international law study group. Report delivered at the Johannesburg Conference, International Law Association.
33.
MillJ. S. (Ed.). (1867). A few words on non-intervention. In Dissertations and discussions: Political, philosophical and historical (vol. 4). Henry Holt.
34.
MüllersonR. (1998). The interplay of objective and subjective elements in customary law. In K. Wellens (Ed.), International law: Theory and practice - Essays in honour of Eric Suy. Martinus Nijhoff.
35.
ObregónL. (2013). The civilized and the uncivilized. In B. Fassbender, A. Peters, S. Peter, & D. Högger (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of the history of international law. Oxford.
36.
ÖzsuU. (2010). Agency, universality, and the politics of international legal history. Harvard International Law Journal, 51, 475.
37.
ParryC. (1965). The sources and evidences of international law. Manchester University Press.
38.
PCIJ. (1928). PCIJ Report Series A.
39.
PCIJ, Advisory Committee of Jurists. (1920). Procès-Verbaux of the proceedings of the committee, June 16–July 24th, 1920 with Annexes. Van Langenhuysen Brothers.
40.
PelletA. (2002). Article 38. In A. Zimmermann, C. Tomuschat, & K. Oellers-Frahm (Eds.), The statute of the international court of justice: A commentary (pp. 677–792). Oxford University Press.
41.
RousseauC. (1944). Principes généraux du droit international public (Vol. 1). Pedone.
42.
SchachterO. (1982). International law in theory and practice: General course on public international law. Martinus Nijhoff.
43.
ShawM. N. (2005). International law(5th ed.). Beijing University Press.
44.
SimpsonG. (2004). Great powers and unequal states: Unequal sovereigns in the international legal order. Cambridge.
45.
SkubiszewskiK. (1987). The elaboration of general multilateral conventions and of non-contractual instruments having a normative function or objective. Report delivered at the Session of Cairo, Cairo.
46.
StarkeJ. G. (1989). An introduction to international law(10th ed.). Butterworths.
47.
TunkinG. (1971). ‘General principles of law’ in international law. In R. Marcic et al (Eds.), Internationale Festschrit Für Alfred Verdross. Wilhelm Fink Verlag Munchen.
48.
UN. (1945, October24). Charter of the United Nations.
49.
UN. (1968). Official records of the United Nations conference on the law of treaties, first session. Summary Records of the Plenary Meeting and of the Meetings of the Committee of the Whole, 56th Meeting.
50.
UN. (1969, May23). Vienna convention on the law of treaties 1155 UNTS 331.
51.
UN. (2019). A/74/10, Chapter IV General principles of law. https://legal.un.org/ilc/reports/2019/english/chp9.pdf
52.
UN. (n.d.). Official records of the United Nations Conference on the Law of Treaties, First Session. Summary records of the plenary meetings and of the meetings of the Committee of the Whole
53.
UN. (n.d.). The United Nations Conference on International Organizations (UNCIO), Documents, Vol. XIV.
54.
VerdrossA. (1981). International law(H. Li, Trans.). Shangwu Press.
55.
VirallyM. (1968). The sources of international law. In M. Sorensen (Ed.), Manual of public international law (pp. 144–148). Macmillan.
56.
WaldockH. (1962). General course on public international law. Rec des Cours 39.
57.
WangT. (1995). International law(12th ed.). Law Press.
58.
Wiki. (1815, February8). Final Act of the Congress of Vienna, Act No. XV., Declaration of the Powers on the Abolition of the Slave Trade. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Final_Act_of_the_Congress_of_Vienna/Act_XV
59.
WolfrumR. (2013). General international law (principles, rules, and standards). In Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law. Oxford University Press.
60.
WoodM. (2013). First report on formation and evidence of customary international law. International Law Commission.
61.
YotovaR. (2017). Challenges in the identification of the ‘general principles of law recognized by civilized nations’: The approach of the International Court. CJCCL, 3(1), 269.
