Protest and Regime Change: Different Experiences of the Arab Uprisings and the 2009 Iranian Presidential Election Protests

Abstract

Political developments, such as the ‘Arab Spring’, have led the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) towards instability, unrest and severe sectarian confrontations. Nearly 2 years before the ‘Arab Spring’, ‘the Iranian Green Movement’ swept over the country and led to the expectations that Iran would undergo a fundamental political change. The article addresses an important question as to why the 2009 Iranian unrest known as the ‘Green Movement’ did not lead to regime change, while on the other hand, the ‘Arab Spring’ ultimately led to the change of political systems in Tunisia and Egypt. Further, some significant factors are highlighted anticipating the degree of stability and instability for the future of political regimes in the MENA region.

Keywords

Protest regime change Arab Spring Iran’s Green Movement Tunisia Egypt

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aarts

Dijke

P. V.

Kolman

Statema

Dahhan

(2012). From resilience to revolt: Making sense of Arab spring. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: University of Amsterdam, Department of Political Science, WODC.

Abdullah

(2012). Repercussions of the Arab spring on GCC states (Research Paper). Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies.

Aliboni

(2011). The international dimension of the Arab spring: The international spectator. Italian Journal of International Affairs , 46(4), 5–9.

Altunişik

M. B.

(2014). Rentier state theory and the Arab uprisings: An appraisal. Uluslararası İlişkiler Dergisi , 11(42), 75–91.

Acemoğlu

Robinson

J. A.

(2012). Why nations fail: The origins of power, prosperity, and poverty . New York, NY: Crown Publishing Group.

Ahmed

Capoccia

(2014). The study of democratization and the Arab Spring. Middle East Law and Governance , 6, 1–31.

Allinson

(2015). Class forces, transition and the Arab uprisings: A comparison of Tunisia, Egypt and Syria. Democratization , 22(2), 294–314.

Al-Sayyid

K. M.

(1993). A civil society in Egypt? The Middle East Journal , 47(2), 228–242.

Amin

Assaad

al-Baharna

Dervis

Desai

R. M.

Dhillon

N. S.

… Kaufmann

(2012). After the spring: Economic transitions in the Arab world . Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

10.

Anderson

(2011). Demystifying the Arab spring: Parsing the differences between Tunisia, Egypt, and Libya. Foreign Affairs , 90(3), 2–7.

11.

Aydin

(2013, December 30). Hereditary oil monarchies: Why Arab Spring fails in GCC Arabian states? Journal of Social Sciences , 30, 123–138.

12.

Behr

Aaltola

(2011). The Arab uprising causes, prospects and implication (FIIA Briefing Paper 76), 1.

13.

Bayat

(2011). Arab revolutions and the study of Middle Eastern societies. International Journal of Middle East Studies , 43(3), 386.

14.

Bayat

. (2013). Life as politics: How ordinary people change the Middle East (2nd ed.). Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.

15.

Bayat

. (2017). Revolution without revolutionaries: Making sense of the Arab spring. Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University Press.

16.

Boening

A. B.

(2014). The Arab spring: Re-balancing the greater Euro-Mediterranean? Springer.

17.

Bogaert

(2013). Contextualizing the Arab revolts: The politics behind three decades of neoliberalism in the Arab world. Middle East Critique , 22(3), 213–234.

18.

Brynen

(2012). Arab uprisings and the study of Middle East politics: Semi-random observations in search of a witty subtitle. In Arab uprisings: New opportunities for political science. The Project on Middle East Political Science, directed by Marc Lynch, Institute for Middle East Studies, George Washington University, 11–13.

19.

Chandy

(2011). Reframing development cooperation. In From aid to global development cooperation: The 2011 Brookings Blum Roundtable Policy Briefs.

20.

Comninos

(2011). Twitter revolutions and cyber crackdowns: User-generated content and social networking in the Arab spring and beyond . Association for Progressive Communications.

21.

Dabashi

(2011). The green movement in Iran (Edited with an introduction by Navid Nikzadfar). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

22.

Dalacoura

(2012). The 2011 uprisings in the Arab Middle East: Political change and geopolitical implications. International Affairs , 88(1), 63–79.

23.

Ehteshami

(1999). Is the Middle East democratizing? British Journal of Middle East Studies , 26(2), 199–217.

24.

El-Ghobashy

(2008). Constitutionalist contention in contemporary Egypt. American Behavioral Scientist , 51(11), 1590–1610.

25.

Elhusseini

(2014). Post Arab spring thoughts: The Middle East between external and internal mechanisms (Political economic & social forces). Hemispheres , 29(2), 5–28.

26.

Esposito

J. L.

Sonn

Voll

J. O.

(2015). Islam and democracy after the Arab spring . Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

27.

Eyadat

(2012). The Arab revolutions of 2011: Revolutions of dignity. In Calleya

Wohlfeld

(Eds.), Change and opportunities in the emerging Mediterranean (pp. 3–19).

28.

Farooq

Bukhari

Ahmed

(2017). Arab spring and the theory of relative deprivation. International Journal of Business and Social Science , 8(1), 126–132.

29.

Foran

(Ed.). (1997). Theorizing revolutions . London, UK: Routledge.

30.

Fridriksson

A. M.

Saarto

Soomre

Hansen

H. H.

(2012). The Arab uprising . Roskilde Universitetscenter’s Digitale Arkiv. Retrieved from https://core.ac.uk/display/12521536

31.

Gerges

F. A.

(Ed.). (2016). Contentious politics in the Middle East: Popular resistance and marginalized activism beyond the Arab uprisings . Springer.

32.

Giddens

(1984). The constitution of society: Outline of the theory of structuration . Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

33.

Gobe

(2010). The Gafsa mining basin between riots and a social movement: Meaning and significance of a protest movement in Ben Ali’s Tunisia.

34.

Goldstone

(1997). Population growth and revolutionary crises. In Foran

(Ed.), Theorizing revolutions (pp. 102–120). London, UK: Routledge.

35.

Goldstone

. (2001). Toward a fourth generation of revolutionary theory. Annual Review of Political Science , 4, 139–187.

36.

Goldstone

J. A.

(2010). From structure to agency to process: The evolution of Charles Tilly’s theories of social action as reflected in his analyses of contentious politics. The American Sociologist , 41(4), 358–367.

37.

Goldstone

J. A.

. (2011a). Understanding the revolutions of 2011: Weakness and resilience in Middle Eastern autocracies. Foreign Affairs , 90(3), 8–16.

38.

Goldstone

J. A.

. (2011b). Cross-class coalitions and the making of the Arab revolts of 2011. Swiss Political Science Review , 17(4), 457–463.

39.

Halaseh

(2012). Civil society, youth and the Arab spring. In Calleya

Wohlfeld

(Eds.), Change and opportunities in the emerging Mediterranean (Ch. 13, pp. 254–273). Msida: Mediterranean Academy of Diplomatic Studies, Malta University Press.

40.

Hamid

(2011). The struggle for Middle East democracy: Why the Arab street finally revolted. The Cairo Review of Global Affairs , 1, 18–29.

41.

Hashemi

Postel

(Eds.). (2010). The people reloaded: The green movement and the struggle for Iran’s future . New York, NY: Melville House.

42.

Howard

P. N.

Duffy

Freelon

Hussain

Mari

Mazaid

(2011). Opening closed regimes: What was the role of social media during the Arab spring ? Retrieved from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Data_Integrity_Notice.cfm?abid=2595096

43.

Howard

P. N.

Hussain

M. M.

(2013). Democracy’s fourth wave? Digital media and the Arab spring . New York, NY: Oxford Studies in Digital Politics, Oxford University Press.

44.

Huntington

S. P.

(1991). The third wave: Democratization in the late twentieth century . Norman; London, UK: University of Oklahoma Press.

45.

Jalaeipour

H. R.

Nasr Esfahani

(2014). Framing analysis of 2009 post-election events in Iran. Journal of Historical Sociology , 6(1), 137–161.

46.

Jamshidi

(2013). The future of the Arab spring: Civic entrepreneurship in politics, art, and technology startups . Butterworth-Heinemann Publications, Elsevier.

47.

Kamrava

Mora

(1998). Civil society and democratizing in comparative perspective: Latin America and the Middle East. Third World Quarterly , 19(5), 893–915.

48.

Khondker

H. H.

(2011). Role of the new media in the Arab Spring. Globalizations , 8(5), 675–679.

49.

Kinninmont

(2012). ‘Bread, dignity and social justice’: The political economy of Egypt’s transition (Chatham House Briefing Paper, avril).

50.

Kurzman

(2012). The Arab spring: Ideals of the Iranian green movement methods of the Iranian revolution. International Journal of Middle East Studies , 44(1), 162–165.

51.

Khusrokhavar

(2012). The new Arab revolutions that shook the world. Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

52.

Lanchovichina

(2017). Eruptions of popular anger: The economics of the Arab spring and its aftermath . Washington, DC: The World Bank.

53.

Lane

D. C.

(2001). Rerum cognoscere causas: Part II—Opportunities generated by the agency/structure debate and suggestions for clarifying the social theoretic position of system dynamics. System Dynamics Review , 17(4), 293–309.

54.

Levine

(2013). Theorizing revolutionary practice: Agendas for research on the Arab uprisings. Middle East Critique , 22(3), 191–212.

55.

Luciani

(Ed.). (2017) Combining economic and political development: The experience of MENA (International Development Policy Series No. 7). Geneva, Switzerland; Boston, MA: Graduate Institute Publications; Brill-Nijhoff.

56.

Lutterbeck

(2013). Arab uprisings, armed forces, and civil–military relations. Armed Forces & Society , 39(1), 28–52.

57.

Lynch

(2011, December). The big think behind the Arab spring: Do the Middle East’s revolutions have a unifying ideology? Foreign Policy , 190, 46.

58.

Lynch

(Ed.). (2014). The Arab uprisings explained: New contentious politics in the Middle East . New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

59.

MacFarquhar

(2011, June 10). Saudi cash is the key to quiet in the kingdom. The International Herald Tribune , p. 4.

60.

Marcovitz

(2014). The Arab spring uprisings . San Diego, CA: Reference Point Press Inc.

61.

Mosco

(2009). The political economy of communication (2nd ed.). SAGE Publications.

62.

Mushtaq

Afzal

(2017). Arab spring: Its causes and consequences. Journal of JPUHS , 30(1), 1–10.

63.

Mustafa

(2011). Arab Spring uprisings: Revolutionary patterns and theoretical explanations. Akademik İncelemeler Dergisi (AID) , 6(2), 41–62.

64.

Nepstad

S. E.

(2013). Mutiny and nonviolence in the Arab spring: Exploring military defections and loyalty in Egypt, Bahrain, and Syria. Journal of Peace Research , 50(3), 337–349.

65.

Omotola

J. S.

(2012). Legitimacy crisis and ‘popular uprisings’ in North Africa. Strategic Analysis , 36(5), 713–719.

66.

Open Net Initiative. (2013). After the green movement: Internet controls in Iran, 2009–2012 . Open Net Initiative.

67.

Pace

Cavatorta

(2012). The Arab uprisings in theoretical perspective—An introduction. Mediterranean Politics , 17(2), 125–138.

68.

Perthes

(2012, February 9). The Arab Revolts in Year Two. Open Democracy . Retrieved from http://www.opendemocracy.net/volker-perthes/arab-revolts-in-year-two [last accessed 22 January 2020].

69.

QadirMushtaq

Afzal

(2017). Arab spring: Its causes and consequences. Journal of the Punjab University Historical Society , 30(1), 1–10.

70.

Rafati

(2012, May). Iran and the Arab spring. LSE Ideas, SR 011, 49–52.

71.

Richter

Steiner

(2008). Politics, economics and tourism development in Egypt: Insights into the sectoral transformations of a neo-patrimonial rentier state. Third World Quarterly , 29(5), 939–959.

72.

Ryan

(2005). Agency-structure integration. In Ritzer

(Ed.), Encyclopedia of social theory (Vol. 1, pp. 5–6). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.

73.

Seeberg

(2015). Guest editor’s introduction: An Arab world in transition, political changes and theoretical discussions in a post-‘Arab spring’ scenario. Middle East Critique , 24(1), 1–7.

74.

Sharp

J. M.

(2015). Egypt: Background and U.S. relations (CRS report for congress). Washington DC: Congressional Research Service.

75.

Sika

(2011). The political economy of the Arab Spring. Mediterranean Politics , 16(3): 427–433.

76.

Sika

. (2014). The Arab state and social contestation. In Kamrava

(Ed.), Beyond the Arab spring: The evolving ruling bargain in the Middle East (pp. 73–98). London, UK: Oxford.

77.

Stein

(2012). Revolution or coup? Egypt’s fraught transition. Survival: Global Politics and Strategy , 54(4), 45–66.

78.

Stepan

Linz

J. J.

(2013). Democratization theory and the ‘Arab spring’. Journal of Democracy , 24(2), 15–30.

79.

Sayyid

B. S.

(1997). A fundamental fear: Eurocentrism and the emergence of Islamism. London, UK & New York, NY: Zed Books.

80.

Selim

G. M.

(2013). The United States and the Arab spring: The dynamics of political engineering. Arab Studies Quarterly , 35(3), 255–272.

81.

Sundquist

V. H.

(2013). Iranian democratization Part I: A historical case study of the Iranian green movement. Journal of Strategic Security , 6(1), 19–34.

82.

Syed

(2014). Exploring the causes of revolutions in Tunisia and Egypt. Ortadoğu Etütleri , 5(2), 55–79.

83.

Taleb

N. N.

Blythe

(2011). The black swan of Cairo: How suppressing volatility makes the world less predictable and more dangerous. Foreign Affairs , 90(3), 33–39.

84.

Yadlin

(2012). The Arab uprising one year on. One Year of The Arab Spring: Global and Regional Implications, Memorandum , 113, 15.

85.

United Nations. (2012). The global partnership for development: Making rhetoric a reality. Millennium development goal 8. MDG Gap Task Force Report .

86.

Valbjørn

Volpi

(2014). Revisiting theories of Arab politics in the aftermath of the Arab uprisings. Mediterranean Politics , 19(1), 134–136.

87.

Volpi

(2014). Framing political revolutions in the aftermath of the Arab uprisings. Mediterranean Politics , 19(1), 153–156.

88.

Wickham-Crowley

T. P.

(1997). Structural theories of revolution. In Foran

(Ed.), Theorizing revolutions (pp. 36–70). London, UK: Routledge.

89.

Zguric

(2012). Challenges for democracy in countries affected by the Arab Spring. Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations , 23(4), 417–434.