The security sector in Afghanistan has received intense international assistance and the investment of many billions of dollars in the nearly ten years since the fall of the Taliban regime, yet the country is still unable to maintain security and stability. While there are many obstacles to reform in the Afghan context itself, not the least being the present insurgency, the international community has made many mistakes that have prevented success. The police is perhaps more important than the military in peace-building, but it is the weakest of all the security forces. There have been three phases of police reform as the international community has tried to find the best approach, but the one factor that has not changed and is the greatest impediment to reform is the insistence on using a ‘military model’ for changing the police, and to use the police more than the army for fighting the insurgency. Now, there is another plan: to prepare the Afghan national security forces to assume leadership and responsibility for security in the country by 2014. Is this another international failure in the making?
BarnesJulian E.MathewRosenbergHabib KhanTotakhil. (2010, 5October). Habib Khan Pakistan urges on Taliban. The Wall Street Journal.
3.
FriesendorfCorneliusKrempelJörg. (2011). Militarized versus Civilian Policing: Problems of Reforming the Afghan National Police. Report no. 102. Translation by BensteadLynn. Frankfurt: Peace Research Institute Frankfurt.
4.
GiustozziAntonio. (2008). Afghanistan’s national army: The ambiguous prospects of Afghanization. Terrorism Monitor (Washington DC), 6(9).
5.
Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. (2010a). Afghanistan: The London Conference Communiqué. 28 January 2010.
6.
Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. (2010b). Kabul: International Conference on Afghanistan. 20 July 2010.
International Crisis Group. (2007). Reforming Afghanistan’s police. Asia Report 138. Brussels: ICG.
9.
International Crisis Group. (2008). Policing in Afghanistan: Still searching for a strategy. Asia Briefing 85. Brussels: ICG.
10.
International Crisis Group. (2010a). A force in fragments: Reconstituting the Afghan national army. Asia Report 190. Brussels: ICG.
11.
International Crisis Group. (2010b). Reforming Afghanistan’s broken judiciary. Asia Report 195. Brussels: ICG.
12.
Islamic Republic of Afghanistan. (2008). Afghanistan national development strategy 1387–1391 (2008–2013): A strategy for security, governance, economic growth and poverty reduction. Kabul: United Nations Development Programme.
13.
JalaliAli Ahmad. (2010). Afghanistan in transition. Parameters, Autumn2010. Carlisle PA: US Army War College.
KaganFrederick W.KaganKimberlyDresslerJeffreyForsbergCarl. (2011). Defining success in Afghanistan. Washington: American Enterprise Institute and the Institute for the Study of War.
16.
MurrayTonita. (2007). Police-building in Afghanistan: A case study of civil security reform. International Peacekeeping, 14(1), 108–126.
17.
MurrayTonita. (2009). The security sector in Afghanistan: Slow and unsteady. South Asian Survey, 16(2).
PeritoRobert M. (2009). Afghanistan’s police: The weak link in security sector reform. Special Report 227. Washington, DC: US Institute of Peace.
20.
RashidAhmad. (2008). Descent into chaos. New York: Viking.
21.
Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security Studies and Foreign Policy Research Institute. (2009). Reforming the Afghan national police. London and Philadelphia: RUSI and FPRI.
22.
RubinBarnett R. (2009). The transformation of the Afghan state. In ThierJ. Alexander (Ed.), The future of Afghanistan. Washington, DC: USIP.
23.
Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR). (2010). Actions needed to improve the reliability of Afghan security force assessments. 29June2010. Washington: SIGAR.
24.
SchwartzMoshe. (2010). Department of defense contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan: Background and analysis, 2July2010. Congressional Research Service, R40764. Washington, D.C: CRS.
25.
SedraMark. (2006). Security sector reform in Afghanistan: The slide toward expediency. International Peacekeeping, 13(1).
26.
SedraMark. (2008). Security sector reform and state building in Afghanistan. In HayesGeoffreySedraMark (Eds), Afghanistan: Transition under threat. Waterloo: Canada: Wilfred Laurier University Press.
27.
TarnoffCurt. (2010, 12August). Afghanistan: U.S. foreign assistance. Washington: Con-gressional Research Service, R40699. Washington, D.C.: CRS.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2010). World Drug Report 2010, E.10.XI.13. New York: United Nations.
32.
Washington Post. (2010, 9September). Karzai seeks to restrict U.S. role in graft inquiries.
33.
WilderAndrew. (2007). Cops or robbers?The struggle to reform the Afghan National Police. Kabul: Afghanistan Research and Evaluation unit, Issues paper series, July.
34.
ZiezulewiczGeoff. (2010, 5December). A motley crew steps up to plug training gaps. Stars and Stripes.
