Does China’s public assistance scheme create welfare dependency? An assessment of the welfare of the Urban Minimum Living Standard Guarantee

Abstract

This study examines the myth of whether China’s public assistance scheme is creating welfare dependency. It first analyses the benefit levels of the Urban Minimum Living Standard Guarantee (UMLSG) according to the international poverty measurements. Then it employs in-depth interviews to reveal the life experiences of 15 UMLSG beneficiaries and the views of 8 welfare officials in Guangzhou city. It concludes that the UMLSG assistance is actually too low to reduce the work motivation of beneficiaries. Instead, supplementary welfare associated with the UMLSG contributes to the staying of beneficiaries, to facilitate access to basic housing, health and educational services.

Keywords

Costs of basic needs global absolute standards minimum living standard poverty welfare dependency

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barnichon

Figura

(2016) ‘Declining Desire to Work and Downward Trends in Unemployment and Participation’, NBER Macroeconomics Annual 30(1): 449–94.

Brezina

(2008) ‘What Went Wrong in New Orleans? An Examination of the Welfare Dependency Explanation’, Social Problems 55(1): 23–42.

Business Inside UK (2017) ‘The Economist Behind Universal Basic Income: Give All Citizens UBI to Help Combat a “Neofascist Wave of Populism”’. Available online at: http://uk.businessinsider.com/free-money-universal-basic-income-guy-standing-economist-neofascism-populism-brexit-2017-1

Chen

Hao

Q.-J.

Stephens

(2010) ‘Assessing Housing Affordability in Post-Reform China: A Case Study of Shanghai’, Housing Studies 25(6): 877–901.

Chen

S.-H.

Ravallion

Wang

Y.-J.

(2006) ‘Dibao: A Guaranteed Minimum Income in China’s Cities?’ Policy Research Working Paper Series, World Bank, Washington, DC, January 2006.

Corcoran

Duncan

Gurin

(1985) ‘Myth and Reality: The Causes and Persistence of Poverty’, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 4(4): 516–36.

Deng

X-P.

(1980) ‘Current Situation and Task’. Available online at: http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64184/64186/66677/4493843.html (in Chinese).

Department for Work & Pensions (DWP) (2010) 21st Century Welfare. London: DWP.

Duoji

C.-R

. (1997) ‘Actively Establishing the Urban and the Rural Minimum Living Standard Guarantee’, in Duoji

C.-R.

(ed.), Research and Practice of the Civil Affairs Work (vol. 1), pp. 250–6. Beijing: China Social Sciences Press (in Chinese).

10.

Duoji

C.-R.

(2001) Research and Practice of China’s Minimum Living Standard Guarantee Institution. Beijing: Renmin Press (in Chinese).

11.

Food Agriculture Organization, World Health Organization and United Nations University (2004) ‘Human Energy Requirements’. Available online at: http://www.fao.org/docrep/007/y5686e/y5686e00.htm

12.

Gao

Zhai

F.-H.

(2012) ‘Anti-Poverty Family Policies in China: A Critical Evaluation’, Asian Social Work and Policy Review 6(2): 122–35.

13.

Gilder

(1981) Wealth and Poverty. New York: Basic Books.

14.

Global Times (2013) ‘Squeezing the Exaggeration of the UMLSG Welfare’. Available online at: http://finance.huanqiu.com/comment/2013-07/4129621.html (in Chinese).

15.

Gustafsson

Deng

Q.-H.

(2011) ‘Dibao Receipt and Its Importance for Combating Poverty in Urban China’, Poverty & Public Policy 3(1): 1–32.

16.

Gustafsson

Gang

(2013) ‘A Comparison of Social Assistance in China and Sweden’, China Journal of Social Work 6(3): 292–310.

17.

Han

K.-Q.

Guo

(2012) ‘The Myth of Welfare Dependency in China: An Empirical Study on China’s Urban Minimum Living-Hood Guarantee Scheme’, Sociological Studies 2: 149–67 (in Chinese).

18.

Hancock

Mooney

(2013) ‘“Welfare Ghettos” and the “Broken Society”: Territorial Stigmatization in the Contemporary UK’, Housing, Theory and Society 30(1): 46–64.

19.

Hussain

(2003) Urban Poverty in China: Measurement, Patterns and Policies. Geneva: International Labour Office.

20.

International Monetary Fund (2010) ‘World Economic Outlook Database 2010’. Available online at: http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2010/02/weodata/index.aspx

21.

Jordan

(2004) ‘The Causes of Poverty – Cultural vs. Structural: Can There Be a Synthesis?’ Perspectives in Public Affairs 1: 18–34.

22.

Khan

A.R.

Riskin

(2001) Inequality and Poverty in China in the Age of Globalization. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

23.

Liu

L.-C.

Lin

M.-G.

(2015) ‘Does “Raising Lazy People” Exist? A Study on Welfare Dependency in the UMLSG’, Dongyue Tribute 36(10): 37–42 (in Chinese).

24.

Meng

Gregory

Wang

Y.-J.

(2005) ‘Poverty, Inequality and Growth in Urban China 1986–2000’, Journal of Comparative Economics 33(4): 710–29.

25.

Ministry of Health (2009) An Analysis Report of National Health Services Survey in China 2008. Beijing: Peking Union Medical College Press (in Chinese).

26.

Mitchell

(2015) ‘Dependency, Work and the Growing Welfare State’. Available online at: http://www.thecommentator.com/article/5796/dependency_work_and_the_growing_welfare_state

27.

Murray

(1984) Losing Ground: American Social Policy 1950–1980. New York: Basic Books.

28.

National Bureau of Statistics (various years) China Statistical Yearbook 2010. Beijing: China Statistics Press (in Chinese).

29.

Ngok

Chan

W.K.

Peng

(2011) ‘Workfare in Mainland China: A Reaction to Welfare Dependency?’ in Chan

C.K.

Ngok

(eds) Welfare Reform in East Asia: Towards Workfare? pp. 17–40. London: Routledge.

30.

Orshansky

(1965) ‘Counting the Poor: Another Look at the Poverty Profile’, Social Security Bulletin 28(1): 3–29.

31.

Ravallion

(1998) ‘Poverty Lines in Theory and Practice’, Living Standards Measurement Study Working Paper, World Bank, Washington, DC, 1 July 1998.

32.

Ravallion

Chen

S.-H.

(2007) ‘China’s (Uneven) Progress Against Poverty’, Journal of Development Economics 82(1): 1–42.

33.

Ravallion

Chen

S.-H.

Sangraula

(2008) ‘Dollar a Day Revisited’, Policy Research Working Paper Series, World Bank, Washington, DC, May 2008.

34.

Ravallion

Datt

Van De Walle

(1991) ‘Quantifying Absolute Poverty in the Developing World’, Review of Income and Wealth 37(4): 345–61.

35.

Shen

(2012) ‘Are Housing Prices Too High in China?’ China Economic Review 23(4): 1206–10.

36.

Shildrick

Rucell

(2015) Sociological Perspectives on Poverty. New York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.

37.

Slater

(2012) ‘The Myth of “Broken Britain”: Welfare Reform and the Production of Ignorance’, Antipode 46(4): 948–69.

38.

State Council (1997) ‘State Council’s Announcement on Establishing a National Minimum Living System for Urban Residents’. Available online at: http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/content/2016-10/19/content_5121479.htm

39.

US Department of Health and Human Services (2014) ‘Welfare Indicators and Risk Factors: Thirteenth Report to Congress’. Available online at: https://aspe.hhs.gov/report/welfare-indicators-and-risk-factors-thirteenth-report-congress

40.

Wang

M.-D.

(1998) ‘The Human Rights Protection of China’s Prisoners’ (in Chinese). Available online at: http://www.humanrights-china.org/cn/zt/qita/zgrqyjh/lslt/t20061025_170892.htm

41.

Wang

Y.-J.

(2002) ‘Assessment and Analysis of Urban Poverty in China’, Market and Demographic Analysis 8(6): 14–8 (in Chinese).

42.

Wang

Y.-J.

(2006) ‘Evaluation of Policy Implementation on the UMLSG’, Statistical Research 10: 49–54 (in Chinese).

43.

White

(2001) ‘No Exit: Rethinking “Welfare Dependency” From a Different Ground’, Australian Journal of Social Issues 36(3): 221–36.

44.

World Bank (2009) From Poor People to Poor People: China’s Evolving Poverty Reduction Agenda. Beijing: World Bank.

45.

Yao

S.-J.

(2004) ‘Unemployment and Urban Poverty in China: A Case Study of Guangzhou and Tianjin’, Journal of International Development 16(2): 171–88.

46.

Yao

S.-J.

Luo

Wang

J.-L.

(2014) ‘Housing Development and Urbanisation in China’, The World Economy 37(3): 481–500.

47.

Zhang

H.-M.

(2012) ‘Discourse Change and Policy Development in Social Assistance in China’, International Journal of Social Welfare 21(4): 433–42.

48.

Zhou

F.-H.

(2012) ‘Selectivity, Welfare Stigma, and the Take-Up of Social Welfare: How Do Chinese People Manage Welfare Stigma?’ Working Paper, Harvard-Yenching Institute, Cambridge, MA, 17–18 May.

49.

Zhu

R-J.

(2000) ‘To Quickly Improve the System of Social Security and Well Ensure the Long-Term Stability of the State’. Available online at: http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64184/64186/66689/4494504.html (in Chinese).

50.

Zhu

R-J.

(2002) ‘To Conduct Well the Work of Re-Employment and Social Security’. Available online at: http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64184/64186/66690/4494542.html (in Chinese).