The emerging ‘science of social work’ in the United States and German-speaking countries: A comparison

Abstract

The aim of this article is to begin a comparison between an emerging ‘science of social work’ in the United States and German-speaking countries (Switzerland, Germany, and Austria), with the intention of moving the discussion forward. It is found that the ‘science of social work’ is more developed in German-speaking Europe than in the United States, but that similar conclusions have been developed in both contexts. However, scholars of the two continents only rarely refer to one another’s work, and the lack of communication between the two groups is hurting the discipline as a whole.

Keywords

Evidence-based practice international comparison practice-based evidence qualitative methods science of social work

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

K.B.

Matto

H.C.

LeCroy

C.W.

(2009) ‘Limitations of Evidence-based Practice for Social Work Education: Unpacking the Complexity’, Journal of Social Work Education 45(2): 165–86.

Anastas

J.W.

(2014) ‘The Science of Social Work and Its Relationship to Social Work Practice’, Research on Social Work Practice 24(5): 571–80.

Becker-Lenz

Lüscher

(2012) ‘Der Nutzen der objektiv hermeneutischen Diagnostik in der Sozialen Arbeit’, Neue Praxis 5: 475–92.

Bellamy

J.L.

Bledsoe

S.E.

Traube

D.E.

(2006) ‘The Current State of Evidence-based Practice in Social Work: A Review of the Literature and Qualitative Analysis of Expert Interviews’, Journal of Evidence-Based Social Work 3(1): 23–48.

Birgmeier

Mührel

(2009) Die Sozialarbeitswissenschaft und ihre Theorie(n). Positionen, Kontroversen, Perspektiven. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

Blythe

B.J.

Briar

(1985) ‘Developing Empirically Based Models of Practice’, Social Work 30(6): 483–8.

Brekke

J.S.

(1986) ‘Scientific Imperatives in Social Work Research: Pluralism Is Not Skepticism’, The Social Service Review 60(4): 538–54.

Brekke

J.S.

(2012) ‘Shaping a Science of Social Work’, Research on Social Work Practice 22(5): 455–64.

Brekke

J.S.

(2014) ‘A Science of Social Work, and Social Work as an Integrative Scientific Discipline: Have We Gone Too Far, or Not Far Enough?’, Research on Social Work Practice 24(5): 517–23.

10.

Brower

A.M.

(1988) ‘Can the Ecological Model Guide Social Work Practice?’, Social Service Review 62(3): 411–29.

11.

DGSA/DGfE (2011) ‘Gemeinsame Stellungnahme der Vorstände der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Soziale Arbeit (DGSA) und des Vorstands der Kommission Sozialpädagogik in der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Erziehungswissenschaft (DGfE)’. Available online at: http://www.praeventionstag.de/kriminalpraevention/Module/News/Media/Stellungnahme_Vorstaende_250.pdf (accessed 14 April 2014).

12.

Engelke

(1992) Soziale Arbeit als Wissenschaft: Eine Orientierung. Freiburg im Breisgau: Lambertus.

13.

Fischer

(1973) ‘Is Casework Effective?’, Social Work 18(1): 5–20.

14.

Gambrill

(2003) ‘From the Editor’, Journal of Social Work Education 39(1): 3–23.

15.

Germain

C.B.

Gitterman

(1980) The Life Model of Social Work Practice: Advances in Theory & Practice. New York: Columbia University Press.

16.

Gibelman

(1999) ‘The Search for Identity: Defining Social Work – Past, Present, Future’, Social Work 44(4): 298–310.

17.

Gray

Coates

(2010) ‘“Indigenization” and Knowledge Development: Extending the Debate’, International Social Work 53(5): 1–15.

18.

Gray

Plath

Webb

S.A.

(2009) Evidence-based Social Work: A Critical Stance. London: Routledge.

19.

Gredig

(2005) ‘The Co-evolution of Knowledge Production and Transfer’, in Sommerfeld

(ed.) Evidence-based Social Work: Towards a New Professionalism?, pp. 173–98. Bern: Peter Lang.

20.

Haken

(1990) Synergetik. Eine Einführung. Berlin: Springer.

21.

Haken

Schiepek

(2010) Synergetik in der Psychologie. Selbstorganisation verstehen und gestalten. Goettingen: Hogrefe.

22.

Haug

(2005) ‘Critical Reflections on the Emerging Discourse of International Social Work’, International Social Work 48(2): 126–35.

23.

Hoffman

Godenzi

(2007) ‘Guest Editorial: Increasing Our Impact through Unification’, Journal of Social Work Education 43(2): 181–5.

24.

Howard

M.O.

McMillen

C.J.

Pollio

D.E.

(2003) ‘Teaching Evidence-based Practice: Toward a New Paradigm for Social Work Education’, Research on Social Work Practice 13(2): 234–59.

25.

Jindra

I.W.

(2014) ‘Why American Sociology Needs Biographical Sociology – European Style’, Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior 44(4): 389–412.

26.

Jindra

I.W.

(2016) ‘Poverty and the controversial work of nonprofits’, Society 53(6): 634–640.

27.

Karscz

(2004) Pourquoi le Travail Social? Paris: Dunod.

28.

Longhofer

Floersch

(2012) ‘The Coming Crisis in Social Work: Some Thoughts on Social Work and Science’, Research on Social Work Practice 22(5): 499–519.

29.

Longhofer

Floersch

Hoy

(2013) Qualitative Methods for Practice Research. London: Oxford University Press.

30.

Luhmann

(1973) ‘Formen des Helfens im Wandel gesellschaftlicher Bedingungen’, in Thole

(ed.) Grundriss soziale Arbeit. Ein einführendes Handbuch, pp. 21–43. Berlin: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

31.

McNeece

A.C.

Thyer

B.A.

(2004) ‘Evidence-based Practice and Social Work’, Journal of Evidence-Based Social Work 1(1): 7–123.

32.

Marsh

(2012) ‘Response: From Fish and Bicycles to a Science of Social Work’, Research on Social Work Practice 22(5): 465–7.

33.

May

(2008) Aktuelle Theoriediskurse Sozialer Arbeit. Eine Einführung. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

34.

Merten

(2000) ‘Systemtheorie Sozialer Arbeit: Eine Einführung’, in Merten

(ed.) Systemtheorie Sozialer Arbeit. Neue Ansätze und veränderte Perspektiven, pp. 7–13. Opladen: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

35.

Mor Barak

M.E.

Brekke

J.S.

(2014) ‘Social Work Science and Identity Formation for Doctoral Scholars within Intellectual Communities’, Research on Social Work Practice 24(5): 616–24.

36.

Mühlum

(1994) Sozial und wissenschaftlich arbeiten. Status und Provisionen der Sozialarbeitswissenschaft. Freiburg im Breisgau: Lambertus.

37.

Mühlum

(2004) ‘Zur Entstehung und Entwicklungsdynamik der Sozialarbeitswissenschaft: Einleitung’, in Mühlum

(ed.) Sozialarbeitswissenschaft, Wissenschaft der Sozialarbeit, pp. 9–26. Freiburg im Breisgau: Lambertus.

38.

Nussbaum

M.C.

(2003) ‘Capabilities as Fundamental Entitlements: Sen and Social Justice’, Feminist Economics 9: 33–59.

39.

Obrecht

(2000) ‘Soziale Systeme, Individuen, soziale Probleme, und soziale Arbeit. Zu den meta-theoretischen, sozialwissenschaftlichen und handlungstheoretischen Grundlagen des “systemischen” Paradigmas der Sozialen Arbeit’, in Merten

(ed.) Systemtheorie Sozialer Arbeit. Neue Ansätze und veränderte Perspektiven, pp. 207–23. Opladen: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

40.

Oevermann

Allert

Kronau

Krambeck

(1987) ‘Structures of Meaning and Objective Hermeneutics’, in Meja

(ed.) Modern German Sociology, pp. 436–47. New York: Columbia University Press.

41.

Okpych

N.J.

J.L.-H.

(2014) ‘A Historical Analysis of Evidence-based Practice in Social Work: The Unfinished Journey toward an Empirically Grounded Profession’, Social Service Review 88(1): 3–58.

42.

Otto

H.U.

Ziegler

(2008) ‘The Notion of Causal Impact in Evidence-based Social Work: An Introduction to the Special Issue of What Works?’, Research on Social Work Practice 18(4): 273–7.

43.

Pincus

Minahan

(1973) Social Work Practice: Model and Method. Itasca, IL: FE Peacock.

44.

Plessner

(1970) Philosophische Anthropologie. Lachen und Weinen. Das Lächeln. Anthropologie der Sinne. Frankfurt: Fischer.

45.

Raven

Garz

(2012) ‘Fälle – zur theoretischen Fundierung der Interventionspraxis professionalis-ierter Sozialarbeit’, Neue Praxis 6: 565–84.

46.

Reid

W.J.

(1994) ‘The Empirical Practice Movement’, Social Service Review 60(4): 504–25.

47.

Rosen

(2003) ‘Evidence-based Social Work Practice: Challenges and Promise’, Social Work Research 27(4): 197–208.

48.

Schütze

(1983) ‘Biographieforschung und narratives interview’, Neue Praxis 13: 283–93.

49.

Sen

(2009) The Idea of Justice. London: Allen Lane.

50.

Shaw

(2014) ‘A Science of Social Work? Response to John Brekke’, Research on Social Work Practice 24(5): 524–6.

51.

Smith

(2015) To Flourish or Destruct: A Personalist Theory of Human Goods, Motivations, and Evil. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

52.

Sommerfeld

(2014) ‘Social Work as an Action Science: A Perspective from Europe’, Research on Social Work Practice. Epub ahead of print 12 June 2014. DOI: 10.1177/1049731514538523.

53.

Sommerfeld

Gredig

(2008) ‘New Proposals for Generating and Exploiting Solution-oriented Knowledge’, Research on Social Work Practice 18(4): 292–300.

54.

Sommerfeld

Hollenstein

(2011) ‘Searching for Appropriate Ways to Face the Challenges of Complexity and Dynamics’, British Journal of Social Work 41(4): 668–88.

55.

Sommerfeld

Hollenstein

Calzaferri

(2011) Integration und Lebensführung. Ein forschungsgestützter Beitrag zur Theoriebildung in der sozialen Arbeit. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

56.

Soydan

(2008) ‘Applying Randomized Controlled Trials and Systematic Reviews in Social Work Research’, Research on Social Work Practice 18(4): 311–8.

57.

Staub-Bernasconi

(1995) Systemtheorie, soziale Probleme und soziale Arbeit: Lokal, national, international oder: Vom Ende der Bescheidenheit. Bern: Lambertus.

58.

Steinert

Sticher-Gil

Sommerfeld

Maier

(1998) Sozialarbeitsforschung, was sie ist und leistet: Eine Bestandsaufnahme. Freiburg im Breisgau: Lambertus.

59.

Thiersch

Grundwald

Köngeter

(2002) ‘Lebensweltorientierte soziale Arbeit’, in Thole

(ed.) Grundriss soziale Arbeit. Ein einführendes Handbuch, pp. 161–78. Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften.

60.

Thyer

B.A.

(2008) ‘The Quest for Evidence-based Practice? We Are All Positivists!’, Research on Social Work Practice 18(4): 339–45.

61.

Thyer

B.A.

Myers

L.A.

(2010) ‘The Quest for Evidence-based Practice: A View from the United States’, Journal of Social Work 11(1): 8–25.

62.

Webb

S.A.

(2001) ‘Some Considerations on the Validity of Evidence-based Practice in Social Work’, British Journal of Social Work 31(1): 57–79.