The problems with current forms of electronic information systems (IS) implemented in human service organizations have been well documented and attention is now focussed on how they might be redesigned for the future. The aim in this article is to demonstrate how previous research and theory can provide useful insights into these problems, which, in turn, can provide guidance for future research-based approaches to redesign. Ideas from ‘cognitive systems theory’ (CSE) and more specifically ‘joint cognitive systems’ (JCS) are explored in relation to the main problems that have been identified with current forms of IS.
BradtL.RooseR.Bouverne-De-BrieM.De SchryverM. (2011) ‘Data Recording and Social Work: From the Relational to the Social’, British Journal of Social Work41: 1372–82.
2.
BroadhurstK.WastellD.WhiteS.HallC.PeckoverS.PithouseA.ThompsonK.DaveyD. (2010) ‘Performing “Initial Assessment”: Identifying the Latent Conditions for Error at the Front-door of Local Authority Children’s Services’, British Journal of Social Work40(2): 352–70.
3.
BurtonJ.van den BroekD. (2009) ‘Accountable and Countable: Information Management Systems and the Bureaucratization of Social Work’, British Journal of Social Work39: 1326–42.
4.
DiaperD.SangerC. (2006) ‘Tasks For and Tasks in Human-Computer Interaction’, Interacting with Computers18: 117–38.
5.
GarrettP.M. (2005) ‘Social Work’s ‘‘Electronic Turn’’: Notes on the Deployment of Information and Communication Technologies in Social Work with Children and Families’, Critical Social Policy25(4): 529–53.
6.
GillinghamP. (2009a) Practitioner Perspectives on the Family Risk Evaluation Tool: An Aide to Decision Making or ‘Just Another Form to Fill In’? Developing Practice: the Child, Family and Youth Work Journal23(4): 46–55.
7.
GillinghamP. (2009b) The use of assessment tools in child protection: an ethnomethodological study. University of Melbourne.
8.
GillinghamP. (2011a) Computer based information systems and human service organizations: Emerging problems and future possibilities. Australian Social Work64(3): 299–312.
9.
GillinghamP. (2011b) Decision making tools and the development of expertise in child protection practitioners: are we “just breeding workers who are good at ticking boxes”?Child and Family Social Work16(4): 412–421.
10.
GillinghamP. (2013a) The development of electronic information systems for the future: practitioners, “embodied structures” and “technologies-in-practice”. The British Journal of Social Work43: 430–445.
11.
GillinghamP. (2013b) Electronic information systems and human services organisations: avoiding the pitfalls of participatory design. The British Journal of Social Work: 1–16.
12.
GillinghamP.HumphreysC. (2010) Child protection practitioners and decision making tools: observations and reflections from the frontline. The British Journal of Social Work40(8): 2598–2616.
13.
HammersleyM.AtkinsonP. (2007) Ethnography: Principles in Practice, 3rd edn.New York: Routledge.
14.
HenmanP. (1995) ‘The Role of Computers in Texturing Micro-social Environments’, ANZJS31(1): 49–63.
15.
HollnagelE. (1998) ‘Commentary Comments on “Conception of the Cognitive Engineering Design Problem” by John Dowell and John Long’, Ergonomics41(2): 160–2.
16.
HollnagelE. (2002) ‘Time and Time Again’, Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science3(2): 143–58.
17.
HollnagelE. (2012) ‘Coping with Complexity: Past, Present and Future’, Cognition, Technology and Work14: 199–205.
18.
HollnagelE.WoodsD.D. (1983) ‘Cognitive Systems Engineering: New Wine in New Bottles’, International Journal of Man and Machine Studies18: 583–600.
19.
HollnagelE.WoodsD.D. (2005) Joint Cognitive Systems: Foundations of Cognitive Systems Engineering. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
20.
HuuskonenS.VakkariP. (2013) ‘Selective Clients’ Trajectories in Case Files: Filtering Out Information in the Recording Process in Child Protection’, British Journal of Social Work Advance Access, 1–7. doi:10.1093/bjsw/bct160
21.
IraniZ. (2002) ‘Information Systems Evaluation: Navigating through the Problem Domain’, Information and Management40: 11–42.
22.
JonesA.MayJ. (1992) Working in Human Services Organizations: A Critical Introduction. London: Longman Cheshire.
MouloudiP.Morizet-MahoudeauxP.ValentinA. (2011) ‘RAMSES: A Method for the Design Process of Interactive Information Systems’, International Journal of Human–Computer Interaction27(2): 107–30.
28.
MunroE. (2005) ‘What Tools Do We Need to Improve Identification of Child Abuse?’, Child Abuse Review14: 374–88.
29.
MunroE. (2011) ‘The Munro Review of Child Protection: Final Report: A Child Centred System’, UK Department for Education, available online at www.education.gov.uk/munroreview/.
30.
NaccaratoT. (2010) ‘Child Welfare Informatics: A Proposed Subspeciality for Social Work’, Children and Youth Services Review32(12): 1729–34.
31.
Ombudsman (2009) ‘Own Motion Investigation into the Department of Human Services Child Protection Program’, November.
32.
OrlikowskiW. (1992) ‘Rethinking the Concept of Technology in Organizations’, Organization Science3(3): 398–427.
33.
PartonN. (2008) ‘Changes in the Form of Knowledge in Social Work: From the ‘‘Social’’ to the ‘‘Informational’’?, British Journal of Social Work38: 253–69.
34.
PeckoverS.WhiteS.HallC. (2008) ‘Managing and Making Electronic Children’, Information, Communication and Society11(3): 375–94.
35.
PithouseA.HallC.PeckoverS.WhiteS. (2009) ‘A Tale of Two CAFS: The Impact of the Electronic Common Assessment Framework’, British Journal of Social Work39: 599–612.
36.
PithouseA.BroadhurstK.HallC.PeckoverS.WastellD.WhiteS. (2012) Trust, risk and the (mis)management of contingency and discretion through new information technologies in children’s services. Journal of Social Work12(2): 158–178.
37.
RasanenJ. (2012) ‘Accounting for IT-based Use of Information in Emergency Social Work Encounters’, Nordic Social Work Research2(1): 21–37.
38.
RasmussenJ.PejtersenA.M.GoodsteinL.P. (1994) Cognitive Systems Engineering. New York: Wiley.
39.
ReganS. (2003) ‘Technology and Systems of Referral Taking: From Narrative to Code’, in HarlowE.WebbS. (eds) Information and Communication Technologies in the Welfare Services, pp. 83–110. Philadelphia, PA: Jessica Kingsley.
40.
SaarioS.StepneyS. (2009) ‘Managerial Audit and Community Mental Health: A Study of Rationalising Practices in Finnish Psychiatric Outpatient Clinics’, European Journal of Social Work12(1): 41–56.
41.
SandfortJ.R. (2010) ‘Human Service Organization Technology: Improving, Understanding and Advancing Research’, in HasenfeldY. (ed.) Human Services as Complex Organizations, 2nd edn, pp. 269–90. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
42.
SenyucelZ. (2008) ‘Impact of ICTs on User-Provider Relations: Perspectives from UK Local Authorities’, Information Technology and People21(4): 401–14.
43.
ShawI.ClaydenJ. (2009) ‘Technology, Evidence and Professional Practice: Reflections on the Integrated Children’s System’, Journal of Children’s Services4(4): 15–27.
44.
ShawI.BellM.SinclairI.SloperP.MitchellW.DysonP.ClaydenJ.RaffertyJ. (2009a) ‘An Exemplary Scheme? An Evaluation of the Integrated Children’s System’, British Journal of Social Work39: 613–26.
45.
ShawI.MorrisK.EdwardsA. (2009b) ‘Technology, Social Services and Organizational Innovation or How Great Expectations in London and Cardiff are Dashed in Lowestoft and Cymtyrch’, Journal of Social Work Practice23(4): 383–400.
46.
SmithB.D. (2010) ‘Service Technologies and the Conditions of Work in Child Welfare’, in HasenfeldY. (ed.) Human Services as Complex Organizations, 2nd edn, pp. 253–68. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE.
47.
SprattT.HoustonS. (1999) ‘Developing Critical Social Work in Theory and in Practice: Child Protection and Communicative Reason’, Child and Family Social Work4:, 315–24.
48.
StevensI.CoxP. (2008) ‘Complexity Theory: Developing New Understandings of Child Protection in Field Settings and in Residential Care’, British Journal of Social Work38(7): 1320–36.
49.
StevensI.HassettP. (2007) ‘Applying Complexity Theory to Risk in Child Protection Practice’, Childhood14: 128–44.
50.
TregeagleS.DarcyM. (2008) Child welfare and information technology: today’s challenge. British Journal of Social Work38: 1481–1498.
WastellD.PeckoverS.WhiteS.BroadhurstK.HallC.PithouseA. (2011) ‘Social Work in the Laboratory: Using Microworlds for Practice Research’, British Journal of Social Work41(4): 744–60.
53.
WhiteS.BroadhurstK.WastellD.PeckoverS.HallC.PithouseA. (2009) ‘Whither Practice-near Research in the Modernization Programme? Policy Blunders in Children’s Services’, Journal of Social Work Practice23(4): 401–11.
54.
WoodJ. (2008) ‘Report of the Special Commission of Inquiry into Child Protection Services in New South Wales’, The Hon James Wood, AO, QC, November.
55.
WoodsD.D.HollnagelE. (2006) Joint Cognitive Systems: Patterns in Cognitive Systems Engineering. Boca Raton, FL: Taylor & Francis.
