In Taiwan, the decision regarding compulsory detention of patients with severe psychiatric disorders is subject to review by the Psychiatric Disease Mandatory Assessment Review Committee. Approved psychiatric social workers are assigned to this court-like body to ensure the involuntary placement criteria are met. We conducted qualitative research to investigate the dilemmas of social workers on this committee.
AdamsP. (2009) โCode of Duties or Ideological Club?โ, Journal of Social Work Values and Ethics6(1). Available online at: www.socialworker.com/jswve (accessed 11 December 2009).
2.
ArkseyH.KnightP. (1999) Interviewing for Social Scientists: An Introductory Resource with Examples. London: SAGE.
3.
BabbieE. (1995) The Practice of Social Research, 7th edn.London: Wadsworth Publishing Company.
4.
BartlettP. (2009) โMental Health Legislationโ, in BrookerC.RepperJ. (eds) Mental Health: From Policy to Practice, pp. 296โ307. London: Elsevier.
5.
BeauchampT.L.ChildressJ.F. (1989) Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
6.
BeverleyA.J.CherylR. (2003) โBeyond Individual Rights and Freedoms: Metaethics in Social Work Researchโ, Social Work48(1): 135โ44.
7.
BiehalN.SainsburyE. (1991) โFrom Values of Rights in Social Workโ, British Journal of Social Work21: 245โ57.
8.
BowersL.ClarkN.CallaghanP. (2003) โMultidisciplinary Reflections on Assessment for Compulsory Admission: The Views of Approved Social Workers, General Practitioners, Ambulance Crews, Police, Community Psychiatric Nurses and Psychiatristsโ, British Journal of Social Work33: 961โ8.
9.
CampbellJ. (2010) โDeciding to Detain: The Use of Compulsory Mental Health Law by UK Social Workersโ, British Journal of Social Work40: 328โ34.
10.
ChanY.Y.LinJ.C.ShenL.J.YangS.N. (2007) โClinical Characteristics of Patients with Schizophrenia Referred for Hospitalization from the Psychiatric Emergency Roomโ, Taiwanese Journal of Psychiatry21(3): 167โ75 (in Chinese).
11.
CummingsS.M.CassieK.M. (2008) โPerceptions of Biopsychosocial Services Needs among Older Adults with Severe Mental Illness: Met and Unmet Needsโ, Health & Social Work33(2): 133โ43.
12.
DavidsonG.CampbellJ. (2009) โAn Audit of Assessment and Reporting by Approved Social Workersโ, British Journal of Social Work40(5): 1609โ27.
13.
FarleyO.W.SmithL.L.BoyleS.W. (2006) Introduction to Social Work. London: Pearson.
14.
FawcettB. (2007) โConsistencies and Inconsistencies: Mental Health, Compulsory Treatment and Community Capacity Building in England, Wales and Australiaโ, British Journal of Social Work37: 1027โ42.
15.
FurmingerE.WebberM. (2008) โThe Effect of Crisis Resolution and Home Treatment on Assessments under the 1983 Mental Health Act: An Increased Workload for Approved Social Workers?โ, British Journal of Social Work39(5): 901โ17.
16.
GolightleyM. (2004) Social Work and Mental Health. Exeter: Learning Matters.
17.
GrobG.N. (2008) โMental Health Policy in the Liberal State: The Example of the United Statesโ, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry31: 89โ100.
18.
HallamL. (2007) โHow Involuntary Commitment Impacts on the Burden of Care of the Familyโ, International Journal of Mental Health Nursing16: 247โ56.
19.
HarrisJ. (1985) The Value of Life. London: Routledge.
20.
HatfieldB. (2008) โPowers to Detain under Mental Health Legislation in England and the Role of the Approved Social Worker: An Analysis of Patterns and Trends under the 1983 Mental Health Act in Six Local Authoritiesโ, British Journal of Social Work38: 1553โ71.
21.
HatfieldB.HuxleyP.MohammadH. (1997) โSocial Factors and Compulsory Detention of Psychiatric Patients in the U.K.โ, International Journal of Law and Psychiatry20(3): 389โ97.
22.
IfeJ. (2008) Human Rights and Social Work, 2nd edn.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23.
KallertT.W.RymaszewskaJ.Torres-GonzรกlezF. (2007) โDifferences of Legal Regulations Concerning Involuntary Psychiatric Hospitalization in Twelve European Countries: Implications for Clinical Practiceโ, International Journal of Forensic Mental Health6(2): 197โ207.
24.
KvaleS. (1996) InterViews: An Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing. London: SAGE.
25.
LeeC.Y.ChouH.C. (2003) โExploration of Compulsory Admission Controversy under Mental Health Act by Reviewing In-patient Casesโ, Journal of Law and Medicine10(3) and 11(1): 42โ9 (in Chinese).
LiuR.Y.TsaiK.Y.ChouH.C.HoW.W.ChenW.J.ChenC.C. (2010) โThe Characteristics of Severely Mentally Ill Patients Who Need Forced Hospitalization before and after the Amended Mental Helath Act in Taiwanโ, Taiwanese Journal of Psychiatry (Taipei)24(2): 131โ9.
28.
LorantV.DepuydtC.GillainB.GuilletA.DuboisV. (2007) โInvoluntary Commitment in Psychiatric Care: What Drives the Decision?โ, Social Psychiatry Epidemiology42: 360โ5.
29.
LyuS.Y. (1991) โThe Impact of the Mental Health Act on Health Careโ, Chinese Journal of Mental Health5(2): 27โ31 (in Chinese).
30.
ManktelowR.HughesP.BrittonF.CampbellJ.HamiltonB.WilsonG. (2002) โThe Experience and Practice of Approved Social Workers in Northern Irelandโ, British Journal of Social Work32: 443โ61.
31.
NewhillC.E. (1992) โAssessing Danger to Others in Clinical Social Work Practiceโ, Social Service Review66(1): 64โ84.
32.
OโNeillO. (2009) โPaternalism and Partial Autonomyโ, in OakleyJ. (ed.) Bioethics, pp. 23โ8. Burlington, VT: Ashgate.
33.
PadgettD.K. (2008) Qualitative Methods in Social Work Research, 2nd edn.London: SAGE.
34.
PintoR.M. (2006) โUsing Social Network Interventions to Improve Mentally Ill Clientsโ Well-beingโ, Clinical Social Work Journal34(1): 83โ100.
35.
QuirkA.LelliottP.AudiniB.BustonK. (2003) โNon-clinical and Extra-legal Influences on Decisions about Compulsory Admission to Psychiatric Hospitalโ, Journal of Mental Health12(2): 119โ30.
36.
RamonS. (2009) โAdult Mental Health in a Changing International Context: The Relevance to Social Workโ, British Journal of Social Work39: 1615โ22.
37.
RapaportJ.ManthorpeJ. (2008) โFamily Matters: Developments Concerning the Role of the Nearest Relative and Social Worker under Mental Health Law in England and Walesโ, British Journal of Social Work38: 1115โ31.
38.
RubinH.J.RubinI.S. (1995) Qualitative Interviewing: The Art of Hearing Data. London: SAGE.
39.
ShenC.W. (1991) โDiscussion of Compulsory Psychiatric Admission in the Psychiatry Emergency Roomโ, Clinical Medicine28: 165โ70 (in Chinese).
40.
SoongW.T.LinL.S.ChenS.Y.ChiuY.N. (1994) โA Repercussion of the ROC Mental Health Lawโ, Chinese Journal of Mental Health7(1): 37โ50 (in Chinese).
41.
SpickerP. (1990) โSocial Work and Self-determinationโ, British Journal of Social Work20: 221โ36.
42.
Taiwanese Society of Psychiatry (2009) A Clinical Practice Guideline to Compulsory Psychiatric Hospitalization and Compulsory Community Treatment. Taipei: Li Zhen (in Chinese).
43.
TaylorM.F. (2006) โSocial Workers and Involuntary Treatment in Mental Healthโ, Advances in Social Work7(2): 23โ33.
44.
WangJ.Y. (2008) โAmendments to the Mental Health Act in Taiwan and Englandโ, Social Policy and Social Work12(1): 189โ218.
45.
WangK.Y. (1997) โA Review of Mental Health Policy in Taiwan: Types of Elite and the Decision-making Processโ, Chinese Journal of Mental Health10(1): 29โ47 (in Chinese).
46.
Weiss-GalI. (2008) โThe Person-in-Environment Approach: Professional Ideology and Practice of Social Work in Israelโ, Social Work53(1): 65โ75.
47.
WilsonG.DalyM. (2007) โShaping the Future of Mental Health Policy and Legislation in Northern Ireland: The Impact of Service User and Professional Social Work Discoursesโ, British Journal of Social Work37: 423โ39.
48.
WuC.C.SongW.T. (2008) โEthical Issues in Mandatory Community Treatmentโ, Taiwanese Journal of Psychiatry22(2): 84โ95.
49.
WuH.C.TangI.C.LinW.I. (in press) โProfessional Values and Attitude on Psychiatric Social Workers toward Involuntary Hospital Admission for the Psychiatric Patientsโ, Journal of Social Work.
50.
YangT.T.WeiC.W. (2008) โThe New Edition of the Mental Health Actโ, Yuan Yuan Nursing2(2): 11โ17 (in Chinese).
51.
YeungK.S.S.HoA.P.Y.LoM.C.H.ChanE.A. (2010) โSocial Work Ethical Decision Making in an Inter-disciplinary Contextโ, British Journal of Social Work40(5): 1573โ90.