The article reveals the results of research done by means of interviews of 63 social workers in psychiatric services in Hong Kong. The ways that social workers defined, perceived and performed psychotherapy for people with mental illness were explored. The findings showed that because of the deprofessionalized context, social workers in these psychiatric services had either superiority or inferiority complexes about providing psychotherapy.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abott, K.A. ( 1981 ) ‘ Clinical Social Work and Mental Health in Hong Kong ’, in T.P. Khoo (ed.) Aspects of Mental Health Care: Hong Kong 1981 , pp. 174 – 179 . Hong Kong : Mental Health Association of Hong Kong .
2.
Abramson, J.S. and T. Mizrahi ( 1994 ) ‘ Examining Social Work/Physician Collaboration: an Application of Ground Theory Methods ’, in C.K. Riessman (ed.) Qualitative Studies in Social Work , pp. 28 – 48 . London : Sage .
3.
Au, M.K. ( 1986 ) ‘ The Roles of Social Workers in Dealing with Special Groups of Patients ’, in T.P. Khoo (ed.) Aspects of Mental Health Care: Hong Kong 1981 , pp. 108 – 110 . Hong Kong : Mental Health Association of Hong Kong .
4.
AuFan, C.T. ( 1986 ) ‘ The Roles of Social Work in the Psychiatric Settings ’, in T.P. Khoo (ed.) Aspects of Mental Health Care: Hong Kong 1981 , pp. 308 – 313 . Hong Kong : Mental Health Association of Hong Kong .
5.
Balestrieri, M. , P. Williams and G. Wilkinson ( 1988 ) ‘ Specialist Mental Health Treatment in General Practice: a Meta-analysis ’, Psychological Medicine18 : 711 – 717 .
6.
Beck, A.T. ( 1976 ) Cognitive Therapy and the Emotional Disorder . New York : International University Press .
7.
Beitman, B.D. , M.R. Gold.eld and J.C. Norcross ( 1989 ) ‘ The Movement Toward Integrating the Psychotherapies: An Overview ’, American Journal of Psychiatry146 : 138 – 147 .
8.
Bender, S. ( 1987 ) ‘ Clinical Challenge of Hospital Social Work Practice ’, Social Work in Health Care13 ( 2 ): 25 – 34 .
9.
Ben-Sira, Z. ( 1988 ) ‘ Social Work in Health Care: Challenges and Implications for Structuring Practice ’, Social Work in Health Care13 ( 1 ): 79 – 100 .
10.
Bruges, R.G. ( 1985 ) Strategies of Educational Research and Qualitative Methods . London : Falmer Press .
11.
Butrym, Z. ( 1967 ) Social Work in Medical Care . New York : Routledge and Kegan Paul .
12.
Caroff, P. ( 1988 ) ‘ Clinical Social Work: Present Role and Future Challenge ’, Social Work in Health Care13 ( 1 ): 21 – 33 .
13.
Carrigan, Z.H. ( 1978 ) ‘ Social Workers in Medical Settings: Who De.nes Us? ’, Social Work in Health Care4 ( 2 ): 149 – 163 .
14.
Cowles, L.A. and M.J. Lefcowitz ( 1995 ) ‘ Interdisciplinary Expectations of the Medical Social Worker in the Hospital Settings: Part 2 ’, Health and Social Work20 ( 4 ): 279 – 285 .
15.
Department of Health ( 1993 ) The Health of the Nation: Key Area Handbook on Mental Illness . London : HMSO .
16.
Department of Health and Social Security ( 1975 ) Better Services for the Mentally Ill . London : HMSO .
17.
Dryden, W. and R. Rentoul , eds ( 1991 ) Adult Clinical Problems and Cognitive Behaviour Therapy . London : Routledge .
18.
Ellis, A. ( 1999 ) ‘ The Main Change Agent in Effective Psychotherapy is Speci.c Techniques and Skill ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 86 – 94 . London : Sage .
19.
Epstein, W.M. ( 1999 ) ‘ The Ineffectiveness of Psychotherapy ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 64 – 73 . London : Sage .
20.
Feltham, C. ( 1999a ) ‘ Controversies in Psychotherapy ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 1 – 6 . London : Sage .
21.
Feltham, C. ( 1999b ) ‘ Against and Beyond Core Theoretical Models ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 182 – 193 . London : Sage .
22.
Freidson, E. ( 1970 ) Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of Medical Care . Chicago, IL : Aldine .
23.
Gale, D. ( 1999 ) ‘ The Limitations of Boundaries ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 124 – 131 . London : Sage .
24.
Goffman, E. ( 1961 ) Asylum . New York : Doubleday .
25.
Gopfert, M. and B. Barnes (1994) ‘Counsellor and Secondary Mental Health Care’. Unpublished presentation. Liverpool: Liverpool Psychotherapy and Consultation Service.
26.
Hogarty, G.E. and R. Goldberg ( 1973 ) ‘ Drug and Sociotherapy in the Aftercare of Schizophrenic Patients ’, Archives of General Psychiatry28 : 54 – 64 .
27.
Hong Kong Government ( 1989 ) Operational Guidelines on Procedures Arising from Provision in Mental Health Ordinance . Hong Kong : Hong Kong Government .
28.
Hong Kong Government ( 1990 ) Hong Kong 1990 Review of Rehabilitation Programme Plan . Hong Kong : Hong Kong Government .
29.
Hong Kong Government ( 1992 ) Equal Opportunities and Full Participation: A Better Tomorrow for All . Hong Kong : Hong Kong Government .
30.
Howe, D. ( 1987 ) An Introduction to Social Work Theory . London : Ashgate .
31.
Howe, D. ( 1999 ) ‘ The Main Change Agent in Psychotherapy is the Relationship between Therapist and Client ’, in C. Feltham (ed.) Controversies in Psychotherapy , pp. 95 – 103 . London : Sage .
32.
Hutton, A. and B. Clayton ( 1988 ) ‘ The Process of Psychotherapy ’, in C.K. Beck , R.P. Rawlins and S.R. Williams (eds) Mental Health Psychiatric Nursing: a Holistic Life-Cycle Approach , pp. 118 – 140 . Washington, DC : C.V. Mosby .
33.
Ives, G. ( 1979 ) ‘ Psychological Treatment in General Practice ’, Journal of the Royal College of Practitioners29 : 343 – 351 .
34.
Ivey, A.E. , M.B. Ivey and L.S. Morgan ( 1993 ) Counselling and Psychotherapy . Boston, MA : Allyn and Bacon .
35.
Karaus, T.B. ( 1989 ) ‘ Psychotherapy ’, in H.I. Kaplan and B.J. Sadock (eds) Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry , 5th edn , pp. 1492 – 1453 . New York : Wilkins .
36.
Kerson, T. ( 1980 ) Medical Social Work: the Para-professional Paradox . New York : Irvington .
37.
Kohut, H. ( 1971 ) The Restoration of the Self . New York : International Universities Press .
38.
Lauber, M. ( 1992 ) ‘ A Taxonomy of Case Management Tasks in Community Mental Health Facilities ’, Social Work Research and Abstracts28 : 3 – 8 .
39.
Lister, L. ( 1980 ) ‘ Role Expectation for Social Workers and Other Health Care Professionals ’, Health and Social Work5 ( 2 ): 41 – 49 .
40.
Marshall, C. and G.B. Rossman ( 1989 ) Designing Qualitative Research . New York : Sage .
41.
Martin, E. and P.M.L. Martin ( 1985 ) ‘ Changes in Psychological Diagnosis and Prescription in a Practice Employing a Counsellor ’, Family Practice24 : 241 – 243 .
42.
Modlin, T.J. and A. Adams ( 1993 ) ‘ Theoretical Approaches ’, in R.P. Rawlins , S.R. Williams and C.K. Beck (eds) Mental Health – Psychiatric Nursing: A Holistic Life-Cycle Approach , 3rd edn , pp. 53 – 59 . Toronto : Mosby .
43.
Moser, G.A. and G. Kalton ( 1976 ) Survey Methods in Social Investigation . London : Heinemann Educational Books .
44.
Mosher, L.R. , and S.J. Keith ( 1980 ) ‘ Psychosocial Treatment: Individual, Group, Family and Community Support Approaches ’, Schizophrenia Bulletin6 : 10 – 41 .
45.
Oslen, K. and M. Oslen ( 1967 ) ‘ Role Expectation and Perception for Social Workers in Medical Settings ’, Social Work12 : 70 – 78 .
46.
Parker, N. ( 1964 ) ‘ The Contribution of a Social Worker to a Mental Health Centre ’, Mental Health in Australia1 : 27 – 30 .
Petterson, G. ( 1992 ) ‘ User Views on Counselling Services Provided at the Forest Hill Group Practice ’, Community Medical Service News32 : 1 – 4 .
49.
Pilgrim, D. ( 1997 ) Psychotherapy and Society . London : Sage .
50.
Wasylenki, D.A. ( 1992 ) ‘ Psychotherapy of Schizophrenia Revisited ’, Hospital and Community Psychiatry43 : 123 – 130 .
51.
Weissman, H.H. , I.E. Epstein and A. Savage ( 1987 ) ‘ Expanding the Role Repertoire of Clinicians ’, Social Casework65 : 150 – 155 .
52.
Wolberg, L.R. ( 1988 ) The Techniques of Psychotherapy . London : Grune and Stratton .
53.
Yip, K.S. ( 1992a ) ‘ Is a Life Model a Practical Model in Working with the Mentally Ill? ’, Asia Paci.c Journal of Social Work2 ( 1 ): 182 – 186 .
54.
Yip, K.S. (1992b) ‘ The Roles of Social Workers in After-Care Services of Psychiatric Ex-patients in Hong Kong ’. Paper presented at XIIth World Congress of Social Psychiatry , Vancouver .
55.
Yip, K.S. ( 2001 ) ‘ Construction of a Role Institutionalization Instrument for Social Workers in Psychiatric Case Management ’, Asia Paci.c Journal of Social Work11 ( 1 ): 71 – 113 .
