The decision to remove children at risk from their homes entails serious dilemmas, since both remaining in and being removed have strong negative psychological repercussions. This article presents an empirical investigation of 194 Israeli child protection officers’ decisions on 368 children at risk. Findings showed that while the officers predicted that all the children would have a better quality of life outside their homes, they removed only those where the projected disparity between the alternatives was substantial. That is, they considered not only whether one alternative was better or worse, but how much better or worse. Implications for decisions in “grey areas” are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Arad, B. (1990) ‘The Decision Making of Youth Welfare Officers Concerning the Removal from Home of Battered and Neglected Children’, thesis submitted for the MA degree of social work at Tel Aviv University.
2.
Bender, B. (1976) ‘Self-chosen Victims: Scapegoating Behavior Sequential to Battering’, Child Welfare55(6): 417-422.
3.
Benedict, M. L., S. Zuravin, D. Brandt and H. Ashley (1994) ‘Types and Frequency of Child Maltreatment by Family Foster Care Provided in an Urban Population’, Child Abuse and Neglect18: 577-585.
4.
Besharov, D. J. (1985) ‘Right Versus Right. The Dilemma of Child Protection’, Public Welfare43(2): 19-27.
5.
Besharov, D. J. (1987) ‘Contending with Overblown Expectations’, Public Welfare45(1): 7-11.
6.
Biran, D. (1986) ‘Variables Affecting the Child Welfare Officer in Exercising his Authority’, MA thesis, School of Social Work, Tel Aviv University.
7.
Blatt, E. R. (1992) ‘Factors Associated with Child Abuse and Neglect in Resident Care Settings’, Children and Youth Services Review16: 493-517.
8.
Bohman, M. and S. Sigvardsson (1980) ‘Long-term Effects of Early Institutional Care: A Prospective Longitudinal Study’, in Annual Progress Child Psychiatry and Child Development, pp. 148-156.
9.
Cairns, D. (1990) ‘Quality of Life, Assessment of Haemodialysis Patients: an Application of a Systemic Life Quality Model’, Sydney, Macquarie University doctoral thesis.
10.
Camasso, M. J. and R. Jagannathan (1995) ‘Prediction Accuracy of Washington and Illinois Risk Assessment in Students. An Application of Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve Analysis’, Social Work Research19: 174-183.
11.
Dolev, T. and D. Rivkin (1996) Children and Families in Care of Child Protection Officers: Characteristics, Needs, Services and Policies. Jerusalem: JDC-Brookdale, Center for Children and Youth.
12.
Doueck, H. J., D. J. English, D. DePanfilis and G. T. Moote (1993) ‘Decision Making in Child Protective Services: a Comparison of Selected Risk Assessment Systems’, Child Welfare72(5): 441-452.
13.
Elizur, D. and S. Shye (1990) ‘Quality of Work Life and its Relation to Quality of Life’, Applied Psychology: An International Review39(3): 275-291.
14.
Giovannoni, J. M. and R. M. Becerra (1982) Defining Child Abuse. New York: The Free Press.
15.
Giovannoni, J. M. and R. M. Becerra (1983) Protecting C.P.S. Clients and Workers. Public Worker.
16.
Gizynsky, M. N. (1985) ‘The Effect of Maternal Depression in Children’, Clinical Social Work Journal13(2): 103-116.
17.
Goldstein, J., A. Freud and A. J. Solnit (1973) Beyond the Best Interest of the Child. New York: The Free Press.
18.
Goldstein, J., A. Freud and A. J. Solnit (1979) Before the Best Interest of the Child. New York: The Free Press.
19.
Green, A. H. (1978) ‘Psychopathology of Abused Children’, American Academy of Child Psychiatry17: 92-103.
20.
Groze, V. (1990) ‘An Exploratory Investigation into Institutional Maltreatment’, Children and Youth Services Review12: 229-241.
21.
Jones, J. (1994) ‘Child Protection and Anti Oppressive Practice: the Dynamic of Partnership with Parents Explored’, Early Child Development and Care102: 101-113.
22.
Kaufman, J. and E. Zigler (1987) ‘Do Abused Children Become Abusive Parents?’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry57(2): 186-192.
23.
Kinard, E. M. (1980) ‘Emotional Development in Physically Abused Children’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry50(4): 686-696.
24.
Levine, K. G. (1988) ‘The Placed Child Examines the Quality of the Parental Care’, Child Welfare67(4): 301-310.
25.
Lewis, D. O., S. S. Shanok, J. H. Pincus and G. H. Glaser (1979) ‘Violent Juvenile Delinquents: Psychiatric, Neurological, Psychological and Abuse Factors’, Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry18(2): 307-319.
26.
Moss, S. Z. and M. S. Moss (1984) ‘Threat to Place a Child’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry54(1): 168-173.
27.
Pecora, P. (1991) ‘Investigating Allegations of Child Maltreatment: the Strengths and Limitations of Current Risk Assessment Systems’, in M. Robin (ed.) Assessing Child Maltreatment Reports: the Problem of False Allegations, pp. 73-92. New York: Haworth Press.
28.
Ronnau, J. P. and C. R. Marlow (1993) ‘Family Preservation Poverty and the Value of Diversity’, Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Human Services74(9): 538-544.
29.
Rosenthal, J., J. Motz, D. Edmondson and V. Groze (1991) ‘A Descriptive Study of Abuse and Neglect in out of Home Placement’, Child Abuse and Neglect15: 249-260.
30.
Rosenthal, K. (1988) ‘The Inanimate Self in Adult Victims in Child Abuse and Neglect’, Social Casework69(8): 505-510.
31.
Shye, S. (1979) A Systemic Facet Theoretical Approach to the Study of Quality of Life. Jerusalem: Institute of Applied Social Research.
32.
Shye, S. (1985) ‘Human Life Quality: an Action System’, in S. Shye (ed.) Multiple Scaling, the Theory and Application of Partial Order Scalogram Analysis. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science.
33.
Shye, S. (1989) ‘The Systemic Quality of Life Model. A Basis for Urban Renewal Evaluation’, Social Indicators Research21: 243-378.
34.
Stein, T. J. and T. L. Rzepnicki (1983) Decision Making at Child Welfare Intake. A Handbook for Practitioners. New York: Child Welfare League of America.
35.
Steinhauer, P. D. (1983) ‘Assessing for Parenting Capacity’, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry53(3): 468-481.
36.
Thompson, A. E. (1985) ‘Making the Decision to Separate Child and Family’, in K. C. Faller (ed.) Social Work with Abused and Neglected Children pp. 84-93. New York: The Free Press.
37.
Veerman, P. E. (1991) The Rights of the Child and the Changing Images of Childhood. Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff.
38.
Walad, M. S. and M. Woolverton (1990) ‘Risk Assessment: the Emperor’s New Clothes?’, Child Welfare69(6): 483-511.
39.
Wasserman, S. and A. Rosenfeld (1986) ‘Decision Making in Child Abuse and Neglect’, Child Welfare65(6): 515-529.
40.
Wilkes, J. R. (1992) ‘Children in Limbo: Working for the Outcome When Children are Taken into Care’, Canada’s Mental Health40(2): 2-5.
41.
Wolins, M., Y. Wozner and S. Shye (1980) ‘Rejuvenating the Asylum: a Field Study’, Social Work Research and Abstracts16(1): 17-25.
42.
Wozner, Y., M. Golan and B. Arad (1993) The Quality of Life in Institutions for Children and Youth in Israel. Bob Shapell School of Social Work, Tel Aviv University. Tel Aviv: Ramot Publication.
43.
Wozner, Y., M. Golan, G. Rahav, B. Arad and B. Pinhasi (1994) Social Work and Welfare Services in Prisons, research report. Jerusalem: Ministry of Internal Security.
