Korea and Japan, neighboring democratic countries in Northeast Asia, announced their first COVID-19 cases in January 2020 and witnessed similar patterns of disease spread but adopted different policy approaches to address the pandemic (agile and proactive approach versus cautious and restraint-based approach). Applying the political nexus triad model, this study analyzes and compares institutional contexts and governance structures of Korea and Japan, then examines the differences in policy responses of the two Asian countries. This study first reviews the state of COVID-19 and examines changes in the conventional president-led political nexus triad in Korea and the bureaucracy-led political nexus triad in Japan. Then, this study examines how the differences in institutional contexts and governance structures shaped policy responses and policy outcomes of the two countries in managing the COVID-19 crisis.
Points for practitioners
• Institutional and governance structure in a society are likely to affect policymaking processes as well as selection of policies among various policy alternatives. • Government officials often need to refer to government capacity as well as citizens’ voluntary participation in resolving wicked policy problems like COVID-19. • Policy decisions made by government officials affect policy outcomes while political environment and political leadership are equally important to policy effectiveness.
AokiN (2018) Japan’s bureaucracy in international perspective. In: FarazmandA (ed.) Global Encyclopedia of Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance.
Cham:
Springer International Publishing, pp. 1–5.
ChoiE (2020) Japan’s crisis management responses to COVID-19 and prospects. Issue report, the Asan Institute for Policy Studies (in Korean).
4.
ComfortLKapucuNKoK,et al. (2020) Crisis decision making on a global scale: Transition from cognition to collective action under threat of COVID‐19. Public Management Review 80(4): 616–622.
5.
DahlströmCLapuenteV (2017) Organizing the Leviathan: How the Relationship Between Politicians and Bureaucrats Shapes Good Government.
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
6.
DahlströmCLapuenteVTeorellJ (2012) Public administration around the world. In: HolmbergSRothsteinB (eds) Good Government: The Relevance of Political Science.
Cheltenham:
Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 40–67.
7.
Estévez‐AbeMKimY-S (2014)
Presidents, prime ministers and politics of care—Why Korea expanded childcare much more than Japan. Social Policy & Administration48(6): 666–685.
8.
FujiiRHataT (2020) Kyugyo semaru “jishuku keisatsu” dema kakusan de kyaku gekigen—sutoresu de kishimu shakai [The “restraint police” are pressing for closure. The number of customers plummeted due to the spread of the hoax]. Yomiuri Shimbun. Available at: https://www.yomiuri.co.jp/national/20200513-OYT1T50231/
GinsburgT (2001)
Dismantling the “developmental state”? Administrative procedure reform in Japan and Korea. The American Journal of Comparative Law49(4): 585–625.
Infectious Disease Control and Prevention Act (IDCPA). http://www.law.go.kr/ (accessed 15 June 2020).
13.
Jiji Press (2020) To no kyugyo yosei ga zenmen kaijo shinjukuku “yorunomachi” sekkyoku kensa—shingata korona [The Tokyo Metropolitan Government’s request to close the office was fully lifted. Shinjuku City actively inspects the “nightlife district”—the new corona]. Jiji Press. Available at: https://www.jiji.com/jc/article?k=2020061801221&g=eco
14.
Jiji Tsushin (2020) Naikakushiji 38%, fushiji 61% Shingatakorona taiou 6 wari hyoukasezu jiji yoronchousa [Cabinet approval rate 38%, disapproval rate 61%. 60% of the respondents did not evaluate the government responses to the new coronavirus]. Available at: https://www.jiji.com/jc/article?k=2020060600324&g=pol
15.
KCDC (Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) (2020)
Weekly report on the COVID-19 situation in the Republic of Korea (as of June 6, 2020). Public Health Weekly Report13(24): 1709–1715.
16.
KimPS (2020) South Korea’s fast response to coronavirus disease: Implications on public policy and public management theory. Public Management Review, epub ahead of print, May 20. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14719037.2020.1766266
17.
KitamuraW (2020)
Nihon no gyousei wa surimu sugiru [Japanese administration is too small].Chuo Kouron134: 42–51.
LeeSHwangC, andMoonJM (2020) Policy learning and crisis policy-making: Quadruple-loop learning and COVID-19 responses in South Korea. Policy and Society 39(3): 363–381.
21.
LeeS-i (2015)
Costly lessons from the 2015 Middle East Respiratory Syndrome coronavirus outbreak in Korea.Journal of Preventive Medicine & Public Health48(6): 274–276.
MaedaK (2014) Shimin wo yatowanai kokka [A State Not Actively Employing Its Citizens].
Tokyo:
Tokyo University Press.
24.
MaedaK (2018) The Japanese civil service. In: FarazmandA (ed.) Global Encyclopedia of Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance.
Cham:
Springer International Publishing, pp. 1–9.
25.
MHLW (Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare) (2018) Iryo shisetsu (seitai, dotai) chosa, byoin hokoku no gaikyo [Summary of the medical facilities (static and dynamic) survey and hospital reports]. Available at: https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/seisakunitsuite/bunya/0000055891.html (accessed 14 June 2020).
MHLW (2020) Shingata koronawirusu nikanrenshita haienno kanjanohassei nitsuite (1reime) [Outbreak of pneumonia associated with the novel coronavirus (case 1)]. Available at: https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/newpage_08906.html (accessed 10 June 2020).
28.
Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (2020) Keizai sangyoshou no shiensaku [METI’s support measures]. Available at: https://www.meti.go.jp/covid-19/index.html (accessed 20 June 2020).
29.
MishimaK (2017)
A big bang for Japanese mandarins? The civil service reform of 2014. International Journal of Public Administration40(13): 1101–1113.
MoonJM (2020) Fighting COVID-19 with agility, transparency, and participation: Wicked policy problems and new governance challenges. Public Administration Review 80(4): 651–656.
32.
MoonJMHwangC (2013)
The state of civil service systems in the Asia-Pacific region: A comparative perspective. Review of Public Personnel Administration33(2): 121–139.
33.
Moon MJ and Ingraham P (1998) Shaping Administrative Reform and Governance: An Examination of the Political Nexus Triads in Three Asian Countries. Governance 11(1): 77–100.
34.
NakamuraA (2012)
Asian model of government re-examined in the aftermath of the global economic crunch: A Japanese perspective from the experience of the triple disasters in March 2011. International Review of Administrative Sciences78(2): 239–259.
Nihon Keizai Shimbun (2020a) Korona taiou hyoukasezu 55% yoronchousa naikakushijiritsu yokobai 49% [Disapproval rate for government’s response to corona 55%, cabinet approval rate unchanged at 49%]. Available at: https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGKKZO58921710Q0A510C2MM8000/
37.
Nihon Keizai Shimbun (2020b) Nihon wa senmonka no shireito-soshiki nashi kengen to sekinin no meikakuka fukaketsu [Absence of expert leadership in Japan: Clear delineation of authorities and responsibilities needed]. Nihon Keizai Shimbun. Available at: https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXMZO58271700Q0A420C2EA2000/ (accessed April 21, 2020).
NNN and the Yomiuri Shimbun National Polls (2020) Yoron Chousa [Public opinion poll]. Available at: https://www.ntv.co.jp/yoron/ (accessed 13 June 2020).
OyaT (2020) Nase Nihon wa Jishuku no Onegai Shika Dekinai no ka: Oya Takehiro san no Baai Zempen. Available at: https://nhkbook-hiraku.com/n/n0e6820c4d2a5 (accessed October 5, 2020).
46.
Repeta, L. 2020. “The coronavirus and Japan’s Constitution.” The Japan Times. April 14, 2020 (accessed February 3, 2021).
SenshoY (2020)
Hitodebusoku to gyoumu kata de kasumigaseki houkai no pinchi [Shortage of labor and overwork will cause the collapse of Kasumigaseki]. Chuou Kouron134: 52–57.
SuzukiKDemirciogluMA (2019)
The association between administrative characteristics and national level innovative activity: Findings from a cross-national study. Public Performance & Management Review42(4): 755–782.
Yomiuri Shimbun (2020a) Korosho Mizugiwataisaku De Gote Kenekiji: Teiryu Kantei Ni Hampatsu [The MHLW falls behind in border measures: Disagree with the cabinet’s idea for stopping for quarantine]. Yomiuri Shimbun, May 28. Available at: https://www.yomiuri.co.jp/member/scrap/20200528-OYT1T50008
55.
Yomiuri Shimbun (2020b) Kyugyoyosei ni bassoku hiteiteki shusho “shiken ni okina seiyaku” [Prime Minister talks against penalties on violation of business suspensions, “severe restrictions on private rights”]. Yomiuri Shimbun, June 16. Available at: https://www.yomiuri.co.jp/politics/20200615-OYT1T50134/
