This article comparatively examines the higher education reform pathways of France and Italy. Using a scheme of empirical indicators, I focus on the divergent and convergent developments in these two countries, which played a pioneering role in the Europeanization of higher education. While France has consistently moved closer to a market-oriented model, legacies of academic self-rule were initially strengthened in Italy, before recent reforms aimed to crack down on academic power abuses. To explain these policy pathways, I pursue a dual theoretical argument by linking institutional isomorphism with historical institutionalism.
Points for practitioners
The article examines the changing structures of higher education management and administration in France and Italy. It focuses on the new roles attributed to the state, university leaders and external stakeholders, and addresses whether both systems have converged on a market-oriented paradigm. I explain how and why various new competitive steering instruments were introduced. The analysis should be of interest to both scholars and practitioners due to its focus on new power arrangements in quality assurance, university administration and research governance.
AustJCrespyC (2009) Napoléon renversé? Institutionnalisation des Pôles de recherche et d’enseignement supérieur et réforme du système académique français. Revue française de science politique59(5): 915–938.
2.
BatoryALindstromN (2011) The power of the purse: Supranational entrepreneurship, financial incentives, and European higher education policy. Governance24(2): 311–329.
3.
Baty P (2010) La France témoigne d’une véritable foi en son enseignement supérieur. Le Monde, 17 September.
4.
Berning E (2002) Hochschulen und Studium in Italien. München: Bayerisches Staatsinstitut für Hochschulforschung und Hochschulplanung.
5.
BoffoSDuboisPMoscatiR (2008) Changes in university governance in France and Italy. Tertiary Education and Management14(1): 13–26.
6.
CapanoG (2008) Looking for serendipity – The problematical reform within Italy’s universities. Higher Education55(4): 481–504.
7.
CapanoG (2011) The government continues to do its job. Public Administration89(4): 1622–1644.
De BoerHGoedegebuureL (2003) New rules of the game? Reflections on governance, management, and systems change. In: FileJGoedegebuureL (eds) Real-time Systems, Enschede: Logo CHEPS, pp. 207–234.
16.
De BoerHEndersJSchimankU (2007) On the way towards New Public Management? In: JansenD (ed.) New Forms of Governance in Research Organizations, Dordrecht: Springer.
17.
DiMaggioPPowellW (eds) (1991) The iron cage revisited: Institutionalised isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields. The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 63–82.
18.
DobbinsMKnillC (2009) Higher education policies in Central and Eastern Europe: Convergence towards a common model?Governance22(3): 397–430.
19.
DobbinsMKnillCVögtleEM (2011) An analytical framework for the cross-country comparison of higher education governance. Higher Education62(5): 665–683.
20.
DoninaDMeoliMPaleariS (forthcoming) Higher education reform in Italy: Tightening regulation instead of steering at a distance. Higher Education Policy.
21.
EspostiMDGeraciM (2010) Thirty years of higher education policy in Italy: Vico’s Ricrosi and beyond. Bulletin of Italian Politics2(2): 111–122.
22.
EstermannTNokkalaTSteinelM (2011) University Autonomy in Europe: The Scorecard, Brussels: European University Association.
FerlieEMusselinCAndresaniG (2008) The steering of higher education systems: A public management perspective. Higher Education56(3): 325–348.
26.
GeorgeABennettA (2005) Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
27.
GiglioliPP (1979) Baroni e burocrati. Il ceto accademico italiano, Bologna: Mulino.
28.
HallPTaylorR (1996) Political science and the three new institutionalisms. Political Studies44(1): 936–957.
29.
JongbloedB (2003) Institutional funding and institutional change. In: FileJGoedegebuureL (eds) Real-time Systems, Enschede: Logo CHEPS, pp. 115–146.
30.
ManghiS (1987) Il Barone e l’apprendista: Ricerche sulla condizione accademica nell’università di massa, Milano: Franco Angeli.
31.
MarginsonSConsidineM (2000) The Enterprise University: Governance and Reinvention in Australian Higher Education, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
MartensKNagelAWindzioM (2010) Transformation of Education Policy, Basingstoke: Palgrave.
33.
Martens K, Rusconi A and Leuze K (eds) (2007) New Arenas of Education Governance – The Impact of International Organisations and Markets on Educational Policy Making. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Università e della Ricerca (MIUR) (2009) Il Processo di Bologna: Lo Spazio Europeo dell’Istruzione Superiore nel prossimo decennio. Available at: http://www.miur.it/UserFiles/3062.pdf (accessed 13 February 2013).
36.
MoscatiR (2001) Italian university professors in transition. Higher Education41(1/2): 103–129.
37.
MoscatiR (2009) The implementation of the Bologna Process in Italy. In: AmaralANeaveGMusselinC (eds) European Integration and the Governance of Higher Education and Research, Dordrecht: Springer.
38.
MoscatiR (2012) University governance in changing European systems of higher education. In: CurajAScottPVlasceanuL (eds) European Higher Education at the Crossroads, Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 599–611.
39.
MusselinC (2001) La longue marche des universités françaises, Paris: PUF.
40.
Musselin C (2009) Seeking autonomy: French universities against the Jacobins. International Higher Education 56(1): 18.
41.
MusselinCParadeiseC (2009) France: From incremental transitions to institutional change. In: ParadeiseCRealeEBleiklieI (eds) University Governance: Western European Perspectives, Dordrecht: Springer.
42.
NeaveG (1998) The evaluative state reconsidered. European Journal of Education33(3): 265–284.
43.
NeaveGVan VughtF (1991) Prometheus Bound: The Changing Relationship between Government and Higher Education in Western Europe, Oxford: Pergamon.
44.
OlsenJ (2007) The institutional dynamics of the European university. In: MaassenPOlsenJ (eds) University Dynamics and European Integration, Dordrecht: Springer.
45.
PollittCBouckaertG (2000) Public Management Reform. A Comparative Analysis, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ricolfi L (2009) Nella direzione giusta. La Stampa, 29 October.
48.
RinaldiP (2011) La governance interna delle università e il principio dell’autonomia Universitaria, Piacenza: Quaderni del Dipartimento di Scienze economiche e sociali.
