This article addresses the question how to distinguish symbolic policies from evidence-based policies, using the efforts of the Brazilian government to improve the achievements of pupils in primary schools as an illustration.
The Brazilian government aimed for achievements in basic education in its country equal to those in the developed world and implemented policies in line with decentralization of the schooling system and improvement of the training of teachers. It will be shown that such policies are symbolic in the sense that they may have an appeal to the national population and to the outside world, but are hardly effective.
This article’s main argument is that governments can prevent such outcomes when they are less opportunistic in following international fashions, such as the striving for decentralization, and have policymakers analyze the problem somewhat more thoroughly, resulting in evidence-based policies.
Points for practitioners
This study points to four criteria to distinguish symbolic versus evidence-based policies and gives an example of how to use these criteria in practice. This is useful for policymakers, policy analysts and policy evaluators.
Andrews CW ( 1998) Descentralização da educação no Brasil. Unpublished manuscript submitted to FGV/ EAESP.
2.
Blühdorn I. ( 2007) Sustaining the unsustainable: Symbolic politics and the politics of simulation. Environmental Politics16(2): 251-275.
3.
Brasil, Congresso Nacional (1996a) Emenda constitucional N° 14. Diário Oficial , 13 September 1996. Retrieved 24 April 2008, from: https://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/Constituicao/Emendas/Emc/emc14htm
4.
Brasil, Congresso Nacional (1996b) Lei N° 9.424. Dispõe sobre o Fundo de Manutenção e Desenvolvimento do Ensino Fundamental e de Valorização do Magistério, na forma prevista no art. 60, § 7°, do Ato das Disposições Constitucionais Transitórias, e dá outras providências. Diário Oficial, 26 December 1996. Retrieved 3 March 2008, from: http://portal.mec.gov.br/arquivos/pdf/lei9424m.pdf
5.
Cabinet Office (1999a) Modernising Government. Presented to Parliament by the Prime Minister and the Minister for the Cabinet Office by Command of Her Majesty. March 1999. London: Cabinet Office .
6.
Cabinet Office (1999b) Professional Policy Making for the Twenty First Century. Report by Strategic Policy Making Team Cabinet Office. (September 1999), London: Cabinet Office.
7.
Cabinet Office (2001) Better Policy Making. Centre for Management and Policy Studies. London: Cabinet Office.
8.
Davies HTO, Nutley S and Smith P (eds) ( 2000) What Works? Evidence-based Policy and Practice in Public Services. Bristol: The Policy Press .
9.
Davies PT ( 1999) What is evidence-based education? British Journal of Educational Studies47(2): 108-121.
10.
Davies P. ( 2004) Is evidence-based government possible?Jerry Lee Lecture, presented at the 4th annual Campbell Collaboration Colloquium. Washington, DC.
11.
Duarte J. ( 1997) Clientelismo e implementación de programas socials: el caso de um proyecto del Banco Mundial para Educación Primaria em Colombia. In: de Ferro MCR and Gutiérrez AD (eds) Política social: desafios y utopias. Bogotá: Pontifícia Universidad Javeriana, 259-285.
12.
Dunn WN ( 1994) Public Policy Analysis: An Introduction. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall .
13.
Edelman M. ( 1964) The Symbolic Uses of Politics. Urbana : University of Illinois Press.
14.
Fernandes R. ( 2007) Índice de desenvolvimento da educação básica (Ideb). Brasília: INEP . (Textos para Discussão n. 26). Retrieved 3 March 2009, from http://www.publicacoes.inep.gov.br/detalhes.asp?pub=4121#
15.
Fernandes R. ( 2008) Índice de desenvolvimento da educação básica (Ideb): metas intermediárias para a sua trajetória no Brasil, estados, municípios e escolas. Brasília : INEP. Retrieved 8 May 2008, from http://www.inep.gov.br/download/Ideb/Artigo_projecoes.pdf
16.
Fiske E. ( 1996) Decentralization of Education: Gaining Consensus (Directions in Development Series). Washington, DC: The World Bank. Retrieved 10 October 1998 from http://www.wds.worldbank.org/servlet/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/1996/11/01/000009265_3970716145037/Rendered/PDF/multi_page.pdf.
17.
Hansjürgens B and Lübbe-Wolff G (eds) (2000) Symbolische Umweltpolitik. Frankfurt/ Main: Suhrkamp.
18.
Litvack J., Junaid A. and Bird RM ( 1998) Rethinking Decentralization in Developing Countries . Washington, DC: World Bank (Sector Studies Series - Poverty Reduction and Economic Management).
19.
MEC/INEP ( 2008a) Sinopse estatistica da educacao basica: censo escolar 2006. Brasilia: Instituto Nacional de Estudos e Pesquisas Educacionais Anísio Teixeira.
20.
MEC/INEP (Ministério da Educação/Instituto Nacional de Estudos e Pesquisas Educacionais ‘Anísio Teixeira’) (2008b) IDEB - Índice da Edução Básica. Brasília : INEP. Retrieved 10 April 2009 , from: http://portalideb.inep.gov.br/
21.
Mertens SB and Anfara VA Jr ( 2009) An International Look at Educating Young Adolescents . Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
22.
Mulgan G. ( 2003) Government, knowledge and the business of policy-making’ . Canberra Bulletin of Public Administration108. 1-5.
23.
Pawson R. ( 2006) Evidence-based Policy: A Realist Perspective. London: Sage.
24.
Pawson R. and Tilly N. ( 1997) Realistic Evaluation. London : Sage.
25.
Prud’homme R. ( 1994) On the Dangers of Decentralization. Washington, DC: World Bank (Policy Research Paper no. 1252).
26.
Rudd K. ( 2008) Address to Heads of Agencies and members of Senior Executive Service, 30 April 2008. Retrieved from http://www.apsc.gov.au/media/rudd300408.htm
27.
Schneider AL and Ingram H. ( 1993) Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American Journal of Political Science Review87(2): 334-346.
28.
UNPD (United Nations Development Program) ( 2000) Atlas do desenvolvimento humano no Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: PNUD.
29.
UNICEF (United Nations Children’s Fund) ( 2009) O Direito de Aprender: Potencializar avanços e reduzir desigualdades [coordenação geral Maria de Salete Silva e Pedro Ivo Alcântara]. Brasília, DF: UNICEF.
30.
Winkler DR and Gershberg AI ( 2000) Education decentralization in Latin America: The effects on the quality of schooling. In: Burki SJ, Eid F, Freire ME, Vergara V and Perry GE (eds) Annual World Bank Conference on Development in Latin America and the Caribbean - 1999 Proceedings: Decentralization and Accountability of the Public Sector. Washington, DC: World Bank, 203-225.
