Some Implications of a Community Mental Health Model for Developing Countries

Abstract

THE aim of this paper is to call attention to certain problems facing many developing countries which are bound to lead to further difficulties in psycho-social adjustment. Almost all these problems are inherent in the process of socio-economic change, urbanization, and industrialization. These changes may not only lead to an increase in the rate of mental illness, but because of their impact on the basic family structure and living conditions, will result in a reduced tolerance of deviation on the part of the community. Moreover, the spread of public education and mass media is also likely to lead to a change in the expectations and attitudes of developing nations making it no longer possible to endure psychological suffering as part of one's destiny. Even the improvement of public health services leading to reduction of infant mortality and a rise in life expectancy may lead to a gross increase in demands for mental health services by the very young and the aged sections of the population.

It is the contention of this paper that a community mental health model, with certain modifications to fit the local culture, will best serve the increasing mental health needs of developing nations. Of particular relevance are such aspects of the model as population and prevention orientation, community involvement, extension of professional resources through consultation, utilization of non-professional man-power, continuity and comprehensiveness of care as well as an open systems conceptualization of the whole process of the organization and delivery of mental health services. The latter approach will help bring about an integration of mental health services within the wider framework of human service agencies, e.g., public health, general and adult education, family planning, and community development.

The implications of these new roles and functions for the training of mental health workers will be discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albee, G.W. , 1967: "The relation of conceptual models to manpower needs", in Cowen, E. L. Gardner, E. A. , and Zax, M. (eds.) Emergent Approaches to Mental Health Problems. New York: Appleton-Century Croft.

Bellak, L. , 1964: Community Psychiatry and Community Mental Health New York: Grune & Stratton.

Bloom B.L. , 1965: "The medical model, miasmatheory, and community mental health", in Community Mental Health Journal, 1, 333-338.

—, 1971: "Strategies for prevention of mental disorders", in Glidewell, J. C., and Rosenblum (eds.), Issues in Community Psychology and Preventive Mental Health New York: Behavioral Publications.

Caplan, G. , 1964: Principles of Preventive Psychiatry New York: Basic Books.

—, 1970: The Theory and Practice of Mental Health Consultation New York: Basic Books.

—, and Caplan R.B. , 1967: "Development of community psychiatry concepts", in Freedman, A. M. , and Kaplan, H. I. (eds.), Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry . Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins , pp. 1499-1516.

—, and Caplan, R. , 1969: Community and Psychiatry in Nineteenth Century America New York: Basic Books.

—, and Grunebaum, H. , 1967: "Perspectives on primary prevention: A review", in Archives of General Psychiatry, 17.

10.

Carstairs, G.M. , 1969: "Changing perception of neurotic illness" in Caudill, W. , and Lin, Tsunz-yi (eds.), Mental Health Research in Asia and the Pacific . Honolulu: East-West Center Press . and Lin, Tsunz-yi (eds.),

11.

Collins, J.A. , 1971: "The paraprofessional: I. Manpower issues in the mental health field: II. Brief mental health training for the community health worker ", in Hospital and Community Psychiatry, pp. 362-370.

12.

Demone, H.W. , 1972: "Human services at state and local levels, and the integration of mental health", in Caplan, G. (ed.), American Handbook of Psychiatry, Vol. IV. Boston: Little Brown (in press).

13.

Dunham, H.W. 1965: "Community psychiatry: The newest therapeutic bandwagon ", in Archives of General Psychiatry, 12, 303-313.

14.

Eisenberg, L. 1966: "Preventive sychiatry: If not now, when", in David, H. P. (ed.), International Trends in Mental Health New York :McGraw-Hill.

15.

Evang, K. , 1967: "Political, national and traditional limitations to health control", in Wolstenholme, G., and O'Connor, M. (eds.), Health of Mankind Boston: Little Brown and Company .

16.

Eysenck, H.J. , 1965: The Effects of Psychotherapy New York : Science House.

17.

Fein. R. , 1958: Economics of Mental Illness New York : Basic Books.

18.

Fried, M. , 1966: "Effects of social change on mental health", in Bergen, B. L. , and Thomas, C. S. (eds.), Issues and Problems in Social Psychiatry. Springfield Illinois: Charles C. Thomas, pp. 358-399.

19.

Hobbs, N. , 1964: "Mental health: third revolution", in American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 34, pp. 822-833.

20.

Iscoe, I. , 1971: "Professional and subprofessional training in commuynity mental health as an aspect of community psychology" in Glidewell, J. C. , and Rosenblum, G. (eds.), Issues in Community Psychology and Preventive Mental Health . New York: Behavioral Publications , pp. 21-32.

21.

Lambo, T.A. , 1966: "Patterns of psychiatric care in developing African countries: The Nigerian village program", in avid, H. P. (ed.), International Trends in Mental Health. New York: McGraw-Hill, pp. 147-153.

22.

Leighton, A.H. , 1966: "Psychiatric disorder and social environment", in Bergen, B. L. , and Thomas, C. S. (eds.), Issues and Problems in Social Psychiatry . Springfield, Illinois: Charles C. Thomas, pp. 155-197.

23.

—. 1968, "Some propositions regarding the relationship of sociocultural integration and disintegration to mental health", in Social Psychiatry, pp. 1-7.

24.

Lin, Tsung-yi , 1963: "Historical survey of psychiatric epidemiology in Asia ", in Mental Hygiene, 47, 351-359.

25.

—, 1968: "Community mental health services: A world view", in Williams, R. H. , and Ozarin, L. D. (eds.), Community Mental Health: An International Perspective. San Francisco: Josscy-Bass, Inc., pp. 3-17.

26.

Lindemann, E. , 1969: "Mental health aspects of rapid social change", in Caudill, W. , and Lin, Tsung-yi (eds.), Mental Health Research in Asia and the Pacific. Honolulu: East-West Center Press, pp. 478-487.

27.

Melehov D.E. , 1967: "Some debatable problems in social psychiatry", in International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 2, 3. pp. 107-110.

28.

Myrdal, G. , 1970: The Challenge of World Poverty. New York: Vintage Books.

29.

Plog, S.C. 1969: "Urbanization psychological disorders, and the heritage of social psychiatry", in Plog, S. C. and Edgarton, R. B. (eds.), Changing Perspectives in Mental Illness. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, pp. 288-312.

30.

Reiff, R. , and Reissman, F. , 1965: The Indigenous Nonprofessional, a Strategy of Change in Community Action and Community Mental Health Programs New York: Behavioral Publications.

31.

Sanggingkeo, P. , 1966: "Mental health in developing countries", in David, H. P. (ed.), International Trends in Mental Health. New York: McGraw-Hill , pp. 53-62.

32.

Senua, V.D. 2 1966: "Sociocultural aspects of psychotherapy and treatment ", in Abt, L. E. , and Bellafl, L. (eds.), Progress in Clinical Psychology , Vol. 8. New York: Grune & Stratton, pp. 151-190.

33.

Schulberg, C. and Baker, F. , 1969: "Community mental health: belief system of the 1960's ", in Psychiatric Opinion, 6, pp. 14-26.

34.

Wittkower, E.C. , and Termansen P.E. , 1969: "Cultural psychiatric research in Asia", in Caudill, W. , and Lin, Tsung-yi (eds.), Mental Health Research in Asia and the Pacific . Honolulu: East-West Center Press , pp. 434-447.