Comorbidity of anxiety and depressive disorders: A comparative population study in Western and non-Western inhabitants in the Netherlands

Abstract

Background: Overlap of depressive and anxiety symptoms is supposedly more common in non-Western populations. This can lead to diagnostic uncertainity and undertreatment.

Aims: The aim of this study was to assess cross-cultural differences regarding the comorbidity of anxiety and depressive disorders in a comparative population study.

Methods: In a random urban population sample, stratified for descent, in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, diagnostic interviews were held by bilingual interviewers. Diagnoses of anxiety and depressive disorders, based on the Composite International Diagnostic Interview, were obtained for 307 native Dutch subjects, 205 Turkish-Dutch subjects and 186 Moroccan-Dutch subjects.

Results: The prevalence rate of comorbid anxiety and depressive disorders was higher in Turkish-Dutch (9.8 %) and Moroccan-Dutch (3.8%) subjects compared to native Dutch subjects (2.3%). However, this could be explained by differences in baseline prevalence rate and level of severity of the separate disorders. The onset order of anxiety disorders and depressive disorders was comparable in each ethnic group.

Conclusions: The high prevalence rate of comorbid anxiety and depressive diorders in non-Western immigrants in the Netherlands necessitates assesssment and treatment of both disorders. There was no indication of a – culturally influenced – stronger overlap between anxiety and depressive disorders in non-Western immigrants in the Netherlands.

Keywords

anxiety disorder comorbidity cross-cultural comparison depressive disorder Morocco Turkey

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agyemang

Ujcic-Voortman

Uitenbroek

Foets

Droomers

(2006) ‘Prevalence and Management of Hypertension among Turkish, Moroccan and Native Dutch Ethnic Groups in Amsterdam, the Netherlands: The Amsterdam Health Monitor Survey.’ Journal Hypertension 24: 2169–2176.

American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th edn. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

American Psychiatric Association (2009) Treatment of Patients with Panic Disorder. 2nd edn. Practice Guideline. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

Andrews

Peters

(1998) ‘The Psychometric Properties of the Composite International Diagnostic Interview.’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 33: 80–88.

Bhugra

(2003) ‘Migration and Depression.’ Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 108 (Suppl. 418): 67–72.

Bhugra

Mastrogianni

(2004) ‘Globalization and Mental Disorders: Overview with Relation to Depression.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 184: 10–20.

Breslau

Aguilar-Gaxiola

Kendler

K.S.

Williams

Kessler

R.C.

(2006) ‘Specifying Race-Ethnic Differences in Risk for Psychiatric Disorder in a USA National Sample.’ Psychological Medicine 36: 57–68.

Carta

M.G.

Bernal

Hardoy

M.C.

Haro-Abad

J.M.

and the Report on the Mental Health in Europe Working Group (2005) ‘Migration and Mental Health in Europe (The State of the Mental Health in Europe Working Group: Appendix I).’ Clinical Practice and Epidemiology in Mental Health 1: 13–26.

Das-Munshi

Goldberg

Bebbington

P.E.

Bhugra

D.K.

Brugha

T.S.

Dewey

M.E.

Jenkins

Stewart

Prince

(2008) ‘Public Health Significance of Mixed Anxiety and Depression: Beyond Current Classification.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 192: 171–177.

10.

de Graaf

Bijl

R.V.

Smit

Vollebergh

W.A.M.

Spijker

(2002) ‘Risk Factors for 12-Month Comorbidity of Mood, Anxiety, and Substance Use Disorders: Findings from the Netherlands Mental Health Survey and Incidence Study.’ American Journal of Psychiatry 159: 620–629.

11.

de Graaf

Bijl

R.V.

Spijker

Beekman

A.T.F.

Vollebergh

W.A.M.

(2003) ‘Temporal Sequencing of Lifetime Mood Disorders in Relation to Comorbid Anxiety and Substance Disorders.’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 38: 1–11.

12.

de Wit

M.A.S.

Tuinebreijer

W.C.

Dekker

Beekman

A.T.F.

Gorissen

W.H.M.

Schrier

A.C.

Penninx

B.W.J.H.

Komproe

I.H.

Verhoeff

A.P.

(2008) ‘Depressive and Anxiety Disorders in Different Ethnic Groups. A Population-Based Study among Native Dutch, and Turkish, Moroccan and Surinamese Migrants in Amsterdam.’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 43: 905–912.

13.

Fassaert

de Wit

M.A.S.

Tuinebreijer

W.C.

Verhoeff

A.P.

Beekman

A.T.F.

Dekker

(2009a) ‘Perceived Need for Mental Health Care among Non-Western Labour Migrants.’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 44: 208–216.

14.

Fassaert

de Wit

M.A.S.

Verhoeff

A.P.

Tuinebreijer

W.C.

Gorissen

W.H.

Beekman

A.T.F.

Dekker

(2009b) ‘Uptake of Health Services for Common Mental Disorders by First- Generation Turkish and Moroccan Migrants in the Netherlands.’ BMC Public Health 9: 307 doi:10.1186/1471-2458-9-30710.1186/1471-2458-9-307.

15.

Fassaert

Peen

van Straten

de Wit

M.A.S.

Schrier

A.C.

Heijnen

Cuijpers

Verhoeff

A.P.

Beekman

A.T.F.

Dekker

(2010) ‘Ethnic Differences and Similarities in Outpatient Treatment for Depression in the Netherlands.’ Psychiatric Services 61: 690–697.

16.

Kessler

R.C.

Andrade

Caraveo-Anduaga

J.J.

Berglund

Bijl

R.V.

de Graaf

Vollebergh

Dragomirecka

Kohn

Keller

Kawakami

Kilic

Offord

Ustun

Vincente

Wittchen

H.-U.

(2003) ‘The Epidemiology of Major Depressive Episodes: Results from the International Consortium of Psychiatric Epidemiology (ICPE) Surveys.’ International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research 12: 3–21.

17.

Kessler

R.C.

Chiu

W.T.

Demler

O.M.

Walters

E.E.

(2005) ‘Prevalence, Severity and Comorbidity of 12-Month DSM-IV Disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication.’ Archives of General Psychiatry 62: 617–627.

18.

Kessler

R.C.

Nelson

C.B.

McGonagle

K.A.

Liu

Swartz

Blazer

D.G.

(1996) ‘Comorbidity of DSM-III-R Major Depressive Disorder in the General Population: Results from the US National Comorbidity Survey.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 168 (Suppl. 30): 17–30.

19.

Kirmayer

L.J.

(2001) ‘Cultural Variations in the Clinical Presentation of Depression and Anxiety: Implications for Diagnosis and Treatment.’ Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 62 (Suppl. 13): S22–S28.

20.

Kohn

Bhui

(2007) ‘Psychiatric Epidemiology and its Contributions to Cultural Psychiatry’, in Bhugra

Bhui

(eds) Textbook of Cultural Psychiatry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

21.

Kraemer

H.C.

(1995) ‘Statistical Issues in Assessing Comorbidity.’ Statistics in Medicine 14: 721–733.

22.

Leff

J.P.

(1973) ‘Culture and the Differentiation of Emotional States.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 123: 299–306.

23.

Leveque

Lodewyckx

Vranken

(2007) ‘Depression and Generalized Anxiety in the General Population in Belgium: A Comparison between Native and Immigrant Groups.’ Journal of Affective Disorders 97: 229–239.

24.

Merikangas

K.R.

Whitaker

Angst

Eaton

Canino

Rubio-Stipec

Wacker

Wittchen

H.-U.

Andrade

Essau

Kraemer

Robins

Kupfer

(1996) ‘Comorbidity and the Boundaries of Affective Disorders with Anxiety Disorders and Substance Misuse: Results of an International Task Force.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 169 (Suppl. 30): 58–67.

25.

Mezzich

J.E.

Kirmayer

L.J.

Kleinman

Fabrega

Parron

D.L.

Good

B.J.

Lin

K.-M.

Manson

S.M.

(1999) ‘The Place of Culture in DSM-IV.’ Journal of Nervous and Mental Disorders 187: 457–464.

26.

National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2004a) Depression: Management of Depression in Primary and Secondary Care. Clinical Guideline 23. London: National Institute for Clinical Excellence.

27.

National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2004b) Clinical Guidelines for the Management of Anxiety. London: National Institute for Clinical Excellence.

28.

O+S Research and Statistics (2009) Key Figures Amsterdam 2008. Amsterdam: O+S, Research and Statistics. URL consulted (January 2011): http://www.os.amsterdam.nl .

29.

Preisig

Merikangas

K.R.

Angst

(2001) ‘Clinical Significance and Comorbidity of Subthreshold Despression and Anxiety in the Community.’ Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 104: 96–103.

30.

Roy-Byrne

P.P.

Stang

Wittchen

H.-U.

Üstün

Walters

E.E.

Kessler

R.C.

(2000) ‘Lifetime Panic-Depression Comorbidity in the National Comorbidity Survey: Association with Symptoms, Impairment, Course and Help-Seeking.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 176: 229–235.

31.

Schrier

A.C.

de Wit

M.A.

Rijmen

Tuinebreijer

W.C.

Verhoeff

A.P.

Kupka

R.W.

Dekker

Beekman

A.T.F.

(2010) ‘Similarity in Depressive Symptom Profile in a Population-Based Study of Migrants in the Netherlands.’ Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 45: 941–951.

32.

Simon

G.E.

Goldberg

D.P.

von Korff

Üstün

T.B.

(2002) ‘Understanding Cross-National Differences in Depression Prevalence.’ Psychological Medicine 32: 585–594.

33.

Smits

C.H.M.

de Vries

W.M.

Beekman

A.T.F.

(2005) ‘The CIDI as an Instrument for Diagnosing Depression in Older Turkish and Moroccan Labour Migrants: An Exploratory into Equivalence.’ International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 20: 436–445.

34.

Social and Cultural Planning Office of the Netherlands (2004) Muslims in the Netherlands. The Hague: Social and Cultural Planning Office of the Netherlands.

35.

Statistics Netherlands (2009) URL (consulted January 2011): http://www.cbs.nl . See definition of ‘country of origin’.

36.

Stockdale

S.E.

Lagomasino

I.T.

Siddique

McGuire

Miranda

(2008) ‘Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Detection and Treatment of Depression and Anxiety among Psychiatric and Primary Health Care Visits, 1995–2005. Medical Care 46: 668–677.

37.

Swinnen

S.G.H.A.

Selten

J.-P.

(2007) ‘Mood Disorders and Migration: Meta-Analysis.’ British Journal of Psychiatry 190: 6–10.

38.

Tseng

W.-S.

(2007) ‘Culture and Psychopathology: General View’, in Bhugra

Bhui

(eds) Textbook of Cultural Psychiatry. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

39.

Wittchen

H.-U.

(1994) ‘Reliability and Validity Studies of the WHO-Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI): A Critical Review.’ Journal of Psychiatric Research 28: 57–84.

40.

Wittchen

H.-U.

Kessler

R.C.

Pfister

Lieb

(2000) ‘Why Do People with Anxiety Disorders Become Depressed? A Prospective-Longitudinal Community Study.’ Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 102 (Suppl. 406): 14–23.

41.

World Health Organization (1997) Composite International Diagnostic Interview. Version 2.1. Geneva: World Health Organization.