British Gujarati Indian Immigrants' and British Caucasians' Beliefs about Health and Illness

Abstract

Background and aims: This study examined cultural differences in beliefs about health and illness to explore differences in younger and older British Caucasians' and British Gujarati Indian immigrants' beliefs about health and illness.

Methods: This study required a matched group consisting of first- and second-generation Gujarati Indian immigrants and native British Caucasians to complete a questionnaire assessing their beliefs concerning health and illness.

Results: Factor analysis of the health beliefs questionnaire identified six clear factors accounting for 36.04% of the variance. Subsequent ANCOVAs conducted on the factor scores, partialling out the demographic differences between the participants, revealed that Gujarati Indian immigrants agreed with items reflecting supernatural explanations of ill health more than indigenous British Caucasian participants. Older Indian immigrants also rated chance-related factors as more important than older Caucasian immigrants. There were no significant differences between the Gujarati Indian immigrants and British Caucasians in terms of attributions made to psychological factors and self-responsibility, social factors and life circumstances, medical treatment and physical vulnerability and the external environment.

Conclusions: Findings are discussed in relation to the model proposed by Helman (2001) and the impact of migration on health beliefs systems; practical implications of the findings are also highlighted.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ARMSTRONG, T.L. & SWARTZMAN, L.C. (1999) Asian versus western differences in satisfaction with western medical care: the mediational effects of illness attributions . Psychology and Health, 14, 403–416 .

BOWLING, A. (1994) Beliefs about illness causation among Turkish and white British people living in a deprived inner London district . Health Education Research, 9, 355–364 .

COOK, P. (1994) Chronic illness beliefs and the role of social networks among Chinese, Indian and Angloceltic Canadians . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 4, 452–465 .

COURTNEY, W.H. , McCREARY, D.R. & MERIGHI, J.R. (2002) Gender and ethnic differences in health beliefs and behaviours . Journal of Health Psychology, 7, 213–219 .

DALAL, A.K. & SINGH, A.K. (1992) Role of causal and recovery beliefs in the psychological adjustment to a chronic disease . Psychology and Health, 6, 193–203 .

DALAL, A.K. (2000) Living with a chronic disease: healing and adjustment in Indian society . Psychology and Developing Societies, 12, 67–81 .

FARR, R. & MARKOVA, I. (1995) Professional and lay representations of health, illness and handicap: a theoretical overview. In Representations of Health, Illness and Handicap (eds I. Markova & R. Farr , pp. 93–110). Geneva: Harwood Academic Publishers .

FLICK, U. (2000) Qualitative inquiries into social representations of health . Journal of Health Psychology, 5, 315–324 .

FURNHAM, A. (1994a) Explaining health and illness: lay beliefs on the nature of health . Personality and Individual Differences, 17, 455–466 .

10.

FURNHAM, A. (1994b) Explaining health and illness: lay perceptions on current and future health, the causes of illness, and the nature of recovery . Social Science and Medicine, 39, 715–725 .

11.

FURNHAM, A. & AKANDE, A. (1997) Cross-cultural differences in attributions for overcoming specifc psychological problems . Journal of Social Behaviour and Personality, 12, 727–742 .

12.

FURNHAM, A. , AKANDE, D. & BAGUMA, P. (1999) Beliefs about health and illness in three countries: Britain, South Africa and Uganda . Psychology, Health & Medicine, 4, 189–201 .

13.

FURNHAM, A. & MALIK, R. (1994) Cross-cultural beliefs about depression . International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 40, 106–123 .

14.

GREENHALGH, T. , HELMAN, C. & CHOWDHURY, A.M. (1998) Health beliefs and folk models of diabetes in British Bangladeshis: a qualitative study . British Medical Journal, 316, 978–983 .

15.

HELMAN, C.G. (1986) ‘Feed a cold, starve a fever’: folk models of infection in an English suburban community, and their relation to medical treatment. Concepts and a model of the comparison of medical systems as cultural systems. In Concepts of Health, Illness and Disease: A Comparative Perspective (eds C. Currer & M. Stacey , pp. 211–231). Leamington Spa: Berg .

16.

HELMAN, C.G. (2001) Culture, Health and Illness. London: Arnold .

17.

HILTON, B.A. , GREWAL, S. , POPATIA, N. , BOTTORFF, J.L. , JOHNSON, J.L. , CLARKE, H. , VENABLES, L.J. , BILKHU, S. & SUMEL, P. (2001) The desi way: traditional health practices of south Asian women in Canada . Health care for Women International, 22, 553–567 .

18.

KLEINMAN, A. (1986) Concepts and a model of the comparison of medical systems as cultural systems. In Concepts of Health, Illness and Disease: A Comparative Perspective (eds C. Currer & M. Stacey , pp. 27–47). Leamington Spa: Berg .

19.

JOSHI, M.S. (1995) Lay explanations of the causes of diabetes in India and the UK. In Representations of Health, Illness and Handicap (eds I. Markova & R. Farr , pp. 163–188). Geneva: Harwood Academic Publishers .

20.

JOSHI, M.S. & LAMB, R. (2000) New foods for old? The diet of South Asians in the UK . Psychology & Developing Societies, 12, 83–103 .

21.

JOVCHELOVITCH, S. & GERVAIS, M.C. (1999) Social representations of health and illness: the case of the Chinese community in England . Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 9, 247–260 .

22.

JUTHANI, N.V. (2001) Psychiatric treatment of Hindus . International Review of Psychiatry, 13, 125–130 .

23.

LANDRINE, H. & KLONOFF, A. (1994) Cultural diversity in causal attributions for illness: the role of the supernatural . Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 17, 181–193 .

24.

LAUNGANI, P. (1994) Cultural differences in stress: India and England . Counselling Psychology Review, 9, 27–37 .

25.

MISRA, R. , PATEL, T.G. , DAVIES, D. & RUSSO, T. (2000) Health promotion behaviors of Gujarati Asian Indian immigrants in the United States . Journal of Immigrant Health, 2, 223–230 .

26.

MOKOUNKOLO, R. & MULLET, E. (1999) Lay beliefs on the nature of health: an English–French comparison . Social Behaviour and Personality, 27, 439–453 .

27.

MORGAN, M. & WATKINS, C.J. (1988) Managing hypertension: belief and responses to medication among cultural groups . Sociology of Health and Illness, 10, 561–578 .

28.

STAINTON-ROGERS, W. (1991) Explaining Health and Illness: An Exploration of Diversity. London: Wheatsheaf .

29.

TORSCH, V.L. & XUEQUIN MA, M.G. (2000) Cross-cultural comparison of health perceptions, concerns and coping strategies among Asian and Pacifc Islander American Elders . Qualitative Health Research, 10, 470–489 .

30.

VINCENT, C. & FURNHAM, A. (1994) The perceived efficacy of complementary and orthodox medicine . Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 2, 128–134 .

31.

VOHRA, S.S. & BROOTA, K.D. (1996) Beliefs and the adaptation to a new culture – the case of Indian immigrants . Journal of the Indian Academy of Applied Psychology, 22, 55–64 .

32.

WILLIAMS, R. & SHAMS, M. (1998) Generational continuity and change in British Asian health and health behaviour . Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 52, 558–563 .