Aims: To review the methods and findings from studies of the therapeutic relationship (TR) in the treatment of severe mental illness.
Method: A literature search was conducted to identify all studies that used an operationalised measurement of the TR in the treatment of severe mental illness. Results: Fifteen scales–the majority of which were developed for psychotherapy–and the expressed emotion index have been used. Most scales have acceptable internal, inter-rater and test–retest reliability. As none of the scales has been used in more than five studies, no single scale is widely established in psychiatric research. A more positive relationship consistently predicts a better short-and long-term outcome. It appears that a large global factor accounts for the greatest proportion of the variance in the therapeutic relationship.
Conclusions: The therapeutic relationship is a reliable predictor of patient outcome in mainstream psychiatric care. Valid assessments may need to take account of different, specific aspects of the relationship in psychiatric settings such as greater heterogeneity of treatment components and goals, increased variability of setting and the statutory responsibility of the clinician. Methodological progress may require conceptual work to ensure valid assessments of this central element of treatment.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALEXANDER, L.B. & COFFEY, D.S. (1997) Understanding the therapeutic relationship . Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 10, 233–238 .
2.
ALLEN, J.G. , TARNOFF, G. & COYNE, L. (1985) Therapeutic alliance and long-term hospital treatment outcome . Comprehensive Psychiatry, 26, 187–194 .
3.
ALLEN, J.G. , NEWSOM, G.E. , GABBARD, G.O. & COYNE, L. (1984) Scales to assess the therapeutic alliance from a psychoanalytic perspective . Bulletin of the Menninger Clinic, 48, 383–400 .
4.
BACHELOR, A. (1991) Comparison and relationship to outcome of diverse dimensions of the helping alliance as seen by client and therapist . Psychotherapy, 28, 534–549 .
5.
BARKER, D.A. , SHERGILL, S.S. , HIGGINSON, I. & ORRELL, M.W. (1996) Patients’ views towards care received from psychiatrists . British Journal of Psychiatry, 168, 641–646 .
6.
BARRETT-LENNARD, G.T. (1962) Dimensions of therapist response as causal factors in therapeutic change . Psychological Monographs, 76, 1–35 .
7.
BEAUFORD, J.E. , MCNIEL, D.E. & BINDER, R.L. (1997) Utility of the initial therapeutic alliance in evaluating psychiatric patients’ risk of violence . American Journal of Psychiatry, 154, 1272–1276 .
8.
BENNUN, I. , HAHLWEG, K. , SCHINDLER, L. & LANGLOTZ, M. (1986) Therapist’s and client’s perceptions in behaviour therapy: the development and cross-cultural analysis of an assessment instrument . British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 25, 275–283 .
9.
BHUI, K. & BHUGRA, D. (2002) Explanatory models for mental distress: implications for clinical practice and research . British Journal of Psychiatry, 181, 6–7 .
10.
BORDIN, E.S. (1979) The generalisability of the psychoanalytic concept of the working alliance . Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 16, 252–260 .
11.
CALLAN, A. & LITTLEWOOD, R. (1998) Patient satisfaction: ethnic origin or explanatory model?International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 44, 1–11 .
12.
CLARKIN, J.F. , HURT, S.W. & CRILLY, J.L. (1987) Therapeutic alliance and hospital treatment outcome . Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 38, 871–875 .
13.
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH (1999) Modern Standards and Service Models: National Service Framework for Mental Health. London: Department of Health .
14.
DOANE, J.A. , WEST, K.L. , GOLDSTEIN, M.J. , RODNICK, E.H. & JONES, J.E. (1981) Parental communication deviance and a.ective style . Archives of General Psychiatry, 38, 679–685 .
15.
DRAINE, J. & SOLOMON, P. (1996) Case manager alliance with clients in an older cohort . Community Mental Health Journal, 32, 125–134 .
16.
DRUSS, B.G. , ROSENHECK, R.A. & STOLAR, M. (1999) Patient satisfaction and administrative measures as indicators of the quality of mental health care . Psychiatric Services, 50, 1053–1058 .
17.
FAKHOURY, W.K. , KAISER, W. , RODER-WANNER, U.-U. & PRIEBE, S. (2002) Subjective evaluation: is there more than one criterion?Schizophrenia Bulletin, 28, 319–327 .
18.
FOREMAN, S.A. & MARMAR, C.R. (1985) Therapist actions that address initially poor therapeutic alliances in psychotherapy . American Journal of Psychiatry, 142, 922–926 .
19.
FRANK, A.F. & GUNDERSON, J.G. (1990) The role of the therapeutic alliance in the treatment of schizophrenia . Archives of General Psychiatry, 47, 228–236 .
20.
FRANK, J. (2000) History: the real basic science of psychotherapy?Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 188, 725–727 .
21.
FREUD, S. (1913) On beginning the treatment. In The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud (ed. J. Strachey ). London: Hogarth Press .
22.
GASTON, L. & MARMAR, C.R. (1991) Manual for the California Psychotherapy Alliance Scales–CALPAS. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Psychiatry, McGill University, Montreal, Canada.
23.
GASTON, L. , THOMPSON, L. , GALLAGHER, D. , COURNOYER, L. & GAGNON, R. (1998) Alliance, technique, and their interactions in predicting outcome of behavioural, cognitive, and brief dynamic therapy . Psychotherapy Research, 8, 190–209 .
24.
GEHRS, M. & GOERING, P. (1994) The relationship between the working alliance and rehabilitation outcomes of schizophrenia . Psychosocial Rehabilitation Journal, 18, 43–54 .
25.
GOERING, P. & STYLIANOS, S. (1988) Exploring the helping relationship between the schizophrenic client and rehabilitation therapist . American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 58, 271–280 .
26.
HANSSON, L. & BERGLUND, M. (1992) Stability of therapeutic alliance and its relationship to outcome in short-term inpatient psychiatric care . Scandinavian Journal of Social Medicine, 20, 45–50 .
27.
HARTLEY, D. & STRUPP, H.H. (1983) The therapeutic alliance: its relationship to outcome in brief psychotherapy. In Empirical Studies of Psychoanalytic Theories, Vol. 1 (ed. J. Masling ). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum .
28.
HATCHER, R.L. & BARENDS, A. (1996) Patients’ view of the alliance in psychotherapy: exploratory factor analysis of three alliance measures . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64, 1326–1336 .
29.
HATCHER, R.L. , BARENDS, A. , HANSELL, J. & JANICE GUTFREUND, M. (1995) Patients’ and therapists’ shared and unique views of the therapeutic alliance: an investigation using con.rmatory factor analysis in a nested design . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 63, 636–643 .
30.
HENTSCHEL, U. , KIESSLING, M. & RUDOLF, G. (1997) Therapeutic alliance and transference: an exploratory study of their empirical relationship . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 185, 254–262 .
31.
HORVATH, A.O. (1994) Research on the alliance. In The Working Alliance: Theory, Research and Practice (ed. A.O. Horvath & L.S. Greenberg ). New York: Wiley .
32.
HORVATH, A.O. & GREENBERG, L.S. (1989) Development and validation of the Working Alliance Inventory . Journal of Counselling Psychology, 36, 223–233 .
33.
HORVATH, A.O. & SYMONDS, B.D. (1991) Relation between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy: a meta-analysis . Journal of Counselling Psychology, 38, 139–149 .
34.
KAVANAGH, D.J. (1992) Recent developments in expressed emotion and schizophrenia . British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 601–620 .
35.
KESSLER, R.C. , BERGLUND, P.A. , WALTERS, E.E. , LEAF, P.J. , KOUZIS, A.C. et al. (1998) A methodology for estimating the 12-month prevalence of serious mental illness. In Mental Health, United States 1998 (ed. R.W. Mandersheid & M.J. Henderson ). Rockville, MD: Centre for Mental Health Services .
36.
KLINKENBERG, W.D. , CALSYN, R.J. & MORSE, G.A. (1998) The helping alliance in case management for homeless persons with severe mental illness . Community Mental Health Journal, 34, 569–578 .
37.
KRUPNICK, J.L. , SOTSKY, S.M. , SIMMENS, S. , MOYER, J. , ELKIN, I. , WATKINS, J. & PILKONIS, P.A. (1996) The role of the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy outcomendings in the national programme . Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 64, 532–539 .
38.
KUIPERS, L. & BEBBINGTON, P. (1988) Expressed emotion research in schizophrenia: theoretical and clinical implications . Psychological Medicine, 18, 893–909 .
39.
KUIPERS, L. & MOORE, E. (1995) Expressed emotion and sta.–client relationships . International Journal of Mental Health, 24, 13–26 .
40.
LUBORSKY, L. , CRITS-CHRISTOPH, M.S. , ALEXANDER, L. , MARGOLIS, M. & COHEN, M. (1983) Two helping alliance methods for predicting outcomes of psychotherapy . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 171, 480–491 .
41.
LUBORSKY, L. , MCLELLAN, T. , WOODY, G. , O’BRIEN, C.P. & AUERBACH, A. (1985) Therapist success and its determinants . Archives of General Psychiatry, 42, 602–611 .
42.
MAGANA, A.B. , GOLDSTEIN, M.J. , KARNO, M. , MIKLOWITZ, D.J. , JENKINS, J. & FALLOON, I.R.H. (1986) A brief method for assessing expressed emotion in relatives of psychiatric patients . Psychiatry Research, 17, 203–212 .
MARMAR, C.R. & GASTON, L. (1988) Manual for the California Psychotherapy Scales–CALPAS. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco, CA.
45.
MARMAR, C.R. , HOROWITZ, M.J. , WEISS, D.S. & MARZIALI, E. (1986) Development of the therapeutic rating system. In The Psychotherapeutic Process: A Research Handbook (ed. L. Greenberg & W. Pinsof ). New York: Guilford .
46.
MARZIALI, E. (1984) Three viewpoints on the therapeutic alliance: similarities, di.erences and associations with psychotherapy outcome . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 172, 417–423 .
47.
MARZIALI, E. , MARMAR, C. & KRUPNICK, J. (1981) Therapeutic alliance scales: development and relationship to psychotherapy outcome . American Journal of Psychiatry, 138, 361–364 .
48.
McCABE, R. & PRIEBE, S. (in press) Explanatory models of illness in schizophrenia patients: A comparison of four ethnic groups . British Journal of Psychiatry.
49.
McCABE, R. & QUAYLE, E. (2002) Knowing your own mind . The Psychologist, 15, 14–16 .
50.
McCABE, R. , RODER-WANNER, U.-U. , HOFFMANN, K. & PRIEBE, S. (1999) Therapeutic relationships and quality of life: association of two subjective constructs in schizophrenia patients . International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 45, 276–283 .
51.
MOORE, E. & KUIPERS, L. (1992) Behavioural correlates of expressed emotion in sta.–patient interactions . Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 27, 298–303 .
52.
MOORE, E. , KUIPERS, L. & BALL, R. (1992) Sta.–patient relationships in the care of the long-term adult mentally ill . Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 27, 28–34 .
53.
NEALE, M.S. & ROSENHECK, R.A. (1995) Therapeutic alliance and outcome in a VA intensive case management programme . Psychiatric Services, 46, 719–721 .
54.
PRIEBE, S. (2000) Ensuring and improving quality in community mental health care . International Review of Psychiatry, 12, 226–232 .
55.
PRIEBE, S. & GRUYTERS, T. (1993) The role of the helping alliance in psychiatric community care: a prospective study . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 181, 552–557 .
56.
PRIEBE, S. & GRUYTERS, T. (1995) Patients’ assessment of treatment predicting outcome . Schizophrenia Bulletin, 21, 87–94 .
57.
PRIEBE, S. & GRUYTERS, T. (1999) A pilot trial of treatment changes according to schizophrenic patients’ wishes . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 187, 441–443 .
58.
ROSENBERG, R.C. & KESSELMAN, M. (1993) The therapeutic alliance and the psychiatric emergency room . Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44, 79–80 .
59.
SALVIO, M. , BEUTLER, L.E. , WOOD, J.M. & ENGLE, D. (1992) The strength of the therapeutic alliance in three treatments for depression . Psychotherapy Research, 2, 31–36 .
60.
SOLOMON, P. & DRAINE, J. (1994) Satisfaction with mental health treatment in a randomized trial of consumer case management . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 182, 179–184 .
61.
SOLOMON, P. , DRAINE, J. & DELANEY, M.A. (1995) The working alliance and consumer case management . Journal of Mental Health Administration, 22, 126–134 .
62.
STANTON, A.H. , GUNDERSON, J.G. , KNAPP, P.H. , FRANK, A.F. , VANNICELLI, M.L. , SCHNITZER, R. & ROSENTHAL, R. (1984) E.ects of psychotherapy in schizophrenia: I. Design and implementation of a controlled study . Schizophrenia Bulletin, 10, 520–583 .
63.
STARK, F.M. (1994) The therapist–patient relationship with schizophrenic patients . Behaviour Change, 11, 234–241 .
64.
STARK, F.M. , LEWANDOWSKI, G. & BUCHKREMER, G. (1992) Therapist–patient relationship as a predictor of the course of schizophrenic illness . European Psychiatry, 7, 161–169 .
65.
SVENSSON, B. & HANSSON, L. (1999a) Relationships among patient and therapist ratings of therapeutic alliance and patient assessments of therapeutic process: a study of cognitive therapy with long-term mentally ill patients . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 187, 580–586 .
66.
SVENSSON, B. & HANSSON, L. (1999b) Therapeutic alliance in cognitive therapy for schizophrenic and other long-term mentally ill patients: development and relationship to outcome in an in-patient treatment programme . Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 99, 281–287 .
67.
TATTAN, T. & TARRIER, N. (2000) The expressed emotion of case managers of the seriously mentally ill: the in.uence of expressed emotion on clinical outcomes . Psychological Medicine, 30, 195–204 .
68.
THORNICROFT, G. (1991) The concept of case management for long-term mental illness . International Review of Psychiatry, 3, 125–132 .
69.
TICHENOR, V. & HILL, C.E. (1989) A comparison of six measures of working alliance . Psychotherapy, 26, 195–199 .
70.
TYRER, P. , MANLEY, C. , VAN HORN, E. , LEDDY, D. & UKOUMUNNE, O.C. (2000) Personality abnormality in severe mental illness and its in.uence on outcome of intensive and standard case management: a randomised controlled trial . European Psychiatry, 15, 7–10 .
71.
VAUGHN, C. & LEFF, J. (1976) The measurement of expressed emotion in the families of psychiatric patients . British Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 15, 157–165 .
72.
WEISS, M. , GASTON, L. , PROPST, A. , WISEBORD, S. & ZICHERMAN, V. (1997) The role of the alliance in the pharmalogic treatment of depression . Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 58, 196–204 .
