Restricted accessOtherFirst published online 2004-03
The Development of the Therapeutic Community in Correctional Establishments: A Comparative Retrospective Account of the ‘DEMOCRATIC’ Maxwell Jones TC and the Hierarchical Concept-Based TC in Prison
Background: The correction-based therapeutic community (TC) is one of the most described treatment modalities for (substance abusing) incarcerated offenders. The origins and development of the therapeutic community have been traced back to two independent traditions: the American hierarchical conceptbased TC and the British democratic Maxwell Jones-type TC. Both branches have developed independently, targeting different people and tackling diverse problems.
Aims: To demonstrate that there are clear and undeniable similarities between the ‘two’ prison-based therapeutic communities.
Method: A comparative historical review of the literature and a critical discussion and comparison.
Results: The links between the democratic and hierarchical therapeutic communities are summarised under five headings: social learning and behavioural modification; permissiveness and modelling; democracy and hierarchy; communalism and community as method; reality testing and ‘acting as if ’.
Conclusions: The ‘two’ correction-based therapeutic communities are on converging pathways. Far from being oppositional models, they can be regarded as being complementary.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BARTOLLAS, C. (1981) Introduction to Corrections. New York: Harper & Row .
2.
BERNE, E. (1972) Games People Play: The Psychology of Human Relationships. Ringwood: Harmondsworth: Penguin Books .
3.
BRACKE, R. (1996) De encounter, het hart van de therapeutische gemeenschap [The encounter, the heart of the therapeutic community]. In De Nieuwe Therapeutische Gemeenschap (ed. E. Broekaert, R. Bracke, D. Calle, A. Cogo, G. van der Straeten & H. Bradt). Leuven: Garant .
4.
BRATTER, T.E., COLLABOLLETTA, E.A., FOSSBENDER, A.J., PENNACHIA, M. & RUBEL, J. (1985) The American self-help residential therapeutic community. In Alcoholism and Substance Abuse: Strategies for Clinical Intervention (ed. T.E. Bratter & G.G. Forrest). New York: The Free Press .
5.
BRIGGS, D.L. (1963) Convicted felons as social therapists . Corrective Psychiatry and Journal of Social Therapy, 9, 122–128 .
6.
BRIGGS, D.L. (1972) Chino, California. In Dealing with Deviants (ed. S. Whiteley, D. Briggs & M. Turner). London: Hogarth Press .
7.
BRIGGS, D.L. (1975) In Place of Prison. London: Morris Temple Smith .
8.
BRIGGS, D.L. (1980) An enclave of freedom: starting a community at Chino. In Therapeutic Communities in Corrections (ed. H. Toch). New York: Praeger .
9.
BRIGGS, D.L. (1993) Record of a Friendship: A Memoir of Maxwell Jones. San Francisco, CA: Special Collections. The Library of the University of California, San Francisco .
10.
BRIGGS, D.L. (2000) In prison: transitional therapeutic communities. Planned Environment Therapy Trust (PETT). Online publication. Available at http://www.pettarchiv.org.uk/pubs-dbriggs-inprison1.pdf (accessed 26 April 2002).
11.
BROEKAERT, E. & VAN DER STRAETEN, G. (1997) Histoire, philosophie et development de la Communaute Therapeutique en Europe. Psychotropes: Revue International des Toxicomanies, 3, 7–23.
12.
BROEKAERT, E., KOOYMAN, M. & OTTENBERG, D. (1998) The ‘new’ drug-free therapeutic community: challenging encounter of classic and open therapeutic communities . Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 15, 595–597 .
13.
BROEKAERT, E., VANDERPLASSCHEN, W., TEMMERMAN, I., OTTENBERG, D.J. & KAPLAN, C. (2000) Retrospective study of similarities and relations between American drug-free and European therapeutic communities for children and adults . Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 32, 407–417 .
14.
BROEKAERT, E., VAN DER STRAETEN, G., D’OOSTERLINCK, F. & KOOYMAN, M. (1999) The therapeutic community for ex-addicts: a view from Europe . Therapeutic Communities: The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organisations, 20, 255–265 .
15.
BROEKAERT, E., VANDEVELDE, S., SCHUYTEN, G.ERAUW, K. & BRACKE, R. (2004) Evolution of encounter group methods in therapeutic communities for substance abusers . Addictive Behaviors, 29, 231–231 .
16.
BUGENTAL, J. (1967) Challenges of Humanistic Psychology. New York: McGraw-Hill .
17.
CLARK, D.H. (1965) The therapeutic community: concept, practice and future . British Journal of Psychiatry, 111, 947–954 .
18.
CLARK, D.H. (1977) The therapeutic community . British Journal of Psychiatry, 131, 553–564 .
19.
COX, J.L. (1998) Re.ections on contemporary community psychiatry: where is the therapy? Therapeutic Communities: The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organisations, 19, 3–14 .
20.
CULLEN, E. (1997) Can a prison be a therapeutic community? The Grendon template. In Therapeutic Communities for Oenders (ed. E. Cullen, L. Jones & W. Woodward). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons .
21.
DE LEON, G. (1997) Therapeutic communities: is there an essential model? In Community as Method: Therapeutic communities for Special Populations and Special Settings (ed. G. de Leon). Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group .
22.
DE LEON, G. (2000) The Therapeutic Community: Theory, Model and Method. New York: Springer Publishing Company .
23.
DE LEON, G., MELNICK, G., THOMAS, G., KRESSEL, D. & WEXLER, H.K. (2000) Motivation for treatment in a prison-based therapeutic community . American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 26, 33–46 .
24.
EMCDDA (2001) An Overview Study: Assistance to Drug Users in European Union Prisons. Abriged version. Lisboa: EMCDDA .
25.
FARABEE, D., PRENDERGAST, M., CARIER, J., WEXLER, H., KNIGHT, K. & ANGLIN, M.D. (1999) Barriers to implementing e.ective correctional drug treatment programs . Prison Journal, 79, 150–162 .
26.
FIELD, G. (1989) A study of the e.ects of intensive treatment on reducing the criminal recidivism of addicted o.enders . Federal Probation, 53, 51–56 .
27.
FRYE, R.V. (2001) A therapeutic bridge. Unpublished manuscript.
28.
GARFIELD, H.M. (1978) The Synanon Religion. Marshall, CA: Synanon Foundation .
29.
GATES, E.M. & BOURDETTE, P.C. (1975) The Synanon alternative to the criminal justice system . Journal of Drug Issues, 5, 232–241 .
30.
GENDERS, E. & PLAYER, E. (1995) Grendon: A Study of a Therapeutic Prison. Oxford: Clarendon Press .
31.
GLASER, F. (1977) The Origins of the Drug-Free Therapeutic Community: A Retrospective History. New York: Daytop Village Foundation .
32.
GLIDER, P., MULLEN, R., HERBST, D., DAVIS, C. & FLEISHMAN, B. (1997) Substance abuse treatment in a jail setting: a therapeutic community model. In Community as Method: Therapeutic Communities for Special Populations and Special Settings (ed. G. de Leon). Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group .
33.
GRANT, J.D. & GRANT, M.Q. (1959) A group dynamics approach to the treatment of nonconformists in the navy . Annals of American Academy of Political and Social Science, 322, 126–135 .
34.
HARRISON, T. & CLARK, D. (1992) The North.eld Experiments . British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 698–708 .
35.
HILLER, M.L., KNIGHT, K. & SIMPSON, D. (1999) Prison-based substance abuse treatment, residential aftercare and recidivism . Addiction, 94, 833–842 .
36.
INCIARDI, J.A., MARTIN, S.S. & SURRATT, H.L. (2001) Therapeutic communities in prisons and work release: e.ective modalities for drug-involved o.enders. In Therapeutic Communities for the Treatment of Drug Users (ed. B. Rawlings & R. Yates). London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers .
37.
INCIARDI, J.A., MARTIN, S.S., BUTZIN, C.A., HOOPER, R.A. & HARRISON, L.D. (1997) An e.ective model of prison-based treatment for drug-involved o.enders . Journal of Drug Issues, 27, 261–278 .
38.
JACKSON, P. (1997) The rise and fall of Synanon. The Daily News Current. Online publication. Available at http://www.morrock.com/synanon.htm#synanon3 (accessed 26 April 2002).
39.
JONES, M. (1952) Social Psychiatry: A Study of Therapeutic Communities. London: Tavistock Publications .
40.
JONES, M. (1962) Social Psychiatry in the Community, in Hospitals, and in Prisons. Spring.eld, IL: Charles C. Thomas .
41.
JONES, M. (1968) Beyond the Therapeutic Community: Social Learning and Social Psychiatry. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
42.
JONES, M. (1976) Why open systems? A personal account. In The Changing Mental Health Scene (ed. R. Hirschowitz & B. Levy). New York: Spectrum Publications .
43.
JONES, M. (1979a) Therapeutic communities, old and new . American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 6, 137–149 .
44.
JONES, M. (1979b) The therapeutic community, social learning and social change. In Therapeutic Communities, Reections and Progress (ed. R.D. Hinshelwood & N. Manning). London: Routledge & Kegan Paul .
45.
JONES, M. (1980) Desirable features of a therapeutic community in prison. In Therapeutic Communities in Corrections (ed. H. Toch). New York: Praeger .
46.
JONES, M. (1982) The Process of Change. Boston, MA: Routlegde & Kegan Paul .
47.
JONES, M. (1984a) Why two therapeutic communities? Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 16, 23–26 .
48.
JONES, M. (1984b) The two therapeutic communities: a review. In Proceedings of the Eighth World Conference of Therapeutic Communities. Rome, Italy: Centro Italiano di Solidarieta .
49.
KENNARD, D. (1998a) An Introduction to Therapeutic Communities. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers .
50.
KENNARD, D. (1998b) Therapeutic communities are back – and there is something a little di.erent about them . Therapeutic Communities: The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organisations, 19, 323–329 .
51.
KNIGHT, K., HILLER, M.L. & SIMPSON, D.D. (1999) Evaluating corrections-based treatment for the drug-abusing criminal o.ender . Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 31, 299–304 .
52.
KOOYMAN, M. (1993) The Therapeutic Community for Addicts: Intimacy, Parent Involvement and Treatment Success. Lisse: Swets & Zeitlinger .
53.
LEAN, G. (1985) On the Tail of a Comet: The Life of Frank Buchman. Colorado Springs, CO: Helmers & Howard .
54.
LEES, J., MANNING, N. & RAWLINGS, B. (1999) Therapeutic Community E.ectiveness: A Systematic International Review of Therapeutic Community Treatment for People with Personality Disorders and Mentally Disordered Oenders. York: York Publishing Services .
55.
LIPTON, D.S. (1994) The correctional opportunity: pathways to drug treatment for o.enders . Journal of Drug Issues, 24, 331–349 .
LIPTON, D.S. (1998b) Therapeutic community treatment programming in corrections . Psychology Crime and Law, 4, 213–263 .
58.
LOCKWOOD, D., INCIARDI, J., BUTZIN, C.A. & HOOPER, R.M. (1997) The therapeutic community continuum in corrections. In Community as Method: Therapeutic Communities for Special Populations and Special Settings (ed. G. de Leon). Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group .
59.
LURIGIO, A.J. (2000) Drug treatment availability and e.ectiveness: studies of the general and criminal justice populations . Criminal Justice and Behavior, 27, 495–528 .
60.
MCCORKLE, L.W., ELIAS, A. & BIXBY, F.L. (1958) The Highfields Story: An Experimental Treatment Project for Youthful Oenders. New York: Henry Holt & Company .
61.
MARTIN, S.S. & BUTZIN, C.A. (1999) Three-year outcomes of therapeutic community treatment for druginvolved o.enders in Delaware . Prison Journal, 79, 294–320 .
62.
MARTIN, S.S., BUTZIN, C.A. & INCIARDI, J.A. (1995) Assessment of a multistage therapeutic community for drug-involved o.enders . Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 27, 109–116 .
63.
MASLOW, A.H. (1967) Synanon and eupsychia . Journal of Humanistic Psychology, 7, 28–35 .
64.
MOWRER, O.H. (1976) Therapeutic groups and communities in retrospect and prospect. In Proceedings of the First World Conference on Therapeutic Communities. Katrineholm, Sweden: Vallmotorp Foundation .
65.
MURTO, K. (1991a) Towards the Well Functioning Community. Jyvaskyla Studies in Education, Psychology and Social Research Nr. 79. Jyvaskyla: University of Jyvaskyla .
66.
MURTO, K. (1991b) Maxwell Jones as an organisation developer . International Journal of Therapeutic Communities, 12, 137–140 .
67.
O’BRIEN, W.B. (1993) You Can’t Do It Alone. New York: Simon & Schuster .
68.
PALMER, T.B. (1971) California’s community treatment program for delinquent adolescents . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 8, 74–92 .
69.
RAPOPORT, R.N. (1960) Community as a Doctor: New Perspectives on a Therapeutic Community. London: Tavistock Publications .
70.
RAPOPORT, R.N. & RAPOPORT, R.S. (1959) Permissiveness and treatment in a therapeutic community . Psychiatry, 22, 57–64 .
71.
RAWLINGS, B. (1999a) Therapeutic communities in prisons: a research review . Therapeutic Communities: The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organisations, 20, 177–193 .
72.
RAWLINGS, B. (1999b) Therapeutic communities in prisons . Policy and Politics, 27, 97–111 .
73.
RAWLINGS, B. & YATES, R. (2001) Introduction. In Therapeutic Communities for the Treatment of Drug Users (ed. B. Rawlings & R. Yates). London & Philadelphia, PA: Jessica Kingsley Publishers .
74.
ROBERTS, J. (1997) History of the therapeutic community. In Therapeutic Communities for Oenders (ed. E. Cullen, L. Jones & W. Woodward). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons .
75.
ROBERTSON, G. & GUNN, J. (1987) A ten-year follow-up of men discharged from Grendon prison . British Journal of Psychiatry, 151, 674–678 .
76.
ROSZAK, T.H. (1978) Person/Planet: The Creative Disintegration of Industrialized Society. New York: Anchor Press–Doubleday .
77.
SCUDDER, K. (1952) Prisoners are People. Garden City, NY: Doubleday .
78.
STUDT, E., MESSINGER, S. & WILSON, T.P. (1968) C-Unit: Search for Community in Prison. New York: Russell Sage .
79.
SUGARMAN, B. (1984) Towards a new, common model of the therapeutic community: structural components, learning processes and outcomes . International Journal of Therapeutic Communities, 5, 77–98 .
80.
SULLIVAN, C., GRANT, M.O. & GRANT, J.D. (1957) The development of interpersonal maturity applications to delinquency . Psychiatry, 20, 373–385 .
81.
SWARTZ, J.A., LURIGIO, A.J. & SLOMKA, S.A. (1996) The impact of IMPACT: an assessment of the e.ectiveness of a jail-based treatment program . Crime and Delinquency, 42, 553–573 .
82.
TURNBULL, P.J. & WEBSTER, R. (1998) Demand reduction activities in the criminal justice system in the European Union . Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy, 5, 177–184 .
83.
VANDEVELDE, S. & BROEKAERT, E. (2003) Maxwell Jones, Harold Bridger, Dennie Briggs and the ‘two’ therapeutic communities: an interview with Juan Pares y Plans (Corelli) about the development of the Centro Italiano di Solidarieta` (CeIS). Therapeutic Communities: The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organisations, 24, 85–104.
84.
WEXLER, H.K. (1995) The success of therapeutic communities for substance abusers in American prisons . Journal of Psychoactive Drugs, 2, 57–66 .
85.
WEXLER, H. (1997) Therapeutic communities in American prisons. In Therapeutic Communities for Oenders (ed. E. Cullen, L. Jones & W. Woodward). Chichester: John Wiley & Sons .
86.
WEXLER, H.K., BLACKMORE, J. & LIPTON, D.S. (1991) Project REFORM: developing a drug abuse treatment strategy for corrections . Journal of Drug Issues, 21, 473–495 .
87.
WEXLER, H.K., DE LEON, G., THOMAS, G., KRESSEL, D. & PETERS, J. (1999) Amity prison TC evaluation: reincarcerating outcomes . Criminal Justice and Behavior, 26, 147–167 .
88.
WILMER, H.A. (1965) The role of the rat in the prison . Federal Probation, 29, 44–49 .
89.
WILMER, H.A. (1966) Free association of people: observations on the changing constellations in large group meetings . International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 12, 44–51 .
90.
WILSON, F.W. (1978) Therapeutic Community: An Innovative Treatment Approach . Thirty-second International Congress on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence, Warsaw, Poland, 3–8 September.
91.
YABLONSKY, L. (1965) Synanon: The Tunnel Back. New York: MacMillan .
92.
YEE, M. (1997) Charles Dederich, founder of cult-like religious group Synanon, dies at 83. Online publication. Available at http://positiveatheism.org/rw/dederich.htm (accessed 26 April 2002).
93.
ZIMMER, D. & WIDMER, A. (1981) Democratically or Hierarchically Structured Therapeutic Communities for Heroin Addicts? Proceedings of the 6th World Conference of Therapeutic Communities, Manilla.
