Family unification received public and political attention following recent global immigration crises, though less within health research. In Israel, under the Family Reunification Order, about 20,000 Palestinian women from the Occupied Palestinian Territories are denied residency and the right to universal health care services (HSC) after marrying Palestinian citizens and moving to Israel. To better understand the relationship between lacking residency and barriers to accessing HCS, we conducted in-depth interviews with 21 Palestinian women (ages 22–59) denied family unification. Our findings revealed that in addition to hindering access to HCS, lacking residency intersects with other political, social, and economic determinants of these women’s health and disrupts normal family life. Lacking residency intensifies poverty (via private health insurance and legal fees, permit extensions) and leads to family separations and risky crossings at military checkpoints into the West Bank for medical treatment. Restrictions on freedom of movement engender fear of deportation and precarity. Denial of residency also exacerbates gender inequality (increased dependence on husbands) and can endanger child custody when mothers’ lack of residency passes to children, violating children’s basic rights. Allowing family unification to Palestinian women would remove barriers to HCS access, allow normal family life, and permit social integration.
GroteJ.Family Reunification of Third-country Nationals in Germany. Focussed Study by the German National Contact Point for the European Migration Network (EMN).
Nuremberg, Germany:
Research Centre of the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees; 2017.
5.
United Nations. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), Article 16 adopted December 10, 1948, G.A. Res. 217A(III), U.N. Doc. A/810 at 711948.
6.
United Nations. The Convention on the Nationality of Married Women. New York City, NY: United Nations General Assembly; 1957.
7.
BerkovitchN.From Motherhood to Citizenship: Women’s Rights and International Organizations.
Baltimore, MD:
Jones Hopkins University Press; 1999.
8.
ShyamR.UN convention on the nationality of married women. Int J Multidiscip Res Dev. 2015;
2(3):719–720.
9.
United Nations. Women, Nationality and Citizenship.
New York, NY:
Department of Advancement of Women and Department of Economic and Social Rights; 2003. ISBN 92-1-1302110.
10.
Human Rights Watch. Lebanon: Laws Discriminate Against Women: Pass Optional Civil Code; Reform Religious Laws, Courts.
New York City, NY:
Human Rights Watch; 2015.
11.
SaidiM.Lebanon’s Sexist Citizenship Law Hurts Mothers and Babies.
New York City, NY:
Aljazeera America; 2015.
12.
TheodorouA.27 Countries Limit a Woman’s Ability to Pass Citizenship to Her Child or Spouse. Washington, DC: Pew Research Center; 2014.
13.
CastanedaHHolmesSMMadrigalDSYoungMEBeyelerNQuesadaJ.Immigration as a social determinant of health.Ann Rev Public Health. 2015;
36:375–392.
14.
ZimmermanCKissLHossainM.Migration and health: a framework for 21st century policy-making.PLoS Med. 2011;
8(5):e1001034.
15.
AsgaryRSegarN.Barriers to health care access among refugee asylum seekers.J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2011;
22(2):506–522.
16.
PapademetriouDG.The Global Struggle With Illegal Migration: No End in Sight.
Washington, DC:
Migration Policy Institute; 2005.
17.
World Bank Group. Immigration and Development: A Role for the World Bank Group.
Washington, DC:
Worl Bank; 2016.
18.
BiswasDToebesBHjernAAscherHNorredamM.Access to health care for undocumented migrants from a human rights perspective: a comparative study of Denmark, Sweden, and The Netherlands.Health Hum Rights. 2012;
14(2):49–60.
19.
GritKden OtterJJSpreijA.Access to health care for undocumented migrants: a comparative policy analysis of England and the Netherlands.J Health Polit Policy Law. 2012;
37(1):37–67.
United Nations. Trends in International Migration.
New York City, NY:
Department of Economic and Social Affairs; 2015.
22.
MagalhaesLCarrascoCGastaldoD.Undocumented migrants in Canada: a scope literature review on health, access to services, and working conditions.J Immigr Minor Health. 2010;
12(1):132–151.
23.
KontosM. Between integration and exclusion: migrant women in European labor markets. Feature. 2011.
24.
HackerKAniesMFolbBLZallmanL.Barriers to health care for undocumented immigrants: a literature review.Risk Manag Healthc Policy. 2015;
8:175–183.
25.
Da LombaS.Vulnerability, irregular migrants’ health-related rights and the European Court of Human Rights.Eur J Health Law. 2014;
21(4):339–364.
26.
FleischmanYWillenSSDavidovitchNMorZ.Migration as a social determinant of health for irregular migrants: Israel as case study.Soc Sci Med. 2015;
147:89–97.
International Organization for Migration. Migration Health: Better Health for All in Europe.
Brussels, Belgium:
Regional Liaison and Co-ordination Office to the European Union; 2009.
29.
DaviesAABastenAFrattiniC.Migration: a social determinant of the health of migrants. Eurohealth. 2009;
16(1):10–12.
30.
FlegarVDalliMToebesB.Access to preventive health care for undocumented migrants: a comparative study of Germany, The Netherlands and Spain from a human rights perspective. Laws. 2016;
5(9):1–22.
31.
NandiAGaleaSLopezGNandiVStrongaroneSOmpadDC.Access to and use of health services among undocumented Mexican immigrants in a US urban area.Am J Public Health. 2008;
98(11):2011–2020.
32.
NorredamM.Migrants’ access to healthcare.Dan Med Bull. 2011;
58(10):B4339.
33.
FlegarV.The principle of non-discrimination: an empty promise for the preventive health care of asylum seekers and undocumented migrants?Gron J Int Law. 2015;
3(2):80–95.
34.
EdwardJ.Undocumented immigrants and access to health care: making a case for policy reform.Policy Polit Nurs Pract. 2014;
15(1–2):5–14.
35.
State of Israel. National Health Insurance; 1994.
36.
State of Israel. Social Security Law; 1995.
37.
Daoud N, Soskolne V, Mindell JS, Roth MA, Manor O. Ethnic inequalities in health between Arabs and Jews in Israel: the relative contribution of individual-level factors and the living environment. International Journal of Public Health. 2018;63:313–23.
38.
ClarfieldAMManorONunGBet al. Health and health care in Israel: an introduction. Lancet. 2017.
39.
SolbergK.Gaza’s health and humanitarian crisis.Lancet. 2014;
384(9941):389–390.
40.
GiacamanRKhatibRShabanehLet al.
Health status and health services in the occupied Palestinian territory.Lancet. 2009;
373(9666):837–849.
Adalah-The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel. Adalah Case Review: The Israeli Supreme Court’s Decision in the Citizenship and Family Unification Law Case; 2012.
43.
The Inter-Menesterial Committee. The Inter-Ministerial Committee to Examine the Health and Social Rights for the Non-Status Persons in Israel. Jerusalem, Israel (Hebrew); 2011.
44.
GlaserBGStraussAL.The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research.
New York, NY:
Aldine de Gruyter; 1967.
45.
WoodwardAHowardNWolffersI.Health and access to care for undocumented migrants living in the European Union: a scoping review.Health Policy Plan. 2014;
29(7):818–830.
46.
López-SandersL.Changing the navigator’s course: how the increasing rationalization of healthcare influences access for undocumented immigrants under the Affordable Care Act.Soc Sci Med. 2017;
178:46–54.
47.
RousseauCLaurin-LamotheARummensJAMeloniFSteinmetzNAlvarezF.Uninsured immigrant and refugee children presenting to Canadian paediatric emergency departments: disparities in help-seeking and service delivery.Paediatr Child Health. 2013;
18(9):465–469.
48.
United Nations Committee on Economic Social and Cultural Rights. General Comment 14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health, UN Document E/C.12/2000/4. Geneva, Switzerland: United Nations; 2000.
United Nations. Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), adopted December 10, 1948, G.A. Res. 217A(III), U.N. Doc. A/810 at 71 (1948); 1948.
52.
CohenR.Social Residency. Tel-Aviv, Israel: Physicians for Human Rights; 2011.
53.
United Nations. Convention on the Rights of the Child; 1989.
54.
DaoudNShoham-VardiIUrquiaMLO’CampoP.Polygamy and poor mental health among Arab Bedouin women: do socioeconomic position and social support matter?Ethn Health. 2014;
19(4):385–405.
55.
BernhardJGoldringLYoungJBerinsteinCWilsonB.Living with precarious legal status in Canada: implications for the well-being of children and families.Refuge. 2007;
24(2):101–114.
