“With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility”: Democracy,the Secretary of State for Health and Blame Shifting Within the English National Health Service
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online July, 2018
“With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility”: Democracy,the Secretary of State for Health and Blame Shifting Within the English National Health Service
The English National Health Service (NHS) has suffered from a democratic deficit since its inception. Democratic accountability was to be through ministers to Parliament, but ministerial control over and responsibility for the NHS were regarded as myths. Reorganizations and management and market reforms, in the neoliberal era, have centralized power within the NHS. However, successive governments have sought to reduce their responsibility for health care through institutional depoliticization, to shift blame, facilitated through legal changes. New Labour’s creation of the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) and Monitor were somewhat successful in reducing ministerial culpability regarding health technology regulation and foundation trusts, respectively. The Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition created NHS England to reduce ministerial culpability for health care more generally. This is pertinent as the NHS is currently being undermined by inadequate funding and privatization. However, the public has not shifted from blaming the government to blaming NHS England. This indicates limits to the capacity of law to legitimize changes to social relations. While market reforms were justified on the basis of empowering patients, I argue that addressing the democratic deficit is a preferable means of achieving this goal.
HarveyD.The Enigma of Capital and the Crises of Capitalism.
London, England:
Profile Books Limited; 2010.
4.
ChariA.A Political Economy of the Senses: Neo-liberalism, Reification, Critique.
Chichester, England:
Columbia University Press; 2015.
5.
WoolhandlerSHimmelsteinD.Competition in a publicly funded healthcare system.Br Med J. 2007;
335:1126–1129.
6.
NavarroV.Medicine Under Capitalism.
New York, NY:
Prodist; 1976.
7.
KlareK.The public/private distinction in labour law.Univ Pa Law Rev. 1982;
130:1358–1422.
8.
JessopB.Repoliticising depoliticisation: theoretical preliminaries on some responses to the American fiscal and Eurozone debt crises. In: FlindersMWoodM, eds. Tracing the Political: Depoliticisation, Governance and the State.
Bristol, England:
Policy Press; 2015.
9.
FlindersMBullerJ. Depoliticisation, democracy and arena shifting. Paper presented at: SCANCOR/SOG Conference; 2005; Stanford, CA.
10.
FawcettPMarshD.Depoliticisation, governance and political participation. Policy Polit. 2014;
42(2):171–188.
11.
LongleyD.Public Law and Health Service Accountability.
Buckingham, England:
Open University Press; 1993.
12.
DiamondP.New labour, politicisation and depoliticisation: the delivery agenda in public services 1997-2007.Br Polit. 2015;
10(4):429–453.
HigginsJ.The Business of Medicine: Private Health Care in Britain.
Basingstoke, England:
Macmillan; 1988.
15.
ThompsonEP.The moral economy of the English crowd in the eighteenth century.Past Present. 1971;
50(1):76–136.
16.
HamC.Health Policy in Britain: 5th Edition.
Basingstoke, England:
Palgrave; 2004.
17.
MackenzieW.Power and Responsibility in Healthcare.
London, England:
Nuffield Trust; 1979.
18.
National Health Service Act (1977).
19.
NewdickC.Who Should We Treat?: Rights, Rationing and Resources in the NHS: 2nd Edition.
Oxford, England:
Oxford University Press; 2005.
20.
KleinR.The eternal triangle: sixty years of the centre-periphery relationship in the National Health Service.Soc Policy Adm. 2010;
44(3):285–304.
21.
MillerPRoseN.Governing the Present: Administering Economic, Social and Personal Life.
Cambridge, England:
Policy Press; 2008.
22.
MaybinJAddicottRDixonAStoreyJ.Accountability in the NHS: Implications of the Government’s Reform Programme.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2011.
23.
FootM.Aneurin Bevan 1945-1960.
St Albans, England:
Granada; 1982.
24.
CooperLCooteADaviesAJacksonC.Voices Off: Tackling the Democratic Deficit in Health.
London, England:
Institute for Public Policy Research; 1995.
25.
JenkinsS.A Short History of England.
London, England:
Profile Books; 2011.
26.
EdwardsB.The National Health Service: A Manager’s Tale 1946-1992.
London, England:
Nuffield Trust; 1993.
27.
OwenD.In Sickness and in Health: The Politics of Medicine.
London, England:
Quartet; 1976.
28.
MerrisonA.Report of the Royal Commission on the National Health Service, Cmnd 7615.
London, England:
HMSO; 1979.
29.
HuttonW.New Life for Health: The Commission on the NHS Chaired by Will Hutton.
London, England:
Vintage; 2000.
30.
DayPKleinR.Accountability: Five Public Services.
London, England:
Tavistock; 1987.
31.
Health Authorities Act (1995).
32.
HoggC.Citizens, Consumers and the NHS: Capturing Voices.
Basingstoke, England:
Palgrave; 2009.
33.
HoggC.The Public and the NHS.
London, England:
Association of Community Health Councils for England and Wales; 1986.
34.
FilipponJGiovanellaLKonderMPollockA.Liberalizing the English National Health Service: background and risks to healthcare entitlement. Cad Saude Publica. 2016;
32(8):1–14.
35.
GriffithsR.Report on the NHS Management Inquiry.
London, England:
HMSO; 1983.
36.
TimminsN.History and analysis. In: TimminsNDaviesE, eds. Glaziers and Window Breakers: The role of the Secretary of State for Health in Their Own Words.
London, England:
Health Foundation; 2015.
37.
MohanJ.A National Health Service? The Restructuring of Healthcare in Britain Since 1979.
Basingstoke, England:
Macmillan; 1995.
38.
MerrySE.Measuring the world: indicators, human rights and global governance.Curr Anthropol. 2011;
52(3):83–95.
39.
EdwardsBFallM.The Executive Years of the NHS: The England Account 1985-2003.
Abingdon, England:
Radcliffe; 2005.
40.
DayPKleinR.Steering But Not Rowing? The Transformation of the Department of Health.
Bristol, England:
Policy Press; 1997.
41.
JenkinsS.Accountable to None: The Tory Nationalisation of Britain.
London, England:
Hamish Hamilton; 1995.
42.
National Health Service and Community Care Act (1990).
43.
Regional and District Health Authorities (Membership and Procedure) Regulations, SI 1990/1331.
44.
DaviesA.Accountability: A Public Law Analysis of Government by Contract.
Oxford, England:
Oxford University Press; 2001.
45.
GoddardMMannionRFergusonB.Contracting in the NHS: Purpose, Process and Policy: Discussion Paper 156.
York, England:
Centre for Health Economics; 1997.
46.
AllenP.A socio-legal and economic analysis of contracting in the NHS internal market using a case study of contracting for district nursing.Soc Sci Med. 2002;
54(2):255–266.
47.
ListerJ.In Defiance of the evidence: conservatives threaten to reform away England’s National Health Service.Int J Health Serv. 2012;
42(1):137–155.
48.
ListerJ.Health Policy Reform: Driving the Wrong Way? A Critical Guide to the Global ‘Health Reform’ industry.
London, England:
Middlesex University Press; 2007.
49.
PollockALeysCPriceDRowlandDGnaniS.NHS PLC: The Privatisation of Our Healthcare.
London, England:
Verso; 2005.
50.
JenkinsS.Thatcher and Sons: A Revolution in Three Acts.
London, England:
Penguin; 2006.
51.
Health Act (1999).
52.
TimminsN.Never Again? The Story of the Health and Social Care Act 2012.
London, England:
The Kings Fund and the Institute for Government; 2012.
53.
PatonC.Cheques and checks: new labour’s record on the NHS. In: PowellM, ed. Evaluating New Labour’s Welfare Reforms.
Bristol, England:
Polity Press; 2002.
54.
National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Act (2002).
55.
BevanGHoodC.Have targets improved performance in the English NHS?Br Med J. 2006;
332:419–422.
56.
Department of Health. NHS Plan. A Plan for Investment. A Plan for Reform.
London, England:
HMSO; 2000.
57.
DixonAAlvarez-RoseteA.Governing the NHS: Alternatives to an Independent Board.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2008.
58.
Department of Health. PCT Procurement Guide for Health Services.
London, England:
Department of Health; 2010.
59.
GreerSMatzkeM.Health Policy in the European Union. In: KuhlmannEBlankRBourgeaultILWendtC, eds. The Palgrave International Handbook of Healthcare Policy and Governance.
Basingstoke, England:
Palgrave; 2015.
60.
StevensS.A Healthy Future? In: DiamondP, ed. Public Matters: The Renewal of the Public Realm.
London, England:
Politico’s; 2007.
61.
National Institute for Clinical Excellence (Establishment and Constitution) Order 1999, SI 1999/220.
62.
Health and Social Care Act (2012).
63.
WoodM.Depoliticisation, resilience and the herceptin post-code lottery crisis: holding back the tide?Br J Polit Int Relat. 2015;
17(4):644–664.
64.
Health and Social Care (Community Health and Standards) Act (2003).
65.
Health and Social Care Act (2008).
66.
PollockAPriceDTalbot-SmithAMohanJ.NHS and the health and social care bill: end of Bevan’s vision?Br Med J. 2003;
327:982–985.
67.
Health Committee. Foundation Trusts Second Report: House of Commons Session 2002-2003.
Vol.I.
London, England:
Stationery Office; 2003.
68.
H.C. Deb. 11 October 2004, Vol. 425, Col.4WS.
69.
LewisR.Governing Foundation Trusts: A New Era for Public Accountability.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2005.
70.
MoyesWWoodJClemenceM.Nothing to Do With Me? Modernising Ministerial Accountability for Decentralised Public Services.
London, England:
Institute for Government; 2011.
71.
JohnsonA.In their own words: interviews with former secretaries of state for health. In: TimminsNDaviesE, eds. Glaziers and Window Breakers: The role of the Secretary of State for Health in their own words.
London, England:
Health Foundation; 2015.
72.
TimminsN.The Chief Executive’s Tale: Views From the Front Line of the NHS.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2016.
73.
Taylor-GoobyPStokerG.The coalition programme: a new vision for Britain or politics as usual.Polit Q. 2011;
82(1):4–15.
74.
BlythM.Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea.
Oxford, England:
Oxford University Press; 2013.
75.
McCartneyM.The State of Medicine: Keeping the Promise of the NHS.
London, England:
Pinter and Martin Limited; 2016.
76.
AdornoT.LivingstoneR, trans. Lectures on Negative Dialectics: Fragments of a Lecture Course 1965-1966.
Cambridge, England:
Polity; 2008.
77.
HolderHRobertsonRRossSBennettLGoslingJCurryN.Risk or Reward? The Changing Role of CCGs in General Practice.
London, England:
Kings Fund and Nuffield Trust; 2015.
78.
National Health Service (Procurement, Patient Choice and Competition) Regulations (No. 2) SI 2013/500.
79.
DaviesA.This time it’s for real: the Health and Social Care Act 2012.Mod Law Rev. 2013;
76(3):564–588.
80.
PeckhamS.Accountability in the UK Healthcare System: an overview.Healthc Policy. 2014;
10(Special Issue):154–162.
81.
PatonC.The Politics of Health Policy Reform in the UK: England’s Permanent Revolution.
London, England:
Palgrave; 2016.
ListerJ.Breaking the public trust. In: DavisJTallisR, eds. NHS SOS: How the NHS Was Betrayed – And How We Can Save It.
London, England:
Oneworld; 2013.
84.
LafondSCharlesworthARobertsA.A Year of Plenty? An Analysis of NHS Finances and Consultant Productivity.
London, England:
Health Foundation; 2017.
85.
PriceC. From red to black: private sector profiting as NHS crumbles. Pulse. October 27, 2016.
86.
KrachlerNGreerI.When does marketization lead to privatisation? Profit-making in English health services after the 2012 Health and Social Care Act. Soc Sci Med. 2015;
124:215–223.
87.
EnglandN.Five Year Forward View.
London, England:
NHS England; 2014.
PollockAPriceD.Duty to Care: In Defence of Universal Healthcare.
London, England:
Centre for Labour and Social Studies; 2013.
91.
FlindersMWoodM.Depoliticisation, governance and the state. Policy Polit. 2014;
42(2):135–149.
92.
HallBTimminsN. Tory challenge to Brown on NHS reform. Financial Times. October 2006.
93.
GreerSJarmanHAzorskyA.A Re-Organisation You Can See From Space: The Architecture of Power in the New NHS.
London, England:
Centre for Health and the Public Interest; 2014.
94.
H.L. Deb. 08 September 2016, Vol. 774, Col. 1201.
95.
GreerSRowlandDJarmanH.The central management of the English NHS. In: ExworthyMMannionRPowellM, eds. Dismantling the NHS? Evaluating the Impact of Health Reforms.
Bristol, England:
Policy Press; 2016.
96.
Public Administration Committee. Who’s Accountable? Relationship Between Government and Arm’s Length Bodies First Report House of Commons Session 2014-15.
London, England:
Stationery Office; 2014.
97.
CampbellD. NHS Patient Safety fears as health watchdog scraps staffing guidelines. Guardian. June 4, 2015.
98.
ToynbeeP. The NHS is on life support. Can this plan revive it? Guardian. October 23, 2014.
99.
StevensS. NHS reform is a risk worth taking
.Financial Times. July 16, 2010.
100.
GallagherP. Is Simon Stevens really the right person to run the NHS? Independent. October 24, 2013.
101.
HughesS. How the new NHS boss has helped to ruin health services on two continents. Morning Star. November 1, 2013.
102.
HughesS. The NHS money boss who used to be a lobbyist trying to privatise your healthcare. Vice. November 21, 2014.
103.
WaltersS. Revealed: Tory ‘£8bn to save the NHS’ election con. Mail on Sunday. March 19, 2016.
104.
Health Committee. Impact of the Spending Review on Health and Social Care First Report: House of Commons Session 2016-17.
London, England:
Stationery Office; 2016.
CampbellD. No extra money for NHS, Theresa May tells health chief. Guardian. October 14, 2016.
107.
GainsburyS.The Bottom Line: Understanding the NHS Deficit and Why It Won’t Go Away.
London, England:
Nuffield Trust; 2017.
108.
Committee of Public Accounts. Financial Sustainability of the NHS; 2017. HC 887 2016-17.
109.
CampbellDStewartH. NHS Chief Simon Stevens refuses to buckle under No. 10 pressure. Guardian. January 12, 2017.
110.
Committee of Public Accounts. Financial Sustainability of the NHS: 43rd Report. House of Commons Session 2016-17.
London, England:
Stationery Office; 2017.
111.
AgerholmH. Brexit: NHS England boss demands £350m-a-week promised to Leave voters. Independent. November 8, 2017.
112.
MasonR. Philip Hammond dismisses NHS chief’s call for £4bn emergency cash injection’. Guardian. November 19, 2017.
113.
EdwardsB.An Independent NHS: A Review of the Options.
London, England:
Nuffield Trust; 2007.
114.
ToynbeeP. NHS crisis: the one act of self-sacrifice that could rescue our health service. Guardian. January 17, 2017.
ToynbeePWalkerD.Cameron’s Coup: How the Tories took Britain to the Brink.
London, England:
Guardian Books; 2015.
117.
AlderwickHDunnPMcKennaHWalshNHamC.Sustainability and Transformation Plans in the NHS: How Are They Being Developed in Practice?
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2016.
118.
Committee of Public Accounts. Integrated Health and Social Care; 2017. HC 959 2016-17.
119.
CollinsB.New Care Models: Emerging Innovations in Governance and Organisational Form.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2016.
120.
HimmelsteinDWoolhandlerSHellanderI.Bleeding the Patient: The Consequences of Corporate Healthcare.
Monroe, ME:
Common Courage Press; 2003.
121.
ListerJ.The Sustainability and Transformation Plans: A Critical Assessment.
London, England:
Centre for Health and the Public Interest; 2017.
122.
PellsR. Thousands march in protest over plans for ‘unprecedented’ NHS cuts. Independent. March 4, 2017.
123.
CampbellD. Theresa May tells NHS boss he will be accountable for winter performance. Guardian. November 10, 2017.
124.
DobsonF.In their own words: interviews with former Secretaries of State for Health. In: TimminsNDaviesE, eds. Glaziers and Window Breakers: The Role of the Secretary of State for Health in Their Own Words.
London, England:
Health Foundation; 2015.
125.
JarmanH. The new NHS structure is unstable. Health Services Journal. February 13, 2014.
126.
BenbowD.The sociology of health and the NHS.Sociol Rev. 2017;
65(2):416–422.
127.
MoldA.Making the Patient Consumer: Patient Organisations and Health Consumerism in Britain.
Manchester, England:
Manchester University Press; 2015.
128.
HamCBairdBGregorySJabbalJAlderwickH.The NHS Under the Coalition Government Part One: NHS Reform.
London, England:
Kings Fund; 2015.
129.
JamesonF.Valences of the Dialectic.
London, England:
Verso; 2010.
130.
AshworthJ.Foreword. In: PhibbsT, ed. Local and National: How the Public Wants the NHS to be Both.
London, England:
Fabian Society; 2017.
131.
NandyL.Democracy at the core. In: PhibbsT, ed. Local and National: How the Public Wants the NHS to be Both.
London, England:
Fabian Society; 2017.
