An investigation is reported in which twenty-four students in electronics and physics sat two different three-hour examinations covering the same syllabus on consecutive days under conventional examination conditions. These papers were later re-marked and the results suggest that inter-paper variation is much larger than inter-marker variation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaileyA. G.BenyonJ. D. E.SimsG. D.‘Examinations and continuous assessment’, Int. J. Elect. Enging. Educ.12, 13–24, (1975).
2.
CarpenterN.‘Continuous assessment and student motivation in management studies’, Int. J. Elect. Enging. Educ.12, 5–12 (1975).
3.
McVeyP. J.“The errors in marking examination scripts in electronic engineering’, Int. J. Elect. Enging. Educ.12, 203–216, (1975).
4.
HillB. J.‘An investigation into the consistency of marking examination scripts in B.Sc. Part I in Mechanical Engineering’. Higher Education, 1, 221–227 (1972).
5.
HillB. J.‘Reliability of marking in B.Sc. examinations in engineering’, Int. J. Mech. Enging. Educ.3, 97–106, (1975).
6.
CoxR.‘Examination in higher education’, Universities quarterly, 21, 292–340, (June 1967).
7.
JamesC.‘The Consistency of Marking a Physics Examination’, Physics Education, 9, 271–274, (1974).
8.
McVeyP. J.‘The “Paper Error” of two examinations in electronic engineering’, Physics Education, 11, 58–60, (1976).
9.
WhiteW.SaltzE.‘The Measurement of Reproducibility’, Problems in Human Assessment ed. by JacksonD. N.MessickS., McGraw-Hill, New York, 241–257, (1967).
10.
ThorndikeR. L.Educational Measurement (2nd Edition), American Council on Educational Measurement (1971).
11.
StanleyJ. C.‘Reliability’ in Ref. 10 above.
12.
NuttallD. L.WillmottA. S.‘British examinations: Techniques and analysis’, National Foundation for Educational Research (1971).
13.
TaylorE. G.NuttallD. L.‘Question choice in examinations: An experiment in geography and science’, Educational Research, p. 143, (N.F.E.R.), (1974).
14.
DunstanM.R.‘Sources of variation in examination marks’, Bulletin No. 3, Educational Research Unit, University of New South Wales, reprinted in HeywoodJ.IliffeA. H. (eds.) ‘Some aspects of testing for academic performance’, Bulletin No. 1, Department of Higher Education, University of Lancaster (1966).
