In a series of interviews with second year electronics engineering students, several of them showed problems with signal properties. In a questionnaire administered to over 150 students in Belgium, these problems were further explored to verify how widespread they are. The questions asked about different aspects of signals. Students showed that they understand the concept of a phase shift, although they have problems with the direction. However, they generally have no idea what a signal with two frequencies looks like in the time domain. Bode plots also proved to be a problem for students, who are not able to construct one from a set of (dummy) measurements. Most of these issues persist after lab instruction.
LinderCJ. Understanding sound: So what is the problem?Phys Educ. 27(5): 258–264.
2.
KautzCHDevelopment of instructional materials to address student difficulties in introductory electrical engineering. In: BernardinoJorgeCarlos QuadradoJosé (eds). Proc. SEFI annual conference, Lisbon 27 September–4 October 2011, pp. 228–235.
3.
Kautz CH. Probing student understanding of basic concepts in introductory electrical engineering courses. In: Proceedings of the 2008 SEFI conference, Aalborg, 2–5 July 2008.
4.
Kautz CH. Teaching Physics to Future Engineers - Current practise, important goals and the use of discipline-based educational research, In: Presentation at the 7th International Conference on Physics Teaching in Engineering Education, Mannheim, 21–23 September 2011.
5.
KautzCHPhysics education research in an engineering context. In: McCulloughLauraHsuLeonHeronPaula (eds). AIP conference proceedings2007; Vol. 883: Syracuse, New York: AIP, pp. 22–25.
6.
Bernhard J and Carstensen A-K. Understanding phase as a key concept in physics and electrical engineering. In: SEFI Annual Conference, Leuven, September 2013, pp.16–20.
7.
Bernhard J and Carstensen A-K. Learning and teaching electrical circuit theory. Physics teaching in engineering education. Leuven, 5–7 June 2002.
8.
Maher RC. All about phase. In: 2009 IEEE 13th digital signal processing workshop and 5th IEEE signal processing education workshop. Marco Island, January 2009, pp.218–222.
9.
WageKEBuckJRWrightCHG. The signals and systems concept inventory. IEEE Trans Educ2005; 48(3): 448–461.
10.
WageKBuckJHjalmarsonM. Analyzing misconceptions using the signals and systems concept inventory and student interviews. In: 2006 IEEE 12th digital signal processing workshop & 4th IEEE signal processing education workshop, Teton National Park: IEEE, September 2006, pp. 123–128.
11.
Nelson JK, Hjalmarson M, Wage KE, et al. Students’ interpretation of the importance and difficulty of concepts in signals and systems. In: 2010 IEEE frontiers in education conference (FIE), Arlington, October 2010, pp.T3G–1–T3G–6.
12.
Scott J, Harlow A and Peter M. Threshold concepts and introductory electronics. In: AaeE conference, Sydney, 5–8 December 2010, pp.409–416.
13.
HoltonDLVermaADesigning animated simulations and web-based assessments to improve electrical engineering education. In: RussellDHaghiAK (eds). Web-based engineering education: Critical design and effective tools, Hershey: IGI Global, 2010, pp. 77–95.
14.
Carstensen A-K and Bernhard J. Bode plots not only a tool of engineers, but also a key to facilitate students learning in electrical and control engineering. Physics teaching in engineering education. Leuven: 5–7 June 2002.
15.
CarstensenA-KBernhardJ. Threshold concepts and keys to the portal of understanding. Threshold concepts within the disciplines, Rotterdam: Sense Publishers, 2007.
16.
Wage KE, Buck JR, Hjalmarson M, et al. Signals and systems assessment: Comparison of responses to multiple choice conceptual questions and open-ended final exam problems. In: 2011 digital signal processing and signal processing education meeting (DSP/SPE). Sedona, January 2011, pp.198–203.
17.
Coppens P, De Cock M and Kautz CH. Student understanding of filters in analog electronics lab courses. In: 40th SEFI annual conference:engineering education 2020: meet the future, Thessaloniki, 23–26 September 2012, pp.196–197.
18.
MartonF. Phenomenography – describing conceptions of the world around us. Instr Sci1981; 10: 177–200.
19.
Holton D, Verma A and Biswas G. Assessing student difficulties in understanding the behavior of AC and DC circuits. ASEE. Pittsburgh, 22–25 June 2008.
