The assertion that material interests underlie ethnic identification is central to instrumentalist approaches to ethnicity. However, recent approaches—circumstantialism and constructivism—refine instrumentalism, addressing posited shortcomings, including an examination of the contexts and conditions in which interests and identities are expressed and constructed. Nevertheless, these later approaches explicitly or implicitly reproduce instrumentalism’s basic material premise. Using survey data from the multiethnic country of Mauritius, I examine this premise by exploring the relationship between economic instrumentalism and ethnic identification within and across ethnic groups. I find limited support for an instrumentalist approach to ethnic identification as this approach explains only a modest amount of variance in ethnic identification and is insufficient for explaining the significant differences that emerge in the relationship between economic instrumentalism and ethnic identification across ethnic groups. Consequently, it is argued that current instrumentalist approaches provide a deficient account of ethnic identification and related group processes.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alba, Richard D.1990. Ethnic Identity: The Transformation of White America. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press .
2.
Anderson, Benedict . 1991. Imagined Communities. London: Verso Books .
3.
Banton, Michael . 1983. Racial and Ethnic Competition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
4.
Bates, R.H.1974. “Ethnic Competition and Modernization in Contemporary Africa” , Comparative Political Studies6: 457–484 .
5.
Bell, Daniel . 1975. “Ethnicity and Social Change.” In Ethnicity: Theory and Experience, edited by N. Glazer and D.P. Moynihan . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
6.
Bentley, G. Carter . 1987. “Ethnicity and Practice” , Society for Comparative Study of Society and History291: 24–55 .
7.
Bollen, Kenneth A.1989. Structural Equations with Latent Variables. New York: Wiley .
8.
Bollen, Kenneth and Rick H. Hoyle . 1990. “Perceived Cohesion: A Conceptual and Empirical Examination” , Social Forces69(2): 479–504 .
9.
Bonacich, Edna . 1972. “A Theory of Ethnic Antagonism: The Split Labor Market” , American Sociological Review37: 547–559 .
10.
Bonacich, Edna . 1973. “A Theory of Middleman Minorities” , American Sociological Review38: 583–594 .
11.
Bourdieu, Pierre . 1977. Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
12.
Brass, Paul R.1976. “Ethnicity and National Formation” , Ethnicity3: 225–241 .
13.
Brass, Paul R.1991. Ethnicity and Nationalism: Theory and Comparison. Newbury Park, CA: Sage .
14.
Brass, Paul R.1997. Theft of an Idol: Text and Context in the Representation of Collective Violence. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
15.
Brenton, Raymond . 1964. “Institutional Completeness of Ethnic Communities and the Personal Relations of Immigrants” , American Journal of Sociology70: 193–205 .
16.
Bunwaree, Shiela S.2002. “Economics, Conflicts and Interculturality in a Small Island State: The Case of Mauritius.”Polis/R.C.S.P./C.P.S.R.9: 1–19 .
17.
Carroll, Terrance and Barbara Carroll . 2000. “Accommodating Ethnic Diversity in a Modernizing Democratic State: Theory and Practice in the Case of Mauritius” , Ethnic and Racial Studies23(1): 120–142 .
18.
Chou, Chih-Ping and Peter M. Bentler . 1995. “Estimates and Tests in Structural Equation Modeling” in Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues and Applications, edited by R. Hoyle . London: Sage .
19.
Chou, Chih-Ping , Peter M. Bentler , and A. Satorra . 1991. “Scaled Test Statistics and Robust Standard Errors for Nonnormal Data in Covariance Structure Analysis: A Monte Carlo Study” , British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology44: 347–357 .
20.
Cohen, Abner . 1974. “Introduction: The Lesson of Ethnicity.” In Urban Ethnicity,edited by A. Cohen . London: Tavistock .
21.
Cornell, Stephen . 1996. “The Variable Ties that Bind: Content and Circumstance in Ethnic Processes” , Ethnic and Racial Studies19(2): 265–289 .
22.
Cornell, Stephen and Douglas Hartmann . 1998. Ethnicity and Race: Making Identities in a Changing World. London: Pine Forge Press .
23.
Deutsch, Karl . 1953. Nationalism and Social Communication. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
24.
Eisenstadt, S.N. and S. Rokkan , eds. 1973. Building States and Nations. Vol 2. Beverly Hills CA: Sage .
25.
Eller, Jack and Reed Coughlin . 1993. “The Poverty of Primordialism: The Demystification of Ethnic Attachments” , Ethnic and Racial Studies10(2): 183–202 .
26.
Eriksen, Thomas Hylland . 1991. “The Cultural Contexts of Ethnic Differences” , Man26(1): 127–144 .
27.
Eriksen, Thomas Hylland . 1992. Us and Them in Modern Societies: Ethnicity and Nationalism in Mauritius, Trinidad and Beyond. Oslo: Scandinavian University Press .
28.
Eriksen, Thomas Hylland . 1998. Common Denominators: Ethnicity, Nation Building and Compromise in Mauritius. Oxford: Berg .
29.
Espiritu, Yen . 1992. Asian American Panethnicity: Bridging Institutions and Identities. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press .
30.
Fearon, James D. and David Laitin . 2000. “Violence and the Social Construction of Ethnic Identity” , International Organization54(4): 845–877 .
31.
Fox, Richard G. , Charlotte H. Aull , and Lous F. Cimino . 1981. “Ethnic Nationalism and the Welfare State.” In Ethnic Change, edited by C. Keyes . Seattle: University of Washington Press .
32.
Geertz, Clifford . 1963. “The Integrative Revolution: Primordial Sentiments and Civil Politics in the New States.” In Old Societies and New States, edited by C. Geertz . New York: Free Press .
33.
Gil-White, Francisco J.1999. “How Thick is Blood? The Plot Thickens...: If Ethnic Actors are Primordialists, what Remains of the Circumstantialist/Primordialist Controversy?” , Ethnic and Racial Studies22(5): 789–820 .
34.
Glazer, Nathan and Daniel P. Moynihan . 1975. “Introduction.” In Ethnicity: Theory and Experience,edited by N. Glazer and D.P. Moynihan . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
35.
Gurr, Ted Robert . 1993. Minorities at Risk. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press .
36.
Gurr, Ted Robert . 1994. “Peoples against States: Ethnopolitical Conflict and the Changing World System” , International Studies Quarterly38: 347–377 .
37.
Hardin, Russell . 1995. One for All: The Logic of Group Conflict. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press .
38.
Hechter, Michael . 1975. Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development, 1536–1966. Berkeley: University of California Press .
39.
Hechter, Michael . 1987. Principles of Group Solidarity. Berkeley/Los Angeles: University of California Press .
40.
Hechter, Michael . 2000. Containing Nationalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
41.
Hein, Jeremy . 1997. “Ethnic Organizations and the Welfare State: The Impact of Social Welfare Programs on the Formation of Indochinese Refugee Associations” , Sociological Forum12(2): 279–295 .
42.
Hirschman, Albert O.1970. Exit, Voice and Loyalty. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
43.
Hollop, Oddvar. 1993. “Changing Conceptualization of Indian Ethnic Identity in Mauritius”. Unpublished doctoral thesis, Anthropology, University of Bergen.
44.
Hoyle, Rick H.1995. “The Structural Equation Modeling Approach: Basic Concepts and Fundamental Issues.” pp. 1–13 in Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues and Applications, edited by R. Hoyle . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage .
45.
Hu, Li-tze and Peter M. Bentler . 1999. “Cutoff Criteria for Fit Indexes in Covariance Structure Analysis: Conventional Criteria Versus New Alternatives” , Structural Equation Modeling6(1): 1–55 .
46.
Isaacs, H.R.1975. “Basic Group Identity: The Idols of the Tribe.” In Ethnicity: Theory and Experience, edited by N. Glazer and D.P. Moynihan , Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
47.
Isajiw, Wsevolod . 1990. “Ethnic Identity Retention.” In Ethnic Identity and Equality: Varieties of Experience in a Canadian City,edited by R. Brenton , W. Isajiw , W. Kalbach and J. Reitz . Toronto: University of Toronto Press .
48.
Jenkins, Richard . 1994. “Rethinking Ethnicity: Identity, Categorization and Power” , Ethnic and Racial Studies17(2): 197–223 .
49.
Jöreskog, Karl G. and Dag Sörbom . 1996. LISREL 8: Users Reference Guide. Chicago, IL: Scientific Software International .
50.
Kasfir, Nelson . 1979. “Explaining Ethnic Political Participation” , World Politics31(3): 365–388 .
51.
Liang, Jersey . 2001. “Assessing Cross-Cultural Comparability in Mental Health Among Older Adults” , Journal of Mental Health and Aging7(1): 21–30 .
52.
Lipset, S.M. and S. Rokkan , eds. 1967. Party Systems and Voter Alignments: Cross-National Perspectives. New York: The Free Press .
53.
Malešić, Siniša . 2002. “Rational Choice Theory and the Sociology of Ethnic Relations: A Critique” , Ethnic and Racial Studies25(2): 193–212 .
54.
Mauritius Central Statistics Office . 2000. The 2000 Housing and Population Census Analysis Report. http://ncb.intnet.mu/cso.htm. April 2004.
55.
Melson, R. and H. Wolpe . 1970. “Modernization and the Politics of Communalism: A Theoretical Perspective” , American Political Science Review64: 1112–1130 .
56.
Miles, William F.S.1999. “The Creole Malaise in Mauritius” , African Affairs98: 211–228 .
57.
Nagel, Joane . 1994. “Constructing Ethnicity: Creating and Recreating Ethnic Identity and Culture” , Social Problems41: 152–176 .
58.
Nielsen, FranÁois . 1985. “Toward a Theory of Ethnic Solidarity in Modern Societies” , American Sociological Review50: 133–149 .
59.
Olson, Mancur . 1965. The Logic of Collective Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
60.
Olzak, Susan . 1983. “Contemporary Ethnic Mobilization.”Annual Review of Sociology9: 355–374 .
61.
Olzak, Susan . 1992. The Dynamics of Ethnic Competition and Conflict. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press .
62.
Olzak, Susan and Joane Nagel . 1986. Competitive Ethnic Relations. New York: Academic .
63.
Patterson, Orlando . 1975. “Context and Choice in Ethnic Allegiance: A Theoretical Framework and Caribbean Case Study.” In Ethnicity: Theory and Experience, edited by N. Glazer and D.P. Moynihan . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
64.
Satorra, Albert and Peter M. Bentler . 1994. “Corrections to Test Statistic and Standard Errors in Covariance Structure Analysis.” pp. 339–419 in Analysis of Latent Variables in Developmental Research, edited by A. Von Eye and C.C. Clogg . Newbury Park, CA: Sage .
65.
Satorra, Albert and Peter M. Bentler . 1999. “A Scaled Difference Chi-Square Test Statistic for Moment Structure Analysis” , Psychometrika66: 507–514 .
66.
Scott, George M. Jr.1990. “A Resynthesis of the Primordial and Circumstantial Approaches to Ethnic Groups Solidarity: Towards an Explanatory Model” , Ethnic and Racial Studies13(2): 147–171 .
67.
Shils, Edward1957. “Primordial, Personal, Sacred and Civil Ties” , British Journal of Sociology82: 130–145 .
68.
Srebrnik, Henry . 2000. “Can an Ethnically-Based Civil Society Succeed? The Case of Mauritius” , Journal of Contemporary African Studies18(1): 7–20 .
69.
Steenkamp, Jan-Benedict E.M. and Hans Baumgartner . 1998. “Assessing Measurement Invariance in Cross-National Consumer Research” , Journal of Consumer Research25: 78–90 .
70.
Steinberg, S.1981. The Ethnic Myth: Race, Ethnicity and Class in America. Boston, MA: Beacon .
71.
Tilly, Virginia . 1997. “Untangling Language about Ethnicity” , Ethnic and Racial Studies20(3): 497–522 .
72.
Vail, Leroy . 1989. “Introduction.” in The Creation of Tribalism in Southern Africa, edited by L. Vail . Berkeley: University of California Press .
73.
Vandenberg, Robert J. and Charles E. Lance . 2000. “A Review and Synthesis of the Measurement Invariance Literature: Suggestions, Practices, and Recommendations for Organizational Research” , Organizational Research Methods3(1): 4–70 .
74.
Wacquant, LoÔc J.D.1997. “For an Analytic of Racial Domination” , Political Power and Social Theory11: 221–234 .
75.
Waters, Mary C.1990. Ethnic Options: Choosing Identities in America. Berkeley: University of California Press .
76.
West, Stephen , John F. Finch , and Patrick J. Curran . 1997. “Structural Equation Models with Nonnormal Variables: Problems and Remedies.” In Structural Equation Modeling: Concepts, Issues and Applications, edited by R. Hoyle . London: Sage .
77.
Williams, Brackette . 1989. “A Class Act: Anthropology and the Race to Nation across Ethnic Terrain” , Annual Review of Anthropology18: 401–444 .
78.
World Bank . 1989. Mauritius: Managing Success. Washington, DC: World Bank .
79.
World Bank . 1992. Mauritius: Expanding Horizons. Washington DC: World Bank .
80.
Yancey, William L. , Eugene P. Eriksen , and Richard N. Juliani . 1976. “Emergent Ethnicity” , American Sociological Review41: 391–403 .
81.
Young, Crawford . 1993. The Rising Tide of Cultural Pluralism: The Nation-State at Bay?Madison: University of Wiscons .in Press
