Although immigrant workers have become an integral part of most organizations in immigrant-receiving countries, there is surprisingly little research on cross-cultural work relations, especially in the professional/white-collar sector. In Israel, where former Soviet immigrants comprise over 20 percent of the Jewish population, the presence of Russian-speaking workers and professionals is dense in almost every workplace.The current qualitative study is focused on everyday work relations and inter-group attitudes between long-time Israeli residents and recent Russian-speaking immigrants in the context of a medical organization. Twenty-five interviews with the veteran and new immigrant workers (conducted in Hebrew and in Russian) indicate that these groups diligently guard their social borders and separate identities, and share similar critical opinions on each other’s work ethic and competence. Conflicts arise around the issues of educational and work status gaps, relations with supervisors, and language use. The continuing use of Russian by immigrant workers is interpreted by Hebrew-speakers as a sign of their separatism and anti-Israeli outlook. The underlying mechanisms of mutual stereotyping are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Austers, I.2002. “Attribution of Value Stereotypes as a Consequence of Group Membership: Latvian and Russian Students Living in Latvia Compared.”International Journal of Intercultural Relations26(3): 273-285 .
2.
Aguirre, A.2003. “Linguistic Diversity in the Workforce: Understanding Social Relations in the Workplace.”Sociological Focus36(1): 65-80 .
3.
Amason, P. , M. Allen , and S. Holmes . 1999. “Social Support and Acculturative Stress in the Multicultural Workplace.”Journal of Applied Communication Research27: 310-334 .
4.
Bar-Tal, D.1997. “Formation and Change of Ethnic and National Stereotypes: An Integrative Model.”International Journal of Intercultural Relations21(4): 491-523 .
5.
Bernstein, J.H. and J.T. Shuval . 1998. “The Occupational Integration of Former Soviet Physicians in Israel . Social Science and Medicine47(6): 809-819 .
6.
Bagchi, A.D. 1999. Making Connections: A Study of the Social Network of Immigrant Professionals. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Wisconsin at Madison, Abstract in Dissertation Abstracts International (The Humanities and Social Sciences) 60(6).
7.
Bond, M.H.1986. “Mutual Stereotypes and the Facilitation of Interaction Across Cultural Lines.”International Journal of Intercultural Relations10: 259-276 .
8.
Bond, M.H. and J. Pyle . 1998. “The Ecology of Diversity in Organizational Settings: Lessons from a Case Study.”Human Relations51: 589-623 .
9.
Boyd, M.2000. “Matching Workers to Work: The Case of Asian Immigrant Engineers in Canada.” Working Paper No 14. The Center for Comparative Immigration Studies, University of California, San-Diego, CA .
10.
CBS . 2002. Statistical Abstract of Israel, 2000. Jerusalem: Central Statistical Bureau of Israel .
11.
Chemers, M.M. , S. Oskamp , and M.A. Costanzo , eds. 1995. Diversity in Organizations: New Perspectives for a Changing Workplace. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage .
12.
Chen, I.H. 1996. Work Values, Acculturation, and Job Satisfaction among Chinese Immigrant Professionals. Ph.D. dissertation, New York University. Abstract in Dissertation Abstracts International (The Humanities and Social Sciences) 57(3): 1332-A.
13.
Crabtree, B.F. and W.L. Miller . 1992. “A Template Approach to Text Analysis: Developing and Using Codebooks.” In Doing Qualitative Research, edited by B.F. Crabtree and W.L. Miller . Newbury Park, CA: Sage .
14.
De Jong, G.F. and A.B. Madamba.2001. “A Double Disadvantage? Minority Group, Immigrant Status, and Underemployment in the United States.”Social Science Quarterly82(1): 117-130 .
15.
Dong, W. and J.W. Salaff . 2000. “Just Friends: Middle-Class Chinese Immigration and Social Networks.” American Sociological Association Paper No 1235/2000.
16.
Dubin, R. and A. Galin . 1991. “Attachments to Work: Russians in Israel.”Work and Occupations18(2): 172-193 .
17.
Dutton, G.1998. “One Workplace, Many Languages.”Management Review87: 42-47 .
18.
Elliott, J.R.2001. “Referral Hiring and Ethnically Homogeneous Jobs: How Prevalent is the Connection and for Whom?”Social Science Research30(3): 401-425 .
19.
Epstein, A. and M. Uritsky . 2002. “Differences in the Cultural Values of Science and Scientists: Scholars from the Post-Soviet States in Israeli Academic Institutions.”Diasporas: An Independent Academic Journal4: 87-115 . ( Moscow: The Jewish University Press; in Russian .)
20.
Fasold, R.1990. The Sociolonguistics of Language. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell .
21.
Fiske, S.T.1993. “Controlling Other People: The Impact of Power on Stereotyping.”American Psychologist48: 621-628 .
22.
Fialkova, L. and M. Yelenevskaya . 2004. “How to Find the West in the Middle East? Perceptions of East and West among ‘Russian’ Jews in Israel.” In Times, Places, Passages: Ethnological Approaches in the New Millennium, edited by A. Paladi-Kovacs . Budapest: Institute of Ethnology, Hungarian Academy of Sciences (Akademiai Kiado) .
Horenczyk, G.1997. “Immigrants’ Perceptions of Host Attitudes and their Reconstruction of Cultural Groups.”Applied Psychology: An International Review46(1): 34-38 .
25.
Horowitz, T. , ed. 1989. The Soviet Man in Open Society. New York: Lantham .
26.
Horowitz, T.1999. “Integration or Separatism?” In Children of Perestroika in Israel, edited by T. Horowitz . Hartford, CT: University Press of America .
27.
IMIA (Israeli Ministry of Immigrant Absorption) . 1998. The Latest Trends in Immigration and Immigrant Integration. Jerusalem: IMIA (Hebrew) .
28.
Jones, A. , ed. 1991. Professions and the State: Expertise and Autonomy in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. Philadelphia: Temple University Press .
29.
Lerner, M. and G. Menachem . 2003. “Decredentialization and Recredentialization: The Role of Government Intervention in Enhancing Occupational Status of Russian Immigrants in Israel of the 1990s.”Work and Occupations30(3): 3-29 .
30.
Macias, R.1997. “Bilingual Workers and Language Use Rules in the Workplace: A Case Study of a Nondiscriminatory Language Policy.”International Journal of the Sociology of Language127: 53-70 .
31.
McGroarty, M.E.1990. “Bilingualism in the Workplace.”Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences511(September): 159-170 .
32.
MOH (Ministry of Health) . 2003. “Statistical Data on Medical Profession in Israel.” Presented at the National Conference on Health Care Administration, February, Kfar-Maccabia (poster).
33.
Montreuil, A. and R.Y. Bourhis . 2001. “Majority Acculturation Orientations Toward ‘Valued’ and ‘Devalued’ Immigrants.”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology32(6): 698-719 .
34.
Naveh, G. and J. King . 1995. The Absorption into Employment of Immigrant Engineers. Jerusalem: JDC-Brookdale Institute (Hebrew) .
35.
Naveh, G. , G. Noam , and E. Benita . 1995. The Employment and Economic Situation of Immigrants from the Former Soviet Union: Selected Findings from a National Employment Survey. Jerusalem: JDC-Brookdale Institute (Hebrew) .
36.
Nirel, N.1999. The Employment of Immigrant Physicians from the former Soviet Union in 1998: Summary of Findings from a Follow-Up Study. Jerusalem: JDC-Brookdale Institute (Hebrew) .
37.
Parliman, G.C. and R.J. Shoeman . 1994. “National Origin Discrimination or Employer Prerogative? An Analysis of Language Rights in the Workplace.”Employee Relations Law Journal19(4): 551-562 .
38.
Prentice, D.A. and D.T. Miller . 1999. Cultural Divides: Understanding and Overcoming Group Conflict. New York: Russel Sage Foundation .
39.
Raijman, R. and M. Semyonov . 1998. “Best of times, Worst of Times, and Occupational Mobility: The Case of Soviet Immigrants in Israel.”International Migration36(3): 291-312 .
40.
Reitz, J.2001. “Immigrant Success in the ‘Knowledge Economy’: Institutional Change and the Immigrant Experience in Canada, 1970-1995.”Journal of Social Issues57(3): 579-613 .
41.
Remennick, L.2002. “Survival of the Fittest: Russian Immigrant Teachers Speak about their Professional Adjustment in Israel.”International Migration40(1): 99-121 .
42.
Remennick, L.2003a“What does ‘Integration’ Mean?” Social Incorporation of Russian Immigrants in Israel.”Journal of International Migration and Integration4(1): 23-48 .
43.
Remennick, L.2003b. “Career Continuity among Immigrant Professionals: Russian Engineers in Israel.”Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies29(4): 701-721 .
44.
Remennick, L. and G. Shakhar . 2003. “‘You never stop being a doctor’: The Stories of Russian Immigrant Physicians who Converted to Physiotherapy.”Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine7(1): 87-108 .
45.
Remennick, L. and R. Shtarkshall . 1997. “Technology Versus Responsibility: Immigrant Physicians from the Former Soviet Union Reflect on Israeli Health Care.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior38(September): 191-202 .
46.
Schwarzwald, J. and Y. Yinon . 1977. “Symmetrical and Asymmetrical Interethnic Perception in Israel.”International Journal of Intercultural Relations1(1): 40-47 .
47.
Shih, J.2002. “‘... Yeah, I Could Hire This One, but I Know it’s Gonna be a Problem’: How Race, Nativity and Gender Affect Employers’ Perceptions of the Manageability of Job Seekers.”Ethnic and Racial Studies25(1): 99-119 .
48.
Shuval, J.T. and J. Bernstein . 1996. “The Dynamics of Professional Commitment: Immigrant Physicians from the Former Soviet Union in Israel.”Social Science and Medicine42(7): 965-974 .
49.
Sicron, M.1998. “Social Capital of Recent Russian Immigrants and the Process of their Occupational Integration.” In The Social Profile of the Immigrant Wave. The Integration Process of the Immigrants from the Former Soviet Union in Israel, 1990-1995, edited by M. Sicron and E. Leshem . Jerusalem: Magnes .
50.
Spears, R. , P.J. Oakes , N. Ellemers , and S.A. Haslam . 1997. “Introduction: The Social Psychology of Stereotyping and Group Life.” In The Social Psychology of Stereotyping and Group Life, edited by R. Spears , P.J. Oakes , N. Ellmers , and S.A. Haslam . Oxford: Blackwell .
51.
Stier, H. and V. Levanon . 2003. “Finding an Adequate Job: Employment and Income of Recent Immigrants to Israel.”International Migration41(2): 81-105 .
52.
Strauss, A. and J. Corbin . 1989. Qualitative Research Methods. Newbury Park, CA: Sage .
53.
Toren, N.1996. “Integration of Immigrants in Science, Medicine and Engineering and the Structure of Collegial Networks in Israel.”Science and Public Policy23(6): 361-367 .
54.
Vinokurov, A. , D. Birmann , and E. Trickett . 2000. “Psychological and Acculturation Correlates of Work Status among Soviet Jewish Refugees in the United States.”International Migration Review34(2): 538-559 .
55.
Wilson, F.D. and G. Jaynes . 2000. “Migration and the Employment and Wages of Native and Immigrant Workers.”Work and Occupations27(2): 135-167 .
56.
Zilberg, N. and E. Leshem . 1996. “Russian-Language Press and Immigrant Community in Israel.”European Revue of International Migrations12(3): 173-189 .
