This paper examines the relationship between sporting dramas, national and civic identity, and the local domains in which collective identities crystallize. The Israeli premier football league is contextualized historically in terms of the Israeli-Arab conflict. By focusing on football matches between an “Arab” team and its various Jewish rivals (i.e., matches played by this Arab team in different Jewish towns) we develop a framework for a comparative discussion of Jewish-Israeli civil identity. Based on a study of 14 football games, this paper highlights the diversity and nuances that the national-civic identity assumes among Jewish-Israelis in different towns, and relates the differences to the particular history and symbolic significance of each town.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Al-Haj, M. and H. Rosenfeld . 1993. Arab Local Government in Israel. Boulder: Westview Press .
2.
Amir, J.1991. “Attitudes to the Idea of Israel’s Election in Modern Jewish Thought.” (Hebrew). In Chosen People, Elect Nations and Universal Mission, edited by S. Almog and M. Heyd . Jerusalem: The Zalman Shazar Center for Jewish History .
3.
Appadurai, A.1995. “The Production of Locality.” In Managing the Diversity of Knowledge, edited by R. N. Fardo . London: Routledge .
4.
Azar, M.1972. “The Rhetoric of Sport Journalists” (Hebrew) . Leshoneinu L’am24, 25-32, 132-141, 200-204, 231-240 .
5.
Bairner, A. and P. Shirlow . 1999. “The Territorial Politics of Soccer in Northern Ireland.” In Football Cultures and Identities, edited by G. Amostrong and R. Giulianotti . London: Macmillan Press Ltd.
6.
Bale, J.1988. “The Place of ‘Place’ in Cultural Studies of Sports.”Progress in Human Geography12: 507-524 .
7.
Bateson, G.1956. “The Message ‘This is play.’” In Group processes, edited by B. SchaftherNew York: Josiah Macy Foundation. Beer-Sheva: Ben Gurion University, the department of behavior sciences . Unpublished paper.
8.
Ben-Ari, E and Y. Bilu . 1997. “Introduction.” In Grasping Land: Space and Place in Contemporary Israeli Discourse and Experience, edited by E. Ari-Ben and Y. Bilu . New York: State University of N.Y. Press .
9.
Ben Porat, A.2001. Biladi, Biladi. (Hebrew). Tel-Aviv: Babel
10.
Bernstein, D.S.2000. Constructing Boundaries. New York: Sunny Press .
11.
Beshara, A.1993. “About the Question of the Palestinian Minority in Israel.” (Hebrew) . Theory and Critique3: 7-20 .
12.
Bhabha, H.1990. Nation and Narration. London and New York: Routledge .
13.
Birenbaum-Carmeli, D.2000. Tel-Aviv North: The Making of Israeli Middle Class. (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Magness-Hebrew University Press .
14.
Bourdieu, P.1978. “Sport and Social Class.”Social Science Information17(66): 819-840 .
15.
Carmeli, Y. and I. Bar . 1999. “Team Selection and The Chosen People in Israel: The Case of Hapoel Taibeh.” In Football, Cultures and Identities, edited by G. Armstrong and R. Giulianotti . London: Macmillan Press .
16.
Carmi, S and H. Rosenfeld . 1974. “The Origin of the Process of Proletariazation and Urbanization of Arab Peasants in Palestine.”Social Investigation Quarterly.
17.
Carmi, S and H. Rosenfeld . 1989. “The Emergence of Militaristic Nationalism in Israel.”International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society3(1): 5-49 .
18.
Central Bureau of Statistics . 1994. The Population in the Settlements. (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Central Bureau of Statistics .
19.
Central Bureau of Statistics . 1997. “Characterization and Ranking of Local Authorities According to the Population Socio-Economic Level in 1995.” (Hebrew). Publication No. 1039. Jerusalem: Central Bureau of Statistics :47-51.
20.
Duke, V.1991. “The Sociology of Football: A Research Agenda for the 1990s.”The Sociological Review39: 627-645 .
21.
Elias, N.1986. “Introduction.” In Quest for Excitement, edited by N. Elias and E. Dunning . Oxford: Basil Blackwell .
22.
Erlich, A.1993. “Society at War: The National Conflict and the Social Structure.” In The Israeli Society: critical dimensions, edited by U. Ram . Tel-Aviv: Breirot (Hebrew) .
23.
Ettinger, S.1991. “The Idea of the Chosen People in Jewish and European History” In Chosen People, Elect Nations and Universal Mission, edited by S. Almog and M. Heyd . Jerusalem: The Zalman Shazar Center for Jewish History (Hebrew).
24.
Geertz, C.1972. “Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight.”Daedalus101: 1-37 .
25.
Gellner, E.1983. Nations and Nationalism. Oxford: Basil Blackwell .
26.
Gilbar, G.1987. “The Development of the Population in the Main Cities: Jerusalem, Jaffa and Haifa.”Cathedra45: 43-56 (Hebrew).
27.
Goffman, E.1961. Encounters. New York: Harper Colophon .
28.
Gurevitch, Z. and G. Aran . 1991. “About the Place: Israeli Anthropology.”‘Alpayim’ — A Multidisciplinary Publication for Contemporary Thought and Literature.4: 9-44 . (Hebrew).
29.
Haddad, M. and M. Padida . 1995. “Changes in the Gaps of Selected Socio-Economic Variables Among Tel-Aviv Neighbourhoods.” In Social Processes and Public Policy in Tel-Aviv — Yafo, edited by D. Nachmias and G. Menahem . Tel aviv: Ramot Publishing House Tel-Aviv University (Hebrew).
30.
Handelman, D.1977. “Play and Ritual: Complementary Frames of Meta-Communication.” In It’s a Funny Thing, Humour, edited by A. Z. Chapman and H. C. Foot . Oxford: Pergamon Press .
31.
Hargreaves, J.1986. Sport, Power and Culture: A Social and Historical Analysis of Popular Sports in Britain. Cambridge: Polity Press .
32.
Harris, J.C.1982. “Sport and Ritual: A Macroscopic Comparison of Form.” In The Paradoxes of Play, edited by J. W. Long . West Point: Leisure Press .
33.
Hobsbawm, E. and T. Ranger eds. 1983. The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
34.
Holston, J. and A. Appadurai . 1996. “Cities and Citizenship.”Public Culture8: 187-204 .
35.
Hughson, J.1997. “Football, Folk Dancing and Fascism: Diversity and Difference in Multicultural Australia.”Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology33(2): 167-186 .
36.
Katz, J.1971. Tradition in Crisis: Jewish Society at the End of the Middle Ages. New York: Shoken books .
37.
Kellerman, A.1989. “Culture Uniqueness and Culture Struggle Between Jerusalem and Tel-Aviv: Does History Repeat Itself?”City and Region. September 1989, No. 19-20:120-130 (Hebrew).
38.
Kellner, M.1993. “Choseness, Not Chauvinism: Maimonides on the Chosen People.” In A People Apart: Choseness and Ritual in Jewish Philosophical Thought, edited by D. H. Frank . Albany: Suny Press .
39.
Kimmerling, B.1985. “Between Primordial and the Civic Definition of the Collective Identity: Erez Israel of the State of Israel?” In Comparative Social Dynamic s, edited by E. Cohen , M. Lissak , and U. Almagor . Boulder: Westview Press .
40.
Kimmerling, B. . 1992. “Sociology, Ideology and Nation-Building: The Palestinians and Their Meaning in Israeli Sociology.”American Sociological Review57: 446-460 .
41.
Liebman, C.S.1975. “Religion and Political Intergration in Israel.”The Jewish Journal of Sociology17(1): 25-42 .
42.
Moorhouse, H.F.1984. “Professional Football and Working Class Culture: English Theories and Scottish Evidence.”The Sociological Review32: 285-313 .
43.
Moorhouse, H.F. . 1996. “One State, Several Countries: Soccer and Nationality in a ‘United’ Kingdom.” In Tribal Identities: Nationalism, Europe, Sport, edited by J.A. Mangan . London: Frank Cass .
44.
Morris, B.1988. The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem 1947-1949. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
45.
Pappé, I.1992. The Making of the 'Arab'-Israeli Conflict 1947-1951. London and New York: I. B. Tauris .
46.
Rabinowitz, D.1993. “Eastern Nostalgy: How Did the Palestinians Become Israeli Arabs?” (Hebrew) . Notebooks of Theory and Critique3: 141-152 .
47.
Rosenzweig, F.1971. The Star of Redemption. London: Routledge .
48.
Rowe, S.1998. “Modern Sports: Liminal Ritual of Liminoid Leisure.”Journal of Ritual Studies12(1): 47-60
49.
Seikaly, M.1956. Haifa. Transformation of a Palestinian Arab Society 1918-1939. New York: I. B. Tauris .
50.
Sorek, T. 2001. “Arab Footbal (Soccer) in Israel—Playing with Identities.” Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, Hebrew University.
51.
Smith, A.D.1998. Nationalism and Modernism. A Critical Survey of Recent Theories of Nations and Nationalism. New York: Routledge .
52.
Smooha, S.1990. “Minority Status in an Ethnic Democracy: The Status of the ‘Arab’ Minority in Israel.”Ethnic and Racial Studies13: 389-413 .
53.
Smooha, S. . 1999. “Transformation in the Israeli Society after 50 years.” ‘Alpayim’, 17: 239-261 .
54.
Swirsky, S.1984. “The Oriental Jews in Israel: Why Many Tilted Toward Begin.”Dissent31(1): 77-91 .
55.
Yazbak, M.1998. Haifa in the Late Ottoman Period, 1864-1914. A Muslim Town in Transiton. Leiden: Brill .
56.
Yazbak, M. . 2000. “From Poverty to Revolt: Economic Factors in the Outbreak of the 1936 Rebellion in Palestine.”Middle Eastern Studies36(3): 93-113 .
57.
Adar, Shaul . 1996. Shem ha-Mishak December.
58.
Abu Ta'amah, Fawzi . 1996. “The Management of Hapo'el Taibe: We Call Our Arab Brothers form the North and the Galilee to Come to Support US.”Al-Sanara, Sport Supplement, p. 1 , November 1.
59.
Golan, Yehuda . 1997. “The Bulldozer Entered the Territory.”Maariv, Sport Supplement, pp. 4-5 , March 23.
60.
Goldstein, Yitshak . 1997. “Thanks God for Taibe.”Yedioth Aharonoth, Sport Supplement, p. 5 , February, 23.
61.
Haj Ehie, Abed . 1997. “Death on the Ground.”Ma'ariv, Sport Supplement, pp. 1-3 , April 6.
62.
Jawadat, Odeh . 1996. “A Very Special View.”Kol el Arab, Sport Supplement, p. 2 , November 1.
63.
Natan, David . 1997. “History Made in Rishon.”Yedioth Aharonoth, Sport Supplement, p. 4 , May 18.
64.
Unnamed reporter . 1997. “Zuhair Bahlul: The Behaviour of Some Jewish Fans During the One Minute Silence Shows their Moral Level.”Fasl el Makal, Sport Supplement, p. 2 , April 10.
65.
Waqed, Ali . 1997. “Beitar Against Taibe.”Ha'ir, March 28.
