Research on democratic transitions and consolidation has emphasized the importance not only of structural factors, such as institutional reform and economic development, but also political culture. There are differing scholarly opinions about whether a democratic political culture can emerge in the Arab world, however. More specifically, there is disagreement about whether the Islamic attachments of ordinary citizens discourage the emergence of democratic attitudes and values. Against this background, the present study uses World Values Survey data from Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, and Algeria to assess the influence of Islamic orientations on attitudes toward democracy. Two separate attitudinal measures pertaining to democracy are dependent variables in the analysis. Independent variables include measures pertaining both to personal religious involvement and the role of Islam in political affairs. The results of this analysis, which are similar in all four countries, show that strong Islamic attachments do not discourage or otherwise influence support for democracy to any significant degree.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABED, Shukri . 1995. “Islam and Democracy.” In Democracy, War, and Peace in the Middle East edited by David Garnham and Mark Tessler . Bloomington: I ndiana University Press .
2.
ANDERSON, Lisa . 1999. “Politics in the Middle East: Opportunities and Limits in the Quest for Theory.” In Area Studies and Social Science: Strategies for Understanding Middle East Politics, edited by Mark Tessler , with Jodi Nachtwey and Anne Banda . Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
3.
ARAB HUMAN DEVELOPMENT REPORT. 2002. New York: United Nations Development Programme . Available online: http://www.undp.org/rbas/ahdr/bychapter.html.
4.
BENNANI-CHRAIBI, Mounia. 1994. Soumis et rebelles: les jeunes au Maroc. Paris: CNRS Editions.
5.
BOWEN, Donna Lee . 1993. “Pragmatic Morality, Islam, and Family Planning in Morocco.” In Everyday Life in the Muslim Middle East, edited by Donna Lee Bowen and Evelyn Early . Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
6.
BRATTON, Michael and Robert Mattes . 2001. “Africans’ Surprising Universalism.”Journal of Democracy12 (January): 107-121 .
7.
BRUMBERG, Daniel . 1995. “Authoritatian Legacies and Reform Strategies in the Arab World.” In Political Liberalization and Democratization in the Arab World: Theoretical Perspectives, edited by Rex Brynen , Bahgat Korany , and Paul Noble . Boulder: Lunne Rienner Publishers .
8.
CHOUEIRI, Y.1996. “The Political Discourse of Contemporary Islamist Movements.” In Islamic Fundamentalism, edited by Abdel Salem Sidahmed and Anoushiravam Ehteshami . Boulder: Westview Press .
9.
CHU, Yun-han , Larry Diamond , and Doh Chull Shin . 2001. “Halting Progress in Korea and Taiwan.”Journal of Democracy12 (January): 122-136 .
10.
CORDESMAN, Anthony . 1999. “Transitions in the Middle East.” Address to the Eighth Annual United States Middle East Policymakers Conference. Washington, D.C.
11.
DUCH, Raymond . 1995. “Economic Chaos and the Fragility of Democratic Transition in Former Communist Regimes.”Journal of Politics57(February): 121-158 .
12.
ESPOSITO, John L.1992. Islam: The Straight Path. New York: Oxford University Press .
13.
ESPOSITO, John L. and James P. Piscatori . 1991. “Democratization and Islam.”Middle East Journal45: 427-440 .
14.
AL-FARAWATI, Oula . 1999. “Arab Intellectuals Review Challenges of Globalization.”Jordan Times, December 9-10.
15.
FLANAGAN, Scott C. and Aie-Rie Lee . 2000. “Value Change and Democratic Reform in Japan and Korea.”Comparative Political Studies33: 626-659 .
16.
GIBSON, James L.1995. “The Resilience of Mass Support for Democratic Institutions and Processes in the Nascent Russian and Ukrainian Democracies.” In Political Culture and Civil Society in Russia and the New States of Eurasia, edited by V. Tismaneanu . New York: M. E. Sharpe .
17.
HALLIDAY, Fred . 1995. Islam and the Myth of Confrontation: Religion and Politics in the Middle East. London: I. B. Tauris .
18.
HAMDI, Mohamed Elhachmi . 1996. “Islam and Democracy: The Limits of the Western Model.”Journal of Democracy7(April): 81-85 .
19.
HARIK, Iliya . 1994. “Pluralism in the Arab World.”Journal of Democracy5(July): 43-56 .
20.
HUDSON, Michael . 1995. “The Political Culture Approach to Arab Democratization: The Case for Bringing It Back In, Carefully.” In Political Liberalization and Democratization in the Arab World, edited by Rex Brynen , Bahgat Korany , and Paul Noble . Boulder: Lynn Reinner Publishers .
21.
HUNTINGTON, Samuel . 1984. “Will More Countries Become Democratic?”Political Science Quarterly99(Summer): 193-218 .
22.
HUNTINGTON, Samuel . 1993. “Democracy’s Third Wave.” In The Global Resurgence of Democracy, edited by Larry Diamond and Marc Plattner . Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
23.
HUNTINGTON, Samuel . 1991. The Third Wave. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press .
24.
INGLEHART, Ronald . 2000. “Culture and Democracy.” In Culture Matters: How Values Shape Human Progress, edited by Lawrence E. Harrison and Samuel Huntinngton . New York: Basic Books .
25.
KARATNYCKY, Adrian . 2000. “A Century of Progress.”The Journal of Democracy11: 187-200 .
26.
KEDOURIE, Elie . 1994. Democracy and Arab Political Culture. London: Frank Cass Publishers .
27.
KHASHAN, Hilal . 1998. “History’s Legacy.”Middle East QuarterlyV(March): 41-48 .
28.
KHOURI, Rami G.2000. “A View from the Arab World.”Jordan Times, July 5.
29.
KORANY, Bahgat . 1994. “Arab Democratization: A Poor Cousin.”PS: Political Science and Politics27(September): 511-513 .
30.
LEWIS, Bernard . 1994. The Shaping of the Modern Middle East. New York: Oxford .
31.
MAINWARING, Scott . 1999. “Democratic Survivability in Latin America.” In Democracy and Its Limits: Lessons from Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, edited by Howard Handelman and Mark Tessler . Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press .
32.
MARRADI, Alberto . 1981. “Factor Analysis as an Aid in the Formulation and Refinement of Empirically Useful Concepts.” In Factor Analysis and Measurement in Sociological Research, edited by Edgar F. Borgatta and David J. Jackson . London: Sage .
33.
MATTES, Robert , and Hermann Thiel . 1998. “Consolidation and Public Opinion in South Africa.”Journal of Democracy9(January): 95-110 .
34.
MERNISSI, Fatima . 1992. Islam and Democracy: Fear of the Modern World. Reading, Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley .
35.
MISHLER, William and Richard Rose . 1999. “Five Years After the Fall: Trajectories of Support for Democracy in Post-Communist Europe.” In Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Goverment, edited by Pippa Norris . Oxford: Oxford University Press .
36.
OTTENMOELLER, Dan . 1998. “Popular Perceptions of Democracy: Elections and Attitudes in Uganda.”Comparative Political Studies31: 98-124 .
37.
ROSE, Richard , William Mishler , and Christian Haerpfer . 1998. Democracy and its Alternatives: Understanding Post-communist Societies. Cambridge: Polity Press .
38.
ROSE, Richard . 1997. “Where Are Postcommunist Countries Going?”Journal of Democracy8 (July): 92-108 .
39.
SCHMITTER, Philippe and Terry Lynn Karl . 1993. “What Democracy Is... and Is Not.” In The Global Resurgence of Demoracy, edited by Larry Diamond and Marc Plattner . Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press .
40.
SELIGSON, Mitchell and John Booth . 1993. “Political Culture and Regime Type: Evidence from Nigaragua and Costa Rica.”Journal of Politics55(August): 777-792 .
41.
SEN, Amartya . 1999. “Democracy as a Universal Value.”Journal of Democracy10: 3-17 .
42.
SHIN, Doh Chull and Huoyan Shyu . 1997. “Political Ambivalence in South Korea and Taiwan.”Journal of Democracy8(July): 109-124 .
43.
SIVAN, Emmanuel . 2000. “Illusions of Change.”Journal of Democracy11: 69-83 .
44.
SIVAN, Emmanuel . 1997. “Constraints and Opportunities in the Arab World.”Journal of Democracy8(April): 103-113 .
45.
AL-SUWAIDI, Jamal . 1995. “Arab and Western Conceptions of Democracy.” In Democracy, War, and Peace in the Middle East, edited by David Garnham and Mark Tessler . Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
46.
TALBI, Mohamed . 2000. “A Record of Failure.”Journal of Democracy11: 58-68 .
47.
TESSLER, Mark . 1999. “Arab Politics and Public Opinion.” Paper presented at U.S. Government Inter-Agency Conference on “Next Generation Politics in the Muslim World.”Washington, D.C.
48.
TESSLER, Mark . 2002. “Islam and Democracy in the Middle East: The Impact of Religious Orientations on Attitudes Toward Democracy in Four Arab Countries.”Comparative Politics34(April): 337-254 .
49.
TESSLER, Mark . 1997. “The Origins of Popular Support for Islamist Movements: A Political Economy Analysis.” In Islam, Democracy, and the State in North Africa, edited by John Entelis . Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
50.
VOLL, John . 1994. Islam, Continuity, and Change in the Modern World. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press .
51.
WALDRON-MOORE, Pamela . 1999. “Eastern Europe at the Crossroads of Democratic Transition.”Comparative Political Studies32(February): 32-62 .
52.
WEI-MING, Tu . 2000. “Multiple Modernities: A Preliminary Inquiry into the Implications of East Asian Modernity.” In Culture Matters: How Values Shape Human Progress, edited by Lawrence E. Harrison and Samuel Huntinngton . New York: Basic Books .
