Day labor, the industry in which workers, primarily men, seek temporary employment daily in open-air street markets or curb-side hiring sites, is a burgeoning market in the United States and a historically important, but declining industry in Japan. Using data from surveys of day laborers in Tokyo and Los Angeles, we analyze the unique characteristics of these two markets, comparing and contrasting the workers, the demand for their employment, and the spatial dimensions of this industry. We find that day laborers in Los Angeles are predominantly young, recent immigrants undertaking varied jobs. In contrast, day laborers in Tokyo are aging and mostly native Japanese displaced from Japan’s slouching post-industrial economy. Demand for day labor is equally contrasting. In Los Angeles, employers are more diversified, associated with a network of industries, and a consumer base that is broad and elastic. On the other hand, employers in Tokyo are overwhelmingly in construction and day laborers only cater to sub-contractors or middlemen. We speculate on the future of day labor in both cities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABU-LUGHOD, J.1994. “Comparing Chicago, New York, and Los Angeles: Testing Some World Cities Hypotheses,” In World Cities, edited by J. Friedmann . New York: Sage Publications .
2.
BELOUS, R.S.1989. The Contingent Economy: The Growth of the Temporary Part-time, and Ssubcontracted Workforce. Washington, DC: National Planning Association .
3.
BRIGGS, W.M. and M. Tienda . 1984. “The Impact of Immigrants on the Earnings of the Native-Born.” In Immigration: Issues and Policies, edited by W.M. Briggs and M. Tienda . Salt Lake City: Utah: Olympus .
4.
BOBO, L. , M.L Oliver , J.H. Johnson Jr. , and A. Valenzuela Jr.2000. Prismatic Metropolois: Inequality in Los Angeles. New York: Russell Sage .
5.
CAMAROTA, S. and M. Krikorian . 1999. “The Impact of Immigration on the United States Labor Market.” In Growing Apart: The Causes and Consequences of Global Wage Inequality, edited by A. Fishlow and K. Parker . New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press .
6.
CAMARILLO, A.1979. Chicanos in a Changing Society. Massachusetts: Harvard University Press .
7.
CRAIG, R.B.1971. The Bracero Program: Interest Groups and Foreign Policy. Austin: University of Texas Press .
8.
DALE, A. and C. Bamford . 1988. “Temporary Work: Cause for Concern or Complacency.”Work, Employment and Society2: 191-209 .
9.
ENDO, K.1996. “San’ya-no Rekishi: Toshi Kasou Shakai Kenkyuu Jousetsu” (“The History of San’ya: An Introduction to Social Research on The Urban Underclass”), Meiji Gakuin Daigaku Shakaigaku/Shakai Fukushi Ronsou (The Meiji Gakuin University Sociology and Social Welfare Review), No. 575. Meiji Gakuin University, Japan .
10.
ESBENSHADE, J.2000. “The ‘Crisis’ over Day Labor: The Politics of Visibility and Public Space.”Working USA3(6): 27-70 .
11.
FOWLER, E.1996. San’ya Blues: Laboring Life in Contemporary Tokyo. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press .
12.
GALARZA, E.1964. Merchants of Labor: The Mexican Bracero Story. Charlotte, California: McNally and Loftin .
13.
GAMBOA, E.1990. Mexican Labor and World War II: Braceros in the Pacific Northwest, 1942-1947. Austin: University of Texas Press .
14.
GIAMO, B.1994. “Order, Disorder and the Homeless in the United States and Japan.”Doshisha Amerika Kenkyu31: 1-19 .
15.
GILL, T.1994. “Sanya Street Life under the Heisei Recession.”Japan Quarterly41: 270-286 .
16.
GILL, T.2001. Men of Uncertainty: The Social Organization of Day Laborers in Contemporary Japan. New York: State University of New York Press .
17.
HARRINGTON, M.1962. The Other America: Poverty in the United States. Baltimore: Penguin Books .
18.
HOCH, C. and R.A. Slayton . 1989. New Homeless and Old: Community and the Skid Row Hotel. Philadelphia: Temple University Press .
19.
KALLEBERG, A.L.2000. “Nonstandard Employment Relations: Part-Time, Temporary and Contract Work.”Annual Review of Sociology26: 341-365 .
20.
KAMBER, M.2001. “On the Corner: New York’s Undocumented Day Laborers Fight for their Piece of the Big Apple.”Village VoiceJuly: 25-31 .
21.
LARROWE, C.P.1955. Shape-Up and Hiring Hall: A Comparison of Hiring Methods and Labor Relations on the New York and Seattle Waterfronts. Berkeley: University of California Press .
22.
LEONARDO, J. and J. O’Shea . 1997. “A Quantitative Analysis of ‘Shap-Ups’ on Long Island.”The Workplace Project Rep. The Workplace Project, Hempstead, NY .
23.
LEUPP, G.P.1992. Servants, Shophands, and Laborers in the Cities of Tokugawa Japan. Princeton: Princeton University Press .
24.
MARTINEZ, T.1973. The Human Marketplace. New Jersey: Transaction Books .
25.
MARR, M.D.1997. “Maintaining Autonomy: The Plight of the American Skidrow and Japanese Yoseba.”Journal of Social Distress and the Homeless6(3): 229-250 .
26.
MARR, M.D.1999. “Down and Out in Kobe: Homelessness Reshaped By Economic and Seismic Upheaval.”Kyoto Journal41: 59-65 .
27.
MARR, M.D. , A. Valenzuela Jr. , J.A. Kawachi , and T. Koike . 2000. “Day Laborers in Tokyo, Japan: Preliminary Findings from the San’ya Day Labor Survey.”UCLA Center for the Study of Urban Poverty Working Paper Series, Los Angeles, CA .
28.
MATSUZAWA, T.1988. “Street Labour Markets, Day Labourers, and the Structure of Oppression.” In The Japanese Trajectory: Modernization and Beyond, edited by G. McCormack and Y. Sugimoto . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
29.
MOORE, M.A.1965. “The Temporary Help Service Industry: Historical Development, Operation, and Scope.”Industrial Labor Relations Review18: 554-569 .
30.
MUND, V.1948. Open Markets: An Essential to Free Enterprise. New York: Harper & Brothers .
31.
MOHL, R.A.1971. Poverty in New York. New York: Oxford University Press .
32.
PARKER, R.E.1994. Flesh Peddlers and Warm Bodies: The Temporary Help Industry and its Workers. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press .
33.
PECK, J. and N. Theodore . 1998. “The Business of Contingent Work: Growth and Restructuring in Chicago’s Temporary Employment Industry.”Work, Employment & Society12(4): 655-674 .
34.
PECK, J. and N. Theodore . 2001. “Contingent Chicago: Restructuring the Spaces of Temporary Labor.”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research25(3): 471-496 .
35.
PECK J. and N. Theodore . 2002. “Temped Out? Industry Rhetoric, Labor Regulation and Economic Restructuring in the Temporary Staffing Business.”Economic and Industrial Democracy. 23(2): 143-175 .
36.
PORTES, A. , M. Castells , and L.A. Benton . 1989. Informal Economy: Studies in Advanced and Less Developed Countries. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press .
37.
PORTES, A. and R.L. Bach . 1985. Latin Journey: Cuban and Mexican Immigrants in the United States. Berkeley: University of California Press .
38.
ROBERTS, W.T. and T. Bartley . 2002. “Structure at the Bottom: Homeless Workers and the Day Labor Industry.”Department of Sociology, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona . Unpublished Manuscript.
39.
ROMO, R. 1975. “Mexican Workers in the City: Los Angeles, 1915-1930.” Ph.D. dissertation, UCLA Department of History, Los Angeles, California.
40.
SASSEN, S.1991. The Global City: New York, London, and Tokyo. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press .
41.
SASSEN, S.1996. “New York City’s Informal Economy.”Development and Change17: 85-119 .
42.
SASSEN, S.2000. “Informalization: Imported Through Immigration or a Feature of Advanced Economies?”Working USA3(6): 6-26 .
43.
SCHMIDT, F.H.1964. “After the Bracero: An Inquiry into the Problems of Farm Labor Recruitment.”With the research assistance of Patricia McFeely. A report submitted to the Department of Employment of the State of California by the Institute of Industrial Relations, UCLA, Los Angeles, California .
44.
SMITH, V.1997. “New Forms of Work Organization.”Annual Review of. Sociology23: 315-339 .
45.
SOUTHERN REGIONAL COUNCIL . 1988. Hard Labor: A Report on Day Labor Pools and Temporary Employment. Southern Regional Council Report, Atlanta, GA .
46.
THEODORE, N.2000. “A Fair Day’s Pay? Homeless Day Laborers in Chicago.” Center for Urban Economic Development Report. College of Urban Planning and Public Affairs, Chicago, Ill . Unpublished Manuscript.
47.
THEODORE, N. and J. Peck . 2002. “The Temporary Staffing Industry: Growth Imperatives and Limits to Contingency.”Economic Geography78(4): 463-493 .
48.
TOMA, R.S. and J. Esbenshade . 2001. “Day Laborer Hiring Sites: Constructive Approaches to Community Conflict.” Los Angeles County Human Relations Commission Report, Los Angeles, California .
49.
VALENZUELA Jr., A.1999. “Day Laborers in Southern California: Preliminary Findings from the Day Labor Survey.” Working Paper (Technical Report) 99-04. Center for the Study of Urban Poverty, Institute for Social Science Research, UCLA, Los Angeles, California .
50.
VALENZUELA Jr., A.2000. “Controlling Day Labor: Government, Community and Worker Responses.” Pp. 41-59 in California Policy Options 2001, edited by D.J.B. Mitchell and P. Nomura . Los Angeles: UCLA Anderson Business Forecast and School of Public Policy and Social Research, Los Angeles, California .
51.
VALENZUELA Jr., A.2001. “Day Labourers as Entrepreneurs?”Journal of Ethnic and. Migration Studies27(2): 335-352 .
52.
VALENZUELA Jr., A.2002. “Working on the Margins in Metropolitan Los Angeles: Immigrants in Day Labor Work.”Migraciones Internacionales1(2): 5-28 .
53.
VALENZUELA Jr., A , Melendez E.2003. Day Labor in New York: Findings from the NYDL Survey. Working Paper 03-01. Center for the Study of Urban Poverty, Institute for Social Science Research, UCLA, Los Angeles, Calif., and Community Development Research Center, Milano Graduate School of Management and Urban Policy, New School University, New York, NY .
54.
VALENZUELA Jr., A.2003 (in press). “Day-Labor Work.”Annual Review of Sociology Vol. 29(1).
55.
WALDINGER, R. and M. Bozorgmehr . 1996. Ethnic Los Angeles. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
56.
WALLACE, S.E.1965. Skid Row as a Way of Life. New Jersey: Bedminister Press .
57.
WILLIAMS, C. and J. Windebank . 1998. Informal Employment in the Advanced Economies: Implications for Work and Welfare. New York: Routledge .
58.
WILENTZ, S.1984. Chantz Democratic: New York City and the Rise of the American Working Class, 1788-1850. New York: Oxford University Press .
59.
WORBY, P.A. 2002. “Pride and Daily Survival: Latino Migrant Day Laborers and Occupational Health.” M.Ph dissertation. Department of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley
