Bronchodilator Resuscitation in the Emergency Department Part 1 of 2: Device Selection

From the Centers for Disease Control: Asthma -United States, 1980-1990. JAMA.1992;268(15):1995, 1999.

National Asthma Education and Prevention Program Expert Panel Report II. Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of asthma. National Institutes of Health.1997.

American Association for Respiratory Care. Aerosol Consensus State-ment -1991. Respir Care.1991;36(9):916–921.

Turner MO , Gafnie A , Swan D , FitzGerald JM . A review and eco-nomic evaluation of bronchodilator delivery methods in hospitalized patients. Arch Intern Med.1996;156(18):2113–2118.

Jasper AC , Mohsenifar Z , Kahan S , Goldberg HS , Koerner SK . Cost-benefit comparison of aerosol bronchodilator delivery methods in hospitalized patients. Chest.1987;91(4):614–618.

Summer W , Elston R , Tharpe L , Nelson S , Haponik EF . Aerosol bronchodilator delivery METHODS: relative impact on pulmonary func-tion and cost of respiratory care. Arch Intern Med.1989;149(3):618–623.

O'Reilly JF , Buchanan DR , Sudlow MF . Pressurised arosol with conical spacer is an effective alternative to nebuliser in chronic sta-ble asthma. Br Med J (Clin Res Ed).1983;286(6377):1548.

Gervais A , Begin P. Bronchodilatation with a metered-dose inhaler plus an extension, using tidal breathing vs jet nebulization. Chest.1987;92(5):822–824.

Tarala RA , Madsen BW , Patterson JW . Comparative efficacy of salbutamol by pressurized aerosol and wet nebulizer in acute asthma. Br J Clin Pharmacol.1980;10(4):393–397.

Bowton DL , Goldsmith WM , Haponick EF . Substitution of metered-dose inhalers for hand-held nebulizers: success and cost savings in a large, acute-care hospital. Chest.1992;101(2):305–308.

Newhouse MT , Dolovich M. Aerosol therapy: nebulizer vs metered dose inhaler. Chest.1987;91(6):799–800.

Turner MO , Patel A , Ginsburg S , FitzGerald JM . Bronchodilator delivery in acute airflow obstruction: a meta-analysis. Arch Intern Med.1997;157(15):1736–1744.

Connolly MJ . Inhaler technique of elderly patients: comparison of metered-dose inhalers and large volume spacer devices. Age Ageing.1995;24(3):190–192.

Newman SP . Aerosol generators and delivery systems. Respir Care.1991;36(9):939–951.

Fink JB , Dhand R , Grychowski J , Fahey PJ , Tobin MJ . Reconciling in vitro and in vivo measurements of aerosol delivery from a metered-dose inahler during mechanical ventilation and defining efficiency-en-hancing factors. Am J Respir Crit Care Med.1999;159(1):63–68.

Newman SP , Pavia D , Moren F , Sheahan NF , Clarke SW . Deposi-tion of pressurised aerosols in the human respiratory tract. Thorax.1981;36:52–55.

Dolovich M , Ruffin RE , Roberts R , Newhouse MT . Optimal deliv-ery of aerosols from metered dose inhalers. Chest.1981;80(6 Suppl):911–915.

Newman SP . A comparison of lung deposition patterns between different asthma inhalers (review). J Aerosol Med.1995;8 Suppl 3:S21–S26; discussion S27.

Larsen JS , Hahn M , Ekholm B , Wick KA . Evaluation of conven-tional press-and-breathe metered-dose inhaler technique in 501 pa-tients. J Asthma.1994;31(3):193–199.

Guidry GG , Brown WD , Stogner SW , George RB . Incorrect use of metered dose inhalers by medical personnel. Chest.1992;101(1):31–33.

Newman SP , Pavia D , Clarke SW . Simple instructions for using pressurized aerosol bronchodilators. J R Soc Med.1980;73(11):776–779.

De Blaquiere P , Christensen DB , Carter WB , Martin TR . Use and misuse of metered-dose inhalers by patients with chronic lung dis-ease: a controlled, randomized trial of two instruction methods. Am Rev Respir Dis.1989;140(4):910–916.

Kraemer R , Frey U , Sommer CW , Russi E. Short-term effect of albuterol, delivered via a new auxiliary device, in wheezy infants. Am Rev Respir Dis.1991;144(2):347–351.

Hodges IGC , Milner AD , Stokes GM . Assessment of a new device for delivering aerosol drugs to asthmatic children. Arch Dis Child.1981;56(10):787–789.

Lee H , Evans HE . Evaluation of inhalation aids of metered dose inhalers in asthmatic children. Chest.1987;91(3):366–369.

Gurwitz D , Levison H , Mindorff C , Reilly P , Worsley G. Assess-ment of a new device (aerochamber) for use with aerosol drugs in asthmatic children. Ann Allergy.1983;50:166–170.

Barbera JM , Sly RM , Eby DM , Middleton HB . Responses to a bronchodilator aerosol delivered by Aerochamber to young children (abstract). Ann Allergy.1984;52(3 Pt 2):224.

Katz R , Rachelefsky G , Rohr A , et al. Use of tube spacer. Aero-chamber (A) to improve the efficacy of a metered dose inhaler (MDI) in asthmatic children (abstract). J Allergy Clin Immunol.1986;77(1 Pt 2):185.

Konig P , Gayer D , Kantak A , Kreutz C , Douglass B , Hordvik NL . A trial of metaproterenol by metered-dose inhaler and two spacers in preschool asthmatics. Pediatr Pulmonol.1988;5(4):247–251.

Conner WT , Dolovich MB , Frame RA , Newhouse MT . Reliable salbutamol administration in 6-to 36-month-old children by means of a metered dose inhaler and Aerochamber with mask. Pediatr Pulmo-nol.1989;6(4):263–267.

Hess D , Horney D , Snyder T. Medication-delivery performance of eight small-volume, hand-held nebulizers: effects of diluent volume, gas flowrate, and nebulizer model. Respir Care.1989;34(8):717–723.

Hess D , Fisher D , Williams P , Pooler S , Kacmarek RM . Medication nebulizer performance: effects of diluent volume, nebulizer flow, and nebulizer brand. Chest.1996;110(2):498–505.

Johnson MA , Newman SP , Bloom R , Talace N , Clarke SW . Delivery of albuterol and ipratropium bromide from two nebulizer systems in chronic stable asthma: efficacy and pulmonary deposition. Chest.1989;96(1):6–10.

Alvine GF , Rodgers P , Fitzsimmons KM , Ahrens RC . Disposable jet nebulizers: how reliable are they? Chest.1992;101(2):316–319.

Malone RA , Hollie MC , Glynn-Barnhart A , Nelson HS . Optimal duration of nebulized albuterol therapy. Chest.1993;104(4):1114–1118.

Lewis RA , Fleming JS . Fractional deposition from a jet nebulizer: how it differs from a metered dose inhaler. Br J Dis Chest.1985;79(4):361–367.

Lipworth BJ , Clark RA , Dhillon DP , Brown RA , McDevitt DG . Beta-adrenoreceptor responses to high doses of inhaled salbutamol in patients with bronchial asthma. Br J Clin Pharmacol.1988;26(5):527–533.

Salzman GA , Steele MT , Pribble JP , Elenbaas RM , Pyszczynski DR . Aerosolized metaproterenol in the treatment of asthmatics with se-vere airflow obstruction: comparison of two delivery methods. Chest.1989;95(5):1017–1020.

Colacone A , Afilalo M , Wolkove N , Kreisman H. A comparison of albuterol administered by metered dose inhaler (and holding cham-ber) or wet nebulizer in acute asthma. Chest.1993;104(3):835–841.

Idris AH , McDermott MF , Raucci JC , Morrabel A , McGorray S , Hendeles L. Emergency department treatment of severe asthma: me-tered-dose inhaler plus holding chamber is equivalent in effective-ness to nebulizer. Chest.1993;103(3):665–672.

Rodrigo G , Rodrigo C. Comparison of salbutamol delivered by neb-ulizer or metered-dose inhaler with a pear-shaped spacer in acute asthma. Current Therapeutic Research. Clinical & Experimental.1993;54(6):797–808. 1993;93(6):800–808.

Rodrigo C , Rodrigo G. Salbutamol treatment of acute severe asthma in the ED: MDI versus hand-held nebulizer. Am J Emerg Med.1998;16(7):637–642.

Robertson D. Dose-response study of albuterol by inhaler or nebu-lizer for acute asthma. Drug Therapeutics.1994;24(1):40.

Turner JR , Corkery KJ , Eckman D , Gelb AM , Lipavsky A , Sheppard D. Equivalence of continuous flow nebulizer and metered-dose in-haler with reservoir bag for treatment of acute airflow obstruction. Chest.1988;93(3):476–481.

Levitt MA , Gambrioli EF , Fink JB . Comparative trial of continuous nebulization versus metered-dose inhaler in the treatment of acute bronchospasm. Ann Emerg Med.1995;26(3):273–277.

Mandelberg A , Chen E , Noviski N , Priel IE . Nebulized wet aerosol treatment in emergency department-is it essential? comparison with large spacer device for metered-dose inhaler. Chest.1997;112(6):1501–1505.

Fuglsang G , Pedersen S. Comparison of Nebuhaler and nebulizer treatment of acute severe asthma in children. Eur J Respir Dis.1986;69(2):109–113.

Kerem E , Levison H , Schuh S , O'Brodovich H , Reisman J , Bentur L , Canny GJ . Efficacy of albuterol administered by nebulizer versus spacer device in children with acute asthma. J Pediatr.1993;123(2):313–317.

Lin YZ , Hsieh KH . Metered dose inhaler and nebulizer in acute asthma. Arch Dis Child.1995;72(3):214–218.

Parkin PC , Saunders NR , Diamond SA , Winders PM , Macarthur C. Randomised trial spacer v nebuliser for acute asthma. Arch Dis Child.1995;72(3):239–240.

Chou KJ , Cunningham SJ , Crain EF . Metered-dose inhalers with spacers vs nebulizers for pediatric asthma. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.1995;149(2):201–205.

Williams JR , Bothner JP , Swanton RD . Delivery of albuterol in a pediatric emergency department. Pediatre Emerg Care.1996;12(4):263–267.

Batra V , Sethi GR , Sachdev HP . Comparative efficacy of jet nebu-lizer and metered dose inhaler with spacer device in the treatment of acute asthma. Indian Pediatr.1997;34(6):497–503.

Robertson CF , Norden MA , Fitzgerald DA , Connor FL , Van As-peren PP , Cooper PJ , et al. Treatment of acute asthma: salbutamol via jet nebuliser vs spacer and metered dose inhaler. J Paediatr Child Health.1998;34(2):142–146.

Barry PW , O'Callaghan C. Multiple actuations of salbutamol MDI into a spacer device reduce the amount of drug recovered in the respirable range. Eur Respir J.1994;7(9):1707–1709.

James RW , Masters IB . Single breath versus panting technique in salbutamol delivery through a 750 ml. spacing device. Pediatr Pul-monol.1990;8(4):263–267.

Closa RM , Ceballos JM , Gomez-Papi A , Galiana AS , Gutierrez C , Marti-Henneber C. Efficacy of bronchodilators adminstered by nebu-lizers versus spacer devices in infants with acute wheezing. Pediatr Pulmonol.1998;26(5):344–348.

Schuh S , Johnson DW , Stephens D , Callahan S , Winders P , Canny GJ . Comparison of albuterol delivered by a metered dose inhaler with spacer versus a nebulizer in children with mild acute asthma. J Pediatr.1999;135(1):22–27.

Kuhl DA , Agiri OA , Mauro LS . Beta-agonists in the treatment of acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (re-view). Ann Pharmacother.1994;28(12):1379–1388.

Cates CJ . Holding chambers versus nebulisers for beta-agonist treat-ment of acute asthma (Cochrane Review). In: The Cochrane Library.Issue 1.1999. Oxford: Update Software.

Gleeson JGA , Price JF . Nebuhaler technique. Br J Dis Chest.1988;82(2):172–174.

Sears MR . Comparison of conventional and ultrasonic nebulization of bronchodilator drugs in asthmatic subjects. NZ Med J.1983;96(743 Pt 2):927–929.

Olivenstein R , Wollkove N , Cohen C , Frank H , Kreisman H. A comparison of responses to albuterol delivered by two aerosol de-vices. Chest.1986;90(3):392–395.

Ballard RD , Bogin RM , Pak J. Assessment of bronchodilator re-sponse to a beta-adrenergic delivered from an ultrasonic nebulizer. Chest.1991;100(2):410–415.

Nakanishi AK , Lamb BM , Foster C , Rubin BK . Ultrasonic nebuli-zation of albuterol is no more effective than jet nebulization for the treatment of acute asthma in children. Chest.1997;111(6):1505–1508.

Timsina MP , Martin GP , Van der Kolk H , Tushulzen E , Enthoben R. The effect of inhalation flow on the performance of a dry powder inhalation system. Int J Pharm.1992;81:199–203.

Timsina MP , Martin GP , Marriott C , Ganderton D , Yainneskis M. Drug delivery to the respiratory tract using dry powder inhalers. Int J Pharm.1994;101:1–13.

Hindle M , Byron PR . Dose emissions from marketed dry powder inhalers. Int J Pharm.1995;116:169–177.

Kim CS , Garcia L. Delivery characteristics of albuterol powder aero-sol by rotahaler. J Aerosol Med.1993;6:199–211.

Hill LS , Slater AL . A comparison of the performance of two modern multidose dry powder asthma inhalers. Respir Med.1998;92(1):105–110.

Bisgaard H , Ifversen M , Klug B , Stamstrup K , Sumby B. Inspiratory flow rate through the Diskus/Accuhaler inhaler and Turbuhaler inhaler in children with asthma (abstract). J Aerosol Med.1995;8:100 (P26).

Roman R , Montealegre F , Tarrats H , Fernandez Cabrero A. A com-parison of albuterol solution nebulized versus albuterol powder given by breath activated metered dose inhaler. Bol Asoc Med PR.1993;85(1-3):12–15.

Raimondi AC , Schottlender J , Lombardi D , Molfino NA . Treatment of acute severe asthma with inhaled albuterol delivered via jet neb-ulizer, metered dose inhaler with spacer, or dry powder. Chest.1997;112(1):24–28.

Tonnesen F , Laursen LC , Evald T , Stahl E , Ibsen TB . Bronchodi-lating effect of terbutaline powder in acute severe bronchial obstruc-tion. Chest.1994;105(3):697–700.

Nana A , Youngchaiyud P , Maranetra N , Boe J , Lofdahl CG , Selroos O , Stahl E. B-agonists administered by a dry powder inhaler can be used in acute asthma. Respir Med.1998;9(2):167–172.

Sole D , Rizzo MCFV , Pimentel AF , Sano F , Barreto BA , Wandalsen NF , Naspitz CK . Effect of inhaled terbutaline sulphate (dry powder, Turbuhaler(TM) and nebulizer solution) in children with acute asthma. Journal of Pediatrics.1995;71(2):82–87. [Article in Portuguese].

Rufin P , Benoist MR , Panqueva P , Brouard JJ , De Blic J , Schein-mann P. [Efficacy of a powder inhaler (Turbuhaler) in moderate asthmatic crises in children]. Rev Mal Respir.1993;10(6):545–550.

Ruggins NR , Milner AD , Swarbrick A. An assessment of a new breath actuated inhaler device in acutely wheezy children. Arch Dis Child.1993;68(4):477–480.

Lipworth BJ , Clark DJ . Lung delivery of salbutamol given by breath activated pressurized aerosol and dry powder inhaler devices. Pulm Pharmacol Ther.1997;10(4):211–214.

Silverman R , Sellers J , Greene S , Flaster E , Colice G. Comparison of the Maxair Autohaler to wet nebulizer in patients with acute asthma. Chest.1998;114(3):766–770.

Dolovich MB , Killian D , Wolff RK , Obminski G , Newhouse MT . Pulmonary aerosol deposition in chronic bronchitis: intermittent pos-itive pressure breathing vs quiet breathing. Am Rev Respir Dis.1977;115(3):397–402.

The Intermittent Positive Pressure Breathing Trial Group. Intermit-tent positive pressure breathing therapy of chronic obstructive pul-monary disease: a clinical trial. Arch Intern Med.1983;99(5):612–620.

Loren M , Chai H , Miklich D , Barwise G. Comparison between sim-ple nebulization and intermittent positive-pressure ventilation in asth-matic children with severe bronchospasm. Chest.1977;72(2):145–147.

Lowenthal D , Kattan M. Facemasks versus mouthpieces for aerosol treatment of asthmatic children. Pediatr Pulmonol.1992;14(3):192–196.

Martin JG , Shore S , Engel LA . Effect of continuous postitive airway pressure on respiratory mechanics and pattern of breathing in in-duced asthma. Am Rev Respir Dis.1982;126(5):812–817.

Wang CH , Lin HC , Huang TJ , Yan CT , Yu CT , Kuo HP . Differential effects of nasal continuous positive airway pressure on reversible or fixed upper and lower airway obstruction. Eur Respir J.1996;9(5):952–959.

Parkes SN , Bersten AD . Aerosol kinetics and bronchodilator effi-cacy during continuous positive airway pressure delivered by face mask. Thorax.1997;52(2):171–175.

Frischknecht-Christensen E , Norregaard O , Dahl R. Treatment of bronchial asthma with terbutaline inhaled by conespacer combined with positive expiratory pressure mask. Chest.1991;100(2):317–321.

Pollack CV Jr. , Fleisch KB , Dowsey K. Treatment of acute broncho-spasm with beta-adrenergic agonist aerosols delivered by a nasal bilevel positive airway pressure circuit. Ann Emerg Med.1995;26(5):552–557.

O'Donohue WJ Jr. . Guidelines for the use of nebulizers in the home and at domicillary sites: report of a consensus conference (review). NAMDRC Consensus Group. Chest.1996;109(3):814–820.

Fink JB . Flawed paradigms drive aerosol device selection (editorial). Chest.1997;112(6):1447–1449.

Hanania NA , Wittman R , Kesten S , Chapman KR . Medical person-nel's knowledge of and ability to use inhaling devices: metered-dose inhalers, spacing chambers, and breath-actuated dry powder inhalers. Chest.1994;105(1):111–116.

Fink JB , Dhand R. Aerosol therapy In: Fink JB , Hunt J editors. Clinical practice in respiratory care.Philadelphia: Raven-Lippincott;1998.