A subject of recurring debate in both academia and the business world is whether workplace committees and other forms of employee participation are substitutes for or supplements to labor unions. One well-established effect of unionization is increased enforcement of government labor policies such as OSHA; this study investigates the enforcement effects of mandated safety and health committees. A comparison of OSHA inspection records for the two years preceding and following the implementation of committee mandates in Oregon in 1991 shows that mandated committees significantly increased the differences between union and nonunion workplaces in OSHA enforcement, with enforcement strengthening considerably in union workplaces but edging upward only slightly in nonunion workplaces. The committees thus appear to have acted more as supplements to than substitutes for labor unions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BernardElaine. 1995. “Canada: Joint Committees on Occupational Safety and Health.” In RogersJoelStreeckWolfgang, eds., Works Councils: Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 351–74.
2.
ChachereDeniseFeuillePeter. 1993. “Grievance Procedures and Due Process in Nonunion Workplaces.” Proceedings of the Forty-Fifth Annual Meeting. Madison, Wis.: Industrial Relations Research Association, pp. 446–55.
3.
Commission on the Future of Worker-Management Relations. 1994a. Fact Finding Report. Washington, D.C.
4.
Commission on the Future of Worker-Management Relations. 1994b. Report and Recommendations. Washington, D.C.
5.
DouglasPaul. 1921. “Shop Committees: Substitute for, or Supplements to Trade Unions?”Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 29, No. 2 (February), pp. 89–107.
6.
EatonAdrienneVoosPaula. 1992. “Unions and Contemporary Innovations in Work Organization, Compensation, and Employee Participation.” In MishelLawrenceVoosPaula, eds., Unions and Economic Competitiveness. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe, pp. 173–215.
7.
EdwardsRichard. 1993. Rights at Work: Employment Relations in the Post-Union Era. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
8.
FeuillePeterDelaneyJohn. 1992. “The Individual Pursuit of Organizational Justice: Grievance Procedures in Nonunion Workplaces.”Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, Vol. 10, pp. 187–232.
9.
FreemanRichardLazearEdward. 1995. “An Economic Analysis of Works Councils.” In RogersJoelStreeckWolfgang, eds., Works Councils: Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 27–50.
10.
FreemanRichardMedoffJames. 1984. What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
11.
HeckerSteven. 1994. “Legally Mandated Joint Safety and Health Committees: The Oregon Experience in Comparative Perspective.” Paper presented at the Conference on Labor Participation and Health and Safety, Higgins Labor Research Center, University of Notre Dame, April 16.
12.
HeckerStevenGwartneyPatriciaBarlowAmy. 1995, Declining Occupational Injury Rates in Oregon, Eugene, Oreg.: Labor Education and Research Center, University of Oregon.
13.
HoymanMicheleStallworthLamont. 1981. “Who Files Suits and Why: An Empirical Portrait of the Litigious Worker.”University of Illinois Law Review, Vol. 198, No. 1, pp, 115–59.
14.
KelleyMaryellenHarrisonBennett. 1992. “Unions, Technology, and Labor Management Cooperation.” In MishelLawrenceVoosPaula, eds., Unions and Economic Competitiveness. Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe, pp. 247–86.
15.
KochanThomasDyerLeeLipskyDavid. 1977. The Effectiveness of Union-Management Safety and Health Committees. Kalamazoo, Mich.: Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
16.
LevineDavidTysonLaura D'Andrea. 1990. “Participation, Productivity, and the Firm's Environment.” In BlinderAlan, ed., Paying for Productivity: A Look at the Evidence. Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution, pp. 183–243.
17.
LofgrenDon J.1989. Dangerous Premises: An Insider's View of OSHA Enforcement. Ithaca, N.Y.: ILR Press.
18.
Meridian Research, Inc. 1994. “Review and Analysis of State-Mandated and Other Worker Protection Programs.” Final Report Prepared for Office of Program Evaluation, Directorate of Policy, Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
Oregon Occupational Safety and Health Division. 1993. Workplace Safety Committees: A Basic Guide to Developing and Implementing an Occupational Safety and Health Committee. Salem, Oreg.: OR-OSHA Resource Center.
21.
PetersonRichard. 1992. “The Union and Nonunion Grievance System.” In LewinDavidMitchellOliviaShererPeter, eds., Research Frontiers in Industrial Relations and Human ResourcesMadison, Wis.: Industrial Relations Research Association.
22.
PompeiiJohn. 1992. “Testimony on the Comprehensive Occupational Safety and Health Reform Act.” Presented to the U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Education and Labor.
23.
ReillyBarryPaciPierellaHollPeter. 1995. “Unions, Safety Committees, and Workplace Injuries.”British Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 33, No. 2 (June), pp. 275–88.
24.
RogersJoelStreeckWolfgang. 1995. “The Study of Works Councils: Concepts and Problems.” In RogersStreeck, eds., Works Councils: Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 3–26.
25.
SamuelsonPaul. 1955. “Diagrammatic Exposition of a Theory of Public Expenditure.”Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 37, pp. 350–56.
26.
ShavellSteven. 1984. “A Model of the Optimal Use of Liability and Safety Regulation.”RAND Journal of Economics, Vol. 15, pp. 271–80.
27.
SimsRobert Hamilton. 1988. “Hazard Abatement as a Function of Firm Size: The Effects of Internal Firm Characteristics and External Incentives.” Ph.D. diss., RAND Graduate Institute.
28.
SmithRobert. 1979. “The Impact of OSHA Inspections on Manufacturing Injury Rates.”Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 145–70.
29.
TuohyCarolynSimardMarcel. 1993. The Impact of Joint Health and Safety Committees in Ontario and Quebec. Study prepared for the Canadian Association of Administrators of Labour Law, Unpublished manuscript.
30.
U.S. Government Accounting Office. 1989. How Well Does OSHA Protect Workers from Reprisals? Inspector Opinions. GAO/T-HRD-90-8.
31.
U.S. Government Accounting Office. 1992a. Occupational Safety and Health: Penalties for Violations Are Well below Maximum Allowable Penalties. GAO/HRD-92-48.
32.
U.S. Government Accounting Office. 1992b. Occupational Safety and Health: Worksite Safety and Health Programs Show Promise. GAO/HRD-92-68.
33.
U.S. Government Accounting Office. 1994. Workplace Regulation: Information on Selected Employer and Union Experiences. GAO/HEHS-94-138.
34.
ViscusiW. Kip. 1983. Risk by Choice: Regulating Health and Safety in the Workplace. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
35.
ViscusiW. KipO'ConnorCharles. 1984. “Adaptive Responses to Chemical Labeling: Are Workers Bayesian Decision Makers?”American Economic Review, Vol. 74, No. 5, pp. 942–56.
36.
WeilDavid. 1991. “Enforcing OSHA: The Role of Labor Unions.”Industrial Relations, Vol. 30, No. 1 (Winter), pp. 20–36.
37.
WeilDavid. 1992. “Building Safety: The Role of Construction Unions in the Enforcement of OSHA.”Journal of Labor Research, Vol. 13, No. 1 (Winter), pp. 121–32.
38.
WeilDavid. 1996. “Regulating the Workplace: The Vexing Problem of Implementation.” In LewinDavidKaufmanBruceSockellDonna, eds., Advances in Industrial and Labor Relations, Vol. 7. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press, pp. 247–86.
