This article examines the actions of trade union leaders in response to religious discrimination in employment in Northern Ireland, and their influence on British Government policy-making on this question. The main finding is that despite the risk of alienating many members, the trade union movement persisted in seeking radical remedies for discrimination during the 1980s, and was influential in the shaping of anti-discrimination legislation enacted in 1989. The author finds points of similarity between this history and the AFL-CIO leadership's civil rights stand in the 1960s, and sees these examples as evidence that egalitarian values have played, and continue to play, an important role in shaping union purpose and action.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Belfast Telegraph (Daily newspaper). 1991a. “Storm over SF Talks with Vice-President of Bombardier.” April 5, p. 1.
2.
Belfast Telegraph (Daily newspaper). 1991b. “Explosion Hits Shorts Complex.” April 16, pp. 1, 6.
3.
BensonLeslie. 1978. Proletarians and Parties. Wellington, N.Z., and London: Methuen/Tavistock.
4.
BlackBoyd. 1992. “Trade Union Density in Northern Ireland.”IBAR—Irish Business and Administrative Research, Vol. 13, pp. 6–19.
5.
BokDerek C.DunlopJohn T., 1970. Labor and the American Community. New York: Simon & Schuster.
6.
BoothHelen E.BertschKenneth A., 1989. The MacBride Principles and U.S. Companies in Northern Ireland. Washington, D.C.: Investor Responsibility Research Center, Inc.
7.
BoydAndrew. 1984. Have the Trade Unions Failed the North?Cork: Mercier.
8.
BurnsHoward. 1987. “Submission by Howard Burns, Board Member of the Fair Employment Agency for Northern Ireland, to the California State Legislature Committee, 13 May 1987.” Mimeo. Belfast: ATGWU/FEA.
9.
Cameron (Lord). 1969. Disturbances in Northern Ireland: Report of the Commission Appointed by the Governor of Northern Ireland. Belfast: HMSO.
10.
CarrJohn. 1987. New Roads to Equality: Contract Compliance for the UK?London: The Fabian Society.
11.
CBI-NI. 1987. “Response to DED Document, Equality of Opportunity in Employment in Northern Ireland.” Mimeo. Belfast: Confederation of British Industry—Northern Ireland.
12.
ClarkeTom. 1977. “Introduction.” In ClarkeT.ClementsL., eds., Trade Unions Under Capitalism. Glasgow: Fontana, pp. 7–23.
13.
CoatesKen. 1982. “The Vagaries of Participation 1945–1960.” In PimlottBenCookChris, eds., Trade Unions in British Politics. Harlow and New York: Longman, pp. 171–87.
14.
CollardDavid. 1978. Altruism and Economy: A Study in Non-Selfish Economics. Oxford: Martin Robertson.
15.
CormackR. J.OsborneR. D., eds. 1983. Religion, Education and Employment: Aspects of Equal Opportunity in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Appletree.
16.
CraddenJoan. 1987. “Equality of Opportunity in Northern Ireland: The Politics of Positive Action.” M.A. Diss., University of Edinburgh.
17.
CraddenTerry. 1991. “The Left in Northern Ireland and the National Question: The Democratic Alternative in the 1940s.”Saothar—Journal of the Irish Labour History Society, Vol. 16, pp. 13–25.
18.
CraddenTerry. 1993a. Trade Unionism, Socialism and Partition: The Labour Movement in Northern Ireland, 1939–1953. Leicester: Leicester University Press, forthcoming.
19.
CraddenTerry. 1993b. “The Tories and Employment Law in Northern Ireland: Seeing Unions in a Different Light?” Forthcoming in Industrial Relations Journal, Vol. 24, Spring.
20.
CrouchColin. 1982a. The Politics of Industrial Relations, 2nd Ed.Glasgow: Fontana.
21.
CrouchColin. 1982b. Trade Unions: The Logic of Collective Action. Glasgow: Fontana.
22.
DarbyJohn, ed. 1983. Northern Ireland: The Background to the Conflict. Belfast and Syracuse: Appletree/Syracuse University Press.
23.
DED. 1986. Equality of Opportunity in Employment in Northern Ireland: Future Strategy Options—A Consultative Paper. Belfast: Department of Economic Development.
24.
DED. 1987a. Religious Equality of Opportunity in Employment: Guide to Effective Practice. Belfast: DED.
25.
DED. 1987b. Religious Equality of Opportunity in Employment: Classification of Schools for Monitoring Purposes. Belfast: DED.
26.
DED. 1989. Fair Employment in Northern Ireland: Code of Practice. Belfast: DED.
27.
DMS. 1978. Guide to Manpower Policy and Practice. Belfast: Department of Manpower Services.
28.
DTI. 1986. Building Business—Not Barriers. London: Department of Trade & Industry White Paper; HMSO.
29.
DullesFoster RheaDubofskyMelvyn. 1984. Labor in America, 4th Ed.Illinois: Harlan Davidson.
30.
EccleshallRobert. 1984. “Introduction: The World of Ideology.” In EccleshallRobertGeogheganVincentJayRichardWilfordRick, eds., Political Ideologies. London: Hutchinson, pp. 7–35.
31.
EOR. 1986. (No author credited.) “The MacBride Principles.”Equal Opportunities Review, No. 8 (July/August), pp. 16–22.
32.
FEA. 1984. Seventh Report and Statement of Accounts of the Fair Employment Agency for Northern Ireland. Belfast: HMSO.
33.
FEA. 1986. “Comments of the Fair Employment Agency for Northern Ireland on the Government Consultative Paper on Future Strategy Options for the Promotion of Equality of Opportunity in Northern Ireland.” Mimeo. Belfast: Fair Employment Agency.
34.
FEC. 1992. Profile of the Workforce in Northern Ireland: Summary of the 1991 Monitoring Returns. Research Report No. 2. Belfast: Fair Employment Commission.
35.
FlandersAllan. 1970. Management and Unions. London: Faber & Faber.
36.
FonerPhillip S.LewisRonald S., eds. 1980. The Black Worker: Vol. 5, The Black Worker from 1900 to 1919. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
37.
FreemanRichard B.MedoffJames L., 1984. What Do Unions Do?New York: Basic Books.
38.
GreenstoneJ. David. 1977. Labor in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
39.
HaagerupN. J. rapporteur. 1984. Report Drawn up on Behalf of the Political Affairs Committee on the Situation in Northern Ireland. Strasbourg: European Parliament Working Documents, 1983–1984; document 1-1526/83.
40.
HamChristopherHillMichael. 1984. The Policy Process in the Modern Capitalist State. Brighton: Wheatsheaf.
RichardHyman, 1975. Industrial Relations: A Marxist Introduction. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
44.
ICTU. 1974. Role and Functions of Congress. Dublin: Irish Congress of Trade Unions.
45.
ICTU. 1986. Equality of Opportunity in Northern Ireland—A Statement of Trade Union Policy. Dublin: ICTU.
46.
ICTU. 1988. Report of Proceedings—Annual Delegate Conference, 1987. Dublin: ICTU.
47.
ICTU. 1989. Report of the Executive Council—1988/89. Dublin: ICTU.
48.
Irish Times. 1987. Sep. 24. Cited in “What People in Ireland Have to Say About the MacBride Principles.” Mimeo. Belfast: DED, undated.
49.
KearnsElizabeth. 1991. “Fair Employment—Fact or Fiction?” Diploma in Personnel Management Diss., University of Ulster.
50.
LukesStephen. 1985. Marxism and Morality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
51.
McCarthyCharles. 1977. Trade Unions in Ireland, 1894–1960. Dublin: Institute of Public Administration.
52.
McCormackInez. 1985. “Speech by Inez McCormack, Regional Organiser, National Union of Public Employees, to Irish-American Labor Coalition in Boston, Mass. U.S.A.” Mimeo. Belfast: NUPE.
53.
McCormackInez. 1986. “The Long, Long March from '68.”Fortnight (Belfast current affairs magazine), No. 246 (Dec), pp. 16–18.
54.
McCormackInezMcCormackVincent. 1986. “DED Jobs Bias Move: A Gestural Politics.”Fortnight, No. 244 (Oct.), pp. 8–9.
55.
McNamaraKevin. 1987. “Government Equality Proposals a Missed Opportunity.”London: House of Commons Press Release; Sept. 10, 1987.
56.
MarengoFranco Damasco. 1979. The Code of British Trade Union Behaviour. Farnborough: Saxon House.
57.
MartinRoss M.1980. TUC: The Growth of a Pressure Group, 1868–1976. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
58.
MartinRoss M.1989. Trade Unionism: Purposes and Forms: Oxford: Clarendon Press.
59.
MastersMarick F.DelaneyJohn Thomas. 1987. “Union Political Activities: A Review of the Empirical Literature.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 40, No. 3 (January), pp. 336–53.
60.
MiddlemassKeith. 1979. Politics in Industrial Society. London: Deutsch.
61.
MullanKeithMcWilliamsMonica. 1990. “Legislating for Equality of Opportunity in the United Kingdom.” In ConnollyM.E.H.LoughlinS., eds., Public Policy in Northern Ireland: Adoption or Adaption?Belfast and Coleraine: Policy Research Institute, pp. 285–302.
62.
NIC-ICTU. 1985. Annual Report—1984–85. Belfast: Northern Ireland Committee—Irish Congress of Trade Unions.
NIC-ICTU/NILP. 1967. Joint Memorandum on Citizens' Rights in Northern Ireland. Belfast: NIC-ICTU, Northern Ireland Labour Party, and the Parliamentary Labour Party.
68.
NIO. 1988. Fair Employment in Northern Ireland. London: Northern Ireland Office White Paper; HMSO.
69.
OAGC. 1990. Review of Adherence to Standards of Fair Employment by Twenty-Five United States Firms with Business Operations in Northern Ireland. Sacramento, Calif.: Office of the Auditor General of California.
70.
PanitchL.1976. Social Democracy and Industrial Militancy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
71.
PattersonHenry. 1980. Class Conflict and Sectarianism. Belfast: Blackstaff/Ulster Polytechnic.
72.
PerlmanSelig. 1951. A Theory of the Labor Movement. New York: Kelley.
PurdieBob. 1990. Politics in the Streets: The Origins of the Civil Rights Movement in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Blackstaff.
75.
RolstonBill. 1980. “The Limits of Trade Unionism.” In O'DowdLiamRolstonBillTomlinsonMike, eds., Northern Ireland—Between Civil Rights and Civil War. London: CSE Books, pp. 68–94.
76.
SabelC. F.1982. Work and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
77.
TowersBrian. 1989. “Running the Gauntlet: British Trade Unions Under Thatcher, 1979–1988.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 42, No. 2 (January), pp. 163–88.
78.
TrotskyL.1977. “Marxism and Trade Unionism.” In ClarkeT.ClementsL., eds., Trade Unions Under Capitalism. Glasgow: Fontana, pp. 77–92.
79.
StraubenzeeVan. 1973. Report and Recommendations of the Working Party on Discrimination in the Private Sector of Employment. Belfast: HMSO.
80.
WhiteBarry. 1984. John Hume: Statesman of the Troubles. Belfast: Blackstaff.
81.
WhyteJohn. 1981. Catholics in Western Democracies. Dublin: Gill & Macmillan.
WithersGlenn A. 1977. “Social Justice and the Unions: A Normative Approach to Co-operation and Conflict Under Inter-dependence.”British Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 15, No. 3, pp. 322–37.
