Industrial relations (IR) scholars emphasize the strategic choices of industrial relations actors to explain IR processes and outcomes. This article asserts that union member satisfaction is critical to realize unions’ objectives and that the local union and work context shapes satisfaction. The authors study the 2019 national UAW strike against General Motors in two, at first sight, very similar union locals. Union members of one local approved the agreement while the other local rejected the agreement. Through quantitative and qualitative analysis, the authors explain the different outcomes. Their analysis of a unique worker survey conducted during the strike shows that general member satisfaction was an important dimension for supporting the union’s strategic choices. Qualitative case studies of the two locals highlight the importance of shares of transfer workers—“invisible divides”—when examining member satisfaction. Broadly, findings contribute to the strategic choice literature and emphasize the local union context as a key locus for producing successful outcomes.
BambergerSimon GrandjeanVindingAnker LundLarsenAneliaNielsenPeterFonagerKirstenNielsenRené N.RyomPiaOmlandØyvind. 2012. Impact of organisational change on mental health: A systematic review. Occupational and Environmental Medicine69(8):592–98. https://doi.org/10.1136/oemed-2011-100381
4.
BarlingJulianFullagarCliveKellowayKevin E.McElvieLeanne.1992. Union loyalty and strike propensity. Journal of Social Psychology132(5):581–90. doi:10.1080/00224545.1992.9713897
5.
BoxallPeter. 2008. Trade union strategy. In BlytonPaulBaconNicolasFioritoJackHeeryEdmund (Eds.), The SAGE Handbook of Industrial Relations, pp. 209–24. London: Sage Publications.
BunkleyNick. 2011. G.M. contract approved with bonus for workers. New York Times, September28.
8.
BurdenMelissa. 2015. UAW ratifies four-year GM contract. Detroit News, November20.
9.
BurdenMelissaWaylandMichael. 2015. GM–UAW ratification held up by skilled trades. Detroit News, November6.
10.
ChenVictor T.2015. Cut Loose: Jobless and Hopeless in an Unfair Economy. Oakland: University of California Press.
11.
DavisPaul R.FengJieTrevorCharlie O.2013. Free to quit or obligated to stay? The effects of prior layoffs on voluntary turnover. Academy of Management Proceedings2013(1):1479–84. https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2013.228
12.
DavisPaul R.TrevorCharlie O.FengJie. 2015. Creating a more quit-friendly national workforce? Individual layoff history and voluntary turnover. Journal of Applied Psychology100(5):1434–55. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000012
13.
de JongTanjaWiezerNoortjede WeerdMarjoleinNielsenKarinaMattila-HolappaPauliinaMockałłoZosia. 2016. The impact of restructuring on employee well-being: A systematic review of longitudinal studies. Work and Stress30(1):91–114. https://doi.org/10.1080/02678373.2015.1136710
14.
DupuisMathieuGreerIan. 2021. Recentralizing industrial relations? Local unions and the politics of insourcing in three North American automakers. ILR Review75(4):1–25.
15.
EdelsteinDavid J.WarnerMalcolm. 1976. Comparative Union Democracy: Organisation and Opposition in British and American Unions. New York: Halsted Press.
16.
EdwardsRichard, C.1979. Contested Terrain. New York: Basic Books.
FineLisa M.2004. The Story of Reo Joe: Work, Kin, and Community in Autotown, USA. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
20.
FioritoJackGallagherDaniel G.FukamiCynthia V.1988. Satisfaction with union representation. Industrial and Labor Relations Review41(2):294–307.
21.
GakovicAnikaTetrickLois E.2003. Psychological contract breach as a source of strain for employees. Journal of Business and Psychology18:235–46.
22.
GallagherDaniel G.TanskyJudith W.WetzelKurt W.1997. Peripheral employment contracts: The relationship between part-time employment and union attachment. In SverkeMagnus (Ed.), The Future of Trade Unionism: International Perspectives on Emerging Union Structures, pp. 327–46. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate.
23.
GellerAdam. 2006. For GM workers, a major break in line of succession ‘gypsies’ caught between closings. Washington Post, March12.
GoslingaSjoerdSverkeMagnus. 2003. Atypical work and trade union membership: Union attitudes and union turnover among traditional vs atypically employed union members. Economic and Industrial Democracy24(2):290–312.
30.
GreenhouseSteven. 1997. Yearlong effort key to success for teamsters. New York Times, August25, pp. A1, A15.
31.
GuestDavid E.2004. The psychology of the employment relationship: An analysis based on the psychological contract. Applied Psychology53(4):541–55. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1464-0597.2004.00187.x
32.
HallKaleaGrzelewskiJordyn. 2023. Under new deal, old GM Lordstown workers can transfer to JV battery site. Detroit News, November3.
33.
HigginsTimHydeJustin. 2009. UAW OKs changes to GM pact. Detroit Free Press, May30.
34.
HighSteven. 2019. The emotional fallout of deindustrialization in Detroit. Labor: Studies in Working Class History of the Americas16(1):127–149.
35.
HuLi-tzeBentlerPeter M.1999. Cutoff criteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis: Conventional criteria versus new alternatives. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal6(1):1–55.
36.
JarleyPaulKuruvillaSaroshCasteelDouglas. 1990. Member-union relations and union satisfaction. Industrial Relations29(1):128-34.
37.
KatzHarry C.BattRosemaryKeefeJeffrey H.2003. The revitalization of the CWA: Integrating collective bargaining, political action, and organizing. Industrial and Labor Relations Review56(4):573–89.
38.
KatzHarry C.ColvinAlexander. 2021. Employment relations in the United States. In BamberGreg J.CookeFang LeeDoellgastVirginiaWrightChris F. (Eds.). International and Comparative Employment Relations: Global Crises and Institutional Responses, pp. 55–80. Los Angeles: Sage.
39.
KatzHarry C.MacDuffieJohn PaulPilFrits K.2013. Crisis and recovery in the U.S. auto industry: Tumultuous times for a collective bargaining pacesetter. In StangerHoward R.FrostAnn C.ClarkPaul F. (Eds.), Collective Bargaining Under Duress: Case Studies of Major U.S. Industries, pp. 45–80. Champaign, IL: Labor and Employment Relations Association.
KlineRex B.2015. Principles and Practice of Structural Equation Modeling. New York: Guilford Press.
42.
KochanThomas A.1992. Walton and McKersie’s Behavioral Theory of Labor Negotiations: An industrial relations perspective. Journal of Organizational Behavior13:289–95.
43.
KochanThomas A.McKersieRobert B.CappelliPeter. 1984. Strategic choice and industrial relations theory. Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society23:16–39.
LeichtKevin T.1989. Unions, plants, jobs, and workers: An analysis of union satisfaction and participation. Sociological Quarterly30(2):331–62.
48.
LévesqueChristianMurrayGregorQueuxStéphane Le. 2005. Union disaffection and social identity: Democracy as a source of union revitalization. Work and Occupations32(4):400–422.
49.
LeviMargaretOlsonDavidAgnoneJonKellyDevin. 2009. Union democracy reexamined. Politics & Society37(2):203–28.
50.
LipsetSeymour M.TrowMartinColemanJames. 1956. Union Democracy: The Inside Politics of the International Typographical Union. New York: Free Press.
MoylePennyParkesKatharine. 1999. The effects of transition stress: A relocation study. Journal of Organizational Behavior20(5):625–46.
55.
MrozowickiAdamTrappmannVera. 2021. Precarity as a biographical problem? Young workers living with precarity in Germany and Poland. Work, Employment and Society35(2):221–38. https://doi.org/10.1177/0950017020936898
56.
NairNishaVohraNeharika. 2012. The concept of alienation: Towards conceptual clarity. International Journal of Organizational Analysis20(1):25–50. https://doi.org/10.1108/19348831211215641
PhillipsBrianCurtissPhyllisLundskowGeorge. 2010. Workers’ relationships to their union: The effects of transfer status and race at a U.S. automobile plant. Social Science Journal47(2):392–417.
59.
PhillipsBrianCurtissPhyllisLundskowGeorge. 2014. A U.S. automobile plant analysis of workers commitment to their union: The effects of transfer status, gender and marital status. Race, Gender & Class21(3/4):210–31.
60.
PreacherKristopher J.ZhangZhenZyphurMichael J.2016. Multilevel structural equation models for assessing moderation within and across levels of analysis. Psychological Methods21(2):189–205.
61.
PreacherKristopher J.ZyphurMichael J.ZhangZhen. 2010. A general multilevel SEM framework for assessing multilevel mediation. Psychological Methods15(3):209–33.
62.
PriddleAlisaGardnerGregSnavelyBrent. 2015. UAW digging for answers. Detroit Free Press, October2.
63.
PriddleAlisaSnavelyBrent. 2015. Done deal: UAW confirms ratification of FCA contract. Detroit Free Press, October22.
64.
RobinsonSandra L.1996. Trust and breach of the psychological contract. Administrative Science Quarterly41(4):574–99. https://doi.org/10.2307/2393868
65.
RothsteinJeffrey S.2016. Contextualizing work: The influence of workplace history and perceptions of the future on lean production at three GM plants. Critical Sociology42(7/8):1143–61.
66.
SarrosJames C.TanewskiGeorge A.WinterR. P.SantoraJ. C.DenstenIain L.2002. Work alienation and organizational leadership. British Journal of Management13:285–304. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8551.00247
VanHulleLindsay. 2014. Oldsmobile's gone 10 years, but all’s not forgotten. Lansing State Journal, April27.
72.
VossKim. 2010. Democratic dilemmas: Union democracy and union renewal. Transfer: European Review of Labour and Research16(3):369–82.
73.
Wall HowardPhoebeLaReauJamie L.2019. UAW targets GM in talks: Toughest picked to set tone; union authorizes strike. Livingston County Daily Press & Argus, September5.
74.
WaltonRichard E.McKersieRobert B.1965. A Behavioral Theory of Labor Negotiations. New York: McGraw-Hill.
75.
WeilDavid. 2005. A strategic choice framework for union decision making. WorkingUSA8(3):327–47.
76.
WielandBarbara. 2008. GM plant manager role duties expanded. Lansing State Journal, October 8.
